ENTERPRISE AGREEMENTS – dispute about matter arising under agreement – s.739 Fair Work Act 2009 – dispute about warnings given to an employee of Bluescope and Bluescope’s alcohol and drug testing procedure under Lysaght Lyndhurst Workplace Agreement 2014 – Bluescope submitted that Agreement did not provide for disputes in relation to misconduct being dealt with under dispute resolution procedure – scope of Commission’s power determined by the terms of the agreement – Golden Cockerel considered – Commission found uncertainty about the meaning to be attached to the words ‘other employment related matters in the normal course of work’ – found scope of the exclusion of issues relative to health and safety was also uncertain – satisfied dispute resolution procedure did not apply to disputes relating to misconduct – application dismissed. The Australian Workers’ Union v BlueScope Steel Limited t/a Lysaght
December 21, 2016
TERMINATION OF EMPLOYMENT – extension of time – s.394 Fair Work Act 2009 – application for unfair dismissal – applicant was retired on grounds of medical incapacity – was last at work in February 2008 – respondent objected to application being made out of time – date of dismissal in dispute – reason for delay was that the applicant believed dismissal on hold pending a Board of Reference decision – respondent submitted date of dismissal was clearly communicated prior to dismissal – dismissal letter to applicant indicated there were other legal remedies available under the Fair Work Act – that an employee has been put on notice about time limits at the time of dismissal weighs heavily against exercising discretion to extend time for making the application [Smart] – Commission not satisfied that exceptional circumstances existed – application dismissed. Krnjeta v Australian Postal Corporation t/a Australia Post
December 21, 2016
TERMINATION OF EMPLOYMENT – misconduct – s.394 Fair Work Act 2009 – application for relief from unfair dismissal – applicant employed as jewellery Store Manager – dismissed for ‘serious gross misconduct’ – on many occasions applicant opened store alone contrary to respondent’s security policy and in circumstances outside of those in which she had been authorised – when opening store alone and early before the second staff member arrived, applicant commonly left door unlocked, opened the safe, removed the tills and money from the safe and at times removed stock from safe and placed it on the counters – applicant aware of respondent’s security policy – on a number of occasions applicant also changed store’s records to show that a sale which had been achieved by another salesperson was falsely recorded as her sale – detrimental to interests of other salesperson and potentially financially beneficial for applicant – Commission found applicant’s actions were reprehensible, dishonest and totally inconsistent with role of Manager – found valid reason for dismissal – applicant was aware of security policy and chose to ignore, in any event common sense would dictate that opening a jewellery store alone and leaving the door unlocked was a serious security risk – applicant continued to do this even after other employees had raised their concerns with her – separately, altering store records to falsely show she was responsible for the sales other staff had achieved was a conscious act and the antithesis of the behaviour expected of any manager – Commission held dismissal was not harsh, unjust or unreasonable – applicant not unfairly dismissed – application dismissed. Tsilivis v The Jewellery Group P/L t/a Zamels
December 21, 2016
TERMINATION OF EMPLOYMENT – contract for specified term – ss.386, 394 Fair Work Act 2009 – application for relief from unfair dismissal – respondent objected on basis that applicant was party to a fixed term contract of employment that operated from 1 July 2013 and expired on 30 June 2016 (the 2013 Contract) – argued that applicant was not ‘dismissed’ – his employment came to an end at the completion of the fixed term period within the meaning of s.386(2) of FW Act – in the alternative, respondent argued that if it was wrong about applicant being bound by the 2013 Contract, he was bound by an earlier contract which commenced in 2007 (the 2007 Contract) and was subject to continuity of government funding – respondent submitted there was no longer government funding for applicant’s role, and thus it was entitled to rely on the 2007 Contract to terminate his employment – respondent could not produce a signed copy of the 2013 Contract – applicant submitted he was employed under the 2007 Contract that was not for a specified period of time, but open ended – Commission held a contract does not need to be signed to be made, and in certain circumstances by not challenging the terms of a contract it can be the case that implied acceptance of the benefits constitutes implied acceptance of an offer – satisfied that at the time the employment ended on 30 June 2016 the 2007 Contract still operated – satisfied the 2013 Contract was never made – found reason for termination was based on a restructuring of the organisation caused by reduced funding – Commission not satisfied dismissal was harsh, unjust or unreasonable – application dismissed. Newson v South West NRM Limited t/a South West NRM
December 21, 2016
The unfair dismissal/labour dispute applications have spiked for the week. Thirty-eight applicants are on today’s list: Yarra Valley Farms (Shaune-Bould), Reece Australia Pty Ltd (Wilde), Showpiece Services Pty Ltd (Shrestha), Parramatta National Rugby League Club Pty Ltd (Muirhead), Menzies International (Australia) Pty Ltd/NSW (Peters), Air Liquide Australia Limited (Moffat), Milton Ulladulla Ex Servos Club (Backhouse), Austral Steelfixing Pty Ltd (Diaz), NTI Limited (Post), Decmil Group Limited (Dreger), Boral Cement Limited (Tuddenham), Experian Australia Pty Ltd (Andersson), South West Radiology Pty Ltd (Ramrakha-Sharma), Mt Arthur Coal Pty Limited (Muller), Yuibera Aboriginal Corporation (Young), HVAR Steel Services Pty Ltd (Liang, Zeng), Gryphon Global Aust Pty Ltd (Morrison), Dept. of Justice Victoria (McInerney), Australia Xiong Zi Pty Ltd (Ming), Spectrum MRC (Nasralla), Austral Steelfixing Pty Ltd (Diaz), Atanaskovic Hartnell Corporate Services Pty Limited & Atanaskovic Hartnell (Kelly), Dykes Bros Pty Ltd (Changezi, Nayeb), Apple Pty Limited (Phipps), Bleasdale National Contractors (Sinclair), Yuibera Aboriginal Corporation (Young), Demjet Pty Ltd (in Liquidation) (Rennie), Grant Johnson Pty Ltd ATF The Grant Johnson Trust (Petrie), Australian Tax Office (Panaouris), Channel Inn (Christmas), H20 Broad water Apartments (Lawrence), Oporto Cavill Ave (Totorewa), Mont Agricultural Development Pty Ltd (Fox), Lift Investments WA Pty Ltd (Perry), Vadasz Lawyers (Stevens), P.R. Hepple & Sons Pty Ltd (Watson).
December 20, 2016
The Fair Work Commission has approved the Allan Engineering T/A Allan Industries Pty Ltd application for its Allan Engineering Pty Ltd – Woolworths Distribution Centre – Enterprise Agreement 2016.
December 20, 2016
TERMINATION OF EMPLOYMENT – remedy – ss.391, 394 Fair Work Act 2009 – in earlier decision Commission found that the two applicants were unfairly dismissed and ordered reinstatement [[2016] FWC 7095] – this decision confined to the question of the amount of lost pay that should be ordered – applicants made submissions an order should be made for back pay or loss of wages between period of dismissal and reinstatement of $27,396.23 for Mr Pirko and $18,959.66 for Mr Bintoro – pretermination average weekly earnings used to calculate lost pay – payment in lieu of notice to be deducted from the total amount – payments received from alternate employment between period of dismissal and reinstatement to be deducted from amount – further deductions due to satchel cage incident determined to be two weeks average remuneration for each applicant – respondent ordered to pay Mr Pirko $22,992.85 and Mr Bintoro $15,689.58 for lost pay. Pirko and Anor v Toll Holdings Ltd t/a Toll Priority
December 20, 2016
Wire Industries Pty Ltd has had its Wire Industries Pty Ltd Enterprise Agreement 2016 application approved by Fair Work Commissioner Roe in Melbourne on 19 December 2016.