NEWS HR

TERMINATION OF EMPLOYMENT – misconduct – ss.387, 394, Fair Work Act 2009 – Regulation 1.07 of the Fair Work Regulations 2009 – applicant employed as Assistance Store Manager at various Prouds and Angus & Coote stores – applicant summarily dismissed following investigation in October 2015 into allegations of misconduct – following investigation into number of allegations including creation of laybys without customer being in store, staff discounts to friend and bullying team member applicant dismissed – respondent submitted applicant breached policies and procedures and terms of contract which required compliance with policies and procedures – applicant submitted actions were administrative errors and not serious enough to warrant termination – applicant also submitted that had good work history – Commission considered whether dismissal harsh, unjust or unreasonable taking into account criteria in s.387 FW Act – phrase ‘termination of employment may be unjust because employee was not guilty of misconduct on which employer acted, may be unreasonable because it was decided upon inferences which could not have reasonably been drawn from material… and may be harsh in its consequences for the personal and economic situation of the employee’ [Byrne v Australian Airlines] – Commission considered each allegation separately and found applicant had engaged in misconduct – found applicant notified of reason and provided with opportunity to respond – found respondent did not unreasonably refuse support person – Commission found not necessary to make finding as to whether misconduct of employee fits definition of serious misconduct under reg. 1.07 FW regulations [O’Connell v Wesfarmers Kleenheat Gas] – Commission found dismissal not harsh, unjust or unreasonable – application dismissed. King v Prouds Jewellers P/L

TERMINATION OF EMPLOYMENT – misconduct – s.394 Fair Work Act 2009 – applicant falsified timesheets claiming overtime not worked – applicant not truthful when allegations put to him by respondent – applicant claimed overtime hours on various days and aggregated a claim for overtime payment into single period – found no evidence such system was in place in respondent’s business – applicant unable to put forward consistent explanation about his timekeeping – Commission found valid reason for dismissal – dismissal not harsh, unjust or unreasonable – application dismissed. Lacase v Neon Group P/L t/a Neon Cosmetics P/L

TERMINATION OF EMPLOYMENT – termination at initiative of employer – casual – s.394 Fair Work Act 2009 – applicant moved states and sought employment at a Melbourne-based store – applicant stopped receiving casual hours after Christmas and concluded he was dismissed – respondent denied applicant dismissed – Commissioner considered ss.385 and 386 in determining whether applicant dismissed – Commission not satisfied applicant dismissed – fluctuation in hours is common for casuals – the lead up to Christmas is commonly busy in retail sector – Commission acknowledges that applicant no longer trusts business on basis that it has not provided ongoing casual work – however, Commission not confident applicant exhausted all casual opportunities – applicant not dismissed – application dismissed. Longman v QBD The Bookshop P/L t/a QBD The Bookshop

TERMINATION OF EMPLOYMENT – extension of time – s.394 Fair Work Act 2009 – application for relief from unfair dismissal remedy filed 2 days out of time – not satisfied acceptable reason for delay for lodging application – consideration of action taken to dispute dismissal weighed in favour of granting application – application has considerable merit and weighs in favour of granting application – satisfied strength of merit case combined with action taken to dispute dismissal sufficient to satisfy Commission that there are exceptional circumstances warranting further period for lodging application – in interests of justice to extend time [Haining] – order issued. Sierra v Comphire P/L

TERMINATION OF EMPLOYMENT – misconduct – s.394 Fair Work Act 2009 – application for unfair dismissal remedy – reasons for termination changed between time of dismissal and determination of unfair dismissal application – respondent verbally advised applicant of termination of employment at meeting due to applicant’s performance issues and falling profitability of business – applicant had no support person – after termination respondent alleged termination based on serious misconduct – applicant not given opportunity to respond to allegations of misconduct – applicant not warned about performance issues – Commission held respondent’s allegations of serious misconduct not valid reason for dismissal – Commission found applicant not notified at time of dismissal of reasons relied upon by respondent in proceedings – compensation ordered. . Bolton v Refresh Waters Queensland P/L

ANTI-BULLYING – bullied at work – s.789FC Fair Work Act 2009 – application for an order to stop bullying – applicant alleged employees checked up on her and complimented other receptionist and not her, and that she was stared at suspiciously, and no longer received text messages from another colleague about work arrangements – having preference of how things should be done and suggestions not being agreed to by a supervisor not found to be bullying – Commission of the view anti-bullying provisions of the FW Act are to protect bullying behaviour, not substantially a person’s feelings – Commission found no repetition of unreasonable behaviour – application dismissed. Mrs Gore

TERMINATION OF EMPLOYMENT – genuine redundancy – ss.389, 394 Fair Work Act 2009 – applicant dismissed after working for respondent for five years – applicant’s employment appeared to be without recorded incident or complaint – applicant called in to the respondent’s place of business on a day she was not rostered to work to attend a meeting with three representatives of the respondent – advised that her position was being terminated because of a serious deterioration in the financial position of the retail operation – respondent submitted that the termination of the applicant was consistent with the Small Business Fair Dismissal Code (the Code) and was a genuine redundancy – Commission found applicant’s dismissal not consistent with the Code as she was not provided with any opportunity to offer alternative suggestions to address the concerns of the respondent – no evidence provided by the respondent upon which the Commission could conclude that the financial difficulties of the respondent necessitated the reduction of one employee – no evidence that the respondent had complied with the requirements of s.389(i)(b) of the Act – abrupt nature of the applicant’s dismissal would fail to provide even the most elementary level of consultation – dismissal not a genuine redundancy – respondent’s initial response document made reference to a number of performance and conduct matters as the basis for dismissal which were not raised at hearing – Commission persuaded that these concerns were the actual basis of the applicant’s dismissal – dismissal harsh and unreasonable because the applicant was not provided with the true reason for her dismissal – the dismissal was implemented in a manner which denied the applicant an opportunity to provide any response to the reasons for her dismissal – compensation appropriate – 25 weeks compensation ordered – order issued. Tarbuck v Frockk P/L t/a Frockk

TERMINATION OF EMPLOYMENT – misconduct – s.394 Fair Work Act 2009 – applicant dismissed for misconduct – various protocol issues and performance based issues – applicant submitted that his behaviour did not amount to misconduct – submitted that there was not a valid reason for his dismissal and that he was denied proper process – Commission found conduct could not be properly construed as inadequate performance or misconduct which could provide sound and defensible reason for dismissal – applicant’s behaviour should have been addressed with some specified identification of particular incidents of concern together with requirement to have the applicant rectify the concerns – instead concerns were generalised and without clear requirements for rectification – Commission considered that the substantive reason for applicant’s dismissal was invalid – respondent’s process for dealing with the applicant’s alleged unsatisfactory performance was severely flawed such that the applicant was denied natural justice – dismissal unjust and unreasonable – compensation an appropriate remedy in the circumstances – applicant made efforts to mitigate the loss suffered – element of established misconduct in the form of retaliatory insubordination – twelve weeks compensation ordered – order issued. Kumar v Consulate General of India, Sydney