ENTERPRISE AGREEMENTS – dispute about matter arising under agreement – ss.533, 739 Fair Work Act 2009 – two applications – application to deal with a dispute in accordance with the Offshore Marine Services P/L Integrated Ratings, Cooks, Caterers and Seafarers (Offshore Oil and Gas) Enterprise Agreement 2010 (SKO Agreement) – application for an order pursuant to s.532(1) of FW Act – respondent in both applications was Skilled Offshore (Australia) P/L (SKO) – SKO provides marine labour services to vessels – SKO was a subsidiary of SKILLED Group Limited – on 16 October 2015 Programmed Maintenance Services Limited acquired all the shares of SKILLED Group Limited – SKO is now trading as Programmed Marine – Programmed Marine P/L (PM) is a subsidiary of Programmed Maintenance Services Limited – PM also trades as Programme Marine – While SKO and PM are discrete and separate legal entities, both trade as Programmed Marine – on 11 February 2016, the General Manager Employee Relations (GMER), sent an email to the MUA advising that ‘Programmed Marine’ would need to make a number of employees in the offshore oil and gas industry redundant – MUA invited to a meeting pursuant to subclause 11.2 of the ‘agreements’ – reasonable to infer that the GMER, when referring to agreements, was referring to both the SKO Agreement and the Total Marine Services P/L Integrated Ratings, Cooks, Caterers and Seafarers (Offshore Oil and Gas) Enterprise Agreement 2010 – Executive General Manager Operations (EGMO) issued a memorandum on 17 February 2016 to all permanent employees that ‘Programmed Marine’ must implement redundancies – on 4 March 2016, EGMO forwarded to employees an email with respect to voluntary redundancies ‘across our offshore business’ – meeting between MUA and Executive General Manager – Programmed Marine (EGM-PM) on 23 May 2016 – MUA submitted that Skilled Offshore was going to make 100% of its employees involuntarily redundant, and that this meeting was the first time that Programmed Marine and SKO had been treated as separate groups – MUA further submitted this was the first time that the MUA was advised that a decision had been made to implement involuntary redundancies – whether redundancies considered major change under clause 55.2 of the SKO Agreement – EGM-PM stated that SKO had complied with its obligations pursuant to the SKO Agreement – MUA in dispute with SKO (and PM) as a consequence of neither SKO nor PM assessing current SKO employees for redundancy together with current PM employees and the failure of SKO (and PM) to consider and transfer employees from SKO to PM – Commission held SKO applied the provisions of subclause 11.2 of the SKO Agreement, to effect the redundancies notwithstanding the MUA’s request for an alternative formula to apply – did not accept that the MUA’s assertion that EGM-PM’s letter of 25 May 2016, regarding the process of redundancies, was a major change – SKO did not make a ‘decision to introduce major change’ pursuant to subclause 55.1 of the SKO Agreement – clear that SKO and the MUA have divergent views on the process of making a number of employees redundant – however, clause 55 of the SKO Agreement provides for consultation and not co-management of the circumstances – satisfied the MUA was notified of the redundancies – satisfied the MUA has been given and has put measures to SKO, to avert or minimise the involuntary redundancies and any adverse effects of those redundancies – both applications dismissed. Maritime Union of Australia v Skilled Offshore (Australia) P/L
July 1, 2016
CASE PROCEDURES – stay order – ss.604, 739 Fair Work Act 2009 – appeal – in the decision at first instance the Commission found that had Monash College acted in accordance with the provisions of the Monash College Proprietary College Ltd (Monash University Foundation Year Teaching Staff) Agreement 2012, it would have appointed some 35 of its Monash University Foundation Year teachers on an ongoing basis with Monash College – Monash College applied for a stay of the decision on the basis that the Commission erred in construing clause 9.6 of the agreement – Kellow-Falkiner Motors considered – Monash College submitted that pivotal to the operation of clause 9.6 of the agreement was whether the reference to ‘reasons’ in the clause contemplates a subjective or objective test – Monash College posited that the Commission found the required test was objective and not subjective, and this conclusion undermined the Commission’s subsequent analysis of the clause – the IEU opposed the stay application, contending Monash College’s line of appeal, which complained that the Commission erred in failing to find that the teachers the subject of the dispute notification had been employed for specific activities and/or to meet peak student enrolment, set out no basis on which the finding of fact or the failure to find a fact is impugned – on this basis, the IEU posited that Monash College had no reasonable prospect of success in respect of this line of appeal – the Commission accepted Monash College’s contention that the decision at first instance, and the effect that the decision has on the contractual relationship between the College and the relevant teachers, raised important issues with regards to the nature of fixed term and ongoing contracts under the agreement – held that Monash College had an arguable case with some reasonable prospect of success in respect of the question of leave to appeal and on the substantial merits of the appeal – found that a stay order was appropriate – decision at first instance stayed pending the hearing and determination of Monash College’s appeal on 14 July 2016. Appeal by Monash College P/L against decision of Bissett C of 6 June 2016 [[2016] FWC 3538] Re: Independent Education Union of Australia
July 1, 2016
ENTERPRISE AGREEMENTS – dispute about matter arising under agreement – s.739 Fair Work Act 2009 – application to deal with a dispute related to provisions of Port Kembla Coal Terminal Limited Enterprise Agreement 2012-2015 regarding consultation about major workplace change – dispute arose after Operations Superintendent raised an improvement initiative with Operations Manager and communicated his intention to undertake a risk assessment – parties agreed question to be answered was ‘has the obligation to consult under clause 7 of the Agreement arisen in relation to the initiative to de-man the Rail Shed’ – CFMEU submitted obligation arises when management representative, in the course of exercising management responsibilities, is considering a change – submitted this point had been reached by virtue of Operations Superintendent initiating the risk assessment with Operations Manager’s knowledge – employer contended initiative was still at an embryonic stage of a Superintendent considering feasibility of change – Commission found no ambiguity in words in clause 7 – obligation to consult arises when Company considering introducing a major change – terms of agreement need to be considered in common sense practical manner and not a strict technical way – wrong to consider question by reference to whether the consideration by a staff member is in the course of performing the staff member’s duties – any preliminary consideration would fall into that category – if consideration is undertaken with a view to advising senior management, who have authority to make the decision, whether a proposal is feasible, it suggests that consideration by the company will come at a later point in time – consultation obligation triggered on or around point where manager with authority to decide receives a proposal and commences a consideration of proposal – on facts that point had not been reached – Commission determined obligation to consult had not arisen – Commission determined answer to disputed question was no. Construction, Forestry, Mining and Energy Union v Port Kembla Coal Terminal Limited
July 1, 2016
ENTERPRISE AGREEMENTS – dispute about matter arising under agreement – s.739 Fair Work Act 2009 – application lodged by AWU to deal with a dispute in relation to the BlueScope Steel Springhill Workplace Agreement 2015 – dispute concerned letter sent by respondent to employees of its Springhill Plant in Port Kembla, regarding implementing proposals for the training of Despatch operators to perform tasks in the Painting and Finishing Department (PFD) on a relief basis – applicant submitted the changes did not satisfy the agreement criteria as they would not be safe, efficient, legal and fair – applicant’s opposition was also based on an alleged lack of consultation – initial discussions held in context of implementing labour cost savings at the Springhill Plant following a collapse in the price of steel – mediation conducted by Commission was held on 8 September 2015 to assist process of identifying labour cost reductions – further letter referring to training in additional tasks sent on 18 March 2016 – conciliations conducted by Commission aimed at resolving the issues between parties over consultation and a compromise position advanced by applicant were not successful – further letter sent by respondent on 5 May 2016 – applicant submitted the onus should be on respondent to demonstrate the changes proposed were safe, efficient, legal and fair – this approach was rejected as the criteria were the same as those in the 2012 agreement applied in BlueScope Steeel (AIS) P/L v AWU and Ors – Commission did not accept that applicant was prejudiced to advance its case due to a lack of consultation – held that a proposed significant change cannot be considered legal if there has not been substantial compliance with consultation processes – held that only the proposed change for operators to perform basic station 5 duties on the Packline was found to be legal as it substantially complied with the agreement – found that proposed change would also be safe, fair and efficient – Commission held that implementation of this proposed change may proceed, and that respondent can recommence consultation about other proposals for change contained in their letter of 5 May 2016. The Australian Workers’ Union v BlueScope Steel Limited
July 1, 2016
MODERN AWARDS – award modernisation – modern enterprise award – Sch. 6, Items 4, 6 Fair Work (Transitional Provisions and Consequential Amendments) Act 2009 – Full Bench – application by the Government of the Australian Capital Territory to make a modern enterprise award entitled the ACT Public Sector Enterprise Award 2016 to replace and consolidate various current enterprise awards in the ACT public sector – applicant and relevant unions in support of the application – Commission considered the relevant factors in Schedule 6 sub-item 4(5) of the TPCA Act – modern awards objective and minimum wage objectives considered – held ACT public service a unique entity and no real industry of the ACT public sector beyond the applicant – relevant current enterprise awards have a long and distinct history – terms and conditions of the current enterprise awards are enterprise specific terms and conditions, thus a consolidated and modernised Award is the most suitable vehicle for a fair and relevant minimum safety net in the future – industry specific modern awards do not reflect the needs, terms and conditions of employees in the ACT public sector – without a modern enterprise award ACT public sector employees would need to be covered by a large number of modern awards which may lead to difficulties in enterprise bargaining and fragmentation of the award safety net – hence, compelling case for making of modern enterprise award for the ACT public service – proposed enterprise award made in terms agreed between the parties. Re: ACT Public Sector Enterprise Award 2016
July 1, 2016
MODERN AWARDS – 4 yearly review – common issues – s.156 Fair Work Act 2009 – Full Bench – annual leave – Full Bench issued a decision (the May 2016 decision) dealing with the variation of modern awards in relation to a number of matters regarding paid annual leave [[2016] FWCFB 3177] – decision varied particular modern awards to insert the model terms in respect of: cashing out of annual leave; electronic funds transfer and paid annual leave; granting annual leave in advance; and excessive annual leave – draft determinations published to provide interested parties with opportunity to comment – May 2016 decision proposed some plain language redrafting of three of the model terms: cashing out of annual leave; annual leave in advance; and excessive annual leave – the changes proposed were intended to make these terms easier to understand, they were not intended to change the substantive effect of any of the model terms – in the May 2016 decision the Full Bench expressed some provisional views regarding the insertion of certain model terms into particular modern awards – in each instance interested parties were provided with an opportunity to notify the Commission, by 1 June 2016, if they wished to contest the Full Bench’s provisional views in respect of any of these matters – no notifications were received – Full Bench will now give effect to the provisionally expressed views – particular modern awards will be varied to insert the model excessive leave term – draft determinations varying modern awards in accordance with the May 2016 decision and the changes addressed in this decision will be published on the Commission website by close of business on Friday 1 July 2016. 4 yearly review of modern awards – Annual leave
July 1, 2016
TERMINATION OF EMPLOYMENT – genuine redundancy – ss.389, 394 Fair Work Act 2009 – application for unfair dismissal remedy – applicant worked as a Trainee Scaffolder on a weekly hire basis – two major clients advised that scaffolding work was to become less frequent – as a result, respondent advised applicant that employment could only be retained on a casual basis – applicant asserted that respondent retained other weekly hire positions and ongoing work was available – applicant further asserted the consultation process did not meet requirements set out in The Pilbara Access P/L Agreement 2014 – Commission satisfied that evidence put forward established respondent no longer required to undertake employment on weekly hire basis – a decrease in the demand for labour meant that respondent could no longer sustain weekly hire employment – fact that other employees not selected for redundancy did not detract from redundancy circumstance – Commission satisfied the requirements of s.389(1)(a) of FW Act had been met – satisfied respondent had taken appropriate steps to explore reasonable redeployment options – held requirements of s.389(2) had been met – dismissal consistent with definition of genuine redundancy – termination of employment cannot be regarded as unfair – application dismissed. Roberts v Pilbara Access P/L t/a Pilbara Access
July 1, 2016
TERMINATION OF EMPLOYMENT – termination at initiative of employer – resignation – ss.386, 394 Fair Work Act 2009 – application for unfair dismissal remedy – applicant employed as diesel mechanic – applicant sent an email to respondent detailing complaints regarding respondent’s actions and concluded that he could no longer work under those circumstances and would not return effective immediately – applicant had been stood down from work on the basis that an investigation was to be undertaken into a truck incident upon which he had worked – applicant’s complaints involved the investigation process – applicant asserted he was forced to resign because of respondent’s actions – respondent asserted that applicant voluntarily resigned and its conduct did not intend or have the result of causing resignation – Commission satisfied that respondent’s investigation applied a normal, understandable approach – Commission not satisfied that the manner in which investigation conducted had any of the characteristics of bullying behaviour asserted by applicant, simply that there was a safety issue investigated and acted upon by respondent – Commission not satisfied that applicant’s allegations objectively met tests in Mozahab and O’Meara such that decision to resign should be regarded as a dismissal at respondent’s initiative – Commission not satisfied that respondent breached policies and procedures or that in any event this left applicant with no alternative other than to resign – Commission not satisfied that respondent under an obligation to either refuse to accept applicant’s resignation or to ensure that he meant to resign – Commission found no dismissal at the initiative of employer – for purposes of s.385 of FW Act applicant not dismissed – application dismissed. Townend v Toll Transport P/L t/a TRGL Equipment