TERMINATION OF EMPLOYMENT – high income threshold – modern award coverage – ss.382, 394 Fair Work Act 2009 – application for unfair dismissal remedy – jurisdictional objection – appropriate test to determine award coverage was the principal purpose test – needed to assess the principal purpose of the primary function of applicant’s employment – modern awards fall into three categories and the Professional Employees Award 2010 was the third category hybrid covering both employers in the industries and occupational coverage [Halasagi] – whether applicant performed professional engineering duties as defined by the award [Baptista] – respondent was a national civil construction contractor – respondent hired applicant in Project Manager role – applicant held a Bachelor of Engineering – tertiary qualifications listed in role’s advertisement were not mandatory – ‘design management’ does not include designing projects – applicant was not qualified to undertake project design – managerial duties separated applicant’s role from award-based employment – Commission held it was unnecessary to hold an engineering degree or equivalent to perform the role – award Schedule B duties performed by applicant were not the primary purpose of his role – Commission found that the modern award did not cover the applicant – application dismissed. Whelan v BMD Constructions P/L
July 1, 2016
TERMINATION OF EMPLOYMENT – other termination proceedings – related court proceedings – s.394 Fair Work Act 2009 – application for relief from unfair dismissal – applicant dismissed for misconduct – matter not resolved at conciliation – applicant sought indefinite adjournment as police investigation was ongoing – Commission granted two month adjournment – applicant sought further adjournment pending decision of investigation – respondent did not oppose application and further two month adjournment was granted – following second adjournment, applicant’s representative advised that no criminal charges had been laid civil proceedings had been commenced against applicant in County Court – a further adjournment was sought by applicant, who submitted it was inappropriate to have two trials dealing with the same issues as it could lead to inconsistent findings of fact – applicant submitted County Court matter should proceed first – Commission adjourned matter until February 2016 – no change in status of investigations – no criminal charges laid but County Court matter adjourned to preserve applicant’s privilege against self-incrimination – McMahon considered – Commission held applicant was on notice since respondent’s response to application alleged she was guilty of misconduct – applicant always at risk in commencing these proceedings – should applicant choose to give evidence in relation to the allegations relied upon by respondent, her evidence could be used against her in other proceedings – if matter proceeds applicant can exercise her right not to answer questions that may incriminate her – Commission not able to draw any adverse inferences from any decision applicant makes to exercise that right – Commission held matter should not be further adjourned – unlikely that County Court will hear and determine matter in near future – Commission and Court will determine different issues – Court will need to determine if applicant had misappropriated funds – Commission to determine if dismissal harsh, unjust or unreasonable – directions to follow. Morton v Lardner Mechanical Repairs P/L
July 1, 2016
ENTERPRISE AGREEMENTS – dispute about matter arising under agreement – s.739 Fair Work Act 2009 – application to deal with a dispute arising under The Visy (Kings Park, Cavan and Forrestfield) and United Voice Enterprise Agreement 2013 – applicant received ‘first written warning’ following allegations of harassment – applicant unsuccessfully attempted to email investigation report conducted by respondent to union – respondent issued final written warning for breach of confidentiality and company policy – respondent submitted applicant was dishonest when asked if he had disclosed report – respondent raised jurisdictional objection that not all steps in dispute settlement procedure exhausted – applicant submitted final written warning should be removed – Commission considered it had broad discretion to arbitrate pursuant to dispute settlement procedure in agreement [Lend Lease] – held applicant was dishonest when asked by respondent whether report provided to union – final warning was appropriate – application dismissed – recommendation issued for respondent and union to agree on provision for relevant documentation, subject to confidentiality, to be provided to union to enable representation of members in disciplinary matters. Higgins v Visy Packaging P/L
July 1, 2016
TERMINATION OF EMPLOYMENT – costs – ss.394, 400A Fair Work Act 2009 – unfair dismissal application dismissed in [2016] FWC 1962 – respondent to unfair dismissal application (Respondent) made an application for costs under s.400A of FW Act – Respondent submitted it incurred costs because of unreasonable omission by Applicant in failing to respond to directions issued by Commission – Commission not satisfied that an unreasonable act or omission of Applicant caused costs to be incurred by Respondent – not satisfied causal nexus existed between unreasonable act or omission by Applicant and costs incurred by Respondent – costs application dismissed. Aminjarrinja Enterprises P/L v Paterson
July 1, 2016
TERMINATION OF EMPLOYMENT – misconduct – ss.391, 394 Fair Work Act 2009 – application for unfair dismissal remedy – applicant employed as afternoon shift driver – respondent contended that applicant forcefully elbowed another employee in the side after leaving a meeting of employees – applicant said incident never happened – standard of proof required to establish a valid reason is the civil standard of proof on the balance of probabilities [Briganshaw v Briganshaw] – applicant had poor work record – was on final warning due to misconduct whilst driving one of the respondent’s vehicles – evidence did not establish to the reasonable satisfaction of the Commission the applicant physically assaulted another employee by forcefully elbowing him in the side – Commission found respondent did not have a valid reason for the dismissal – found dismissal was harsh, unjust and unreasonable – reinstatement appropriate – respondent ordered to maintain both continuity of applicant’s employment and period of applicant’s continuous service with respondent under s.391(2) of FW Act. Stone v Citywide Service Solutions
June 30, 2016
The Fair Work Commission has approved the Firesafe Sprinkler Systems and CEPU – Plumbing Division (Vic) Fire Protection Agreement Victoria 2015-2019.
June 30, 2016
Twenty-one allegations of unfair dismissal will be heard by the Fair Work Commission today. The full list is: The trustee for Theo Sourlos Family Trust No. 2 (Baker), Yalbillinga Boori Day Care Centre Aboriginal Corporation (Ingram), Hillsbs Co. Pty Ltd (Perry), Taxa Australia Pty Ltd (Wang), AMP Services Limited (Wilkinson), Australian Postal Corporation (Southwell), Pathfinders Ltd (Felkin), Maxam Australia Pty Ltd (Bushel), Gravity Discovery Centre Foundation Board Inc (Dickinson), Carbridge Pty Ltd (Louw), Sarens Australia Pty Ltd (Roberston), Worsley Alumnia Pty Ltd (Bream), Benedict Recycling Pty Ltd (Nolan), Lifeview Residential Care (Devlin), Holmesglen TAFE (Gnanasekaren), Highland Pallets Pty Ltd (Jeganathan), Devonport GP Superclinic (Anthony), Colemans Group Australia Pty Limited (Cleland), Anglo Coal (Dawson Services) Pty Ltd (Frethey), Eureka Operations Pty Ltd (Cutting), Mitchels Quality Foods (Gacayan).
June 29, 2016
TERMINATION OF EMPLOYMENT – misconduct – ss.394, 400, 604 Fair Work Act 2009 – appeal – Full Bench – on 23 March 2016 the Full Bench issued a decision granting the appellant permission to appeal on the grounds of appeal regarding the assessment of compensation awarded in his favour [[2016] FWCFB 1795] – appellant dismissed after misuse of company fuel card – at first instance the Commission found the respondent denied appellant procedural fairness – held dismissal unfair – appellant awarded compensation of four weeks’ pay plus superannuation – appellant appealed the assessment of compensation – whether compensation assessment addressed criteria under s.392 of FW Act – calculating compensation requires orthodox approach [Bowden] – Full Bench found Commission miscarried discretion by failure to consider factors in s.392 – appeal allowed on that ground – first instance compensation order quashed – Full Bench re-exercised discretion by reference to each of the factors in s.392 – relied on evidence before Commission at first instance – determination of the period of time the appellant would have remained employed by the respondent, or would have likely remained employed with the respondent, had he not been dismissed – while the task of determining an anticipated period of employment can be difficult, it must be done [McCulloch v Calvary Health Care Adelaide] – Full Bench found applicant’s employment would have continued for a further three weeks – considered the remuneration earned and income reasonably likely to be earned – found appellant took steps to mitigate the loss of his employment – held the conduct which founded the valid reason for termination could be characterised as misconduct – any amount of compensation to be paid should be reduced by 50% by reason of that misconduct – Full Bench decided to award no compensation. Appeal by Smith against decision of Riordan C of 21 October 2015 [[2015] FWC 6900] Re: Buick Holdings P/L t/a DVG Automotive Group – Midland City