Termination of employment – genuine redundancy – ss.389, 394 Fair Work Act 2009 – applicant was permanent part-time employee of the ABC’s News Division – respondent identified a number of positions to be made redundant in the News Division – applicant submitted casual employees were performing production tasks she previously performed – Commission satisfied applicant’s job was no longer required due to changes to ABC’s operational requirements – ABC Enterprise Agreement 2013-2016 applied to applicant’s employment – Commission accepted ABC discharged its obligations to consult applicant as per agreement – Commission satisfied not reasonable in all circumstances for applicant to be deployed – found applicant’s dismissal genuine redundancy – application dismissed. Tan v Australian Broadcasting Corporation.
February 5, 2016
Termination of employment – valid reason – s.394 Fair Work Act 2009 – applicant commenced employment as the Assistant to the Director of Studies which also encompassed a senior mathematics teaching role – in 2003 the applicant’s position was extended to include all aspects of timetabling, the academic database and the administrative tasks previously overseen by the Director of Studies – extended role became known as Academic Administrator (AA) – in 2013 the applicant became ill and was diagnosed with depression and anxiety, she finished the school year two days early due to her health – in December 2013 she had already applied for, and was granted, long service leave for the first term of the 2014 academic year – letter of termination did not cite reason for dismissal – loss of trust and confidence – extensive evidence led regarding applicants dispute with respondent about additional responsibility of AA role being removed from her duties – evidence led relating to return to work plan and allegations of conflict with colleagues – Selvachandran, Australian Meat Holdings P/L and McVinish considered – Commission found no valid reason for dismissal – reinstatement inappropriate – compensation appropriate – further hearing to be held regarding criteria for compensation. Anders v The Hutchins School.
February 5, 2016
Enterprise agreements – approval – s.185 Fair Work Act 2009 – application for approval of enterprise agreement – Commission concern regarding whether Notice of Employee Representation Rights (NERR) given to employees in the prescribed form; whether employer had taken reasonable steps to explain terms of Agreement and effect of those terms; and whether the Agreement passed the better off overall test (BOOT) – employees provided with two versions of NERR embedded within the text of an email – first version incomplete – second version embedded within other unrelated content – confusing and unclear – employee also attached weblink to NERR within email and within SMS message to employees – Commission found weblink to NERR set out in lengthy and confusing email, did not take employees directly to a copy of the NERR and did not direct their attention to the NERR – NERR not validly given – Commission not satisfied that weblink to a copy of the proposed Agreement and a range of other documents constituted an explanation of the Agreement or the effect of its terms – no genuine agreement – found numerous provisions of the Agreement when compared to Award caused Agreement not to pass the BOOT – application dismissed. Traineeship and Mining Services Enterprise Agreement 2015.
February 5, 2016
Enterprise agreements – termination of agreement – ss.225, 226 Fair Work Act 2009 – application by RCR Resolve FM P/L t/a RCR Resolve FM to terminate agreement after its nominal expiry date – nominal expiry date 31 May 2015 – Union of Christmas Island Workers (UCIW) opposed termination – no employees employed under agreement since 1 March 2014 – transfer of business to Serco Immigration Services P/L (Serco) on 28 February 2014 – employees employment with Serco regulated in part by agreement – UCIW and Serco had not concluded replacement enterprise agreement – applicant wished to ‘tie up’ loose ends – UCIW submitted agreement a transferable instrument and applied to relevant Serco employees – termination would provoke uncertainty for employees – Commission considered likely effect of termination on applicant and employees – satisfied not appropriate to terminate agreement – considered whether termination would be contrary to the public interest – on balance, with regard for all unusual circumstances, Commission satisfied contrary to public interest to terminate agreement – application dismissed. Union of Christmas Island Workers and Resolve FM Enterprise Agreement 2011.
February 5, 2016
Enterprise agreements – termination of agreement – ss.225, 226 Fair Work Act 2009 – application by Boom Logistics Ltd for termination of an enterprise agreement after its nominal expiry date – nominal expiry date was 1 September 2013 – CFMEU is the employee organisation covered by agreement – parties have been seeking to negotiate a replacement agreement since October 2013 but have not been successful – employees rejected a replacement agreement on 1 July 2015 – application for termination opposed by CFMEU – Aurizon considered – whether termination of the agreement was an appropriate response to the market difficulties in all the circumstances of the case – Commission not satisfied that it is not contrary to the public interest to terminate the agreement – termination would shift the balance in bargaining when the evidence shows that the agreement does not place Boom in a position of disadvantage in the market place – not satisfied that the requirements of s.226(a) and (b) of the FW Act have been established – termination of the agreement is not appropriate in all of the circumstances – application dismissed. Boom Logistics Ltd Hunter Valley Enterprise Agreement 2013.
February 5, 2016
Termination of employment – extension of time – s.394 Fair Work Act 2009 – application lodged 45 days late – following dismissal applicant claimed redundancy payments and sought entitlements through Fair Work Ombudsman (FWO) prior to filing for unfair dismissal – applicant submitted the respondent’s delay in denying his claim for redundancy pay contributed to his late lodgement – Commission held the applicant was aware of the denial of his claim for redundancy pay on 22 October when his application would have been within time – applicant also did not file until 10 days following the FWO advising it was not taking action – Commission not satisfied that a reasonable explanation provided for the whole of the delay – that applicant sought to resolve his claim for redundancy pay and entitlements prior to lodgement is not unusual – application dismissed. Green v Lanotec Australia P/L t/a Lanotec.
February 4, 2016
TERMINATION OF EMPLOYMENT – misconduct – s.394 Fair Work Act 2009 – applicant employed as ABA’s Training Manager – applicant terminated for engaging socially with a student at a private function outside normal business hours, that was unrelated to their education, and escorted a student to his private residence – applicant submitted reasons for termination did not appear in his employment contract and specifically did not appear under reasons for summary termination, adding that policies were not contractual in nature – applicant further submitted he had never been provided with evidence of the person who made the allegations against him – respondent submitted actions were not unduly harsh because the outcome was proportionate to the gravity of the applicant’s misconduct and senior position and influence within the company – respondent further submitted it risked reputation, viability and/or profitability of ABA’s business, including carrying with it the prospect of ABA losing its license to operate under both the National Vocational Education and Training Regulator Act 2011 and the ACT’s working with vulnerable people legislation – Rode’s decision considered – Commission found applicant’s actions fell within the definition of serious misconduct – as set out in ABA’s Workplace Behaviours Employee handbook – valid reason for dismissal – application dismissed. Farhnhill v Australian Business Academy P/L
February 4, 2016
ENTERPRISE AGREEMENTS – dispute about matter arising under agreement – s.739 Fair Work Act – application to deal with a dispute under the Bureau of Meteorology Enterprise Agreement 2011-2014 – employee sought correct calculation of salary for superannuation purposes – whether rent-free housing received by employee should be included in calculation of salary – employee entitled to rent-free housing pursuant to clause 29.4(a) of agreement – Superannuation Act 1990 and Public Sector Superannuation Scheme Trust Deed considered – whether rent-free housing provided to employee is a type of allowance referred to in Reg 5(e) of the Superannuation (CSS) Salary Regulations 1978 – held employee received rent-free housing because of the particular office he holds – agreement does not provide Commission with power to determine correct calculation of salary for superannuation purposes – determination not issued. Hegarty v Commonwealth of Australia (acting through and represented by the Bureau of Meteorology)