An ‘unfair dismissal lite’ day faces the Fair Work Commissioners. The full list is: ACT Government as represented by the Justice and Community Safety Directorate (Neville), All Earth Group Pty Ltd (Mayne), Ozcare (Mazi), Commonwealth of Australia (Department of Defence) (Bebawi), Evolution Traffic Control Pty Ltd (Adra), Jacobs Australia Pty Ltd (Brown), A Quick Core Concrete Cutting Service Pty Ltd (Morrison), Gino’s Automotive Accident Repair Centre Pty Ltd (Brookman), Zitron Australia Pty Ltd (Joy), Hair & Beauty on Dana (Lindsay), Seller Solutions Pty Ltd (Chamberlin), Embassy of Algeria – Canberra (Kim), Global Express Couriers Pty Ltd (Whitney), Achieve Corporate Services Pty Ltd as Trustee for Achieve Cleaning Services Trust (Souter-Robertson), Anglo Coal (Callide Management) Pty Ltd (Renton-Power), Centacare Catholic Family Services (Bartel).
June 10, 2016
Only a handful of unfair dismissal dispute cases will be heard on the eve of a long weekend. The full list is: Helensburgh Coal Pty Ltd (Cheetham), SJJ Group Pty Ltd (Abra), Algon Steel Pty Ltd (Mallinson), Bedingfeld Park Inc (Beliniak), Northern Co-operative Meat Company Ltd (Jackson), Australia Academy of Music and Performing Arts (Woodward), Electricity Generation and Retail Corporation (Turua), Vulcan Steel Pty Ltd (Elders), Kryolan Australia Pty Ltd (Richards), BPS Wholesales Pty Ltd (Hum), McLeanm Hayden Davison (Lewis-Driver), Truss Guard Rail Pty Ltd (Hart), The Trustee for The Grace Freeman Nelson Trust (Zosel), Francher Pty Ltd (Cooper), A&B Mylec Pty Ltd (Khalesirad), AECOM Australia Pty Ltd (Brown), Credit Corp Group Limited (Morgan), Cairns Dive Centre (Root), Journeys Kitchen & Bar (Winder), PSG Holdings (Anuj), Apollo Batteries (SA) Pty Ltd (Beldi), Cornerstone Stud Farm Pty Ltd (Twomey).
June 10, 2016
ENTERPRISE AGREEMENTS – dispute about matter arising under agreement – anti-bullying – ss.739, 789FC Fair Work Act 2009 – application to deal with dispute in accordance with dispute settlement procedures in the Essential Energy Far West Electricity Enterprise Agreement 2011 and Essential Energy (Electricity) Agreement 2013 (the Agreements) – two employees were advised substantive positions no longer required – now redeployees – Essential Energy had policy not to accept application for voluntary redundancy where employee entitled to more than 52 weeks’ redundancy pay – employees’ entitlements more than 52 weeks – applications for voluntary redundancy rejected – employees worked for 15 months, one given no tasks and other given insufficient meaningful work – CFMEU submitted Essential Energy obliged to pay redundancy pay as no meaningful roles or sufficient meaningful work provided – not a valid exercise of managerial prerogative – Essential Energy submitted acted reasonably in deciding not to accept applications, pursuing redeployment opportunities and providing temporary placements in meantime – employees also applied for orders to stop bullying – alleged bullying behaviour by CEO in leaving applicants without meaningful work and role for lengthy period – regarding anti-bullying applications, Commission noted that to meet bullying definition behaviour must be directed to or at the individual – Commission found no basis to infer that Essential Energy’s decision to adopt policy was directed to or at either employee personally – applications dismissed – in relation to disputes under the Agreements, Commission satisfied applicants’ employment not terminated – no repudiation – no contractual obligation for employer to provide work – no breach of terms of Agreements – found Essential Energy had not acted unlawfully – in absence of specific limitation in the Agreements, Commission not restricted to considering whether employer acted lawfully – under managerial prerogative principle, Commission not to interfere with right of employer to manage own business unless employer seeking something from employees which is unjust or unreasonable [XPT Case] – not unreasonable for Essential Energy to adopt general policy, but reasonableness undermined where unable to find useful work for employees whose roles were abolished and seeking voluntary redundancy – inevitable point where more costly to retain as employees than to accept voluntary redundancy – unreasonable as objectively irrational [Bropho] – impact on employees harsh – Essential Energy ordered to accept employees’ applications for voluntary redundancy. Millman and Anor v Essential Energy and Anor; Construction, Forestry, Mining and Energy Union v Essential Energy
June 10, 2016
TERMINATION OF EMPLOYMENT – misconduct – s.394 Fair Work Act 2009 – applicant employed for 3 years as a Dump Truck Operator – applicant had accident in work vehicle and did not report it – incident reported by another driver – applicant then acknowledged he was responsible for the damage – applicant stood down from work – applicant interviewed the following day – advised in interview that respondent considered the matter serious due to incident and applicants failure to report it – applicant attended disciplinary meeting and was terminated due to breach of safety procedures – applicant asserted termination was harsh, unjust and unreasonable – applicant asserted there was no valid reason for termination or, alternatively, the termination was disproportionate to the incident – applicant asserted termination was procedurally unfair as he was not advised that dismissal was a possible result of the first meeting – applicant gained further alternative employment nine weeks after termination and sought compensation rather than reinstatement – respondent argued it had a rigorous safety regime and policy in place which the applicant had been trained in and applicants failure to report breached this policy – respondent asserted there was a valid reason for termination due to the significant breach – Commission found respondent had a rigorous safety policy in place and the applicant breached this policy – Commission satisfied applicants decision not to report the incident significant – Commission found that although there was a breach of safety policies and practices, this was not a valid reason for dismissal – Commission found termination decision disproportionate to behaviour – Commission found termination harsh and unreasonable – reinstatement not appropriate – Sprigg considered regarding compensation – considered applicant would have been employed for another 6 months – applicant secured other comparable work within 9 weeks of termination – deduction of 50% for misconduct – compensation awarded – order issued. Atkinson v BGC Contracting P/L
June 10, 2016
RIGHT OF ENTRY – misuse of system – s.604 Fair Work Act 2009 – appeal – Full Bench – two previous decisions were made by Watson VP – this appeal related to the second of the decisions to suspend or revoke the entry permits of certain CFMEU officials – prior to the appeal hearing written submissions and authorities had been considered by the Full Bench – the preliminary view was that permission to appeal should be granted and that the first instance decision had not contained sufficient reasons resulting in procedural unfairness – in addition as the CFMEU Queensland had not been a party to the original proceedings the orders relating to that organisation should be quashed – on the basis of the preliminary view the parties reached a consent position upholding the appeal, quashing the relevant decision and orders and remitting the matter to Catanzariti VP – the FWBC had requested that the matter be remitted to Watson VP and this was opposed by the CFMEU – the Full Bench held that it would not be inappropriate to remit the matter to Watson VP but given the strong opposition to this by the CFMEU, it was preferable to remit the matter to another Member. Appeal by Construction, Forestry, Mining and Energy Union against decision of Watson VP of 7 March 2016 in [2016] FWC 811 Re: Director of the Fair Work Building Industry Inspectorate t/a Fair Work Building and Construction
June 10, 2016
MODERN AWARDS – dispute about matter arising under award – ss.604, 739 Fair Work Act 2009 – appeal – Full Bench – appeal against decision regarding dispute concerning long service leave (LSL) entitlements – appellant dismissed and applied to Coal Industry Long Service Leave Corporation to access LSL entitlements on basis he was retrenched – denied access to LSL – respondent contended dismissed for reasons not including redundancy – application dismissed at first instance for jurisdictional reasons – appellant submitted Commission erred in exercising powers judicial in nature and ignored original evidence – Full Bench found Commission had jurisdiction to deal with matter under s.39D of Coal Mining Industry Long Service Leave Act 1992 (CLSL Act), not dispute resolution clause under Black Coal Mining Industry Award 2010 – in relation to original evidence, appellant argued Commission did not take into account termination letter; retrenched to make way for new water carts, and position not filled following termination – Full Bench found Commission did consider letter but respondent’s evidence more convincing on this point – Commission’s analysis of water carts correct – new equipment on site does not establish retrenchment – conclusion that rosters and fact that position may have been filled by existing employee does not establish retrenchment a reasonable conclusion based on material – no error by Commission – appellant dismissed for reasons not including redundancy – no entitlement under CLSL Act – original application dismissed. . Appeal by Cowley against decision of Asbury DP of 25 August 2015 [[2015] FWC 2024] Re: Dust-A-Side Australia P/L
June 10, 2016
MODERN AWARDS – award modernisation – modern enterprise award – Sch. 6, Items 2, 4, 6 Fair Work (Transitional Provisions and Consequential Amendments) Act 2009 – Full Bench – application by Indian Ocean Territories Administration – Order issued at hearing making Christmas Island Administration Enterprise Award 2016 – reasons for decision – circumstances that led to making of enterprise instrument rather than an instrument of more general application considered – Full Bench held award to have had a long and distinct history, a factor that weighed in favour of making of modern award – Full Bench also found there was no single award, but for proposed award, that would cover all employees covered by current instrument – content of award and terms both weighed in favour – no opposition to making of modern enterprise award – unique nature of Indian Ocean Territories Administration and lack of any convenient alternative award that would better satisfy modern awards objective considered – Full Bench considered consolidated and modernised enterprise award remained most suitable vehicle for fair and relevant safety net into future – compelling case for making of modern enterprise award – proposed enterprise award made in terms agreed between parties. Christmas Island Administration Enterprise Award 2016
June 10, 2016
ENTERPRISE AGREEMENTS – employee organisation coverage – ss.590, 604 Fair Work Act – permission to appeal – Full Bench – appellant applied for permission to appeal interim decision arising from application for approval of Agreement at first instance – Commission granted standing for unions as interveners in first instance matter – found entitled to appear and be heard in respect of proceedings – appellant claimed decision at first instance inconsistent with Collinsville Coal decision – Full Bench must be satisfied public interest test met – might be attracted where matter raises issues of importance and general application [GlaxoSmithKline] – Full Bench found appeal against interlocutory procedural decision usually deprecated and will not usually be case that permission would be granted – found no reason to think decision will affect prospects of appellant ultimately succeeding in application for approval – Full Bench disagreed with appellant submission that interim decision substantive rather than procedural – Full Bench found decision at first instance consistent with Collinsville – authority for the proposition that union which was not bargaining representative for enterprise agreement did not have right to be heard in relation to application for approval of agreement simply because it had representational rights in respect of employees who might be employed under the agreement in future – decision made in exercise of broad discretionary power – permission to appeal refused. Appeal by Inco Ships P/L against decision of Cambridge C of 16 March 2016 [[2016] FWC 1637] Re: The Australian Institute of Marine and Power Engineers & Anor