NEWS HR

RIGHT OF ENTRY – dispute over right of entry – ss.505, 604 Fair Work Act 2009 – appeal – Full Bench – Commission at first instance determined remedy sought by appellant in right of entry dispute was an exercise in judicial power beyond the Commission’s jurisdiction – in any event, before and after workers shifts was not ‘other breaks’ within the meaning of s.490 of FW Act – CFMEU officials had no right of entry at those times – grounds of appeal included the Commission erred in concluding the application was a request to exercise judicial power, failed to find the application was an exercise in the regulation of future rights and in the interpretation of the meaning of ‘other breaks’ – appeal raised an important jurisdictional issue – only matter in dispute was whether the reference to ‘other breaks’ included periods before and after employees’ shift start and finish times – determined this involved ascertaining legal rights and obligations created by s.490 – the ascertainment, declaration or enforcement of legal rights is the exercise of judicial power whereas opinions formed in the course of deciding what rights should exist in the future is an arbitral power conferred on the Commission [Ranger Uranium Case] – Full Bench satisfied the Commission was correct in his decision that he had no jurisdiction to consider the dispute – permission to appeal granted – appeal dismissed. Appeal by Construction, Forestry, Mining and Energy Union against decision of Williams C of 12 July 2016 [[2016] FWC 3829] Re: BHP Billiton Nickel West P/L

ENTERPRISE AGREEMENTS – dispute about matter arising under agreement – s.739 Fair Work Act 2009 – application to deal with a dispute under Cormack Packaging MFG P/L Enterprise Agreement 2015-2018 – employees work either an 8 ordinary hour roster (known as 24/5) or a 12 hour roster (known as 24/7) – these rosters have been worked at least since 1 July 2011 under previous enterprise agreement – under the terms of the previous agreement and the current agreement, employees working the 24/7 roster had their wages paid as an ‘all-up’ or ‘loaded’ rate to incorporate payments for shift loadings and overtime or penalties – this rate became the base rate and was used to calculate the payments for other entitlements such as annual leave, personal/carer’s leave, public holidays and overtime – on 9 May 2016 the respondent advised its employees working on the 24/7 roster that they would have their payments for abovementioned entitlements changed from the established method of ‘loaded’ rate to base rate – respondent submitted that the change would be made as it had identified an administrative miscalculation with previous payments – applicant submitted respondent formed incorrect view of the appropriate meaning of ‘base rate of pay’ for employees on 24/7 roster – Commission held when the respondent’s employees were notified on 9 May 2016 of a change to be instituted from 6 June 2016 to the calculation of various entitlements, they were being notified of the proposed change from the basis on which those entitlements had been calculated since 2011 – the NES does not prohibit the payment of amounts greater than the base rate of pay pursuant to an agreement or otherwise – Commission found that the payment of the loaded rates of pay the subject of this dispute notification did not occur as a result of an administrative miscalculation – those amounts were paid because that was the agreement between the parties, acknowledged by the continued payment of that rate of pay from 2011 uninterrupted from one agreement to another until the correspondence of 9 May 2016 – Commission found the characterisation of these payments as having occurred as a result of an administrative miscalculation is an attempt to remake agreed terms acknowledged and confirmed by long practice. Australian Workers’ Union, The v Cormack Packaging MFG P/L

TERMINATION OF EMPLOYMENT – misconduct – s.394 Fair Work Act 2009 – applicant employed at Salvos Stores since May 2005 as casual shop assistant and shortly after promoted to Store Manager – no issues of misconduct until dismissed from employment in July 2016 – respondent alleged applicant stole money from a sale rather than putting the transaction through the register – s.387 FW Act considered – Commission discussed requirement to apply civil standard of proof, ie ‘the balance of probabilities’, however given serious nature of alleged misconduct the Commission must be careful not to rely on ‘inexact proofs, indefinite testimony, or indirect inferences’ [Briginshaw] – held respondent asked Commission to rely on indirect inferences in contrast to the applicant’s more plausible evidence – Commission satisfied no valid reason for dismissal and applicant not guilty of misconduct – Commission surprised as to alacrity with which the respondent accepted customer’s version of events over a long standing employee – found dismissal unjust and unreasonable – applicant did not seek reinstatement – payment for compensation reasonable in circumstances – Sprigg formula applied – Commission calculated compensation figure of $34,809 – compensation cap is $22,404.50 (half of applicant’s annual salary) – ordered compensation of $22,405.50, less tax. Walker v Salvation Army (NSW) Property Trust t/a The Salvation Army – Salvos Stores

TERMINATION OF EMPLOYMENT – Small Business Fair Dismissal Code – ss.388, 394 Fair Work Act 2009 – application for unfair dismissal remedy – employer a small business – whether Small Business Fair Dismissal Code (Code) complied with – applicant absent from work for 14 months – allegations of bullying – application for anti-bullying orders dismissed [[2016] FWC 3550] – workers’ compensation claims – applicant’s medical condition prevents contact with supervisor – no reasonable adjustments able to be made by small business – applicant unable to indicate being able to return to work on normal duties – unable to fulfil the inherent requirements of the job – warnings and opportunity to respond – dismissal Code compliant – no unfair dismissal – application dismissed. Samuel v Inner South-West Community Development Organisation t/a ISWCDO

TERMINATION OF EMPLOYMENT – unlawful termination – extension of time – s.773 Fair Work Act 2009 – application to deal with unlawful termination dispute lodged 904 days outside time – applicant dismissed in November 2013 – made application to Queensland Industrial Relations Commission (QIRC) in November 2013, alleging dismissal unfair as harsh, unjust or unreasonable and for invalid reason due to temporary absence due to illness – QIRC application dismissed and subject to number of unsuccessful appeals by applicant – applicant lodged unlawful termination application in June 2016 alleging termination because of temporary absence from work due to illness – at time of dismissal s.774 of FW Act required application be filed within 60 days – applicant submitted reason for delay was that respondent and legal advisors advised her to make QIRC application and she did not know of option to make unlawful termination application until advised by Fair Work Ombudsman in June 2016 – under s.774, Commission must be satisfied of exceptional circumstances, such that discretion to extend time is triggered – Commission was not satisfied there were exceptional circumstances justifying exercise of discretion to extend time – applicant did not receive misleading or incorrect advice about options to pursue dispute – applicant not accepting outcome in QIRC and seeking to re-run case only apparent reason for application – no reasons for delay that constituted exceptional circumstances – while applicant disputed dismissal, not a factor weighing in favour of exercising discretion – respondent expended considerable time, cost and effort in defending QIRC application in circumstances where the same dispute as applicant sought to advance in Commission was dealt with to finality – witnesses for respondent no longer employed by respondent – period of time elapsed would prejudice respondent beyond usual prejudice – merits at best neutral and did not outweigh other factors – not appropriate to exercise discretion to grant extension of time – application dismissed. Wanninayake v Department of Natural Resources and Mines t/a Department of Natural Resources and Mines (Simtars)

ENTERPRISE AGREEMENTS – dispute about matter arising under agreement – s.739 Fair Work Act 2009 – application to deal with dispute under the NCI Holdings P/L (Northcote) and National Union of Workers Enterprise Agreement 2015 – NCI manufactured packaging materials and operated manufacturing plants at Northcote and Tullamarine – prior to its closure in 2014 NCI operated a manufacturing plant in Bayswater – number of employees previously worked at the Bayswater were transferred to work at the Northcote plant – NCI further announced plans to close Northcote plant and offered employees choice of relocating to Tullamarine plant or having employment terminated on redundancy grounds – clause 21.6 of Agreement entitled ex Bayswater employees ‘three and one half (3.5) weeks per each year of service part thereof…’ – dispute concerned constituent elements of a ‘week’s pay’ for the purposes of determining the dollar value amount of ‘three and one half weeks’ for each year of service or part thereof that is to be paid to an eligible ex Bayswater employee – NUW maintained that an ex Bayswater employee’s redundancy pay included that employee’s applicable shift loading as it sourced the definition of ‘week’s pay’ from clause 20.3 – NCI claimed that an ex Bayswater employee’s redundancy pay entitlement was to be calculated using the applicable base rate of pay and did not operate together with clause 20 – redundancy entitlement arose out of self-selection and in entirely different circumstances to the entitlement severance payment under clause 20.3 – clause 20.3 arose by reason of an act of NCI, not an election by an employee – Commission found that ‘applicable shift loading’ did not form part of the 3.5 weeks per year of service or part thereof, or the additional one week’s pay for each year of service or part thereof in respect of employee over the age of 45 years redundancy pay entitlements. National Union of Workers v NCI Holdings P/L t/a NCI Packaging

RIGHT OF ENTRY – application for permit – s.512 Fair Work Act 2009 – application by Victorian Branch of the AMWU for a right of entry permit for official, Mr John Webb – Australian Building and Construction Commissioner filed and served written submission addressing permit qualification matters but not whether an entry permit should be issued – content for application to be determined without hearing – Commission noted relevant statutory provisions and application – considered MUA decision of Full Court of Federal Court of Australia re ‘fit and proper person’ – also CEPU decision of Hatcher VP – statutory declaration filed by AMWU – Commission accepted disclosed information as accurate and correct – declarations disclosed that Mr Webb had previously engaged unprotected industrial action and a proceeding in Federal Court of Australia in relation to that conduct was pending – disclosed that Mr Webb had cooperated and made an admission in respect of conduct in contravention of s.417(1)(a) of FW Act – Tracey J ordered Mr Webb to pay a pecuniary penalty in respect of contravention – Mr Webb filed further statement and provided some context for previous conduct – acknowledged his obligation to comply with the law and gave assurances regarding future conduct – Commission noted assessment of application is not punitive aimed at continuing punishment for past wrongdoings – assessment is whether Mr Webb was fit and proper person to hold entry permit having regard to permit qualification matters – Commission considered Mr Webb to be a fit and proper person to hold permit – unnecessary to consider imposing conditions – application granted. “Automotive, Food, Metals, Engineering, Printing and Kindred Industries Union” known as the Australian Manufacturing Workers’ Union (AMWU)-Victorian Branch

TERMINATION OF EMPLOYMENT – extension of time – s.394 Fair Work Act 2009 – application for relief from unfair dismissal lodged 11 days out of time – respondent originally objected to the application on the grounds that the application was out of time however this was withdrawn following receipt of report from the Commission’s IT Department – report provided list of email addresses that sent correspondence to Commission email account between 5pm to 7pm on 6 October 2016 – notwithstanding withdrawal of jurisdictional objection Commission to make a determination itself in relation to the extension of time application – applicant submitted delay due to lack of technology – applicant filled out application by hand went to the Port Melbourne Library to lodge application electronically however lodgment failed – applicant filed again in person 11 days later at the Commission whilst noting the previous lodgment – report from the Commission’s IT Department showed email was sent from applicant’s email account – Nulty adopted – Commission found reasons for delay acceptable as applicant made genuine attempt to lodge her application within time when taken together with exceptional circumstances justify granting extension of time – application for extension of time granted – application referred to conciliation. Price v Coles Supermarkets t/a Coles