NEWS HR

ENTERPRISE AGREEMENTS – dispute about matter arising under agreement – s.739 Fair Work Act 2009 – applicant notified Commission of a dispute arising under the terms of the BlueScope Steel Western Port Enterprise Agreement 2014-2017 (the Agreement) – applicant wanted to engage labour hire provider to provide four workers to meet short-term increase in workload which was opposed by respondent which wanted increased workload to be covered by overtime – respondent raised jurisdictional objection – contended Commission did not have jurisdiction to deal with alleged dispute – submitted jurisdiction of Commission to deal with a dispute was dependent on applicant complying with each step of the dispute resolution process in clause 11 of the Agreement – further submitted subject matter of the dispute was about the operation of clause 13.1.3 of the Agreement which was not the subject of discussion between the parties – applicant submitted dispute could be referred to the Commission because it had met the necessary requirements of the dispute resolution procedure in the Agreement – considered construction of clause 11 of the Agreement – Commission found clause 11.9 of the Agreement unambiguously provided for unresolved disputes to be referred to the Commission – whether applicant could refer a dispute to the Commission if the procedure set out in clauses 11.5, 11.6 and 11.7 had not been followed and followed in sequence – whether applicant engaged in discussions which met clauses 11.6 and 11.7 – Commission held discussions which took place met requirements of clauses 11.6 and 11.7 – found contention of respondent that operation of clause 13.1.3 was not material – satisfied applicant followed procedural steps of clause 11 as far as was possible in relation to subject matter of dispute – held Commission had jurisdiction to deal with the dispute – jurisdictional objection dismissed – matter to proceed to arbitration. BlueScope Steel Limited t/a BlueScope v Australian Workers’ Union

TERMINATION OF EMPLOYMENT – genuine redundancy – ss.389, 394 Fair Work Act 2009 – application for unfair dismissal remedy – applicant was employed as Payroll Officer – applicant submitted she was unfairly dismissed and her termination was not a genuine redundancy – during time of applicant’s transition to new role of PEO HR Coordinator, respondent was considering operational requirements of business across three offices – respondent recently lost some substantial Perth-based contracts – decided it had too many people involved in the PEO process resulting in inefficiencies – applicant’s responsibility of providing PEO services – applicant had some miscommunications with Sydney due to time zones – respondent decided only one full-time HR Manager position was required – respondent held three meetings with applicant in October and November – Commission satisfied that duties applicant had been doing would be distributed to other fulltime Payroll Officers and that her duties would be performed by new full-time HR Manager job based in Sydney office – Commission satisfied respondent no longer required the applicant’s job to be performed by anyone – respondent complied with obligations to consult once it had made a definite decision to change its staffing arrangements – applicant offered opportunity to apply for the HR Manager role in Sydney on numerous occasions – applicant did not apply as she did not want to relocate or work full-time for family and financial reasons – no redeployment opportunities available – dismissal was genuine redundancy – application dismissed. Wrzoskiewicz v Easy Payroll Perth P/L

It’s still a listless list of applicants seeking redress from unfair dismissal and employment contract adjustment in the Fair Work Commission today. Twenty-five are scheduled to appeal: Banana Coast Community Credit Union Ltd (Murphy), Qantas Airways (Delaney), Broometown Holdings Pty Ltd ATF The Nelen Family Trust (Rowland), Nulsen Haven Association (Inc) (D’Vauz), Qantas Airways Ltd (Jeffs), Shade Solutions (Marriott), Jim Aitken & Partners No 1 Pty Ltd (Godkin), Quirindi Retirement Homes Limited (Ryan), Talking Heads Speech Pathology (Aron), Affinity Diamonds Pty Ltd (Park), Western Sydney Community Legal Centre Incorporated (Girdler), The Returned and Services League of Australia (New South Wales Branch) (Kolomeitz), Coca-Cola Amatil Limited (Braughton), Multicap (Keating-Jones), Stumpf, Eric Simon (Costin), Bluestone Mines Tasmania Joint Venture Pty Ltd (Goodsell), Fullers Bookshop (Andrews, Tilsley), Serco Australia Pty Limited (Ndou), CSL Limited (Saunders), Brockman House Inc (Reilly), Fluor Rail Services Pty Ltd (Goerke), Sealing Australia Pty Ltd (Akhurst), Coles Group Supply Chain Pty Ltd (Ly), Estia Health (Brackley).

An application for approval of the Victorian WorkCover Authority Enterprise Agreement 2016-2020 (s.185 – Application for approval of a single-enterprise agreement) will be heard today by Commissioner Cirkovic in Court 4 & Conference Room C – Level 6 in Melbourne at 10am.

The conga line of unfair dismissal/employment dispute applicants in the Fair Work Commission is shrinking. A mere seventeen are listed for hearing today: A and A Excavations (Cooper), Aldi Stores (A Limited Partnership), Viator Systems Pty Ltd (Antoniades), Komatsu Forklift Australia (Finnegan), WesTrac Pty Ltd (Armstrong), Metro Scaffold Hire (Gullotti), Dextera Pty Ltd (Pocklington), Network Aviation Pty Ltd (Ryan), L R Enterprise Australia Pty Ltd (Clark), Rumbalara Aboriginal Co-Operative Ltd (Jackson), Bis Industries (Larcombe), ITM (Athian), Rio Tinto Aluminium Limited (Gill), Groote Eylandt Mining Company Pty Ltd (Langtree), Carlswood Pty Ltd (Brown), Temapet Pty Ltd ATF TCMG Unit Trust (Singh), Orica Australia Pty Ltd (Connell).

Twenty-one unfair dismissal/employment dispute applicants will appear in the Fair Work Commission today. The full list is: A and A Excavations (Cooper), Rio Tinto Aluminium Limited (Gill), Central Gippsland Health Service (Pusher), Wilson Services Company Pty Ltd (Marshall), Solartint (Galvin), Agia Projects (Magee), Stella Bella Wine Pty Ltd (James-Martin), TSA (VIC) Property Trust as Trustee the Salvation Army (Vic) Social Work (Bokori-Mayman, Ewels, Talarico), RACV (Venianakis), Shailer Transport (Kerr), Moreland City Council (Evans), Ventia Pty Ltd (Alvisio), Virgin Australia Airlines Pty Ltd (Ingall), Hilti (aust) Pty Ltd (Harvy), Department of Natural Resources and Mines (Wanninayake), Qube Logistics (SA) Pty Ltd (McIntyre), Watervalley Pty Limited (Sutton), Playford City Soccer and Community Club Inc (Fowler), Millennium Services Group Ltd (Hannemann).

TERMINATION OF EMPLOYMENT – termination at initiative of employer – constructive dismissal – s.394 Fair Work Act 2009 – application for unfair dismissal remedy – applicant submitted she was unfairly constructively dismissed and was seeking an order for compensation – applicant was employed as a full-time early childhood teacher – in 2016 a fellow employee made a bullying complaint against applicant – applicant subsequently stood down – in May 2016 applicant was diagnosed with anxiety and depression which was exacerbated after the complaint – investigation occurred and it was found that applicant had engaged in ‘low grade bullying’ – written warning issued – applicant thought outcome was harsh – during this time applicant produced a number of medical certificates which attested to her unfitness for work – on 5 December applicant’s lawyers wrote to respondent stating the respondent had denied the applicant the ability to continue with her career and in consequence the applicant had suffered psychological injury – a meeting was requested between the respondent and the applicant – on 20 December applicant’s lawyers wrote to respondent that the respondent had disregarded the request for a meeting and as a result, applicant had been left with no alternative other than to resign – applicant submitted she was forced to resign because of conduct, or a course of conduct, engaged in by the respondent – applicant submitted the conduct was ‘the refusal of the respondent to agree…to meet with the applicant and her representative to discuss what might be done to ensure her safe return…’ – Commission considered the Full Bench decision in O’Meara ‘that there. be some action on the part of the employer which is either intended to bring the employment to an end or has the probable result of bringing the employment relationship to an end’ – it is not simply a question of whether ‘the act of the employer [resulted] directly or consequentially in the termination of the employment’ [O’Meara] – Commission found the applicant had a number of options or alternatives to resignation to contest respondent’s failure to take up her request for a meeting to discuss the basis for her return to work – Commission referred to the Dispute Settlement Procedure as a mechanism to resolve disputes and noted that if dispute unresolved internally, they can be referred to the Commission – Commission found it could not be fairly said the applicant had no other choice than to resign – found applicant was not dismissed from her employment with the respondent within the meaning of s.386 of the FW Act – found there was no dismissal by the employer – application dismissed. Hoolahan v North Ryde Community Pre-School Inc t/a North Ryde Community Preschool

ENTERPRISE AGREEMENTS – dispute about matter arising under agreement – – ss.604, 739 Fair Work Act 2009 – appeal – Full Bench – respondent issued notifications that it intended to proceed with significant change in accordance with consultation provisions in Pacific National Coal NSW Enterprise Agreement 2013 (Agreement) – appellant applied to Commission to deal with a dispute involving respondent under s.739 of FW Act – alleged respondent had failed to meet its obligations under Agreement in relation to significant change – in application, appellant named itself as applicant and did not identify by name the employee parties to the dispute – respondent raised jurisdictional objection – claimed a valid dispute had not been notified by appellant and lodged in Commission and clause A30.2(a) of Agreement had not been complied with – at first instance Commission upheld jurisdictional objection – held application not been made in accordance with FW Act – dismissed application – appellant sought permission to appeal – Commission must grant permission to appeal if satisfied in the public interest to do so – GlaxoSmithKline applied – rarely appropriate to grant permission to appeal unless an arguable case of appealable error demonstrated [Wan] – Commission at first instance dismissed application for two reasons – first, clause A30.2(a) not complied with – second, application did not name any employee affected by change – Full Bench noted that by virtue of clause A29.3(a), clause A30.2(a) was not required to be complied with – no obligation to provide respondent with notification of grievance – Full Bench satisfied Commission erred by concluding application had not been made in accordance with FW Act on the grounds clause A30.2(a) had not been complied with – Full Bench noted the FW Act does not require an application made under s.739 to identify by name each employee who was a party to the dispute nor does Agreement – noted appellant had provided respondent with names of employees after application had been lodged – held that the fact appellant did not provide names of employee parties at time of or prior to lodging application did not mean Commission did not have jurisdiction to deal with dispute – Full Bench satisfied that Commission at first instance erred in relying on the fact that the application did not name employee parties and in concluding that application was not properly made in accordance with FW Act – permission to appeal granted – decision quashed – appellant and respondent accepted that dispute subject to application was at end – matter not required to be remitted – application dismissed. Appeal by Australian Rail, Tram and Bus Industry Union against decision of Sams DP of 5 January 2017 [[2017] FWC 27] Re: Asciano Services P/L t/a Pacific National