CASE PROCEDURES – application dismissed on FWC’s own initiative – ss.394, 587 Fair Work Act 2009 – application for unfair dismissal remedy – at conference applicant requested to provide medical assessment to confirm he was medically fit to continue application – upon receipt of medical evidence Commission issued further amended directions – applicant failed to attend further conference and failed to comply with directions and amended directions – parties unable to provide an Agreed Statement of Facts pursuant to amended directions – applicant advised Commission he was medically unfit to continue and arbitration vacated – Commission contacted applicant several items to confirm whether applicant pursue application – Commission requested applicant provide evidence that he was medically unfit to proceed with application – applicant advised that failure to provide information would lead to dismissal of matter – no further communications received from applicant – application dismissed for want of prosecution pursuant to s.587(3) of FW Act – Order issued. Spee v BHP Billiton WAIO P/L
March 3, 2016
TERMINATION OF EMPLOYMENT – misconduct – s.394 Fair Work ACt 2009 – application for unfair dismissal remedy – applicant dismissed for serious misconduct – a number of employees who reported to the applicant had left the organisation – respondent conducted investigation regarding applicant’s behaviour towards employees – found the treatment of subordinates condescending, belittling and humiliating – applicant’s behaviour towards employees – found the treatment of subordinate condescending, belittling and humiliating – applicant’s supervisory practices amounted to a breach of bullying and harassment policy which amounted to serious misconduct – found valid reason for dismissal – applicant’s conduct was inappropriate for the position she held – found applicant not unfairly dismissed – application dismissed. McLean v The Australian Council for Education Research Limited.
March 3, 2016
CASE PROCEDURES – employer in liquidation – s.394 Fair Work Act 2009 – application for unfair dismissal remedy made in July 2012 – conciliation unsuccessful – matter listed for hearing – in October 2012 respondent advised Commission it had appointed a voluntary administrator from SV Partners – in June 2015 SV Partners informed the Commission that the winding up of the company was on-going – application cannot proceed without leave of the Court – Commission is not a ‘Court’ and is therefore unable to grant leave [Smith] – application stayed until leave of the Court is granted. Carlson v Poolrite Australia P/L
March 3, 2016
ENTERPRISE AGREEMENTS – dispute about matter arising under agreement – s.739 Fair Work Act 2009 – alleged dispute regarding sick leave – whether employee entitled to extended sick leave in accordance with Moorabbin Manufacturing Operations Enterprise Agreement 2011-2015 – applicant bitten by poisonous spider – absent from work for 17 days – issue whether medical condition was ‘prolonged’ and ‘expected to last for an extended period’ – Golden Cockerel applied – ambiguity in terms ‘prolonged’, ‘serious’, and ‘extended’ – company’s history of applying term considered – applicant’s condition not found to be serious or expected to last for an extended period – applicant not entitled to extended sick leave. Daley v Coca Cola Amatil t/a Coca Cola Amatil (Australia) P/L
March 3, 2016
Twenty three applicants will chance their arm today and try and convince a Fair Work Commissioner they have been wronged. The full list of angels includes: Medalist [Test-Rite] (Kazmar); Commonwealth of Australia as represented by the Australian Federal Police (Read); Westpac Banking Corporation (Simpson); IBM Australia (Rogan); Belgravia Leisure Pty Ltd (Pertot); Ngnampa Health Council (Hodder); Woolworths Limited (Mastorakos); True Value Solar Pty Ltd (Skoullos); Spotless Group [Utility Services Group Limited] (Spencer); CUB Pty Ltd (Aitken); JLF System Pty Ltd (Edwards); FPC30 Ltd as Trustee for FPC Green Fund Trust (You); Trans North Bus & Coach (Doyle); JLF Systems Pty Ltd (Edwards); Proud Jewellers Pty Ltd (King); Civil Contractors Federation-Queensland Branch (Sawford); Ozcare (Mazi); Ace Recycling Pty Ltd (Hain); Calvary Health Care Adelaide Limited (Hansen); Heigh Manufacturing [No 2] Pty Ltd (Strudwick); LHI Retirement Services – Glynde (Vucetic); Salena Estate Wines Pty Ltd (Anderson); and Gowdie Management Group (Lankapothu).
March 2, 2016
CASE PROCEDURES – apprehension of bias – s.394 Fair Work Act 2009 – application for relief from unfair dismissal – respondent objected on basis applicant had not been employed for minimum employment period, and applicant filed application three days before dismissal took effect – applicant subsequently filed a second application which was out of time – both applications listed for mention – respondent withdrew its objection that applicant had not served minimum employment period – respondent’s lawyer sought that the Commissioner rescue himself from determining the second objection on the basis of apprehended bias given a comment made during the mention – respondent contended that an apprehension of bias arose because the Commission had cautioned respondent in respect of costs if the jurisdictional objection regarding the expiry of time and the waiver of irregularity was pursued – respondent claimed the caution as to costs indicated that the Commission may have pre-judged the merit of the objection before having the benefit of submissions – no audio recording of exact words used by the Commission and parties exists – Commission acknowledged the issue of costs was raised but did not recall words used – ResMed Ltd v AMWU considered – reasonable bystander test – unrealistic to conclude that a fair minded lay observer would come to the view that comments made by the Commission at the mention would lead to a real possibility the Commission would not bring an impartial mind to resolution of respondent’s second objection once both applicant and respondent set out their respective cases – reasonable apprehension must be ‘firmly established’ – any view or comment expressed by the Commission in the mention would have no possible impact on substantive proceedings or any costs applications – Commission did not rescue himself from dealing with the matter. Gee v Tasmania Ports Corporation P/L t/a Tasports
March 2, 2016
ENTERPRISE AGREEMENTS – dispute about matter arising under agreement – jurisdiction – s.739 Fair Work Act 2009 – dispute relates to redundancy provisions arising under clause 23 and Appendix 2 of the Treasury Wine Estates Vintners Ltd – Great Western Maintenance and Laboratory Collective Agreement 2014 – jurisdictional objection – respondent asserts that AMWU raised dispute after affected employees were no longer employed and for a dispute of this kind to be progressed it had to be initiated by the employees when they were in employment – AMWU asserts that whilst dispute concerned entitlements of two individuals it could also be characterised as a dispute about the application of clause 23 and Appendix 2 of the agreement in general – Commission satisfied dispute is about the application of clause 23 and Appendix 2 of the agreement – Commission satisfied on wording of agreement that AMWU has the right to initiate a dispute and the power to notify a dispute to the Commission in its own right – North Goonyella and King distinguished from the circumstances of this matter – Commission found dispute was notified by the AMWU in its own right and this is not affected by the fact that the employees in question had left employment at the time the dispute was notified – Commission satisfied it has jurisdiction to deal with the dispute – respondent directed to file further materials – matter listed for further hearing. ‘Automotive, Food, Metals, Engineering, Printing and Kindred Industries Union’ known as the Australian manufacturing Workers’ Union (AMWU) v Southcorp Wines P/L.
March 2, 2016
The Australian Municipal, Administrative, Clerical and Services Union and Buloke Shire Council are in a s.739 (Application to deal with a dispute) arm-wrestle before Fair Work Commissioner Bissett in Melbourne.