ENTERPRISE AGREEMENTS – dispute about matter arising under agreement – ss.604, 739 Fair Work Act 2009 – appeal – Full Bench – Commission granted extension of time for Broadspectrum to lodge appeal – at first instance the Commission found it had had jurisdiction to arbitrate a dispute between Mr Crawford and Broadspectrum Australia P/L under the Transfield Services Limited (Maintenance Services – Wyee) Collective Agreement 2011 – 2015 where Mr Crawford was no longer an employee of Broadspectrum – also found Mr Crawford not entitled to overtime for training attended during overtime hours – the Construction, Forestry, Mining and Energy Union (CFMEU) and Broadspectrum lodged respective appeals against parts of the decision at first instance – Broadspectrum’s appeal concerned Commission’s jurisdiction to arbitrate the dispute – at first instance Commissioner decided Commission had jurisdiction to hear dispute [Jajoo], notwithstanding Mr Crawford was no longer an employee of Broadspectrum – Full Bench of the view that Broadspectrum’s submissions concerning the Commission’s jurisdiction raised important questions pertaining to rights arising from enterprise agreements – on this basis permission to appeal with respect to the dispute over jurisdiction was granted – whether, pursuant to s.739 of FW Act, the Commission has the jurisdiction to deal with a dispute concerning a former employee – if an employee agitates a claim arising under an enterprise agreement while employed, the Commission has the jurisdiction to deal with the dispute, even after that employee’s relationship with the employer is terminated [Jajoo, Wollongong] – Full Bench do not need to adhere to precedent of Jajoo and Wollongong – should only depart from precent if persuaded sufficient reason to do so – Full Bench not persuaded findings in Patrick Projects and Kentz there was sufficient reason to depart from Jajoo and Wollongong – not persuaded Commission erred in its jurisdiction when finding dispute was to be arbitrated by the Commission – found terms of Agreement did not oust the jurisdiction of the Commission to deal with the dispute – satisfied Commission has jurisdiction to deal with dispute – CFMEU’s appeal regarding whether compulsory training is to be deemed ‘work’ within the meaning of Agreement and whether Mr Crawford entitled to overtime pay – Agreement provides that overtime rates will be paid for ‘work’ that is performed outside ordinary hours – if training constitutes ‘work’ then training in overtime attracts overtime pay – at first instance Commission found that training was not ‘work’ and that training conducted outside of ordinary hours did not attract overtime pay – whether the Commission erred in finding that training was not ‘work’ for the purposes of the Agreement – Full Bench believed appeal raised important questions of construction and interpretation of Agreement – held dispute matter of public interest – permission to appeal granted – grounds of appeal included that the Agreement contained no definition of ‘work’ or ‘training’ which created ambiguity; and that the decisions relied on by the Commission turned upon their own facts which were distinguishable to those before the Commission at first instance – Full Bench found that Excelior was distinguishable to the present case – Golden Cockerel considered – Full Bench considered an employee who attends training at the direction of his or her employer outside of ordinary hours is carrying out ‘work’ and is entitled to overtime remuneration – appeal upheld – decision at first instance quashed – held Mr Crawford is entitled to overtime remuneration for the training that he undertook outside of ordinary hours. Appeal by Construction, Forestry, Mining and Energy Union against decision in transcript of Saunders C of 2 September 2016 Re: Broadspectrum Australia P/L
January 24, 2017
ENTERPRISE AGREEMENTS – dispute about matter arising under agreement – ss.604, 739 Fair Work Act 2009 – appeal – Full Bench – appellant employed as Locomotive Driver – passed signal at red and was subject to disciplinary action by respondent – appellant lodged application for Commission to deal with dispute arising under the Aurizon (Western Australia) Rail Operations Enterprise Agreement 2014 (Agreement) disputing nature and extent of the disciplinary action – Commission at first instance held any determination that would reverse or alter disciplinary action taken would be inconsistent with the Agreement and s.739(5) of the FW Act – appellant contended Commission’s construction of s.739(5) was erroneous and the provision did not oust the Commission’s jurisdiction to deal with disputes – Commission will grant permission to appeal only if it is in the public interest to do so – GlaxosmithKline applied – Full Bench satisfied appeal raised important questions concerning application of s.739(5) – permission to appeal granted – s.739(5) does not alter the character of the arbitration which the Commission undertakes under an enterprise agreement [Endeavour Energy] – held provision did not limit Commission’s jurisdiction in dealing with a dispute about the terms of an agreement but may impact on the nature of remedy – found Commission at first instance had jurisdiction to deal with dispute – appeal upheld – first instance decision quashed – matter remitted to Williams C for determination. Appeal by Lloyd against decision of Williams C of 12 August 2016 [[2016] FWC 5568] Re: Australia Western Railroad P/L t/a ARG an Aurizon Company
January 24, 2017
TERMINATION OF EMPLOYMENT – termination at initiative of employer – abandonment of employment – ss.136, 137, 604 Fair Work Act 2009 – appeal – Full Bench – at first instance Commission dismissed appellant’s unfair dismissal application – found appellant had abandoned his employment – grounds for appeal that Commission misapplied clause 21 of Manufacturing Award in concluding award operated to automatically terminate employment – submitted clause 21 not a permitted or required term of modern award – that contrary to s.136 FW Act and by reason of s.137, term has no effect – also submitted term objectionable because it required or permitted dismissal in contravention of s.352 – Full Bench persuaded appellant made out case of error on at least one of the bases underpinning first ground of appeal – held error of the type described in House v The King in that decision-maker acted on wrong principle – permission to appeal granted – clause 21 did not have effect of automatically terminating employment – an employee deemed to have abandoned employment within meaning of clause 21 does not mean employee’s employment was thereby at an end – employer must take additional step of terminating employment – employment continues if it does not do so – employment did not come to an end by operation of statute [Mahoney] – no automatic termination of appellant’s employment under clause 21 – conduct of employer reinforced fact that termination occurred on employer’s initiative – even if clause 21 operated in manner determined by Commission, it had no effect because clause 21 was neither permitted nor a required term of a modern award – term had no effect by virtue of s.137 – Full Bench did not accept submission of employer that term was ancillary or incidental to operation or Division 11 or that it supplemented national employment standards, pursuant to s.55(4) – provision in award which would operate to automatically terminate employment cannot reasonably be described as ancillary or incidental to operation of a provision which deals with obligations of an employer when employer seeks to terminate employee’s employment – found termination at employer’s initiative – jurisdictional objection of employer dismissed – appeal upheld – application remitted to O’Callaghan SDP for hearing and determination. Appeal by Bienias against decision of O’Callaghan SDP of 17 October 2016 [[2016] FWC 6624] re: Iplex Pipelines Australian P/L t/a Iplex Pipelines Australia
January 24, 2017
INDUSTRIAL ACTION – order against industrial action – ss.418, 604 Fair Work Act 2009 – appeal – Full Bench – at first instance the Commission made an order in relation to alleged unprotected industrial action taken by employees of Delta Coal Mining P/L (Delta Coal) engaged at the Appin mine site in New South Wales operated by South32 Ltd – grounds for appeal included that Commission erred in making the order in circumstances where he could not be satisfied that there were current employees of Delta Coal at the South32’s Appin coal mine taking industrial action at the time the order was made; that the Commission erred in making the order by taking into account extraneous or irrelevant matters, mistaking the facts and not taking into account material considerations in finding that he was satisfied that current employees of Delta Coal at the Appin mine were taking industrial action at the time the order was made; and that the order was not valid because it exceeded the power available under s.418 of the FW Act to make an order – on 20 December clause 3.2 of the Order was stayed pending the hearing and determination of the appeal [PR588831] – Full Bench not satisfied the Commission made any error of the requisite kind in finding that there was a continuing employment relationship between Delta Coal and the employees at the Appin coal mine – however Full Bench satisfied that the Order made at first instance was in certain respects beyond power – Full Bench grant permission to appeal the Order on this basis only and will vary it so as to bring it within the Commission’s jurisdiction – MUA v Patrick Stevedores considered – alleged lack of specificity in the Order – definition of ‘Industrial Action’ restricted – clause 3.2 of the Order deleted – at clause 3.3 obligations are imposed being that the CFMEU its officers, employees, agents and delegates and the employees to immediately stop organising and refrain from organising any industrial action involving any of the employees – at clause 3.3(b) of the Order the CFMEU its officers, employees, agents and delegates and the employees must additionally not organise, aid, abet, direct, procure, induce, advise, authorise or encourage any employee to engage in industrial action and not facilitate any industrial action by any employee – found detail is unnecessary – additional obligations removed in the absence of any demonstrated necessity for their inclusion – Full Bench quashed those clauses of the Order that were found to be beyond power and issued an amended Order. Appeal by Construction, Forestry, Mining and Energy Union against order of Sams DP of 16 December 2016 [PR588682] Re: Delta Coal Mining P/L
January 24, 2017
TERMINATION OF EMPLOYMENT – costs – ss.394, 400A, 611 Fair Work Act 2009 – application by respondent for costs – respondent alleged applicant acted unreasonably in continuing to deny conduct proven by evidence of witnesses and refusing settlement offers – applicant’s position was that he was seeking to clear his name and sought reinstatement – Commission found dismissing an application was not a foundation for awarding costs – not satisfied it was initially apparent to applicant that his case was groundless – found that applicant should pay costs from the time of his refusal of the second settlement offer, when it was reasonably apparent his case had no reasonable prospect of success, to the conclusion of the merits hearing – parties ordered to agree on amount and payment method. Applicant v Respondent
January 24, 2017
TERMINATION OF EMPLOYMENT – extension of time – s.394 Fair Work Act 2009 – application for unfair dismissal remedy lodged 11 months and 7 days outside the statutory 21 day time limit – reasons provided for delay were misleading legal advice, conduct of others, psychological and financial impacts, juggling two jobs and partner’s miscarriage – Nulty considered – while sympathetic to these circumstances the Commission found the applicant’s reasons for delay were not ‘exceptional circumstances’ to warrant granting an extension of time – extension of time refused. Costelloe v Origin Energy Resources Limited t/a Origin Energy
January 24, 2017
TERMINATION OF EMPLOYMENT – demotion – ss.386, 394 Fair Work Act 2009 – application for unfair dismissal remedy – applicant demoted from position as site manager due to failure to follow company policies – inability to communicate and inability to fulfil requirements of position – provided with new employment contract – applicant refused to accept demotion – alleged demotion constituted dismissal – alternatively alleged constructive dismissal by respondent – respondent submitted demotion did not result in dismissal because employment contract permitted demotion – submitted resignation voluntary – Commission considered applicant claiming forced resignation must show they had no real choice but resignation [Mohazab] – demotion of an employee, where that demotion is provided for in contract of employment or industrial instrument, cannot constitute, by itself, a dismissal [Moyle], [Singh] – while applicant’s demotion involved significant reduction in remuneration or duties for purposes of s.386(2)(c)(i) of FW Act, this section is an exception to general definition of dismissal in s.386(1) and will not apply if demotion is provided for in employment contract – necessary to consider s.386(1) – Commission found no intention to dismiss by respondent – respondent did not end employment relationship as it demoted applicant pursuant to employment contract – contract provided there was demotion in relation to performance – no repudiation of contract by respondent – found applicant resigned – Commission satisfied allegations against applicant substantiated and respondent’s investigation process satisfactory – applicant not forced to resign – resignation did not satisfy requirements of s.386(1)(b) – applicant not dismissed – application dismissed. Carter v MSS Security P/L
January 24, 2017
TERMINATION OF EMPLOYMENT – misconduct – s.394 Fair Work Act 2009 – application for unfair dismissal remedy – applicant had financial difficulties that led to depression and being certified unfit for work – unable to secure accommodation for family in Port Hedland – required support of family – respondent granted applicant discretionary leave which allowed temporary relocation to Perth as applicant had claimed investment property in Port Hedland was subject of a long term formal lease – applicant said that wife and children relocated to Perth so that children could undertake schooling in Perth – claimed that wife planned to return to live in Port Hedland when youngest child completed education – this differed from the information the applicant previously provided to respondent and to a medical practitioner assessing fitness to work that family moved to Perth because the family home was sold as a result of financial difficulties being experienced – had purchased the family home from the company under the Housing Ownership Scheme – company claimed to also uncover fraudulent claims for Annual Leave Travel Assistance – claimed applicant provided misleading information about own and family’s residential options and improperly claimed electricity subsidies – even if investment property was the principle place of residence for purposes of accessing electricity subsidies, not entitled to claim such subsidies for periods in which absent from Port Hedland – terminated employment – applicant admitted wife preferred schooling available in Perth and not forced to sell home due to financial difficulties – applicant obtained a benefit that would not have otherwise obtained – satisfied that conduct provided valid reason for dismissal – severely damaged respondent’s trust and confidence – applicant admitted to wilfully and knowingly obtaining benefits by deceit – Commission satisfied dismissal was not harsh, unjust or unreasonable – application dismissed. Adeley v BHP Billiton Iron Ore P/L