NEWS HR

RIGHT OF ENTRY – application for permit – conditions – ss.512, 515 Fair Work Act 2009 – application for entry permit for Mr Michael Haire – Mr Haire has been employed as an organiser by the Queensland and Northern Territory Divisional Branch of the CEPU since September 2010 – based in Cairns, his area of responsibility is far North Queensland – in May 2016 the Federal Court issued its judgement in Robinson – the Federal Court found that during the course of the dispute three union officials, including Mr Haire, organised industrial action by employees of Laing O’Rourke Construction Australia P/L during the term of an enterprise agreement, in breach of s.417 of the FW Act – the Federal Court imposed a penalty of $6,700 on Mr Haire and $35,500 on the CEPU in relation to Mr Haire’s conduct – in June 2016 the Director of the Fair Work Building Industry Inspectorate (the Director) applied to the Commission under s.507(1)(a) for a condition to be imposed on Mr Haire’s entry permit – on 5 July 2016 Watson VP ordered that ‘a three month suspension be imposed, but that suspension be suspended’ – a matter of days after Watson VP’s order was issued, Simpson C issued his decision in JKC [[2016] FWC 536] – decision concerned an application for orders pursuant to s.505 against six respondents, including the CEPU and Mr Haire – application stemmed from a dispute that initially arose from a right of entry exercised by Mr Haire and two other officials – conduct of Mr Haire was inconsistent with his obligations under ss.491, 492 and 492A – Simpson C decided not to issue any orders – Mr Haire submitted that his entry permit should be renewed with the balance of the condition imposed by Watson VP ‘rolled over’ so that the ‘suspended suspension’ would remain in place for 12 months from the date that it was issued (5 July 2016) – role of Commission in matters such as this is concerned with the future conduct of the permit holder rather than punishing him or her for past misconduct – In the absence of Simpson C’s decision in JKC the Commission would have been content to ‘roll over’ the condition imposed by Watson VP with an expiry date of 5 July 2017 – Commission satisfied that Mr Haire’s permit should be renewed, but that a condition should be imposed – with the imposition of the condition, and having regard to all the permit qualification matters, Commission satisfied that Mr Haire was a fit and proper person to hold an entry permit. Communications, Electrical, Electronic, Energy, Information, Postal, Plumbing and Allied Services Union of Australia – Electrical, Energy and Services Division – Queensland and Northern Territory Divisional Branch

ENTERPRISE AGREEMENTS – dispute about matter arising under agreement – ss.604, 739 Fair Work Act 2009 – appeal – Full Bench – appeal against decision of Commission that Coles had the ability to unilaterally decline to increase the base wage rate value it used in its Incentive Scheme calculations in line with the negotiated wage increases in the Coles Kewdale Distribution Centre WA Agreement 2014 – Commission held that Coles did not revise form and structure of the Scheme – clause 20.8.2 of Agreement permits the Commission to grant leave to appeal if matter of such importance that leave should be granted – leave to appeal granted given history of clause 10 of Agreement, Incentive Scheme and potential impact of the decision of Coles on the employees – Full Bench held that the words ‘form and structure’ in clause 10 have a plain and ordinary meaning – ‘form’ refers to shape or appearance of Scheme and ‘structure’ refers to constituent parts or inputs arranged together to compose the Scheme – determined that structure is comprised of two inputs, performance percentage and monetary value, both variable – no evidence that the monetary value input was anything other than the amount of an employee’s prevailing base wage – variable nature of performance measurement tools was an inherent feature of Scheme – held that Coles’ decision to change monetary value input from a variable amount to a permanently fixed amount amounted to a revision of the structure of the Scheme and therefore prior consultation with team members was required before change effected – not contested that consultation did not occur – Full Bench consider that Commission erroneously concluded that the decision announced by Coles on 4 May 2015 was not a revision to the form and structure of the Incentive Scheme contrary to clause 10 of Agreement – appeal upheld – decision at first instance quashed. Appeal by Hutchings against decision of Bull DP of 29 July 2016 [[2016] FWC 4050] Re: Coles Group Supply Chain P/L t/a Coles Kewdale Distribution Centre

ENTERPRISE AGREEMENTS – termination of agreement – s.225 Fair Work Act 2009 – application by AGL Loy Yang P/L for termination of the Loy Yang Power Enterprise Agreement 2012 – nominal expiry date of Agreement was 31 December 2015 – application was opposed by the Construction, Forestry, Mining and Energy Union (CFMEU), the Australian Municipal, Administrative, Clerical and Services Union (ASU), the Communications, Electrical, Electronic, Energy, Information, Postal, Plumbing and Allied Services Union of Australia (Electrical Trades Union of Victoria branch) (ETU) and the Association of Professional Engineers, Scientists and Managers, Australia (Professionals Australia) – Agreement covers about 578 employees at the Loy Yang A Power Station (Station) and adjacent open cut brown coal Loy Yang Mine (Mine) at Traralgon in Victoria – AGL Loy Yang cited a range of provisions in the Agreement it claims unduly restricts its ability to make changes to its operations to increase productivity and reduce inefficiencies – Loy Yang commenced negotiations for a new agreement with Unions in July 2015 – in April 2016 AGL Loy Yang filed a bargaining dispute application under s.240 of FW Act, followed almost immediately by the CFMEU’s application under s.229 for bargaining orders – s.240 process is ongoing – Commission declined to make the orders sought by the CFMEU [[2016] FWC 3376] – in May 2016 the CFMEU made application for a protected action ballot order (PABO) under s.437 – application dismissed because Commission not satisfied at that time that the CFMEU had been or was genuinely trying to reach agreement [[2016] FWC 4364] – appeal by CFMEU about decision dismissed by Full Bench [[2016] FWCFB 6332] – in September 2016 the CFMEU made further application for a PABO under s.437 – application was heard, determined and granted by Commission [[2016] FWC 7839] – AGL Loy Yang has stated it will continue to bargain in good faith for a new agreement in the event the Agreement is terminated – for a period of three months following the termination AGL Loy Yang will maintain certain conditions from the Agreement it says are significantly more beneficial than the Electrical Power Industry Award 2010 minimum terms and conditions – Commission must terminate the Agreement if satisfied that it is not contrary to the public interest to do so and consider it appropriate to do so taking into account all the circumstances, including the views of the employees, AGL Loy Yang, the CFMEU and the other Unions and their circumstances, including the likely effect the termination will have on each of them – Aurizon adopted – Kellogg applied – Commission satisfied it was not contrary to the public interest to terminate the Agreement – satisfied that the dispute is intractable as things currently stand – Commission persuaded that a change in the status quo through the termination of the Agreement will better support good faith bargaining for a new agreement that delivers productivity benefits – termination of the Agreement will change the bargaining dynamic but this is not counter to the object of a fair framework for collective bargaining and facilitating good faith bargaining [Aurizon] – Commission accepted there was opposition to the termination of the Agreement from the Employees – found this was not insignificant and their concern at the prospect of diminished terms and conditions of employment compared to the ones they currently enjoy was understandable – after taking into account all the circumstances Commission found it was appropriate to terminate the Agreement – termination will take effect on and from 30 January 2017. Loy Yang Power Enterprise Agreement 2012

TERMINATION OF EMPLOYMENT – misconduct – s.394 Fair Work Act 2009 – application for relief from unfair dismissal – applicant required to travel with another employee in a council truck to perform their work – vehicle applicant was driving was involved in a collision – vehicle was impacted by a sedan that disobeyed a give way/stop sign – applicant directed to take a drug and alcohol test which returned a positive result – applicant notified of result the same day – suspended immediately with pay – applicant conceded he had used cannabis three days before accident – applicant advised urine sample would be sent for further analysis – disputed he was told sample would be sent for second or confirmatory test – further analysis determined positive result for cannabis – applicant dismissed on grounds of serious misconduct – respondent drug and alcohol policy demands a zero count for a drug analysis test – Commission found respondent had a valid reason for dismissal, however applicant was not provided with an opportunity to respond to the respondent’s reasons for dismissal – failure to give an employee dismissed for drug use an opportunity to respond to the reasons for termination would not have any bearing on the outcome of the disciplinary process [Hafer v Ensign Australia] – in circumstances where a dismissal for misconduct has been found to be justified, it will be rare for a defect in an internal disciplinary process preceding the dismissal to justify a conclusion that the dismissal was harsh, unjust or unreasonable [Farquharson v Qantas Airways Ltd] – Commission held that even if respondent formally put result to the applicant, and that such should lead to his dismissal, no explanation from applicant would alter the outcome of the matter – found seriousness of applicant’s actions outweighed the procedural faults of the respondent – found applicant not unfairly dismissed – application dismissed. Albert v Alice Springs Town Council

ENTERPRISE BARGAINING – majority support determination – s.236 Fair Work Act 2009 – respondent not yet agreed to bargain or initiated bargaining for agreement proposed by NUW – Commission satisfied majority of workers wished to bargain five months in advance of nominal expiry date of agreement – decided to conduct ballot to determine majority or not – employer provided notice – Commission requested that particular sentences in notice be replaced – Commission concerned that current wording would discourage employees from participating in vote which would be contrary to the decision of the Commission to seek views of employees – respondent rejected request to make changes – disagreed there were errors in notice – Commission proposed to issue a direction for the issue of the notice in the form proposed – if respondent persisted with proposal, Commission proposed to issue further directions to allow applicant opportunity to respond to material circulated by the company as part of procedures directed by the Commission – matter listed for hearing – respondent did not attend hearing – actions of company in publishing partisan notice discouraged employees from voting ‘yes’ – Commission doubted that ballot would be appropriate and effective method for determining question – issued that respondent reissue notice with the following amendments ‘This notice replaces earlier notices concerning the vote. This notice is issued at the direction of the Fair Work Commission’ – NUW to provide Commission with text of the notice instead – respondent able to provide comments – Commission will advise respondent on distribution of notice. National Union of Workers v Coldunit P/L

TERMINATION OF EMPLOYMENT – misconduct – s.394 Fair Work Act 2009 – application for relief from unfair dismissal – applicant employed as Product Handler – performed two unsafe forklift manoeuvres on 3 December 2015 which resulted in incident forms and a subsequent formal meeting – also knocked a pallet of cornice off the truck when unloading pallets on 18 December 2015 where he nearly hit the truck jockey – on two occasions applicant was also found not wearing his safety glasses in contravention of work site PPE regulations – Commission found alleged incidents occurred and were in breach of policies that the applicant either knew or should have known – found failure to display contrition for breaches, or acknowledge the seriousness of incidents, led to a valid reason for termination – termination not harsh, unjust or unreasonable – applicant was warned that repeated breaches of safety could result in termination – found dismissal was not disproportionate to the gravity of the misconduct – application dismissed. Palmer v USG Boral Building Products P/L

ENTERPRISE AGREEMENTS – approval – valid vote – s.185 Fair Work Act 2009 – application by Stramit Corporation P/L t/a Stramit Building Products to approve single enterprise agreement – three employees did not vote in secret ballot – employer called the employees to ask which way they were going to vote – Commission satisfied that the three votes may well have affected the outcome of the ballot – unlikely that a vote which is exercised contrary to the notice of the time and place at which the vote will occur, and the voting method which will be used, can be regarded as a valid vote – held the three votes exercised were directly contrary to the notified secret ballot method, time limits and locations – Commission not satisfied s.182(1) of FW Act met – not satisfied Agreement genuinely agreed to by employees – application dismissed. Stramit Building Products Maddington Enterprise Agreement 2016

ENTERPRISE AGREEMENTS – dispute about matter arising under agreement – s.739 Fair Work Act 2009 – application for dispute under CBH Kwinana Plant Operators Collective Union Agreement 2013 – applicant alleged respondent did not comply with consultation about change clause in enterprise agreement when engaging 11 additional casual employees as plant operators – casuals employed for peak harvest period – applicant also sought status quo remain until dispute resolved ie additional casuals employment to be on hold – applicant argued employment of additional casuals would reduce opportunity for existing employees to work overtime and full time hours – respondent contended employment of casuals is part of ordinary course of business not a workplace change – respondent had historically always recruited casual employees without consulting existing employees – Commission did not issue interim orders as applicant could not prove an arguable case – applicant would not suffer prejudice that cannot be remedied by damages – did not prove on balance of convenience favours making the orders sought – orders sought go beyond the scope of the dispute – Commission considered original employees cannot be required to work additional hours – employees’ acceptance of hours is voluntary – employees restricted in working additional hours due to fatigue management policy – Commission determined consequences of issuing orders weighs more against respondent – no decision made with respect to status quo provision – interim orders not issued. The Maritime Union of Australia v Co-operative Bulk Handling Ltd t/a CBH Group