TERMINATION OF EMPLOYMENT – performance – s.394 Fair Work Act 2009 – application for relief for unfair dismissal – applicant commenced employment with respondent on 30 September 2014 as a Port Hedland based Inventory Controller – applicant was transferred to respondent’s Perth Inventory Management Team in June 2014 – respondent submitted applicant lacked the necessary skills, capabilities and knowledge to adequately perform his role and his manner and attitude to customers and internal personnel was unsatisfactory – further submitted applicant experienced difficulty in his relationships with colleagues and clients – submitted applicant was informally mentored by an experienced team member but no improvement ensued, and that group training sessions were also held so applicant didn’t feel singled out – single training sessions with the applicant were also undertaken as a performance improvement plan but again no improvement made – on 3 August 2016 the applicant was asked to attend a meeting where he was given a termination letter – applicant responded to letter on 8 August by showing up to work – respondent advised applicant his employment was terminated on 3 August 2017 – Commission satisfied genuine reason for dismissal based on belief that applicant was incapable of perceiving or achieving an acceptable level of work performance – satisfied that for nearly a year the respondent sought to communicate their performance expectations and provide opportunity for applicant to improve and respond to concerns raised – Commission found dismissal not harsh, unjust or unreasonable – application dismissed. Etienne v FMG Personnel Services P/L
June 2, 2017
TERMINATION OF EMPLOYMENT – costs – ss.390, 394, 400A, 401, 604 Fair Work Act 2009 – Mrs Sologinkin had her application for an unfair dismissal remedy dismissed by the Commission on grounds her dismissal was not harsh, unjust or unreasonable – Coty made an application for costs against Mrs Sologinkin on the grounds that it should have been reasonably apparent that her application had no reasonable prospect of success – Coty also made an application for costs against Mrs Sologinkin’s representative Australian Dismissal Services on the grounds that they caused Coty to incur costs through an unreasonable act or omission – the Commission considered the principles of when an application is made without reasonable cause summarised in Keep v Performance Automobiles and found that Mrs Sologinkin had a reasonably arguable case given her lengthy unblemished service and apology she had sent to the client – Coty alleged that Australian Dismissal Services had caused Coty to incur costs due to an unreasonable act or omission in failing to settle the matter based on an offer from Coty – the Commission found that given Mrs Sologinkin had an arguable case it was not unreasonable to reject the offer – application for costs dismissed. Sologinkin v Cosmetic Suppliers P/L t/a Coty
June 2, 2017
ENTERPRISE AGREEMENTS – approval – ss.185, 604 Fair Work Act 2009 – appeal – Full Bench – at first instance the Commission determined that the application for approval of the MTP Enterprise Agreement 2016 be dismissed because the Commission was not satisfied that the employees who voted for the Agreement were covered by it – appellant submitted that the Commission wholly failed to understand and consider the evidence and the effect of the evidence at first instance – Full Bench held the erroneous construction of the coverage provision of the Agreement resulted in an incorrect conclusion that the requirements in s.186(2)(a) of FW Act had not been met – permission to appeal granted – appeal upheld – Decision at first instance quashed – application for approval of the Agreement remitted to Lee C. Appeal by Thiess P/L against decision of Roe C of 6 February 2017 [[2017] FWC 718] Re: Construction, Forestry, Mining and Energy Union
June 2, 2017
ENTERPRISE AGREEMENTS – dispute about matter arising under agreement – ss.604, 739 Fair Work Act 2009 – permission to appeal – Full Bench – at first instance it was found that the additional competencies that Freight Operators were being trained in did not fall within the scope of the ‘role for which they are employed’ for the purposes of clause 29.4 of the Aurizon Train Crew and Transport Operations Enterprise Agreement 2015 (the Agreement) – that they should not be compensated for the relevant tasks at the rate equivalent of a Traincrew Support employee for the time that they were carrying out the tasks – that they should not be compensated for the period of time they were performing the relevant tasks based on the work value of those tasks as this was not pursued – that they should not be back-paid for the period of time they had been carrying out the tasks – therefore Commission held that the claimed remuneration of the Higher Grade Allowance was not applicable to the subset of duties sought to be undertaken – that since the extra duties the Freight Operators were being directed to perform did not fall within their classification, the direction was not in accordance with the applicable Agreement provisions – the grounds of appeal essentially related to central issue of whether the additional competencies for which Freight Operators were being trained fell within the scope of the ‘role for which they are employed’ for the purposes of clause 29.4 of the Agreement – permission to appeal must not be granted unless in public interest – public interest test is discretionary and involves broad value judgment – Full Bench observed the Commission had regard to context and purpose of Agreement by referring to clauses 29 and 42 – in considering context and purpose the Commission noted the additional tasks Freight Operators were being asked to perform – Full Bench found the Commission adopted an orthodox approach in construing the context and purpose – Commission had not erred in finding that competencies did not fall within the scope of the ‘role for which they are employed’ – Commission had not erred in finding that the Agreement was ambiguous when applying the principles in Golden Cockerel – Commission undertook an orthodox approach in her application of those principles and her application was not disharmonious when compared with other decisions dealing with similar matters – Full Bench found no arguable case of error in relation to any of the grounds of appeal – concluded that appeal did not attract public interest after taking into account considerations in GlaxoSmithKline – not satisfied there is a diversity of decisions at first instance so that guidance from appellate body is required, nor that appeal raises issues of importance and/or general application – also not satisfied decision at first instance manifests injustice, or result is counterintuitive, nor that legal principles applied were disharmonious when compared with other decisions dealing with similar matters – permission to appeal refused. Appeal by Aurizon Operations Limited t/a Aurizon against decision of Spencer C of 20 February 2017 [[2017] FWC 955] Re: Australian Rail, Tram and Bus Industry Union
June 2, 2017
ENTERPRISE AGREEMENTS – dispute about matter arising under agreement – ss.604, 739 Fair Work Act 2009 – permission to appeal – Full Bench – initial matter filed by AWU, which was intervened by AMWU in resolving a dispute under the Bluescope Steel Port Kembla Steelworks Agreement 2015 (the Agreement) – at first instance the Commission found BlueScope had not complied with the introduction of change process contained in clause 35.2 of the Agreement – Commission determined the consultation process for the maintenance employees was not fair, comprehensive or genuine – recommended parties return to consultation process regarding proposed changes – appellant contended the Commission did not have the power to prevent or halt the decision to introduce changes only the power to arbitrate about its implementation – contended the Commission erred by not addressing relevant test in clause 35.2.1(c) – appellant further contended that it adequately carried out its consultation requirements – argued that the Commission erred in finding the consultation that took place was not fair, comprehensive or genuine for maintenance employees – powers of appeal only exercisable if there is an error by the primary decision maker [Coal & Allied] – if it is in the public interest to do so the test is a discretionary one involving broad value judgement [GlaxoSmithKline] – Full Bench not satisfied there was an arguable case of error in any of the appellant’s grounds for appeal in relation the Decision – not satisfied it would be in the public interest to grant permission to appeal – permission to appeal refused. Appeal by BlueScope Steel (AIS) Port Kembla against decision of Riordan C of 21 February 2017 [[2017] FWC 335] Re: The “Automotive, Food, Metals, Engineering, Printing and Kindred Industries Union” known as the Australian Manufacturing Workers’ Union (AMWU) and Anor
June 1, 2017
A 24 applicant trickle will test the minds of Fair Work Commissioners today. The unfair dismissal/labour dispute list is: Teekay Shipping (Australia) Pty Ltd (Wood), TTG Transportation Technology Pty Ltd (Mackenzie), Forster Tuncurry Memorial Services Club Limited (Sweeney), Woolworths Limited related body corp of (Marangon), Scribal Group Pty Ltd (Lindley), Maryland Care & Early Education Centre (Connell), Wax Converters Textiles Pty Limited (Nichols), Yoga Loft (Kelly), Community Environment Network Inc (CEN) (Bailey), Shining Knight Facility Services (Reid), The Trustee for The KG Service Trust (Scott), Nortale Pty Ltd (Abela), Orana Incorporated (Thompson), 360 Gradi Pty Ltd (De Marzi), Coca-Cola Amatil Limited (Braughton), Stumpf, Eric Simon (Costin), Australian Diabetes Educators Association Limited (Oddy), Australian Federal Police (Drummond), Department of Education and Training (Decker), Australian Tallow Producers Pty Ltd (Garang), Amalgamated Pest Control Pty Ltd (Law), Win Services Pty Ltd (Mihaere), Digital Skies Group Pty Ltd (Harding), The Department of the Prime Minister and Cabinet (Dubois).
May 31, 2017
Forty-two unfair dismissal and labour dispute applications come before the Fair Work Commission today. The full list is: Wollongong Asphalt Pty Ltd (White), Australian and Air Force Canteen Services (Shamim), Serco Australia Pty Ltd Darwin IDC (Onah), Corrective Services NSW (Sheather), Toyota Motor Corporation Australia Ltd (Obazee), BiltBeta Constructions (De Maria), Active Kids Group Pty Ltd (Harrouk), Lumlan and Associates Services (Levalds), Sodexo (Culpitt), Southern Ports Authority (Murray), Town of Victoria Park (Wilson), Global Care Incorporated (Granito), Jewish Care Victoria Inc (Hantke), Linfox Australia Pty Ltd (Grey), Emergency Services Telecommunications Authority (Hellyer), Thornlie Christian College Inc (Ialeggio), Somerville Retail Services Pty Ltd (Delos Santos), Cranbourne Transit Pty Ltd (Guner), Broadspectrum (Australia) Pty Ltd (Hubeek), Spotless Facilities Services Pty Ltd (Hambridge), The Commonwealth of Australia (Department of Immigration and Border Protection) (Gibbens), Cafe SA Pty Ltd (Kurda), Serco Australia Pty Ltd Darwin IDC (Onah), Game Traffic and Contracting (Faralla), Australian Skills Quality Authority (Byrnes), National Australia Bank Pty Ltd (McAvaney), Serco Immigration Services (Anderson), Rail Commissioner (Williams), Coca-Cola Amatil Limited (Braughton), Virgin Australia Airlines Pty Ltd (Ingall), eBlueprint (Nagendra), Nestle Australia Ltd (Furlong), Finance Sector Union of Australia (Johnson), ISS Facility Services Australia Ltd (Baltas), Westpac Banking Corporation (Santos), Thompson Healthcare Pty Ltd (Adamopoulos), Celesty Family Trust Pty Ltd (Allan), Hibiscus Chinese Takeaway and Cafe Food (Chan), Uniting Agewell Victoria (Wakelam), Doutta Galla Aged Services Limited (Hussein), North Albury APCO (Hird), 360 Gradi Pty Ltd (De Marzi).
May 30, 2017
Robert Etienne has had his unfair dismissal claim against FMG Personnel Services Pty Ltd knocked back by Fair Work Deputy President Binet in Perth.