TERMINATION OF EMPLOYMENT – misconduct – s.394 Fair Work Act 2009 – application for relief from unfair dismissal – applicant was terminated for breach of a lawful and reasonable direction given by employer regarding loading of ship – applicant had received three prior warnings for threatening behaviour and failing to follow company procedure – submitted that breach was not deliberate and that he was under a lot of pressure that day – respondent submitted that applicant’s submissions in relation to nature or quality of breach was irrelevant to question of valid reason – submitted that applicant knew about procedure and decided consciously and wilfully not to follow it – Commission found applicant breached company procedure and that he was familiar with it but as it was an isolated event, it did not constitute a valid reason for dismissal – applicant submitted that prior warnings were not relevant as they were dubious factually with dubious processes – respondent submitted that applicant’s previous warnings should be taken into account but only to the extent of whether or not the incidents had occurred – found dismissal was harsh, unjust or unreasonable – reinstatement inappropriate – compensation of $18,225.80 less taxation ordered. Taylor v Qube Ports P/L t/a Qube Ports
May 9, 2017
ENTERPRISE AGREEMENTS – dispute about matter arising under agreement – s.739 Fair Work Act 2009 – application to deal with a dispute – dispute concerned the interpretation of clause 32.17 of EnergyAustralia Yallourn Enterprise Agreement 2013 (Agreement) which dealt with Transitional Cross-Stage Training Arrangements – applicant contended that clause was clear and unambiguous; requiring the company to provide applicant with cross-training as requested – it was common ground that applicant completed a course – respondent submitted that course included cross-stage training which was sufficient to satisfy the requirements of clause – applicant contended training was for purpose of initial training in the role and there was an absence of proper training records – respondent claimed that only obligation to applicant was to provide a scheduled training program and advise of when it would be provided – as to the content of the program, respondent submitted that this was a matter for its discretion, having regard to applicant’s training, skills and experience – Golden Cockerel considered – Commission found clause had a plain meaning and there was no ambiguity – respondent was required to provide applicant with a two week cross-stage training course run as 4 x 9 hours per day on day work, together with the consolidation clause 32.17 required upon its completion. Construction, Forestry, Mining and Energy Union v Energy Australia Yallourn P/L t/a Energy Australia
May 9, 2017
ENTERPRISE AGREEMENTS – dispute about matter arising under agreement – s.739 Fair Work Act 2009 – dispute arising under the Patricks Terminals Enterprise Agreement 2016 (the Agreement) – application for an interim order to restrain the respondent from requiring employees working in the rail operation at the Port Botany Terminal to load empty containers from Qube container yard onto trains – applicant alleges that respondent directing employees to perform work differently to accepted practices, and alleges a suspected breach of the Agreement – Commission considered the terms of the Agreement and ss.739(4) and (5) of the Act, and determined that the Commission had no jurisdiction to determine the interim order application because the Act limits the power of the Commission to arbitrate a dispute to the express terms of the dispute resolution procedure, in this case, clause 4.2 – the industrial action subject to the s.418 application before and interim orders by Deputy President Booth and orders of the Federal Court are in relation to the ‘matter at hand’, being ‘bans on the loading or unloading of trucks arriving at the rail yard’ – Commission held that it is bound by the Federal Court order – should the Commission be incorrect in its determination of jurisdiction, it further held that the application should be dismissed as to its merits by applying the principles in ABC v O’Neill – Commission held balance of convenience does not favour interim order being granted – application dismissed – matter to be determined in proceedings on 3 May 2017. Maritime Union of Australia v Patrick Stevedores Holdings P/L
May 8, 2017
A s.365 (General protections) order sought by Paul Walker against the Australian Broadcasting Corporation has been dismissed by Fair Work Deputy President Gooley in Melbourne on 5 May 2017.
May 8, 2017
Kandice Ryan has collected $18,323 in an unfair dismissal claim against Zalcom Pty Ltd T/A Zalcom.
May 8, 2017
A mere 17 unfair dismissal/labour dispute applicants will trouble Fair Work commissioners nationwide today. The full list included three disgruntled Salvation Army ex-staff: The Junction Works Limited (Dolan), Viator Systems Pty Ltd (Antoniades), Murray Engineering Pty Ltd (Mulvaney), Baker Hughes Australia Pty Limited (Manescu), The trustee for The C D J Trust (Penfold), BHP Billiton Iron Ore Pty Ltd (Hodder), Activated Carbon Technologies (Kevin), Tiger Airways Australia Pty Ltd (Snelten), TSA (VIC) Property Trust as Trustee the Salvation Army (Vic) Social Work (Bokori-Mayman, Ewels, Talarico), Nestle Australia Ltd (Furlong), Avel Pty Ltd (Netto), Vadagnini (De Marzi), R and R Poultry Pty Ltd (Crowe), Ventia Pty Ltd (Alvisio), Anglican Community Services (Dickinson).
May 5, 2017
Only 21 unfair dismissal/contract employment dispute applications will trouble the labour market gatekeepers today. The Fair Work Commissioners will work through the following list: JB Holly Pty Ltd (Williams), Zalcom Pty Ltd (Ryan), Rogers, Seller & Myhill Pty Ltd (Gibbons), Star Track Express Pty Ltd (Gianetti), Oracle Corporation Australia Pty Limited (Lawrence), Integrated Clinical Oncology Network Pty Ltd (Squires), Coca-Cola Amatil Pty Ltd (Skoko), The Sisters of Our Lady of China Health Care Pty Ltd (Agawin), Special Broadcasting Service (SBS) (Hill), Western Sydney Community Legal Centre Incorporated (Girdler), Japeroch Investments (Hendry), Downer EDI Mining Pty Ltd (McDonald), CSL Limited (Saunders), 3D Scaffolding (Trialonas), Koschel Developments (Castle), The Trustee for O’Reilly Family Trust (Harrison), Crew Services Group (Wild), Pakenham Racing Club (Raleigh), Bunnings Group Limited (Corney), GateGourmet (Piper), GBW GAPbuster Worldwide Pty Ltd (Okamoto).
May 4, 2017
A light work load will cheer the faces of Fair Work Commissioners today. Only 14 unfair dismissal/employment dispute applications are listed for hearing. They are: PricewaterhouseCoopers (Ochiltree-Dean), Australian Diabetes Educators Association Limited (Oddy), BlueScope Steel Limited (O’Dwyer), Star City Pty Ltd (Zacovich), Kingsway Football & Sporting Club Inc (Jones), Western Power Corporation (Cope-Wyatt), National Jet Systems Pty Ltd (Kinnaird), Skill Hire WA Pty Ltd (Pemberton), RCR Corporate Pty Ltd (Bowness), Sydney Trains (Singh), Millennium hi tech (Cadd), Department of Natural Resources and Mines (Wanninayake), Oracle Financial Planning Pty Ltd (Clark), Uraidla Physio (Mitchell).