NEWS HR

TERMINATION OF EMPLOYMENT – misconduct – ss.394, 400, 604 Fair Work Act 2009 – appeal – Full Bench – Appellant dismissed following incident at work – Appellant was loading cornices onto a truck when the load dislodged and fell, almost hitting the truck jockey who had moved out of safe zone – Commission at first instance found Appellant’s dismissal was not unfair and dismissed the application – Full Bench found that the Commission made findings as to the Appellant’s acknowledgment of the seriousness of conduct but not findings as to the conduct itself – not open to the Commission to determine that there was valid reason for the dismissal – found the Commission erred in finding the Appellant did not properly report the near miss involving the jockey as the Commission had not made any findings as to the Appellant being aware of the near miss – held the Commission did not err in finding the Respondent’s safety policy was not applied inconsistently given Appellant had been on first and final warning and received number of requests to wear safety glasses – not satisfied errors relating to assessment that Appellant breached safety glasses policy or that Commission applied the incorrect question when determining whether Appellant’s conduct was sufficiently serious to support a finding of valid reason – satisfied appealable error in relation to two grounds of appeal in accordance with House v The King – permission to appeal granted – appeal upheld – application for unfair dismissal remedy referred to Cirkovic C for rehearing. Appeal by Palmer against decision of Cirkovic C of 9 January 2017 [[2017] FWC 147] Re: USG Boral Building Products P/L

TERMINATION OF EMPLOYMENT – misconduct – Small Business Fair Dismissal Code – s.394 Fair Work Act 2009 – jurisdictional decision found applicant was dismissed [[2017] FWC 543] – further proceeding to determine whether dismissal unfair – Small Business Fair Dismissal Code not complied with – no valid reason for dismissal – applicant not warned employment at risk – applicant not provided with opportunity to respond to any concerns about conduct or capacity – real reason for dismissal was breakdown in relationship between applicant and respondent’s son – respondent argued that if situation with applicant’s husband was ‘fixed’ then she could return to work – respondent then accused applicant of theft to justify dismissal – whether harsh, unjust or unreasonable – no valid reason – applicant not notified of (valid or invalid) reason for dismissal until day of dismissal – no opportunity to respond – no warnings about conduct or capacity – respondent claims long history in business and industry – not reflected in dismissal procedures – satisfied dismissal harsh, unjust and unreasonable – applicant unfairly dismissed – reinstatement inappropriate given bitter relationship between applicant and respondent – compensation considered – evidence applicant made considerable effort to mitigate loss whilst acting as principal carer for her five children – given family responsibilities, applicant unlikely to have resigned from job which afforded her considerable flexibility – estimated length of future employment at least six months – amount earned since dismissal deducted – no other deductions – added three weeks’ pay in lieu of notice – ordered compensation in amount of $29,714.30. Sirl v HK Group P/L t/a Buzzbee Long Day Care Centre – No.2

TERMINATION OF EMPLOYMENT – genuine redundancy – ss.394, 400, 604 Fair Work Act 2009 – permission to appeal – Full Bench – application for relief from unfair dismissal dismissed at first instance – appellant applied for permission to appeal two decisions relating to appellant’s application for unfair dismissal remedy – first decision decided no genuine redundancy – second decision did not find dismissal harsh, unfair or unreasonable – in second decision the Commission relied on findings made in first decision to support conclusions – Full Bench considered whether it was in public interest to grant permission to appeal – whether decision at first instance involved significant error of fact – Coal & Allied and GlaxoSmithKline applied – rarely appropriate to grant permission to appeal unless arguable case of appealable error is demonstrated [Wan] – Full Bench not persuaded that appellant’s grounds of appeal disclosed arguable case of error – permission to appeal refused. Appeal by Smith against decisions of Cloghan C of 25 August 2016 [[2016] FWC 5788] and 28 September 2016 [[2016] FWC 6861] Re: AWH P/L

ENTERPRISE BARGAINING – majority support determination – s.236 Fair Work Act 2009 – application for a majority support determination – Muswellbrook branch of Hitachi Construction Machinery (Australia) P/L (Hitachi) supplies mining and construction equipment and related services, parts and technical support – some employees work predominantly at service workshop at Muswellbrook branch but most spend significant time working at different coal mines around Hunter Region – Construction, Forestry, Mining and Energy Union (CFMEU) contends that 17 service employees of Hitachi who work at Liddell open cut coal mine (Liddell Mine) in Hunter Valley (Employees) are not covered by Hitachi Construction Machinery (Australia) P/L Service Enterprise Agreement 2014 (Agreement) and want to renegotiate their own agreement with Hitachi – applied for majority support determination in relation to Employees – parties requested that Commission determine whether the Agreement covered the Employees as a threshold issue in proceedings – CFMEU contended in order to be covered by Agreement, an employee must work and be based and perform work at the Hitachi Muswellbrook branch 190, 27-35 Thomas Mitchell Drive, Muswellbrook and perform work at other locations in accordance with the needs of business conducted from the Muswellbrook Hitachi branch – Hitachi contended that Agreement covered service employees engaged in Muswellbrook operations while they were performing work at service workshop, as well as site work – Golden Cockrell P/L considered – Commission found there was ambiguity or uncertainty in coverage clauses of Agreement concerning whether service employees must perform work at each of the locations referred to in CFMEU’s claim or whether they were covered if performed work either at service workshop or site location as contended for by Hitachi – Agreement must be construed as a whole – evident that part of service work undertaken by service employees is performed at workshop in Muswellbrook but other service work is undertaken ‘in the field’ – unsurprising given that Hitachi’s business involves sale and servicing of mining and construction equipment, much of which cannot easily be transported to workshop for servicing or repairs – under construction contended by CFMEU, employees would only begin to be covered by Agreement once undertaken work at Muswellbrook branch and some work at site location – as a result, employees would become covered by Agreement at different times – some employees would never become covered by the Agreement, some employees would become covered soon after commencing operation and other employees would only become covered in third or fourth year of Agreement when they undertook work in service workshop, having worked rest of the time at one or more mine sites – Commission found that Hitachi’s interpretation of coverage provisions of Agreement accorded with business common sense but CFMEU’s did not – Commission satisfied on evidence that each Employee was covered by Agreement because they were service employees (classifications 4S to 1S) who worked at Muswellbrook branch of Hitachi, based at 27-35 Thomas Mitchell Drive, Muswellbrook and who performed work in service workshop and/or in locations designated by the Muswellbrook branch from time to time – application dismissed. Construction, Forestry, Mining and Energy Union – Northern Mining and NSW Energy District v Hitachi Construction Machinery (Australia) P/L

TERMINATION OF EMPLOYMENT – misconduct – s.394 Fair Work Act 2009 – application for relief for unfair dismissal – respondent is a small business with only four employees – respondent argued the applicant was terminated for serious misconduct on the basis that she hit respondent with loose papers and failed to follow a lawful direction and leave the premises after terminated – applicant submitted she intervened in what she thought was a serious and possibly violent argument – submitted the respondent pushed her and attempted to remove her from her chair resulting in her falling backwards onto the floor and suffering injuries – Commission regarded the respondent’s behaviour as a serious breach of OH&S – Commission accepted that applicant struck the respondent on the shoulder in a non-threatening manner – Commission found actions of the respondent contrary to that of a model employer – Commission found the summary dismissal of the applicant was not in accordance with the Code – Commission found that as applicant did not act violently towards respondent, her actions did not constitute a valid reason for dismissal – both parties submitted employment relationship had irretrievably broken down – Commission found applicant’s actions constituted misconduct at the low end of the spectrum and discounted order for compensation by 5% – Commission found applicant was unfairly dismissed and order for compensation made. Ferla v C&V Engineering Co P/L t/a C&V Engineering Services P/L

TERMINATION OF EMPLOYMENT – costs – ss.394, 611 Fair Work Act 2009 – application by respondent for costs – applicant was employed as Production Team Leader with respondent prior to termination on 11 July 2016 – application for relief from unfair dismissal lodged by applicant was dismissed on 3 October 2016 – respondent submitted that the application was made vexatiously, without reasonable cause and had no reasonable prospects of success because it was lodged outside of 21 days without explanation for the delay; applicant was a casual employee; and applicant was dismissed for serious misconduct – respondent further submitted the applicant provided misleading information on the application by stating the date of dismissal took effect on 22 July 2016 rather than the actual date of 11 July 2016 – respondent claimed $1980.00 incurred in legal costs – s.611 FW Act considered – Commission satisfied that application was not made vexatiously as applicant believed that he was entitled to payment in lieu of notice based on letter sent in error from respondent and that the effective date of dismissal was, therefore, at end of notice period on 22 July 2016 – applicant took advice from employment law centre to lodge a remedy for unfair dismissal claim – Commission satisfied there were no circumstances in which it was reasonably apparent to applicant that the application was unlikely to be successful, particularly since the effective date of dismissal was disputed – application for costs dismissed. Brown v Kingskipp P/L atf the RJ King Family Trust t/a Gateway Printing

ENTERPRISE AGREEMENTS – dispute about matter arising under agreement – s.739 Fair Work Act 2009 – application to deal with a dispute arising under the CBH Kwinana Plant Operators Collective Union Agreement 2013 (the Agreement) – respondent decided to engage 11 additional casual employees to work as Plant Operators – applicant contended respondent was required to but did not comply with clause 34 Consultation about Change (Consultation clause) of Agreement before engaging casual employees – respondent argued Consultation clause did not apply in the circumstances – issue whether Consultation clause in Agreement applied in the particular circumstances and whether there was an obligation to consult – applicant contended engaging additional casual employees was a change in the organisation of labour or to the structure of the workforce and was a ‘significant effect’ – further argued change would result in diminution of opportunities to work overtime for some existing employees – respondent contended applicant’s interpretation of Consultation clause was strained, oversimplified and pedantic – argued ‘change’ meant an act or process through which something becomes different – noted it had a casual pool of employees available to perform work on a casual basis and had a long history of engaging casual employees during busy periods – argued therefore engagement of casual employees was not a ‘change’ through which its business became different but a continuation of a system that pre-dated the Agreement – construction of Consultation clause – Commission held not all likely changes to composition or size of a workforce will be likely to have a significant effect – held if the clause was to mean obligation to consult applied when there was a change that had any effect on employees, the word ‘significant’ would not have been used – use of ‘significant’ twice in clause cannot be ignored – onus on applicant to provide evidence to support its application – Commission found no evidence that between when new casual employees began work at end of November 2016 and February 2017 there had been any actual effect on existing employees let alone evidence of a significant effect – found no evidence of diminution of opportunities for existing employees – Commission found on the evidence engaging additional casual employees was not likely to have a significant effect on existing employees – no obligation for respondent to notify employees or hold discussions under Consultation clause – respondent not required to comply with Consultation clause prior to engaging additional casual employees – dispute determined. The Maritime Union of Australia v Co-Operative Bulk Handling Limited t/a CBH Group

ENTERPRISE BARGAINING – majority support determination – ss.236, 237 Fair Work Act 2009 – application for majority support determination to undertake bargaining – respondent opposed application – initial November 2016 employee petition lost and a new petition made in March 2017 – respondent argued no majority of employees wished to bargain and no need to bargain – after application lodged, respondent held own secret ballot of employees – ballot abandoned due to different questions on the notice and the ballot – scope of second respondent ballot different from NUW application – disagreement between parties about number of employees for the purposes of determining majority – evidence provided regarding eligibility of a number of disputed employees in the petition – Commission satisfied application properly made and group of employees fairly chosen – Commission satisfied a majority of eligible employees wanted to bargain – determination issued. National Union of Workers v Early Settler P/L