NEWS HR

Perfume Network NSW Pty Ltd is ‘on the nose’ with four ex-staffers. The quartet is amongst a 30 strong tribe pressing the Fair Work Commission to give them a golden handshake. The full list of applicants is: University of Wollongong (Saffitoi), ISS Facility Services Australia Ltd (Rucker), Davell Products (Davies), HNZ Australia Pty Ltd (Gorlin), Next Residential Pty Ltd (Gardiner), Australia Western Railroad Pty Ltd (Moroe), Giacci Bros Pty Ltd (Ruiz/Wheatley), Country Fire Authority (Ross), Employsure Pty Ltd (Sidney), Milgate Primary School (Heading), Pearcedale Egg Farm (Morphett), CUB Pty Ltd (Sayers), Jania Jewellery Pty Ltd (Suto-Allday), FS Structural Pty Ltd (Barry), Boathouse Tavern (Roberts), Legrand Australia (Sheehan), The H + C Trust (Rauk), Phillip Arcidiacono (Llauder-Caddy), JLF Systems Pty Ltd (Edwards), FPC30 Ltd as Trustee for FPC Green Fund Trust (You), Trans North Bus & Coach (Doyle), JLF Systems Pty Ltd (Edwards), Prouds Jewellers Pty Ltd (King), Civil Contractors Federation-Queensland Branch (Sawford), Gilbarco Aus Pty Ltd (Singh), San Remo Macaroni Company Pty Ltd (Sianipar), Boart Longyear Australia Pty Ltd (Mudge), Perfume Network NSW Pty Ltd (Abbasi, Kashif, Mushtaq, Riaz), Trustee for the Marshall Family Trust (Hanlsow).

CONDITIONS OF EMPLOYMENT – redundancy – s.120 Fair Work Act 2009 – application for variation of redundancy pay – applicant sought to reduce redundancy pay from 14 weeks to four weeks – respondent employed for over eight years as store manager – respondent made redundant due to store closure – applicant submitted made respondent offer of ‘acceptable employment’ at another store location – applicant rejected offer and respondent relocated another staff member to create role for respondent at further store location – respondent submitted was presented with options of redeployment of a redundancy package – respondent contended initially decided to take redundancy package as new store too far to travel – Commission not satisfied respondent entitled to conclude he had choice of redeployment or pay of full redundancy entitlements in circumstances – applicant entitled to pursue application where offer of redeployment rejected – s.120 of FW Act does not impose absolute test on employer’s ability to ‘obtain’ alternative employment but rather refers to action which redundant employee [Derole Nominees] – applicant did act to additional inconvenience and cost for respondent in another store – minor applicant’s offer not deemed sufficient basis for refusing offer of redeployment [Spotless] – offer of redeployment held to be ‘acceptable employment’ – redundancy entitlement reduced to four weeks – order issued. Man to Man P/L t/a Man to Man v Mekkaoui

TERMINATION OF EMPLOYMENT – misconduct – ss.387, .400, 604 Fair Work Act – appeal – Full Bench – Commission found at first instance while vaild reason to dismiss, dismissal harsh and unjust – $42,846.90 compensation ordered – employer appeal related to finding dismissal harsh and unjust and quantum of compensation – employee applicant appeal concerned remedy – employer submitted Commissioner erred in making findings of fact which did not reflect evidence, or incorrectly understood evidence – Commission noted public interest test under s.400 FW Act ‘a stringent one’ (Allied Mining Services) – decision of discretionary nature usually can only be successfully challenged on appeal if shown discretion not exercised correctly – Full Bench considered in public interest to grant permission to appeal due to importance of appeals’ subject matter and strength of grounds advanced – regarding finding dismissal ahrsh and unjust, Full Bench held in finding that no opportunity to respond was provided, Commissioner did not properly consider opportunities given to applicant during investigation process – reached conclusion inconsistent with evidence – approach inconsistent with authorities – Full Bench held no basis for finding – finding a significant error of fact – consequences of erroneous finding was that a factor which tended towards overall finding of fairness was considered a factor indicating unfairness, to the point combined with other considerations, of outweighing the finding of a valid reason for dismissal – Full Bench considered error meant that discretion vested in Commissioner miscarried and that appeal must be allowed and fairness of dismissal reconsidered – not necessary to determine other appeal grounds – permission to appeal granted – appeal allowed – decisions and order of Commissioner quashed – Full Bench to determine application based on evidence adduced before Commissioner – matter to be relisted. Appeal by BHP Coal P/L t/a BMA against decisions and order of Booth C of 7 May 2015, 18 August 2015 and 19 August 2015 [[2015] FWC 2724 and [2015] FWC 5699] and appeal by Schmidt against decisions and order of Booth C of 7 May 2015, 18 August 2015 and 19 August 2015 [[2015] FWC 2724 and [2015] FWC 5699] re:Schmidt

GENERAL PROTECTIONS – extension of time – amendment of application -ss.365, 586 Fair Work Act 2009 – application to deal with contraventions involving dismissal made by AWU on behalf of six members – lodged five days outside statutory timeframe – application to amend general protections application by addition of further respondents – employees engaged by MPC Gas under the Murphy Pipe and Civil Gas QCLNC Upstream Project Works redundant – MPC Operations Labour employed employees – employees now subject to Old Employee Collective Enterprise Agreement 2014 – AWU alleged work undertaken by employees work previously covered by Murphy Pipe and Civil Gas QCLNC Upstream Project Works Enterprise Agreement 2011 – AWU alleged adverse action against employees because employees had a workplace right being entitlement to benefit of Murphy Pipe and Civil Gas QCLNC Upstream Project Works Enterprise Agrement 2011 – AWU submitted MPC Operations Labour was involved in contravention of s.340(1) – whether exceptional circumstances to extend time – AWU relied on reason for delay being a representative error – general protections application indicated AWU applicant represented by Maurice Blackburn Lawyers – representative error may constitute exceptional circumstances and be sufficient reason to extend time [Interstate Transport P/L] Commission found AWU was not acting as a representative when general protections application made – employees did not provide instructions to AWU to make application – Commission did not accept to exercise discretion to extend time where AWU was the applicant – whether Commission has power under s.586 to amend general protections application by adding MPC Construction as a Respondent – AWU asserted being unaware of involvement of MPC Constructions when application was made – must be treated as a fresh application against the Company – application made outside of time – Commission accepted company structures under MPC Construction operates is complex – Commission not satisfied exceptional circumstances existed to allow exercise of discretion to extend time for making general protections application – application dismissed – application to amend general protections application also dismissed. The Australian Workers’ Union v Murphy Pipe & Civil Gas P/L and Ors

TERMINATION OF EMPLOYMENT – incapacity – inherent requirements – s.394 Fair Work Act 2009 – application for unfair dismissal remedy – applicant employed as Credit Assessment Officer – applicant also sole director of mortgage services company – Australian Securities and Investments Commission (ASIC) banned applicant from engaging in ‘credit activities’ for period of five years – ASIC based decision on applicant submitting two false and misleading annual compliance certificates – respondent submitted applicant unable to perform inherent requirements of role and failed to seek approval for outside business interest – lost confidence in applicant as she was not honest and forthright during investigations – whether applicant able to perform things essential to her position considered – it is the substantive position or role of the employee that must be considered and not some modified, restricted duties or temporary alternative position [Boag and Son] – an inability to perform inherent requirements of position will generally provide a valid reason for dismissal but will not invariably be so … dismissal based on an incapacity to perform inherent requirements of position may be valid reason if employee has capacity to perform inherent requirements of job [Qantas Airways Ltd v Christie] – Commission found effect of banning order meant applicant could not perform inherent requirements of position – also found applicant’s failure to be candid and honest, together with failure to notify respondent, were sufficient reasons that respondent could no longer have trust and confidence in her as employee – Commission found applicant not unfairly dismissed – application dismissed. Callychum v Australia and New Zealand Banking Group t/a ANZ

ENTERPRISE AGREEMENTS – dispute about matter arising under agreement – s.739 Fair Work Act 2009 – application to deal with a dispute regarding income protection insurance under Kentz (Australia) P/L Ichtys Onshore Construction Greenfields Agreement – CEPU claimed Kentz were not paying income protection insurance to approved insurer within meaning of the clause – Kentz made arrangements with alternative insurer instead of insurers named in agreement – interpretation of clause and whether Kentz’s arrangements are compliant – Kentz referenced s.12 Insurance Act 1973 (Cth) that enables Australian Prudential Regulatory Authority to receive applications from bodies corporate – question of the meaning of phrase approved insurer – interpretation of enterprise agreement requires construction of words of the instrument [Golden Cockerel] – necessary to determine whether an agreement has a plain meaning or contains ambiguity – regard has to be made to the whole of the term and not only phrase ‘approved insurer’ – regard may be had to evidence of surrounding circumstances in determining whether an ambiguity exists – task of interpreting an agreement does not involve rewriting agreement to achieve fair or just outcome – plain meaning of clause requires Kentz to make income protection arrangements with an approved insurer – list is non-restrictive – Commission concluded insufficient material to express concluded view if a party desires to depart from named insurers listed. Communications, Electrical, Electronic, Energy, Information, Postal, Plumbing and Allied Services Union of Australia v Kentz (Australia) P/L

ENTERPRISE AGREEMENTS – dispute about matter arising under agreement – s.739 Fair Work Act 2009 – application to deal with a dispute arising under the Kentz (Australia) P/L Ichthys Onshore Construction Greenfields Agreement – dispute over the permissibility for a notice of termination to run concurrently with a period of Rest and Recreation (R&R) provided for in the agreement – Commission satisfied it has jurisdiction to deal with dispute – CEPU submitted that an employer cannot give notice concurrent with other forms of leave, and characterised R&R as an entitlement to be absent – further submitted that as R&R provides for time away from the workplace for a designated reason while notice of termination is to enable alternative employment to be sought, allowing these to run concurrently vitiates the reason for notice or the reason for absence – submitted by Kentz that R&R is not comparable to other periods of leave as it is a ‘creature of the parties agreement’ and is a separate part of the agreement to that dealing with leave – also submitted by Kentz that clause 8.6(c) does not prohibit notice being given during, or to coincide with, a period of R&R – no definition in agreement of ‘rest and recreation’ as it is only defined in relation to rosters – Commission satisfied that in the absence of any construction or purpose of R&R to the contrary. It is a form of regulated and approved leave – held that in providing payment in lieu of notice under the agreement, notice cannot be given such that it runs concurrent with a period of R&R. Communications, Electrical, Electronic, Energy, Information, Postal, Plumbing and Allied Services Union of Australia v Kentz (Australia) P/L

Twenty-five unfair dismissal cases will be heard today by Fair Work Commissioners. The full list is: ADSE Pty Ltd (Karaklic), Wambo Open Cut Pty Ltd (Garland), AECOM Government Services Australia Pty Ltd (Hall), Calvary Health Care Tasmania Limited (Beamish), Merlin Tyres Pty Ltd (Cooper), AGL Loy Yang Pty Ltd (Wright), BNR Logistics Pty Ltd (Leota), CUB Pty Ltd (Sayers), Geelong Harley-Davidson (Wall), The Hutchins School (Anders), Evolve Training Systems Pty Ltd (Weston), SMSF Audits Pty Ltd (Cooney), Bailey Civil Contractors Pty Ltd (Logan), Sinclair Recruitment (Remfrey), JBS Australia Pty Limited & Labour Solutions Australia Pty Ltd (Muhammad), Menzies Jewellers (Gaszner), The Trustee for Sogal Trust (Gupta), Bupa Care Services Pty Limited (Cox), ACE Insurance Limited (Sweeney), Prosegur Australia Pty Ltd (Kirk), Ivana’s Pty Ltd (Gunnery), Perfume Network NSW Pty Ltd (Abbasi/Kashif/Mushtaq/Riaz) and Pactum Australia Pty Ltd (Tamati).