NEWS HR

CASE PROCEDURES – appeals – ss.394, 400, 604 Fair Work Act 2009 – permission to appeal – Full Bench – appeal against unfair dismissal decision – held at first instance dismissal not unfair – at first instance found appellant harassed and/or intimidated colleagues and breached respondent’s standard and behaviour code – appellant alleged 20 grounds of appeal for errors of law and significant errors of fact – Coal & Allied considered – not persuaded any grounds of appeal relied on raised issue of importance or general application nor persuaded appellant disclosed arguable cases of error – noted no requirement, though desirable, to separately identify particular parts of evidence of individual witnesses relied on in first instance – found public interest not engaged – found most conduct was admitted by the appellant – held Commission entitled to take into account prior disciplinary history at first instance – not required to expressly refer to behaviour regarded as harassment – public interest not enlivened – first instance conclusion was not unreasonable nor manifested by any injustice and not counter-intuitive – no basis to justify the grant of permission to appeal or otherwise – permission to appeal refused. Appeal by Larcombe against decision and order of Platt C of 18 July 2017 [[2017] FWC 3764 and PR594631] Re: Bis Industries Limited

TERMINATION OF EMPLOYMENT – valid reason – ss.391, 394 Fair Work Act 2009 – application for unfair dismissal remedy – respondent alleged applicant’s employment contract had been frustrated as a result of loss of Working with Children Check Clearance (Clearance) and operation of relevant legislation – respondent’s view that employment had terminated when applicant had been summonsed to attend Court – Court decision issued by Court in February 2017 – charges against applicant dismissed – applicant submitted contract of employment was not frustrated and that decision to dismiss was without valid reason and unfair – respondent submitted employment ended as a consequence of losing Clearance as applicant could no longer perform role – Commission found applicant not given opportunity to respond to reasons for dismissal and other matters – found applicant’s employment not frustrated and he was dismissed – found loss of Clearance was valid reason for dismissal but dismissal was harsh and unreasonable – found dismissal unfair as applicant only charged, not convicted of a criminal offence – lack of procedural fairness also weighs in favour of dismissal being unfair – reinstatement order with continuity of employment – income reinstated from date of Court decision less income earned from work performed in relevant period. Toohey v White, Executive Director of Catholic Schools and legal representative of the Catholic Education Office, Sydney

TERMINATION OF EMPLOYMENT – valid reason – ss.385, 387 394, 396 Fair Work Act 2009 – application for unfair dismissal remedy – applicant submitted dismissal harsh, unjust and unreasonable due to personal and economic impact and it being a disproportionate response – applicant dismissed for serious misconduct –allegations of falsification of timesheet, fraudulent completion of attendance record, dishonest dealings with subcontractor – applicant provided opportunity to respond – applicant failed to address concerns and breached instructions by respondent not to interfere with investigation – constituted valid reason for termination – dismissal was not harsh, unjust or unreasonable – application dismissed. Balkan v securecorp P/L t/a securecorp

ENTERPRISE BARGAINING – majority support determination – s.236 Fair Work Act 2009 – CFMEU application lodged in September was accompanied by petitions signed by 10 employees – 7 employees signed a petition in April and 3 further employees signed a petition in June – Commission must be satisfied that a majority of employees who are employed at a time determined by the Commission and who will be covered by the Agreement want to bargain – lapse in time since signing petition and uncertainty over total number of employees meant Commission could not be satisfied that there was a majority of employees in support of bargaining – CFMEU submitted the FWC should conduct a ballot – further hearing listed. Construction, Forestry, Mining and Energy Union

TERMINATION OF EMPLOYMENT – misconduct – s.394 Fair Work Act 2009 – application for unfair dismissal remedy – in September 2016 the respondent developed concerns about the applicant’s workplace behaviour and conduct – on 30 March 2017 respondent was presented with allegations made against applicant by four employees – allegations involved two separate but similar incidents – incidents related to applicant’s indecent exposure in workplace – respondent immediately suspended the applicant from work with pay whilst it conducted an investigation into the allegations – following the investigation respondent concluded that applicant had engaged in serious misconduct – respondent provided applicant with a letter of dismissal – Commission confirmed the findings of serious misconduct made by the respondent against the applicant represented a valid reason for summary dismissal – found respondent conducted a fair, thorough and balanced investigation into the serious allegations made against applicant – found the dismissal of the applicant was not harsh, unjust or unreasonable – applicant’s claim for unfair dismissal remedy was dismissed. Maciel v Lynch Admin Services P/T t/a Lynch Group

INDUSTRIAL ACTION – order against industrial action – s.418 Fair Work Act 2009 – application for an order to stop industrial action on the grounds that industrial action was not protected industrial action because it was not authorised in accordance with s.459 FW Act – Commission considered whether industrial action occurred outside the 30 day authorisation period – found notice to commence industrial action on 22 September 2017 that is not otherwise authorised cannot be authorised and any action taken pursuant to such a notice is therefore not protected industrial action – United Collieries considered – applied Health Imaging Services P/L v Health Services Union – found that Question 1 in the action ballot was characterised as a range of options for stoppages that may or may not be taken and the authorisation of one of the options for a stoppage of work does not authorise all of the options contained in that question – Commission not satisfied that there was authorisation for 24 hour stoppage of work as action was to commence outside extended 60 day period – found that the stoppages already taken of one hour duration do not provide the authorisation for a 24 hour stoppage – found proposed industrial action would not be protected industrial action – satisfied that the industrial action was being organised – application for Order stopping industrial action granted. James Cook University v National Tertiary Education Industry Union

ENTERPRISE AGREEMENTS – dispute about matter arising under agreement – s.739 Fair Work Act 2009 – dispute relating to applicant’s appropriate classification under enterprise agreement – Berri considered – satisfied parties making agreement knew of history of agreement provisions from earlier agreements and awards – also satisfied parties were aware of relevant law and regulations that apply in the sector – satisfied Commission may have regard to history of provisions and relevant law and regulations to assist determining if ambiguity or uncertainty exists – provision must be considered in context of agreement as a whole – even if regard is not had to the history of classification, clause and its implications suggests uncertainty and ambiguity in relevant classifications – agreement does not have plain meaning when read in context – satisfied that objective background facts support finding that agreement is uncertain and ambiguous in relation to relevant classifications – not satisfied ambiguity resolved when definition of Children’s Services Employees considered – satisfied intent of agreement is that Assistant Children’s Services Employee should be classified at Class 2 – conclusions as to uncertainty and intent of agreement supported by (but not based on) classification descriptions in modern award and finalisation of replacement agreement which clarifies distinction between relevant classifications – applicant has no claim to be classified as Class 3 based on provisions of agreement in question – this is not to say applicant might not have claim to be classified as such on some other basis – application dismissed. Grey v Melbourne City Council t/a North Melbourne Children’s Centre

RIGHT OF ENTRY – application for permit – s.512 Fair Work Act 2009 – application for right of entry permit – permit qualification matters under s.513 FW Act considered – applicant disclosed two matters that fall within category of offences in s.513(1)(c)(i) and (ii) – a conviction of common assault and stalking/intimidation from 2007 and a conviction of three counts of obtaining money by deception from 2009 – applicant also disclosed two driving offences matters which were considered for purposes of s.513(1)(g) – Commission satisfied there was a considerable passage of time since applicant’s convictions – applicant showed contrition for his actions and made changes to his life – satisfied applicant a fit and proper person – entry permit issued. Construction, Forestry, Mining and Energy Union – Construction and General Division, New South Wales Divisional Branch