Eighteen unfair dismissal/labour dispute applications are due to be heard today by the Fair Work Commission. The full list includes: Mt Arthur Coal Pty Limited (Muller), Brightlife Nominees Pty Ltd (Clucas), Ferngrove Pharmaceuticals Pty Ltd (Manda), Deluxe Entertainment Services Group (Krsmanovic), Branski Pty Ltd (Rahman), Boral Cement Limited (Blake), Green Mountain Food Processing (Abraham), Southern Suburbs Football Club (Mackay) Inc. (Conelius), Airbus Group Australia Pacific Limited (McLaren), Gold Training Pty Ltd (Carroll), Griffith University (Berkers), Police Financial Services Limited (Iacono), Metro Trains Melbourne (Kumari), Stihl Pty Ltd (O’Shea), Glen Iris Day Care Centre (Miller), RJVincent (Charnock), Bicycle South Australia Inc (Bridge), Millenium Services Group Ltd (Hanneman).
January 18, 2017
ENTERPRISE BARGAINING – majority support determination – ss.236, 604 Fair Work Act 2009 – appeal – Full Bench – at first instance Commission determined that 25 May 2016 represented the most appropriate time for determining whether majority support for bargaining existed – satisfied majority of employees support bargaining for an enterprise agreement – appellant sought permission to appeal – whether in public interest is a discretionary test involving broad value judgment [GlaxoSmithKline] – in public interest to grant permission to appeal – Full Bench satisfied important questions raised concerning the application of s.237 of FW Act in circumstances where Commission’s discretion to determine whether a majority of employees wanted to bargain is an issue in dispute – important matter regarding Commission’s approach in such a determination – Full Bench only authorised to set aside the decision if error on part of decision maker has been demonstrated – not authorised to substitute its own discretion [House v The King] – appellant submitted that amongst other things ss.237(2) and 237(3) erroneously applied – decision is to be made on the basis of the most current material available to the decision maker [PekoWallsend] – respondent submitted amongst other things that all that is necessary is that the Commission consider the method selected as appropriate to expose a majority – Full Bench found that s.237(2(a)(i) is directed at fixing time at which the Commission determines who are the persons employed only – Full Bench agreed with appellant – not open to Commission to determine a point in time other than the time of the decision as the time at which a majority of employees could be said to want to bargain – identified that Commission did not take into account the most current information available to him at the time of determination – found that appellant demonstrated a House v King error in Commissioner’s decision – appeal upheld and decision at first instance quashed – matter referred to Johns C. Appeal by Kantfield P/L t/a Martogg & Company against decision of Ryan C of 9 September 2016 [[2016] FWC 6473] Re: Australian Workers’ Union, The
January 18, 2017
CASE PROCEDURES – referral to Full Bench – ss.512, 615A Fair Work Act 2009 – application for President to direct a Full Bench to perform a function – CEPU had made an application for an entry permit for Mr Metcher – Mr Metcher holds the office of Branch Secretary of the NSW Postal and Telecommunications Branch of the CEPU – Commission Member was satisfied Mr Metcher was a fit and proper person to hold a permit under s.512 of FW Act and issued decision granting application – subsequent Report by Director of Commission’s Regulatory Compliance Branch requested that consideration be given to variation or revocation of the decision on basis that Mr Metcher had failed to disclose a number of assault charges in August 2007 and that the charges were the subject of court proceedings – matter was allocated to same Commission Member and listed for hearing – Minister applied for the matter to be referred to a Full Bench – submitted significant public interest considerations raised which warranted attention of the Full Bench – firstly, whether or not charges of assault and court proceedings concerning alleged incidences of domestic violence are matters relevant to the ‘fit and proper person’ assessment for purposes of s.512 – secondly, whether or not there should be disclosure to the Commission of such charges and related court orders – CEPU then advised Commission that as Mr Metcher had stood aside from duties of Branch Secretary, did not need to exercise a right of entry – returned permits and requested that they be administratively cancelled – further requested the listing be vacated and proceedings treated as closed – AGS submitted that Commission should proceed to decide under s.603 whether or not to revoke or vary the decision and to consider whether or not Mr Metcher was a fit and proper person to hold a permit – President noted the revocation or variation of decision required the exercise of the power in s.603 – broad discretionary power – generally only exercised where there has been a change in circumstances such as to warrant the revocation or variation of original decision or where original decision was based on incomplete or false information – decision to issue entry permit may be revoked if, in relation to one or more of the ‘permit qualification matters’ in s.513(1), the decision had been made on incorrect facts – in the usual course, the Member whose decision is to be reconsidered is in the best position to determine whether their decision should be varied or revoked because it was based on an incomplete factual matrix – President did not accept submission on behalf of Minister that usual practice should be departed from because of the importance of the issue of principle to be determined – given the nature of the matter sought to be referred to a Full Bench, being an own motion proceeding in which Member to consider, whether or not to revoke or vary own decision, and the availability of the review mechanism in s.605 to deal with any alleged error in the Member’s determination of the issue of principle, President not satisfied that it was in the public interest to refer the matter to a Full Bench under s.615A – Minister not having a right to be heard in the proceedings before the Member not a consideration which enlivened public interest test under s.615A – President not satisfied that it was in the public interest to direct a Full Bench to hear and determine the application under s.512 – application refused. Communications, Electrical, Electronic, Energy, Information, Postal, Plumbing and Allied Services Union of Australia – Communications Division – New South Wales Postal and Telecommunications Branch v Metcher
January 18, 2017
RIGHT OF ENTRY – misuse of system – ss.508, 587 Fair Work Act 2009 – application by respondent to dismiss substantive matter – respondent submitted proceedings are vexatious and an abuse of process because they are being conducted in a manner unfairly burdensome and productive of serious and unjustified harassment to all of the respondents to the substantive manner – the respondent also submitted that the proceedings are an abuse of process because they are doomed to fail owing to events that have occurred since their commencement and because of the circumstances known to the applicant – application to dismiss substantive matter arose because of additional material relied upon by the applicant – consideration of application to dismiss confined to additional material to which respondent objects – power to dismiss arises from s.587(1) FW Act – three categories of abuse of process from Rogers v The Queen relevant [LCR Group] – legislation concerned with substance and motive with which application is commenced and prosecuted – Commission not satisfied applicant’s reliance on additional material motivated by desire to harass or embarrass respondent, or that the attempt to rely on the material was frivolous or vexatious – Commission not satisfied of an abuse of process – Commission not persuaded substantive application should be dismissed – parties to be afforded an opportunity to be heard on admissibility of additional material – application to dismiss substantive matter dismissed. The Director of the Fair Work Building Industry Inspectorate v Construction, Forestry, Mining and Energy Union and Ors
January 18, 2017
INDUSTRIAL ACTION – termination of protected industrial action – s.424 Fair Work Act 2009 – two applications made by the Minister for Industrial Relations for the State of Victoria (the Minister) that orders be made terminating protected industrial action notified by The Australian Workers’ Union, the Communications, Electrical, Electronic, Energy, Information, Postal, Plumbing and Allied Services Union of Australia and the “Automotive, Food, Metals, Engineering, Printing and Kindred Industries Union” known as the Australian Manufacturing Workers’ Union (AMWU) (the Unions) against Esso Australia P/L (Esso) – industrial action notified by the Unions related to employees who would be covered by the proposed enterprise agreements to replace the Esso Gippsland (Longford and Long Island Point) Enterprise Agreement 2011 (the Gippsland Agreement) and the Esso Offshore Enterprise Agreement 2011 (the Offshore Agreement) – parties have been negotiating for over two years – intention was to take industrial action in the form of 24 consecutive one hour stoppages on the performance of all work by the employees commencing at 6:00am on 9 December 2016, and repeated from 6:00am on each day thereafter, until 6:00am on 1 March 2017 – applications were brought on the basis that the industrial action has threatened, is threatening, or would threaten to endanger the welfare of the population or a part of it and cause significant damage to the Australian economy or an important part of it – Commission satisfied that protected industrial action as described in the Notices was threatened, impending and probable – found industrial action would immediately threaten gas supply to each of the regions and industries currently supplied with gas through the Esso production facility – inevitable that that the protected industrial action threatened to endanger the welfare of the population in various regions of South East Australia – no doubt that the industrial action would cause significant damage to the Victorian economy and additional damage to other parts of South East Australia – termination of the protected industrial action will move the negotiating parties from the extended impasse in their negotiations to an alternative path of conciliation and arbitration – Commission decided to terminate the protected industrial action. Minister for Industrial Relations for the State of Victoria v Australian Workers’ Union, The and Ors
January 18, 2017
TERMINATION OF EMPLOYMENT – termination at initiative of employer – ss.386, 394 Fair Work Act 2009 – application for relief from unfair dismissal – parties de-identified – on 14 July 2016 the applicant advised the respondent that he was leaving but did not provide any further explanation for his departure from work – respondent concluded that applicant had resigned his position – in an email to the applicant on 18 July 2016, the respondent confirmed it had concluded he had left their employment of his own volition – applicant submitted he had a panic attack at work on 14 July 2016 as a result of behaviour directed towards him by the respondent – further submitted this should not be viewed as a resignation because it was due to what he perceived as an immediate threat to his health and safety – Mohazab considered – Commission found the termination of the applicant’s employment was at the initiative of the employer on 18 July 2016 – found no valid reason for dismissal – dismissal considered unfair – reinstatement not appropriate – compensation of two week’s pay, less tax, but with commensurate superannuation payments ordered. Mr A v The Respondent
January 18, 2017
ENTERPRISE BARGAINING – bargaining order – s.229 Fair Work Act 2009 – application for bargaining order – applicant alleged respondent had engaged in capricious or unfair conduct that undermined freedom of association and collective bargaining – respondent decided to implement operational changes that resulted in redundancies – enterprise bargaining taking place – reason for changes was delays caused by employees taking protected industrial action – whether redundancies in the circumstances breached respondent’s good faith bargaining obligations under s.228(1)(e) of FW Act – respondent submitted decision to restructure not connected to enterprise bargaining and therefore not unfair – submitted conduct was not conduct that undermined freedom of association or collective bargaining – construction of s.228(1)(e) – Commission found the legislation does not stop an employer from making changes to its operations while protected industrial action is taking place or in response to that action provided it is not for reasons or in a manner that is inconsistent with good faith bargaining requirements or other legislative provisions – conduct for the purposes of s.228(1)(e) must have the effect or likely effect of undermining collective bargaining – conduct that is simply unfair or capricious not sufficient – Commission found restructure proposal and decision to implement it not capricious or unfair – restructure not undertaken because of industrial action or to hinder employees’ right to take industrial action or bargaining position – cannot be held to undermine collective bargaining or freedom of association. Construction, Forestry, Mining and Energy Union v Anglo Coal (Capcoal Management) P/L t/a Capcoal
January 18, 2017
ENTERPRISE AGREEMENTS – dispute about matter arising under agreement – jurisdiction – s.739 Fair Work Act 2009 – two enterprise agreements applied to work at prison project, the Entire Mechanical Services P/L and CEPU – Plumbing Division Victorian Branch Enterprise Agreement 2015-2019 (the Mechanical Services Agreement) and the Entire Fire Protection P/L and CEPU – Plumbing Division (Vic) Fire Protection Agreement 2015-2019 (the Fire Protection Agreement) – dispute resolution procedure in both agreements provided that decisions of Victorian Building Industry Disputes Panel (VBIDP) could be referred to Commission for review and Commission could exercise conciliation and/or arbitration powers – VBIDP decided on dispute over payment of employees for period of work stoppage – applicants referred decision for review by Commission – parties in dispute over scope of review – applicants submitted review would be hearing de novo – CEPU submitted review would be appeal – Commission previously held that review means hearing de novo [CDK Commercial Construction P/L] – agreements must be looked to for meaning of wording – relevant that parties did not use word ‘appeal’ – term ‘review’ not defined but meaning ascertainable from agreements – Commission satisfied parties intended rehearing – agreements provided for conciliation and empowered Commission to make formal binding determination after parties had been heard on ‘matters in dispute’ – nothing in language limited dispute to one about correctness of VBIDP’s decision – agreements also referred to Commission only having regard to materials put before it at hearing – language did not suggest Commission was limited to consideration of material before VBIDP subject to right to call new evidence – if parties had wished to limit Commission’s role they could have entered into agreements providing for such limitation and they did not – Commission invited parties to request conciliation – if no agreement regarding usefulness of conciliation, matter would be set down for hearing and determination. Entire Mechanical Services P/L and Anor v Communications, Electrical, Electronic, Energy, Information, Postal, Plumbing and Allied Services Union of Australia