TERMINATION OF EMPLOYMENT – costs – application made out of time – ss.394, 402 Fair Work Act 2009 – applicant discontinued unfair dismissal application after the respondent made jurisdictional objections – respondent applied for costs against the applicant – costs application not made within 14 days of the matter being discontinued – Commission received evidence the reason for the delay in submitting the costs application was that the respondent’s in house counsel was in an accident and suffered concussion – the respondent argued an extension of time be granted – Commission held that unlike ss.366 and 394 of the FW Act, s.402 does not provide the Commission power to grant an extension of time – in circumstances where the costs application was lodged two days outside the 14 day time limit, the application for costs must be dismissed – application dismissed. Horgan v Spredfast Australia P/L
May 2, 2017
CASE PROCEDURES – procedural and interim decisions – workplace determination – ss.266, 590 Fair Work Act 2009 – Full Bench – the Australian Workers’ Union, the “Automotive, Food, Metals, Engineering, Printing and Kindred Industries Union” known as the Australian Manufacturing workers Union (AMWU) and the Communications, Electrical, Electronic, Energy, Information, Postal, Plumbing and Allied Services Union of Australia (collectively the Unions) sought order requiring Esso to provide copies of financial documents or records pursuant to s.590(2)(c) of the FW Act – parties currently involved in proceeding conducted pursuant to s.266 – Australian Nursing Federation v Victorian Hospitals’ Industrial Association adopted – Unions submitted that certain documents may set out Esso’s real financial position – Esso opposed production of the documents on the basis of relevance, oppressiveness and that proposed categories cover enormous array of documents – Commission granted order for production of specified annual statements as they were relevant to issues that will likely require determination in substantive proceeding and production would not be oppressive – refused order requiring production of specified loan documents as same evidence can be elicited through cross examination of Esso’s witnesses – refused order requiring production of specified documents evidencing proposal for a particular development as many of which are likely to be of no relevance to issues that will fall for determination and it is therefore oppressive – also not likely to shed any light on evidence regarding challenges for Esso in presenting a business case for capital investment – refused order requiring production of certain documents relating to annual take or pay volume, revenue and certain gas supply contracts on basis that production would be oppressive and annual statements ordered to be produced are likely to yield sufficient information regarding issues – granted order for production of specified forecasting reports as they were relevant, however documents to be produced are to be most current or recent of any report, analysis or paper in the identified period – refused order for production of certain contracts on basis that they were irrelevant and oppressive and may require disclosure of confidential contractual documents – Commission issued orders requiring production of documents falling within reformulated Categories 1 to 4 and Category 10 of the draft order (relating to specified annual statements and forecasting reports) but not otherwise. Esso Australia P/L v Australian Workers’ Union and Ors
May 2, 2017
ENTERPRISE AGREEMENTS – approval – undertakings – ss.185, 604 Fair Work Act 2009 – appeal – Full Bench – at first instance the Commission approved the CSRP Enterprise Agreement 2016 (the Agreement) after accepting undertakings proffered by respondent – appellant submitted three grounds of appeal – firstly, the Commission erred in being satisfied the Agreement was genuinely agreed to by employees covered by it – secondly, the Commission erred in being satisfied the terms of the Agreement did not contravene s.55 of the Fair Work Act – thirdly, the Commission erred in being satisfied the Agreement did not contain any unlawful terms – whether appellant had sufficient interest and connection to issue to be able to bring appeal – appellant was not a bargaining representative in relation to the Agreement and did not have a member who was employed by respondent when the Agreement was made – appellant contended it was aggrieved by decision because it had an interest beyond that of an ordinary member of the public and eligibility coverage under its rules – respondent submitted appellant did not have sufficient interest and connection to bring appeal because it did not show actual or apprehended impingement of its legal rights as result of first instance decision – Full Bench found appellant had requisite interest in first instance decision – CEPU v Main People applied – respondent’s challenge to appellant’s standing to bring appeal rejected – appellant’s appeal grounds considered – Full Bench not persuaded Commission at first instance erred in being satisfied the Agreement was genuinely agreed to – not persuaded that uncertainty or questionable legal efficacy in relation to term of an agreement is sufficient basis to doubt whether an agreement was genuinely agreed to – found there was sufficient information in respondent’s statutory declaration to support Commission’s finding of being satisfied the Agreement was genuinely agreed to – first ground of appeal rejected – appellant contended three provisions of the Agreement contravened s.55 – Full Bench found clause 5.5 of the Agreement would have effect of excluding an employee’s entitlement to be ‘paid annual leave’ and could exclude other NES entitlements – found clause 7.5 of the Agreement had the effect of excluding operation of ss.114(1) and (3) – found third paragraph of clause 8.1 of the Agreement was a term not permitted by s.55(4) – held clause was detrimental to employees because it denied employees full benefit of s.88 – clause did not contain one of the three requirements of permitted cashing out term as set out in s.93(2) – appellant contended clause 14 of the Agreement contained unlawful terms – Full Bench rejected this ground of appeal – Full Bench concluded appellant had made good the second ground of its appeal – permission to appeal granted – appeal upheld – decision to approve the Agreement quashed – respondent allowed 14 days from date of decision to provide any written undertaking it proposed. Appeal by Construction, Forestry, Mining and Energy Union against decision of Roe C of 9 December 2016 [[2016] FWCA 8835] Re: CSRP P/L
May 2, 2017
TERMINATION OF EMPLOYMENT – termination at initiative of employer – contract for a specific task – s.394 Fair Work Act 2009 – respondent labour hire company provided labour hire employees to businesses which include Placard P/L (Placard) – applicant paid by respondent as casual employee and generally worked regular and systematic hours with Placard – applicant injured wrist and took few days off work – applicant not rostered on for following week – respondent claimed not being rostered for that week was no way due to applicant’s injury but by needs of client – subsequent emails between applicant and respondent about work pointed strongly to attempts by respondent to further the employment relationship and offer applicant additional work – applicant accepted had work been offered in appropriate location, she would have accepted the work – applicant not pursuing those work opportunities was by no means respondent’s fault – employment was terminated not because of any act of the respondent – the act of ending the assignment was an act of Placard – Commission satisfied that applicant was not dismissed – no jurisdiction – application dismissed. Singh v Labourforce Impex Personnel P/L
May 2, 2017
TERMINATION OF EMPLOYMENT – performance – s.394 Fair Work Act 2009 – application for relief from unfair dismissal – applicant employed since 11 August 2014 and notified of dismissal on 1 September 2016 – respondent submitted an F3 stating applicant was terminated on 31 August 2016 because he refused to clean up unset concrete as instructed by his supervisor – respondent did not participate in the hearing – Commission found no valid reason for dismissal, no notification of a valid reason or an opportunity to respond – found the termination was harsh and unjust – ordered compensation of $12,433.60. Melim v Construction Staff NSW
May 2, 2017
TERMINATION OF EMPLOYMENT – incapacity – inherent requirements – s.394 Fair Work Act 2009 – applicant absent from workplace due to illness from September 2016 until termination in December 2016 – respondent dismissed applicant because absence from workplace no longer temporary and therefore applicant unable to perform inherent requirements of position – applicant submitted he could return to work if reasonable adjustments made by respondent – applicant’s medical practitioner proposed conference between parties be carried out to try and define issues and work out long term sustainable solution for applicant’s return to work – respondent rejected medical practitioners proposal – satisfied not reasonable for respondent to conclude that reasonable adjustments were not available without first responding to proposal made by applicant’s medical practitioner – satisfied it was premature to reach conclusion applicant unable to perform inherent requirements of job – no valid reason for dismissal – dismissal harsh and unjust – reinstatement inappropriate as relationship of trust and confidence between parties broken – $7,631.16 compensation less taxation ordered. Naeem v Boroondara City Council
May 1, 2017
The Fair Work Commission has twenty one unfair dismissal/employment dispute applications to hear today. The full list is: Shining Knight Facility Services (Reid), L.R. Enterprises Australia Pty Ltd (Clark), Aroona PT&T Pty Ltd (Colella), Mark Moran at Little Bay Pty Ltd (Gebremeskel), Terumo Australia Pty Limited (Havier), University of Sydney & Graham (Lum), Harbour Roof Tiling Pty Ltd (Raza), Pittwater High School P & C Association (Inc) (Groves), Cafe SA Pty Ltd (Kurda), Glenelg Financial Services Pty Ltd (Taylor), AO Tong Bao Pty Ltd (Palmer), Linfox Armaguard Pty Ltd (Borg), Crossmark Australia Pty Limited (Iurato), Beechworth Montessori Children’s Group Incorporated (Martin), Ikon Administration Pty Ltd (Tham), Ventura Buslines (Hill), Plantagenet Bakery (Barnes), Remote Fire (WA) Pty Ltd (Hayman), PCI Services Pty Ltd (Rose-Wilson), Aroona P&T Pty Ltd (Colella), The Commonwealth of Australia (Department of Immigration and Border Protection) (Gibbens).
April 28, 2017
The week finishes with 34 applications for employment relief in the Fair Work Commission. The full list includes: Futuris Automotive Interiors Pty Ltd (Illingworth), The C Hammick Family Trust & The Trustee for The Andrew Dean Family Trust (Kalioros), Citycoast Freight (Chaffey), Ventia Pty Ltd (Alvisio), Southern Star Road Pilots Pty Ltd (Gerchow), Jeanette Margaret Kennedy (Waldron), Football Brisbane Inc (Austin), Shandong Energy Co (Xu), Lifestyle Solutions (Aust) Ltd (Thompson), Dolci Firme Shoes (Biskup), Circa 1821 Admin Pty Ltd (Whitehead), The Trustee for Bartlett Family Trust (King), Monash University (Oliver), BlueScope Steel Limited (Willmot), Direct Fright Express Pty Limited (Shinan), Booth Transport Pty Ltd (Hourigan), 3D Scaffolding (Trialonas), Desago Real Estate Pty Ltd (Stevenson), Department of Education and Training (Adams), Volunteer Task Force Inc (Gillet), DDP Dream Design Property (Cavar), Millenium Hi Tech Group Pty Ltd (Kheir), Surfside Properties (Ulladulla) Pty Limited (McLennan), AAPC Properties Pty Limited (Janma), Mereweather Golf Club Ltd (Wilson), Weir Minerals Australia Ltd (Cohen), Kentz Pty Ltd (Ketchup, Weekley, Harbrow), Southern Star Road Pilots Pty Ltd (Gerchow), Regents on the Lake / Me-n-u Catering (Donovan), Federation University (Pallet), Neibo Real Estate Pty Ltd (Carlin-Smith), K&S Freighters Pty Ltd (Souter).