NEWS HR

TERMINATION OF EMPLOYMENT – misconduct – s.394 Fair Work Act 2009 – application for unfair dismissal remedy – applicant was employed by respondent as a technical support consultant – terminated following a number of allegations of sexual harassment – Commission examined each allegation – found applicant engaged in an inappropriate pattern of behaviour in the workplace – satisfied there was a valid reason for dismissal – dismissal not harsh, unjust or unreasonable – application dismissed. Tanyi v Foxtel Management P/L t/a Foxtel

ENTERPRISE AGREEMENTS – dispute about matter arising under agreement – ss.604, 739 Fair Work Act 2009 – permission to appeal – Full Bench – decision at first instance found that Commission did not have jurisdiction to deal with a dispute submitted under clause 10 of the MC Labour Services P/L and the CFMEU (Victorian Construction and General Division) Labour Hire Industry Enterprise Agreement 2016-2018 (Agreement) – GlaxoSmithKline applied regarding considerations that may attract the public interest when deciding whether or not to grant permission to appeal – Commission satisfied that divergence of views exists in decisions of the Commission regarding its jurisdiction in dealing with a matter referred to it under a dispute settlement procedure in an enterprise agreement – Commission satisfied it was in public interest to grant appeal – permission to appeal granted – found Commissioner’s conclusion she had no jurisdiction to deal with the dispute took into account, and was consistent with, the legislative framework – found that s.186(6) of the Fair Work Act does not mandate an unconditional or universal role for the Commission or other independent person in the settlement of disputes arising under an agreement – found s.739 of the Fair Work Act applied if a term of an enterprise agreement ‘requires or allows’ the Commission to deal with a dispute – the resolution of a disputed construction to begin with the ordinary meaning of the relevant words, considered in context, in accordance with the principles summarised in AMWU v Berri – found that clause 10.4 of the enterprise agreement set pre-conditions for the capacity of the Commission to deal with a dispute and those pre-conditions were not met – found that there is no general discretion afforded to the Commission under the Fair Work Act to deal with a dispute under an enterprise agreement – found that the enterprise agreement affords no such discretion – appeal dismissed. Appeal by The Australian Workers’ Union against decision of McKinnon C of 3 August 2017 [[2017] FWC 4075] Re: MC Labour Services P/L

TERMINATION OF EMPLOYMENT – termination at initiative of employer – s.394 Fair Work Act 2009 – applicant, a casual employee, claimed unfair dismissal by respondent, a labour hire company – applicant left work placement early but did not tell employer or respondent – claimed respondent terminated their employment over telephone – no termination of employment found as applicant remained on respondent’s database and respondent still continued to try and source work for applicant – application dismissed. Gavin v Jugiter P/L t/a Torque Recruitment Group

The case load for the Fair Work Commission is rising. Today 28 unfair dismissal/labour dispute applications are listed for hearing. The full list is: Aurrum Pty ltd (Hoppenbrouwer), Workforce Variable Pty Ltd (Thiruvasan), Broadspectrum (Australia) Pty Ltd (Petch), The Star Pty Limited (Banerji, Wickramatilake), Dominelli Group Pty Ltd (Zhang), Gunnedah Leather Processors Pty Ltd (Goodacare), IBS Software Services Private Limited (Golwara), Allianz Australia (Zackey), Move Well Pty Ltd & The Arena Practice Trust & The N and L Cliff Family Trust (Nazzari), Curtin University of Technology (Lichtenzveig), Schwing Concrete Constructions (Downes), RBA Architects and Conservation Consultants Pty Ltd (Le), Australian Criminal Intelligence Commission (Demos), Mallee District Aboriginal Services Limited & Kirby (Connelly), JM Golden Care Pty Ltd (Anderson, Wardill), Moonee Valley City Council (Piscitelli), Conlon Murphy (O’Byrne), BMI Group Pty Ltd (Russell), RSL Care Limited (Gwak), York Territory Realty (Rogers), Workforce Variable Pty Ltd (Thiruvasan), Gateway Lifestyle Residential Parks Pty Ltd (Blackburn), Australian Personnel Global Pty Ltd (Hussein, Mohammadi, Phuaprasert), Mental Illness Fellowship of South Australia Incorporated (Griffith).

Twenty unfair dismissal/labour dispute applications are listed for hearing in the Fair Work Commission today. The full list is: Epworth Foundation & Ching (Chang), The Camberwell Grammar School (Dai), Health Services Union – Victoria No 1 Branch (Sanli), Cabrini Health Limited (Velesquez), Murray Goulburn Co-Operative Co Ltd (Rooney), Furniture Galore Pty Ltd (Broadhead), Watterhalls (Taurima), Condobolin RSL Club Ltd (Glen), Westpac Banking Corporation (Grant), Yoogalu Pty Ltd (Kariotakis), Westpac Banking Corporation (Tandon), State Government of Victoria (Pender), Mater Health Services (Mater Misericordiae Health Services Brisbane Limited) (Graham), Hitsol Pty Ltd (Walton), Townsville Aboriginal And Torres Strait Islander Corporation For Media (Gela), Rivex Crane Hire Pty Ltd (Anderson), Sunshine Hair Studio Pty Ltd (Dale), TRG Administration Pty Ltd (Ward), Aldi Foods Pty Limited (Gillman), Kimberley College Ltd (Ford).

Another case load ‘lite’ day faces the Fair Work Commission. The twenty labour dispute applications are: Aus Water & Gas Pty Ltd (Simounds), Lutheran Church of Australia Queensland District (Bos), ISS Facility Services (Turner), Australia Postal Corporation (Bird), CPC Services NQ Pty Ltd (Green), Suncorp (McTavish), Allied Rubber Technologies (Australia) Pty Ltd (Kelly), Royal Canin Australia Pty Ltd (Wright), KLS Martin Australia Pty Limited (Lingford), Reward Hospitality (Barin), CFC Employment Trust (Carberry), KDR Victoria Pty Ltd (Tan), KinCare, In-home Carers (Dennehy), PAC Perth Pty Ltd (Stoney), Department of Human Services (Cooke), Sydney Trains (Malik), Western Sydney Community Legal Centre Incorporated (Girdler), Regis Aged Care Pty Ltd (Wang), Lockin Pty Ltd (Ware), Artisan Wine Storage Pty Ltd (Oldfield).

TERMINATION OF EMPLOYMENT – minimum employment period – ss.117, 383, 394, 400, 604 Fair Work Act – appeal – Full Bench – appeal against decision dismissing appellant’s jurisdictional objection that respondent had not served minimum employment period – letter dated 10 May 2016, appellant informed respondent of decision to terminate his employment, but would ‘not implement this decision until the dispute between the parties is resolved’ – dispute concerned s.739 application appellant regarding respondent’s employment – dispute determined by Full Bench in decision of November 2016 – appellant subsequently sent letter to respondent terminating his employment with immediate effect – at first instance, Commission found there was a valid notice of dismissal but letter dated 24 May 2016 did not meet requirements under s.117(1) of FW Act because date of dismissal lacked sufficient certainty – Commission found respondent had served minimum employment period and was protected from unfair dismissal – appellant submitted Commission erred in these conclusions – powers on appeal only exercisable if there is error on part of the primary decision maker – whether in public interest, where test is a ‘discretionary one involving a broad value judgement’ [Coal & Allied] – Full Bench found interrelationship between notice of termination requirements under s.117 and giving of notice of dismissal in accordance with s.383(a)(i) are an issue of importance and had not been previously considered by a Full Bench of the Commission – found first instance decision was, in part, erroneous and should be corrected – Full Bench satisfied in public interest to grant permission to appeal – found Commission in first instance was wrong to conclude that a notice of dismissal for the purpose of s.383(a)(i) FW Act must also meet requirements of s.117 – found that s.383(a)(i) does not make any reference to s.117 nor does it state that the notice has to be in writing or inform the recipient ‘of the day of termination’ as required by s.117 – employer is obligated to meet notice requirements under s.117 or contract in order to avoid unlawful dismissal – an unlawful dismissal does not invalidate termination of employment relationship, as distinct from employment contract – accordingly, Full Bench found that a notice of termination which did not comply with s.117 FW Act may be effective to bring about termination of employment relationship – Full Bench found part of the purpose of s.383(a)(i) is to provide certainty to both employer and employee as to whether the employment relationship is to be ongoing, or if not, when that relationship will come to an end – agreed with Commission in first instance a ‘notice of dismissal’ must either specify a time when termination is to take effect or that time must be ascertainable – held letter of 24 May 2016 did not specify a time when termination was to take effect, or made that time ascertainable – respondent could not have ascertained when dispute would be resolved and outcome of dispute uncertain – agreed with first instance decision letter of 24 May 2016 did not constitute a ‘notice of dismissal’ within the meaning of s.383(a)(i) – upheld decision in first instance to dismiss the appellant’s jurisdictional objection – appeal dismissed. Appeal by Metropolitan Fire and Emergency Services Board against decision of Ryan C of 7 March 2017 [[2017] FWC 1197] Re: Duggan

MODERN AWARDS – 4 yearly review – s.156 Fair Work Act 2009 – Full Bench proposed variations to the Broadcasting and Recorded Entertainment Award 2010 (Award) as part of 4 yearly review of modern awards – application to vary Award to expand coverage to types of roles not currently covered and clarify roles covered – applicants, Community and Public Sector Union (CPSU) and Media, Entertainment and Arts Alliance (MEAA), tended witness statements in support of variation and data set showing breakdown of adult and junior employees employed by cinema representatives as at 30 March 2015 and their respective classifications within Award – Screen Producers Association of Australia (SPA), also party to matter, expressed concerns about potential effects of specific wording set out in MEAA’s proposal to extend coverage of Award to include dancers in principle – no alternative proposal provided – no other submissions received opposing other aspects of variations – Penalty Rates Case decision adopted – Commission held would be inconsistent with modern awards objective for employees in new roles to remain awardfree, save for the Miscellaneous Award and a lone enterprise award – agreed that Award was most appropriate Award to cover these employees – fact that no opposition to CPSU’s proposal also considered – found necessary to extend coverage of Award to include new roles – MEAA proposal also considered necessary to meet modern awards objective by making Award ‘simple, easy to understand, stable and sustainable’ – Commission found current wording in exposure draft should be retained – determination varying Award to be made and comments sought from interested parties within four weeks of decision. Broadcasting and Recorded Entertainment Award 2010