NEWS HR

CASE PROCEDURES – appeals – ss.394, 400, 604 Fair Work Act 2009 – permission to appeal – Full Bench – unfair dismissal application dismissed at first instance – found appellant’s actions breached company procedures – valid reason for dismissal – three principal grounds of appeal – matters relating to third warning, details of collision and that Commission mischaracterised appellant’s evidence in cross-examination – Full Bench did not consider appellant established arguable case of error in relation to treatment of third warning and conduct to which it related – did not consider appellant’s contentions established that conclusions in relation to facts of collision were erroneous – arguable case that Commission erred in finding appellant made ‘different submissions’, or ‘inconsistent’ submissions; however, not considered a significant error of fact for purposes of s.400(2) – Full Bench did not consider this plausibly affected the outcome of decision at first instance – no arguable case of error – not satisfied in public interest to grant permission to appeal – permission to appeal refused. Appeal by Hill against decision of Spencer C of 18 May 2017 [[2017] FWC 1952] Re: Peabody Energy Australia PCI P/L

Twenty-two labour dispute applications are lined up for hearing in the Fair Work Commission today. The full list is: Wrightville Operations Pty Ltd (Hatibovich), Aus Water & Gas Pty Ltd (Simounds), RSL Care Limited (Gwak), R J Dingle (Dingle), The Heran Building Group Pty Ltd (Nieberg), Lutheran Church of Australia Queensland District (Bos), The Commonwealth of Australia (Department of Immigration and Border Protection) (Gibbens), Amalgamated Pest Control Pty Ltd (Law), Elmo Software Limited (Pettit), Australian Super Pty Ltd (Lim), Goodyear & Dunlop Tyres (Aust) Pty Ltd & Hamilton and Others (Andrade), New Leaf Developments (Sim), Alcami Managed Services Pty Ltd & Transport for NSW and Others (Barr), Fitzgerald Memorial Aged Care Facility Ltd (Brown), Jetstar Airways Pty Limited (Corbani), Gunnedah Leather Processors Pty Ltd (Goodacre), NSW Trains (De Giusti), Cowra Tyre & Brake Centre Pty Limited (Davis), Suretek Global Pty Ltd (Scott), Anglicare Community Services (Lama), Lockin Pty Ltd (Ware).

Another very light lawlist governing labour disputes faces an underworked Fair Work Commission today. The eleven applications are: UGL Rail Services Pty Ltd (Williams), Moree Local Aboriginal Land Council (Leslie-Briggs), Prixcar Services Pty Ltd (Leonardi), Bei Fang Food Supplies Pty Ltd (Yang), StarTrack Express Pty Ltd (Benson), YMCA SA (Slade), Jasmina Trust (Singh), Alemlube Pty Ltd (Astin), Broadspectrum (Australia) Pty Ltd (Johnson), Barcoo Retirement Village Incorporated (Hinds), Asciano Services Pty Ltd (Pemberton & Bryant and Others).

The light case load faces returning Fair Work Commissioners. Only 16 labour dispute applications are listed for hearing: The High Gate Group (Heydon), BRC Recruitment Pty Limited (Nisha), Degabriele Kitchens NSW Pty Ltd (Squadrito), CPB Contractors Pty Limited (Wilson), Thompson Healthcare Pty Ltd (Adamopoulos), Bendigo Kangan Institute (Michael), Australian College of Optometry (Battista), Searchlight Education Springfield (Mokhondo), Origin Energy Resource Limited (Costelloe), CPB Contractors Pty Limited (Wilson), Prime Enterprise Holdings Pty Ltd (Wang), CPB Contractors Pty Limited (Wilson), WesTrac Pty Ltd (Thay), Sodexo Remote Sites Australia Pty Ltd (Hallam), Woolworths Ltd (Jacobson), Origin Energy Resources Limited (Costelloe).

TERMINATION OF EMPLOYMENT – misconduct – s.394 Fair Work Act 2009 – application for unfair dismissal remedy – applicant employed as bus driver – facts of case involved applicant driving with expired driver’s licence – applicant became aware licence had expired when requested to produce it for examination – advised supervisor he was in possession of expired licence and would ask wife for renewed licence at home – applicant left message for wife and then departed depot undertaking driving duties without confirmation that his driver’s licence had been renewed – applicant called into meeting two days later and dismissed – applicant claimed respondent had already determined would be dismissed summarily prior to meeting and respondent not interested in explanation – applicant’s case was put on basis that when advised that his driver’s licence appeared to not have been renewed respondent allowed applicant to complete driving duties for day – was not contacted by respondent asking him to stop driving or return to depot during shift – actions of applicant said to be neither wilful nor deliberate – acted immediately to renew driver’s licence once it was drawn to his attention that it had expired – respondent submitted that applicant was terminated based on valid reason and that he was provided with opportunity to respond to allegation of driving on expired driver’s licence – applicant submitted that Road Traffic Act 1974 (WA) (RT Act) provides an exemption to offence of driving while not authorised ‘because the licence expired’ and grace period of six months to continue driving without committing offence – Commission found applicant’s driver’s licence no longer current until further renewed within six month period with effect from date of renewal – rejected argument that RT Act provides for exemptions or grace period – Commission satisfied valid reason for dismissal – driving motor vehicle without current driver’s licence an offence and therefore amounted to serious misconduct – accepted that decision to drive made spur of moment while applicant was in state of shock rather than action taken designed to destroy employment relationship in wilful manner – found applicant demonstrated remorse for actions – applicant’s unblemished employment record of seven years and age taken into consideration – Commission found despite finding of valid reason, Commission found actions of applicant did not justify summary dismissal – dismissal unfair based on its summary nature – held compensation should be ordered in the amount of payment of five weeks wages. Nieuwpoort v South West Transit Group P/L

TERMINATION OF EMPLOYMENT – minimum employment period – casual employee – ss.22, 384, 394 Fair Work Act 2009 – whether periods of absence were ‘excluded periods’ within s.22 FW Act – respondent raised jurisdictional objection before conciliation – respondent not a small business – applicant worked regular and systematic casual roster with reasonable expectation of continuing employment on a regular and systematic basis – employed for six months and 25 days with two periods of absence – suffered foot injury – submitted first period of absence was decided by employer against applicant’s wishes and not ‘unauthorised absence’, ‘unpaid leave’ nor ‘unpaid authorised absence’ – submitted first absence was a ‘stand down’ – submitted second absence was part agreed and part ‘stand down’ – respondent submitted both periods of leave were authorised and either period could be classified as ‘unpaid authorised absence’ or ‘unpaid leave’ – Commission held that absence was authorised as it was known to the employer and occurred with its acceptance and authority – satisfied that period between 18 March and 23 April was not a ‘stand down’ within s.524 FW Act – found that 36 days an ‘unpaid authorised absence’ within s.22 FW Act and therefore an excluded period – jurisdictional objection upheld – application dismissed. De Silva v Murphy Holdings (SA) P/L t/a Murphy Holdings (SA) P/L

TERMINATION OF EMPLOYMENT – costs – ss.400A, 401, 611 Fair Work Act 2009 – application for costs – employee lodged unfair dismissal application and discontinued application six days before the matter was listed for hearing – employer claimed that employee should pay its costs because it should have been reasonably apparent that the unfair dismissal application had no reasonable prospect of success – Commission required to determine whether unfair dismissal application had a substantial prospect of success despite discontinuance – found employer had terminated employee’s access to termination server, email address and mobile phone and stopped paying employee while employee was on annual leave – found on an objective analysis, employee faced with similar situation would likely treat themselves as dismissed – employer claimed Small Business Fair Dismissal Code (Code) applied – Code allows employer to dismiss employee without notice or warning if employer believes on reasonable grounds that employee’s conduct is serious misconduct – witness affidavit in proceedings disclosed extensive misappropriations by employee – misappropriations constituted conduct that justifies immediate dismissal, however Code requires positive act of dismissal from employer – employee treated as constructively dismissed – found Code not a defence to unfair dismissal – Commission considered whether employee and employee’s representative engaged in unreasonable act or omission by filing Notice of Discontinuance six days before hearing – found employee and employee’s representative did not engage in unreasonable act or omission – found no jurisdiction to order costs – application dismissed. Versace v Fanissa P/L t/a PJ Pools & Spas

TERMINATION OF EMPLOYMENT – misconduct – s.394 Fair Work Act 2009 – application for unfair dismissal – applicant protected person from unfair dismissal – applicant contended dismissal harsh, unjust and unreasonable – respondent contended termination was genuine redundancy as decision made to restructure business – Commission considered whether applicant’s dismissal consistent with Small Business Fair Dismissal Code or whether case of genuine redundancy – evidence provided demonstrated applicant’s employment ended due to allegations of misconduct – Commission found respondent small business employer within the meaning of the FW Act – insufficient evidence that respondent’s belief of misconduct was objective and based on reasonable grounds – considered whether applicant’s dismissal was an unfair dismissal within the meaning of the FW Act – found applicant was unfairly dismissed and dismissal was harsh, unjust and unreasonable – reinstatement inappropriate remedy – compensation appropriate – respondent to pay applicant $5812. Carlin-Smith v Neirbo Real Estate P/L t/a Homes Group Estate Agents