NEWS HR

Thirty-six sweet innocent angels who believe they have been collectively wronged will today plead their case before the Fair Work Commissioners. The full list of lily-whites is listed and includes: Trend Laboratories Pty Ltd (Lowe), Stay in Bed Milk & Bread Pty Ltd (Malhotra), Blamey Community Group (Adams), West Coast Council (Billett), Labour Resources Central West Pty Ltd (Hodges), Sydney Trains (Chand), BigAir Group (Anand), Coles Group Supply Chain Pty Ltd (Collins/ Roberts), Access Group Solutions Pty Ltd (Kaur), Serco Australia Pty Ltd (Markovska), Australian Institute of Workplace Learning (Corolis), St John of God Health Care Inc (Tarus), Spotless Limited (Williams), Big Daddy’s Pty Ltd (Smith), Azza Family Day Care (Schurer), Ashton College Pty Ltd (Pohl), CSL Australia Pty Ltd (Blom/ Clothier/ Kohler/ MacDonald/ Rokov), UAM Pty Ltd (Collins), Boyle Smelters Limited (Maycock), Jetstar Airways Pty Ltd (Eakins), Veolia Environmental Services (Australia) Pty Ltd (Bradley), Golridge Pty Ltd (Solman), ALSCO Pty Limited (Podesta), TNT Australia Pty Ltd (Martin), Golden Cockerel Pty Ltd (Tuki), Secure Parking Pty Ltd (Syed), Les Brazier Special Valentines Pty Ltd (Hawkins), Balanced Habitats (Bronakowski), Como Glasshouse Unit Trust (McCulley), SA Motorcycles (Case), RCR Laser Pty Ltd (Laird).

ENTERPRISE BARGAINING – bargaining order – s.229 Fair Work Act 2009 – application for a bargaining order – CPSU alleged that bargaining had been impeded because of failure by Australian Electoral Commission (AEC) to give genuine consideration to proposals made – alleged AEC failed to disclose relevant information – alleged failures relate to consultation clause and additional clauses, including domestic violence leave clause and NAIDOC/ceremonial/cultural leave clause – CPSU sought order which included process for fully authorised officers of the Australian Public Service Commission or the Minister Assisting the Prime Minister for the Public Service to be brought to the bargaining table – consideration given to the terms ‘bargaining representative’ and ’employing authority’ – found that ‘an employer that will be covered by the agreement’ (being a bargaining representative for the agreement) is a reference to the employer being the Commonwealth and that any of the following; ‘the Public Service Minister’, ‘The Agency Minister’, ‘The Agency Head’ or ‘an APS employee’ may be an employing authority so far as it is concerned with AEC bargaining – good faith bargaining requirements and Endeavour Coal considered – Consultation clause – CPSU alleges that AEC representatives were instructed by APSC about what could be proposed for agreement – CPSU allege as a result AEC failed to genuinely consider the CPSU proposal as well as failed to explain reasoning – Commission found evidence showed genuineness to bargaining – not satisfied there was failure to meet good faith bargaining requirements – Additional clauses – AEC alleged CPSU had not validly brought application regarding additional clauses – AEC argued CPSU had not raised additional clauses as a failure to meet good faith bargaining and that there continues to be bargaining regarding these clauses – Commission found CPSU had not complied with requirements of s.229(4)(b) of FW Act – found it not appropriate to consider the application notwithstanding it was not made in accordance with FW Act – found nothing in the AEC’s conduct regarding the additional clauses that would cause the Commission to find it had not met good faith bargaining requirements – Conduct of APSC or Minister – found no evidence that any other employer bargaining representative did not meet good faith bargaining requirements – found that a policy of some kind (whether written or not) is not unusual in bargaining – found not unusual for there to be negotiating instructions or parameters that limit authority of bargaining representatives – Esso considered – Disclosure of information – found information sought by CPSU has been provided by the AEC – application dismissed. CPSU, the Community and Public Sector Union v The Commonwealth of Australia (Acting through and represented by the Australian Electoral Commission and/or the Minister Assisting the Prime Minister for the Public Service)

ENTERPRISE AGREEMENTS – dispute about matter arising under agreement – ss.604, 739 Fair Work Act 2009 – appeal – Full Bench – appeal by Kentz against decision regarding application by CEPU to resolve a dispute in relation to notice of termination and rest and recreation provisions (R&R) of the Kentz (Australia) P/L Ichthys Onshore Construction Greenfields Agreement – grounds of appeal were that the Commission erred in exercising powers judicial in nature and outside remit of s.739 of FW Act – erred in mischaracterising R&R as akin to a leave entitlement that would be undermined by a period of notice of termination operating concurrently with it – erred in misconstruing clause 8.6(a) of agreement as preventing Kentz from providing a period of notice of termination in relation to a period of time including R&R days under predetermined work cycle – Full Bench granted permission to appeal in the public interest due to jurisdictional issue raised, broader implication for Ichthys agreements and error found in relation to characterisation of R&R – in relation to jurisdictional ground, Full Bench found Commission, in dealing with dispute under clause 18 of agreement, properly undertook role of private arbitration and was not engaged in the exercise of judicial power – appeal ground dismissed – in relation to the characterisation of R&R, Full Bench found Commission erred in characterisation of R&R in context of agreement and in the application of relevant authorities to R&R in that context – relevant element of first instance decision quashed, in particular findings that R&R a form of regulated and approved leave; notice of termination of employment unable to run concurrently with period of leave; pay in lieu of notice cannot assume employee would have been on unpaid leave for part of notice period and consequently reduce the amount of pay in lieu; and finding that in providing payment in lieu under agreement, notice could not be given such that it ran concurrently with a period of R&R – Full Bench determined relevant aspect of dispute itself and substituted its findings for those of Commission – held that R&R is properly characterised as the block of authorised non-work time which forms an integral part of the work cycle – employee whose employment terminated with payment in lieu would have worked the working hours established in their work cycle had their employment continued until the end of the minimum period of notice and would not have worked, or been paid in respect of, any R&R period which fell within the work cycle over that period of time – held no error by Commission with respect to clause 8.6(a) of agreement – appeal dismissed in relation to characterisation of clause 8.6(a). Appeal by Kentz (Australia) P/L against decision of Bissett C of 3 February 2016 [[2016] FWC 669] Re: Communications, Electrical, Electronic, Energy, Information, Postal, Plumbing and Allied Services Union of Australia

TERMINATION OF EMPLOYMENT – misconduct – s.394 Fair Work Act 2009 – applicant dismissed for alleged serious misconduct – respondent had gone into liquidation and neither the receiver and manager of the liquidator filed any material in opposition to the application – Commission unable to be satisfied that the applicant had committed serious misconduct – found the dismissal was unfair – no valid reason to dismiss and applicant denied procedural fairness – applicant sought reinstatement and payment of five months wages, being the time from his dismissal to the present date, because he has struggled to find work and will continue to struggle to find work because his reputation has been tarnished – found no position with the company to which he could be reinstated – Commission unable to make orders that new owner offer him employment. – reinstatement not appropriate in these circumstances – compensation appropriate – increased by 30% to compensate applicant for the loss of income beyond the sale of the business – ordered compensation of $13,752.96 plus and additional $1,306.53 to his nominated superannuation fund. Roberts v Fraser-Scott Developments P/L (Receivers and Managers Appointed) (In Liquidation)

TERMINATION OF EMPLOYMENT – extension of time – date dismissal took effect – s.394 Fair Work Act 2009 – application for relief from unfair dismissal lodged outside 21 day statutory timeframe – in employer response form respondent contended applicant notified of dismissal on 7 October 2015 – in written submissions respondent submitted applicant was aware of her dismissal on 30 September 2015 – applicant submitted that she only received correspondence advising her of her dismissal on 7 October 2015 – termination of employment does not take effect unless and until it is communicated to the employee whose employment is being terminated [Burns] – at hearing respondent acknowledged it had originally cited 7 October 2015 as the termination date and stated this had been done in error – material before the Commission indicated the respondent’s letter of 25 September 2015 did not state that employment had been terminated, it advised applicant employment will be terminated if she did not provide the required medical certificates by 29 September 2015 – proposed termination conditional on applicant not doing something within specified timeframe – applicant only received letter on 30 September 2015, though respondent had previously requested the medical certificates – applicant not advised she had been dismissed until email of 7 October 2015 – Commission held effective date of dismissal was 7 October 2015 and her application was lodged within the 21 day statutory timeframe – jurisdictional objection dismissed – application listed for conference. Hunt v Reinforced Concrete Pipes Australia P/L

CASE PROCEDURES – representation – s.596 Fair Work Act 2009 – application for relief from unfair dismissal – respondent submitted it was entitled to be represented by Australian Mines and Metals Association (AMMA) without needing to seek or be granted permission – submitted it was a member of AMMA and that AMMA was an association of employers not registered under the Fair Work (Registered Organisations) Act 2009 (RO Act) – FW Act provides that a party to a proceeding may be represented by an association of employers not registered under the RO Act – Commission considered meaning of ‘association of employers’ – satisfied that AMMA an association of employers – witness statement of AMMA Executive Director stated AMMA’s principal purpose the provision of industry advocacy and employment advice and representation for employers in the Australian resources industry, and that respondent a member of AMMA – witness statement unchallenged – Commission satisfied that a purpose of AMMA is the protection and promotion of interests of employers in matters concerning employment – Commission satisfied respondent a member of AMMA – satisfied respondent entitled to be represented by AMMA without needing to seek or be granted permission from Commission. Marrs v Subsea 7 i-Tech Australia P/L t/a Subsea 7

TERMINATION OF EMPLOYMENT – extension of time – s.394 Fair Work Act 2009 – application for relief from unfair dismissal – application made 14 days outside the 21 day time limit – applicant submitted she contacted ‘Fairwork’ and a law firm, however neither stated that the lodgment should be made within 21 days – applicant contacted the respondent directly to try to resolve the matter – Commission found applicant took positive steps to determine her rights but for some unexplained reason never sought to ensure that her application was made within time – respondent did not oppose the grant of extension of time – extension of time granted – matter referred to further programing. Raschilla v Ausino West P/L atf The Supercrane Unit Trust t/a Supercrane Engineered Lifting Technology

TERMINATION OF EMPLOYMENT – application to dismiss by employer – non-compliance with directions – ss.394, 399A, 587 Fair Work Act 2009 – application for relief from unfair dismissal – applicant directed to file material in support of his application by 21 March 2016 – on 16 March 2016 applicant sent email requesting extension of time to file material – applicant asked to advise how long he was requesting so his application for an extension of time could be considered – on 21 March 2016 applicant advised he sought a six month extension – on 22 March 2016 respondent wrote to Commission noting the applicant’s non-compliance and said there were ‘grounds for the Fair Work Commission to strike out this matter’ – applicant provided with a copy of respondent’s application and asked to respond by 14 April 2016 – on 6 April 2016 applicant advised request for a six month adjournment had been rejected – applicant again requested a six month adjournment – respondent filed submissions in support of its application – applicant did not comply with the directions issued for him to file his material by 14 April 2016 – primary submission was applicant’s claim should be dismissed because he had unreasonably failed to comply with two sets of directions – further submitted applicant will not in the foreseeable future be able to prosecute his claim and provide evidence, that this should give rise to finding that his application had no reasonable prospects of success – applicant did not provide any compelling reasons why he is not able to prepare his case in time normally provided to parties – significant amount of material on Commission’s website to assist unrepresented parties – Commission has discretion to dismiss application because there has been unreasonable non-compliance with directions – role of case management in Ghalloub adopted – Commission not satisfied applicant’s case has no reasonable prospects of success – not satisfied his failure to comply with directions means case is bound to fail – found applicant has not ignored the Commission – not satisfied applicant shown intention not to prosecute claim – Commission not prepared to dismiss applicant’s application – directions for applicant to file his material within 14 days of this decision issued – if applicant does not comply with these directions then his application will be dismissed without further notice. Costello v Queensland Rail Transit Authority t/a Queensland Rail