TERMINATION OF EMPLOYMENT – misconduct – ss.394, 400, 604 Fair Work Act 2009 – appeal – Full Bench – Commission at first instance dismissed unfair dismissal application – found valid reason for termination – grounds of appeal claimed Commission erred in a number of respects including making findings in relation to data obtained from a personal digital assistant (PDA) – permission to appear granted to representatives of both parties due to complexity of matter – appellant sought to lead further evidence – principles in Power Projects International and Akins considered – respondent’s submissions contained 386 pages of evidence and highly technical data – appellant not provided opportunity to file reply submissions – not able to properly assess material without some form of technical or expert assistance – appellant denied opportunity to put a case on an important issue which could have led to a different outcome – evidence credible – new evidence allowed – GlaxoSmithKline and Stead v State Insurance Commission considered – Full Bench held that appellant did not have benefit of provision of reply submissions – held that period between receiving high technical data and hearing was short – noted that appeal could have been avoided if a reply submission had been provided for in originating directions and a longer timeframe had been provided for between written submissions and hearing date – Full Bench found appellant denied natural justice – permission to appeal granted – decision under appeal quashed – matter referred to Commission for rehearing. Appeal by Colella against decision and order of Williams C of 1 March 2017 [2017] FWC 1139 and [PR590568] Re: Aroona P&T P/L t/a Aroona Alliance
May 12, 2017
ENTERPRISE AGREEMENTS – greenfields agreement – ss.185, 604 Fair Work Act 2009 – appeal – Full Bench – greenfields agreement titled TCQ Labour P/L / AWU Civil Construction Metro Greenfield Agreement 2016 (Agreement) was made by TCQ Labour P/L (TCQ) and the Australian Workers’ Union (AWU) on 31 August 2016 – Construction, Forestry, Mining, and Energy Union (CFMEU) opposed the approval of the Agreement and, though not a bargaining representative for the Agreement, was permitted to make submissions in opposition and to appear at the hearing – CFMEU was confined to questions about whether the Agreement related to a genuine new enterprise, whether the Agreement passed the better off overall test and whether it was in the public interest to approve the Agreement – at first instance the Agreement was approved with undertakings – grounds for appeal included that the Commission erred in failing to give any or adequate reasons for its decision; in failing to take into account inconsistent evidence; made a serious error of fact in concluding that there was a genuine new enterprise; and erred in accepting undertakings – Full Bench not persuaded that the answers to questions given in the statutory declarations were contradictory or could not be reconciled – held that although the Commission did not expressly engage with the CFMEU’s argument or give reasons for its rejection, the omission was not fatal – found that the undertaking was not one capable of being accepted by the Commission under s.190 of the FW Act – Full Bench persuaded that permission to appeal should be granted because an error in the Decision has been established and the nature of the error identified raises for consideration the proper administration of the Commission’s power to accept undertakings during the agreement approval process – grounds of appeal concerning the undertaking upheld – given the nature of the error identified, Full Bench did not consider it needed to set aside the Decision to approve the Agreement – s.607 provides that the Commission may, in relation to an appeal, vary the Decision – as paragraphs 1 and 6 of the undertaking were not capable of being accepted because they did not respond to any concern that the Agreement did not meet any particular requirement in ss.186 or 187, removal of those paragraphs from the undertaking will not have a bearing on the validity of the decision to approve the Agreement – Full Bench exercised its power to vary the Decision by removing the impugned paragraphs from the undertaking. Appeal by Construction, Forestry, Mining and Energy Union against decision of Lawrence DP of 23 December 2016 [[2016] FWCA 9249] Re: Australian Workers’ Union and Anor
May 12, 2017
ENTERPRISE AGREEMENTS – dispute about matter arising under agreement – s.739 Fair Work Act 2009 – application to deal with dispute in accordance with dispute settlement procedures in Wilson Fire Protection and Plumbing Division Union Collective Agreement 2011-2015 (earlier agreement) and Wilson Fire Protection Plumbing Division Union Collective Agreement 2015- 2019 (agreement) – dispute concerns underpayment of entitlements of four former employees – examined whether the respondent is obligated to pay the former employees the monies claimed – applicant raised jurisdictional question as to whether one of the former employees could bring a dispute to the Commission given employment ceased on 30 June 2016 – Commission satisfied former employee attempted to resolve the dispute at the workplace level pursuant to the dispute settlement procedure clause in the earlier agreement – satisfied other former employees had no jurisdictional concerns – Commission found there is jurisdiction to have dispute arbitrated – Commission satisfied former employees owed the unpaid entitlements they claimed except for two employees who claimed eligibility of an allin rate entitlement as the provisions of the agreement had not been met. Communications, Electrical, Electronic, Energy, Information, Postal, Plumbing and Allied Services Union of Australia v Wilson Fire Protection
May 12, 2017
TERMINATION OF EMPLOYMENT – Small Business Fair Dismissal Code – ss.388, 394 Fair Work Act 2009 – application for relief from unfair dismissal – applicant employed as a full-time office manager – claimed her dismissal was harsh, unjust and unreasonable – Director of respondent appeared at a directions hearing on 7 March 2017, he informed the Commission that he intended to call about eight witnesses to defend the unfair dismissal application – respondent did not attend hearing – applicant the only person to give evidence at the hearing and the case was decided on that evidence – in its Employer Response, the respondent contended it had nine employees at the time the applicant was dismissed and her dismissal was consistent with the Small Business Fair Dismissal Code (the Code) – applicant gave evidence, which was accepted, that the respondent did not have fewer than 15 employees at the time of her dismissal – Commission found respondent was not a small business employer at that time – however, even if respondent was a small business employer at the time it dismissed the applicant, Commission satisfied that respondent did not comply with the Code in relation to the dismissal – found no valid reason for dismissal – satisfied dismissal was harsh, unjust and unreasonable – ordered compensation in the sum of $18,323.04. Ryan v Zalcom P/L t/a Zalcom
May 12, 2017
TERMINATION OF EMPLOYMENT – extension of time – s.394 Fair Work Act 2009 – applicant lodged unfair dismissal claim – application lodged one day out of time – whether exceptional circumstances to warrant extension of time – applicant had workplace injury and was absent on leave without pay for a period of seven months – respondent claimed that applicant failed to comply with notification obligations under enterprise agreement about absence – respondent received medical certificate further extending absence – respondent terminated applicant’s employment on basis applicant had no intention to engage in a return to work process in any capacity and was not reasonable or practicable to allow applicant to continue taking leave without pay – applicant’s unfair dismissal application posted on 28 December 2016 and received by Commission on 4 January 2017 – Commission considered whether credible reason for the whole period that the application was delayed beyond 21 day period – 21 day period started on the day following the dismissal – if final day of 21 day period is national public holiday or weekend then the timeframe extended until next business day – public holidays and weekends during the 21 day period will not extend the period of lodgement – applicant submitted that delay was due to lawyer advising it was not the time to pursue claim – under impression that application posted on 28 December would arrive in time – Commission found exceptional circumstances as applicant had been advised not to proceed with application, had poor literacy skills and needed assistance from his partner to fill out form and post application – whether limited evidence discloses a likely unfair dismissal – considered Kyvelos – Commission not required to make finding of fact as to evidence brought forward on the merits of application – Commission held insufficient material to draw conclusions about the prospect of success – Commission granted extension of time. Ninyette v BGC Contracting P/L
May 12, 2017
ENTERPRISE AGREEMENTS – dispute about matter arising under agreement – s.739 Fair Work Act 2009 – dispute in accordance with the dispute resolution procedure of the Australia Post Enterprise Agreement 2013 – whether the position in dispute in the Customer Contact Centre was correctly classified at Level 3 or whether it should be classified at Level 4 – Commission not satisfied that the work of the team as a whole fits the Level 4 descriptor – however satisfied that highly experienced members of the team who meet certain characteristics should be classified at Level 4 – given the finding that only some of the team members are likely to meet the criteria some further process is required to finalise the dispute – Australia Post to provide its proposal, together with its rationale, as to which members of the team meet the requirements within 14 days – CEPU may respond to the Australia Post proposal within a further seven days – conference to be convened on 26 May 2017 at 10am to finalise the matter. Communications, Electrical, Electronic, Energy, Information, Postal, Plumbing and Allied Services Union of Australia (CEPU) v Australian Postal Corporation t/a Australia Post
May 12, 2017
ENTERPRISE AGREEMENTS – dispute about matter arising under agreement – s.739 Fair Work Act 2009 – applicant wanted to utilise a number of labour hire employees to cover a spike in workload at its Westernport facility – contended that despite the opposition from its employees and the respondent that it was able to utilise labour hire under clause 13.1 of the Agreement – Golden Cockerel and Paper Australia considered – Commission held that applicant had considered the appropriateness of the use of contractors as an alternative to the use of full-time employees – however, held it was also clear that applicant had not considered the appropriateness of the use of fixed term employment as an alternative to the use of either full-time employment or the use of contractors – Commission could not be satisfied that the use of contractors was an appropriate alternative arrangement – issue in dispute remains unresolved – appropriate that the parties be given an opportunity to make further submissions having regard to the contents of this interim decision. BlueScope Steel Limited t/a BlueScope v Australian Workers’ Union, The
May 12, 2017
ENTERPRISE AGREEMENTS – dispute about matter arising under agreement – s.739 Fair Work Act 2009 – submissions sought by Commission on options to resolve dispute after determination was made that first written warning issued to CFMEU delegate, the applicant, pursuant to clause 29 of the Energy Australia Yallourn Enterprise Agreement 2013 (agreement), be withdrawn – Commission considered how respondent’s failure to act in accordance with clause 29 of the agreement impacted on the applicant – considered that the dispute settlement procedure of agreement meant the penalty imposed cannot be backdated and that the dispute resolution term provided wide discretion to the employer to resolve disputes and thus their views should be an important consideration – Commission not satisfied that no further action should be taken given the short comings of the process adopted by the respondent – ordered first written warning effective 1 May 2017 expiring 17 June 2017. Construction, Forestry, Mining and Energy Union v Energy Australia Yallourn P/L