ENTERPRISE AGREEMENTS – termination of agreement – ss.225, 604 Fair Work Act 2009 – permission to appeal – Full Bench – appeal against decision of Hamberger SDP to terminate the Sedgman Employment Services P/L Bowen Basin Front Line Employee Enterprise Agreement 2011-2014 (Agreement) – agreement negotiated by Sedgman Employment Services but applied to Peabody Energy after Peabody insourced certain operations – agreement had reached nominal expiry date – Peabody’s application to terminate agreement granted on grounds that agreement was negotiated in very different circumstances, by a different organisation, with provisions irrelevant to Peabody – Hamberger SDP satisfied termination of agreement not contrary to public interest and would facilitate bargaining for new agreement – Construction, Forestry, Mining and Energy Union (CFMEU) appealed on the basis that the decision was attended by appealable errors, that Hamberger SDP took an erroneous approach to the public interest by taking into account his own views about the suitability of the current terms of the agreement, and that the primary findings or conclusions were in error because they were purely speculative or not supported by evidence – appeal may only proceed if Commission satisfied public interest enlivened – Commission not satisfied public interest enlivened or that permission to appeal should be granted on discretionary grounds – Commission not satisfied decision at first instance was attended by sufficient doubt to warrant its reconsideration – Commission not satisfied appeal raised any legal or industrial issue of general significance or that refusal to grant permission would result in any manifest injustice to CFMEU or its members – permission to appeal refused. Appeal by Construction, Forestry, Mining and Energy Union against decision of Hamberger SDP of 11 March 2016 [[2016] FWCA 1595] Re: Peabody Energy Australia PCI Mine Management P/L
June 29, 2016
TERMINATION OF EMPLOYMENT – extension of time – s.394 Fair Work Act 2009 – application for relief from unfair dismissal lodged approximately three months and ten days late – during this period applicant believed the dismissal was a genuine redundancy – applicant then became aware similar position had been advertised – formed view that dismissal was not a redundancy – Commission found circumstances were exceptional – appropriate to fully test the contention that the termination was a case of genuine redundancy – extension of time granted. Wijeyesinghe v Pioneer Personnel P/L t/a Pioneer Facility Services
June 29, 2016
TERMINATION OF EMPLOYMENT – demotion – s.394 Fair Work Act 2009 – applicant dismissed for refusing to accept reduction in pay – respondent suffered unforeseen and significant reduction in revenue and cash flow in 2015 – expenditure cut – reluctant to reduce labour headcount – respondent engaged with staff by giving a presentation and asked them to take a temporary 10% pay cut – vast majority accepted – Commission held this was a legitimate course of action – applicant on annual leave when presentation given – returned to work and was advised he had until close of business the next day to agree to the reduction in pay or be terminated – Commission held applicant should have been treated the same way the other staff were treated – found applicant refusing to accept reduction in pay was not a valid reason for termination as case lacked procedural fairness – dismissal was harsh, unjust or unreasonable – reinstatement not appropriate in the circumstances – ordered compensation of $3,259.70, taxed according to law. Piggott v Wellpark Holdings P/L t/a ERGT Australia
June 29, 2016
TERMINATION OF EMPLOYMENT – identity of employer – labour hire – s.394 Fair Work Act 2009 – application for unfair dismissal remedy – respondent objected on basis that it did not employ applicant, he was employed by a labour hire company Reddy’s General Services (RGS) – whether applicant an employee of respondent – applicant signed a contract with RGS – respondent contracted RGS to provide labour – RGS sent applicant to perform work at Nissan Casting Plant Dandenong, but he could be relocated to other sites – RGS uniform was too small for the applicant so he wore his own clothes on site – employees of the labour hire companies wore different uniforms that were visually distinguishable from employees of respondent – clothing worn by applicant similar to RGS uniform – applicant received payslips from RGS – respondent supervisors directed applicant’s work – RGS texted applicant that respondent did not require him to attend work again – applicant lodged unfair dismissal application – Commission found the signed employment contract was evidence applicant was employed by RGS – RGS’ lack of contact was not unusual for labour hire agreements – respondent supervisor directing applicant’s work was not unusual – Commission not satisfied applicant was employed by respondent – application dismissed. Cresp v Nissan Casting Plant (Australia) P/L
June 29, 2016
TERMINATION OF EMPLOYMENT – termination at initiative of employer- resignation – ss.385, 386, 394 Fair Work Act 2009 – application for unfair dismissal remedy – applicant employed as truck driver – respondent sought to hold a discussion with applicant about an accident that had occurred in the course of the applicant undertaking his delivery duties on a prior date – respondent contended that when he attempted to speak to the applicant, the applicant became abusive and argumentative – at that juncture, the respondent contended the applicant told him to ‘shove your job I won’t be back’ – applicant claimed respondent terminated his employment – did not present for work for his next shift – gave no reason for absence on a rostered working day – failed to respond to respondent’s frequent and varied efforts to contact him – Commission found there was no dismissal at the initiative of the employer – requirement under s.385(a) not made out – application dismissed. Taylor v AGAS National
June 29, 2016
TERMINATION OF EMPLOYMENT – extension of time – s.394 Fair Work Act 2009 – application for relief from unfair dismissal lodged after 21 day period – dismissal took effect on 26 April 2016 – Commission can exercise discretion to extend time in exceptional circumstances [Nulty] – applicant tried to file her application online but had difficulties – posted application by express post, from post office, on 16 May 2016 – application addressed to Fair Work Ombudsman (FWO) – delivered to FWO at 5.40pm on 17 May 2016 – forwarded to Commission on 18 May 2016 – Commission held it was not unusual for employees to confuse the FWO and the Commission – applicant overseas from 5 to 10 May 2016 – received termination letter on 5 May 2016 – respondent submitted there was sufficient time before applicant went on holidays and after she returned to lodge her application – not clear that even if the applicant sent her application to the correct address that it would have arrived in time – Commission found applicant had a reasonable explanation for the delay – satisfied it was not unreasonable for her to rely on Australia Post delivery guarantee – time for lodging application extended to 18 May 2016 – application referred to conciliation. Mayne v All Earth Group P/L
June 29, 2016
TERMINATION OF EMPLOYMENT – costs – ss.394, 400A, 611 Fair Work Act 2009 – application for an unfair dismissal remedy dismissed [[2016] FWC 1029] – respondent made application for costs – alleged that applicant’s unreasonable refusal to accept that he had not been dismissed caused it to incur costs – applicant appealed decision at first instance – Full Bench refused permission to appeal [[2016] FWCFB 2642] – respondent submitted applicant made no genuine attempt to engage in settlement negotiations and sought the payment of monies in excess of the Commission’s jurisdiction – mere fact that applicant unsuccessful in establishing he was dismissed does not mean his non-acceptance of the offer of settlement was unreasonable [Roy Morgan Research Ltd v Baker] – often difficult to determine when a casual employee’s employment is in fact terminated – applicant given one day to respond to settlement offer – Commission held decision to not settle his claim was not unreasonable given the very limited period of time given – found non-acceptance of the offer of settlement not unreasonable – necessary prerequisites for making a cost order have not been satisfied – application for costs dismissed. Kim v ORC International P/L
June 29, 2016
ENTERPRISE AGREEMENTS – employee organisation coverage – application to be heard – s.185 Fair Work Act 2009 – application for approval of a single-enterprise agreement made by DOF Management Australia (DOF) – Maritime Union of Australia (MUA) made application to be heard as a full participant in the matter – DOF objected to MUA being heard in any capacity – Commission noted four avenues for employee organisation to establish standing in relation to agreement approval application – as a bargaining representative; as a matter of procedural fairness if right, interest or legitimate expectation adversely affected; if invited by the Commission; and on appeal if grievance beyond that of an ordinary member of public – Commission found default position of the MUA as bargaining representative ceased when DOF employees appointed bargaining representatives – held no right to be heard as a bargaining representative – Commission found that as proposed agreement specifically referred to the MUA and imposed on it rights and/or obligations to perform in specified ways functions or tasks which would not otherwise exist, the MUA had a right, interest or legitimate expectation that might be potentially affected by decision to approve agreement – as the MUA not a participant in agreement negotiations, ought to be given opportunity to be heard – held MUA had right to be heard as a matter of procedural fairness – Commission has broad power to inform itself under s.590 of FW Act – found that by permitting MUA to make submissions and lead evidence, Commission can properly inform itself in relation to concerns raised by MUA regarding proposed agreement – standing granted to MUA to appear and be heard with respect to the Application including opportunity to scrutinise issues of concern and cross examine witnesses. DOF Management Australia P/L