NEWS HR

TERMINATION OF EMPLOYMENT – contract for specified term – 457 visa – s.394 Fair Work Act 2009 – application for unfair dismissal remedy – applicant employed as a carpenter – contract of employment subject to 457 visa approval – 457 visa approved 13 September 2012 – during employment the applicant submitted he suffered some abuse as his supervisor tried to slap his face in 2015 and in November 2015 yelled at him after leaving work early and threatened to dismiss him – 457 visa set to expire 13 September 2016 – on 23 July 2016 applicant enquired as to whether his 457 visa would be extended – Commission satisfied neutral response was provided advising this was a decision for the respondent’s directors – respondent submitted directors did not intend to apply for an extension as no shortage of local carpenters – on 31 July 2016 respondent advised applicant via letter that it would not be making an application for extension of his visa and that they were terminating his employment that day with pay in lieu of notice to 1 August 2016 – applicant submitted he was dismissed for being more skilled than his supervisor and that he did not accept his poor treatment – Commission found no evidence applicant’s supervisor had any influence over or involvement in respondent’s decision to dismiss applicant – respondent submits that the reason for dismissal was that the respondent could not legally employ the applicant beyond 13 September 2016 when his visa expired – Commission found respondent had good reasons why this was neither necessary nor was it likely to be successful even if they had made such an application for an extension of his visa – found respondent was not required to apply for an extension of his visa – respondent had had no capacity to employ applicant after his visa expired – Commission found reason for dismissal was sound, defensible and well founded and thus was a valid reason for applicant’s dismissal – however Commission found no valid reason for early termination on 1 August 2016 – applicant could have remained employed until visa expiry on 13 September 2016 – respondent provided no explanation for reason for early termination – found premature ending of employment denied the applicant three weeks’ wages and only to that extent his dismissal was harsh – Commission satisfied applicant unfairly dismissed – reinstatement inappropriate – compensation appropriate – anticipated period of employment until expiration of visa on 13 September 2016 – order issued for payment three weeks wages. Austria v MCPBB P/L t/a Modern Joinery

TERMINATION OF EMPLOYMENT – extension of time – s.394 Fair Work Act 2009 – two applications for relief from unfair dismissal – both applicants claimed they were dismissed by respondent – respondent claimed applicants abandoned employment – applicants were offered new contracts with reduced wages, neither of which was signed – applicants have limited English language skills – applicants informed through interpreter on 31 May 2016 that unless contract was signed they were not to attend work the following day – applicants have not attended work since – applicants claimed they were awaiting instructions from the respondent to return to work – respondent claimed to have posted letter on 7 June 2016 requesting the applicants to explain their absence and advised that if no explanation is received their absence will be considered as an act of termination of employment – Union representative sent email to respondent on 10 June 2016 seeking to reimburse applicant’s lost wages and advise when they can return to work – respondent responded that they would look into it – respondent sent second letter to applicants on 13 June 2016 requesting an explanation for their absence – applicants claim that had not received both letters – applicants became aware that their employment had terminated on 4 August 2016 while pursuing claims for lost wages against respondent in WAIRC – subsequently applicants made unfair dismissal applications on 18 August 2016 – Commission satisfied applicants were not aware that respondent had considered them to have abandoned employment – doubt as to whether letters and other correspondence were received by the applicants – satisfied that even if letters were received, applicants possessed limited English language skills to read and respond to – satisfied that applicant’s legal and union representative were not aware of the letters and that their client’s employment had been considered terminated – Nulty considered – Commission satisfied that only communication to applicants in Chinese was text of 31 May 2016 – found that even if dismissal took effect from 31 May 2016, respondent took no action to provide the applicants with their final wages or separation certificate – found it unusual that respondent ignored union representative and only advised applicant’s lawyer that they considered the applicants to have abandoned employment four weeks after receipt of application to the WAIRC – satisfied exceptional circumstances existed – extensions of time granted. Liang and Anor v H’VAR Steel services

ENTERPRISE BARGAINING – protected action ballot – s.437 Fair Work Act 2009 – two applications for protected action ballot orders in relation to certain employees – both applications heard together – whether unions have been, and are, genuinely trying to reach agreement with employer – employer objected on basis that unions not genuinely trying to reach agreement as refused to revise log of claims and pursuing non-permitted terms during bargaining – claimed that were previously genuinely trying to reach agreement but since 16 November 2016 have not – no dispute between parties otherwise – Commission satisfied on evidence in statutory declaration provided requirement for protected action ballot orders sought by unions met – whether unions have been, and are, genuinely trying to reach an agreement question of fact to be decided having regard to all of the facts and circumstances of the particular case [Esso Australia] – no specific stage must be reached in negotiations in order for there to be finding that unions are, and have been, genuinely trying to reach an agreement with employer [HJ Heinz Company Australia] – both sides put their bargaining positions to the other in November 2016 – significant gap between bargaining positions adopted by each party – Commission rejected employer’s contention unions not genuinely trying to reach agreement and protected action ballot order applications premature – evidence unions responded quickly to written communications with employer and requested counter offer to their log of claims – fact that unions did not comply with employer’s request to submit revised log of claims did not amount to not genuinely trying to reach agreement – employer claimed three out of nine claims made by unions about non-permitted matters – unions claim for incorporation of terms and conditions of Building Award – unions claim for casual employees to automatically become full-time after two weeks – unions claim for employees to be covered by Coverforce sickness, accident and top-up workers compensation insurance – employer did not identify any particular term or condition of Building Award which it contended was not about permitted matter, and second two claims found to pertain to relationship between employer and its employees – Commission found three claims not about non-permitted matters – even if contrary were to be found, Commission held unions would still be genuinely trying to reach agreement with employer as employer of employees who were to be balloted based on communications between parties – s.437 of FW Act satisfied – Commission must make protected action ballot order – orders issued. Australian Workers’ Union and Anor v Telum (QLD) P/L t/a Telum

An application by the Country Fire Authority (s.240 – Application to deal with a bargaining dispute) will be heard by Commissioner Wilson in the Fair Work Commission 11 Exhibition Street Melbourne at 10am today.

Nineteen unfair dismissal/labour contract applications will be heard by the Fair Work Commission today. The full list is: Police Citizens Youth Club NSW Ltd (Nicholls), Staples Australia Pty Ltd (Rogers, Williams, Wu), Australian Federal Police (Hackett), Nobis Australia Pty Ltd (Kohler), Toll Ipec Pty Ltd (Scott), Steve Jarvin Motors Pty Ltd (Al-Khalil), Holcim (Australia) Pty Ltd (West), Alsco Pty Limited (Lakiss), Allianz Insurance Australia (Rogers), Coles Supermarkets (Price), Waterfind Australia (Sevilla), Green Mountain Food Processing (Abraham), TNT Australia Pty Ltd (Pryke), Fifty Five Trading Trust (Winnin), Red Spot Rentals Group Management Pty Ltd (Claymore-behan), Monadelphous Engineering Pty Ltd (Mirabella), Simon Transport Pty Ltd (O’Brien).

ENTERPRISE AGREEMENTS – dispute about matter arising under agreement – s.739 Fair Work Act 2009 – application for Commission to deal with a dispute pursuant to the terms of the Peabody Energy Australia Coppabella Enterprise Agreement 2013 (the Agreement) – the Agreement provided for aggregated remuneration (termed Total Fixed Remuneration or TFR) based on continuous even time rosters and for review of remuneration when rosters were amended – whether methodology adopted by the applicant to disaggregate the TFR for the purposes of calculating remuneration following changes to rosters was appropriate – respondent did not accept methodology adopted by applicant and contended the Agreement prohibited applicant from adopting a methodology based on the Black Coal Industry Mining Award 2010 (the Award) – respondent contended that in adopting an Award based methodology the applicant was making an extra claim, contrary to the term of the Agreement – the Agreement did not provide a methodology by which a review of the base salary and/or roster allowances was to be conducted – applicant developed methodology – to review the TFR Commission found it necessary to deconstruct it – methodology proposed by respondent would have resulted in situation where all hours, regardless of when worked, would be paid at the same hourly rate – respondent’s approach inconsistent with the manner in which the TFR was originally constructed and with the contextual background in which it was developed – Commission did not accept respondent’s contention that applicant made extra claim contrary to the Agreement – methodology adopted by applicant consistent with the terms of the Agreement and intent of the parties – determination of issues in dispute not simply an interpretation of the Agreement – determination required exercise of Commission’s broad discretion and consideration of fairness – approached consideration of issues on basis that its’ role was not to place itself in the shoes of the parties but to objectively consider the matters having regard to the rights of employers to manage their businesses in a manner that promotes productivity and flexibility and the rights of employees to resist having an unfair, unreasonable, inflexible or unsafe outcome imposed on them [Bundaberg Sugar] – appropriate base ordinary hourly rate to be used for the purposes of the review methodology is the rate calculated with reference to the methodology proposed by applicant – half of the non-rostered overtime rate applied to calculated hours in accordance with the Award. Peabody Energy Australia Coal P/L t/a Peabody Energy Australia PCI Mine Management P/L v Construction, Forestry, Mining and Energy Union and Anor

MODERN AWARDS – 4 yearly review – s.156 Fair Work Act 2009 – modern awards divided into four groups for the purpose of the award stage of the 4 yearly review (Review) – initial conference for the 19 Group 2 awards held on 23 October 2014 – Group 2 awards further divided into sub-groups – conference held on 2 December 2014 to identify the variations sought to these awards – exposure drafts for Group 2 awards published in December 2014 – Group 2 exposure drafts amended and republished in accordance with decisions on general drafting and technical issues common to multiple exposure drafts – technical and drafting issues in the Group 2 awards, along with a number of changes sought by parties (other than substantive changes requiring extensive evidence) dealt with in this decision – each award under Review in Group 2 considered – further revised exposure drafts for Group 2 awards (incorporating the changes outlined in this decision and any determinations arising from the Annual leave and Award flexibility common issues proceedings) will be published in the week commencing 17 October 2016 – parties asked to provide feedback on the revised exposure drafts by 5.00 pm on Friday 18 November 2016 – feedback to be submitted in writing to [email protected] – Review is an iterative process and parties will continue to be given further opportunities to comment on revised exposure drafts and any further proposals to vary provisions in modern awards – review of each award not considered complete until the final determinations are issued for that award. 4 yearly review of modern awards-Group 2

ENTERPRISE AGREEMENTS – approval – ss.180, 185, 604 Fair Work Act 2009 – permission to appeal – Full Bench – appellant contended Commission erred at first instance in concluding employer complied with s.180(2) of FW Act prior to employees voting – contended permission to appeal should be granted, appeal upheld and employer’s application be subject to rehearing – further contended requirements in ss.186 and 188 be reconsidered along with compliance with s.180(2) – appellant submitted first approval decision did not deal with policies of mine operators as well as labour hire company nor with failure to provide industry codes of practice – submitted reliance on undertaking an error and that it was for employer to satisfy that s.180(2) was complied with, not appellant having to satisfy that s.180(2) was not complied with – employer did not deny errors contended by appellant – submitted employees had access to documentation in variety of ways – McDonalds and NTEIU considered – Full Bench satisfied Commission erred in consideration of whether s.180(2) had been complied with – permission to appeal granted – additional factual matters emerged during appeal – Full Bench decided in public interest for Commissioner Spencer to rehear and reconsider requirements of ss.186 and 188 – allowed parties to adduce further evidence if necessary – once re-heard matter to be returned to Full Bench for further orders as may be necessary. Appeal by Construction, Forestry, Mining and Energy Union against decisions of Spencer C of 5 July 2016 [[2016] FWC 3100] and 6 July 2016 [[2016] FWCA 4528] Re: Sparta Mining Services P/L