NEWS HR

TERMINATION OF EMPLOYMENT – extension of time – date dismissal took effect – s.394 Fair Work Act 2009 – application for relief from unfair dismissal filed 3 August 2016 – respondent raised jurisdictional objection – submitted applicant resigned on 9 June 2016 and termination took effect on this day – submitted application therefore outside of 21-day time limit – applicant submitted resignation took effect on 13 July 2016 when she received her final pay – was confused as to whether she was still employed with respondent and thought she had been on sick leave – submitted she was unable to file application within the 21- day time limit because she was the primary carer for her seriously ill mother and was herself medically incapable – further submitted she had been constructively dismissed by respondent – Commission must be satisfied there are ‘exceptional circumstances’ warranting the extension of time – found the applicant resigned on 9 June 2016 and resignation was effective on that date – held the reasons for delay did not meet the ‘exceptional circumstances’ test in s.394(3) of FW Act – held applicant was not comprehensively prevented by her circumstances from making application – held applicant voluntarily resigned and therefore no termination at initiative of respondent – application dismissed. Hardwick v National Australia Bank t/a National Australia Bank

ENTERPRISE AGREEMENTS – dispute about matter arising under agreement – s.739 Fair Work Act 2009 – dispute under the TNTTWU Fair Work Agreement 2014-2017 concerning applicant’s ability to perform the inherent requirements of role as a Bulk Freight Delivery Driver – applicant was stood down without pay in 2014 as a result of an injury to right knee – workers’ compensation application was not successful – applicant advised would not be able to continue to perform any duties until fit to fulfil the complete duties of role, and was able to provide a medical clearance that would enable such – applicant underwent a total right knee replacement and on 24 September 2015, obtained a medical clearance from General Practitioner to return to work – respondent advised applicant of request to have a further assessment to ensure fitness was adequate to return to normal role – applicant ‘required’ to attend two medical appointments; a functional assessment with an Exercise Physiologist, and a fitness for duties assessment with an Occupational Physician – on 14 January 2016, the applicant attended a meeting with the respondent and was handed a ‘show cause’ letter – the TWU, on behalf of the applicant, disputed the show cause letter, which was ultimately withdrawn – on 4 March 2016, the applicant attended a further meeting at and provided with a further show cause letter with the subject ‘Outcomes of Fitness for Duties Assessment’ – as a result of report from the Occupational Physician respondent advised the applicant that ‘The results of the assessment indicate that you are unable to safely perform the inherent physical requirements of your current role and impose significant restrictions on the kind of work that you can safely perform at TNT’ – show cause letter indicated the respondent sought to consult with the applicant regarding the assessments and their impact on suitability for continued employment in current position, and any alternative positions the applicant might otherwise be qualified to safely perform – letter advised that should suitable alternative roles not be identified, the applicant’s employment would be terminated as a result of incapacity to safely perform the inherent requirements of the position – Boag considered – inherent requirements for a bulk driver must be considered in combination with the surrounding context of the applicant’s workplace and duties [X v The Commonwealth] – onus is on the employer to demonstrate that the employee cannot meet the inherent requirements of the position – couldn’t be concluded that TNT had established that the ability to lift weights of over 40kg, unaided, was an essential requirement of the position of Bulk Driver – Commission found the evidence did not represent that what was asserted as the inherent requirements of the role of Bulk Delivery Driver were the inherent requirements in practice – satisfied applicant was fit to perform the inherent requirements of the role and should be returned to role immediately with appropriate ‘work hardening’ as recommended by the Occupational Physician. Martin v TNT Australia P/L t/a TNT

CONDITIONS OF EMPLOYMENT – redundancy – s.120 Fair Work Act 2009 – application to reduce redundancy pay from four weeks to two weeks – respondent employed under Dalart P/L t/as Charman Roofing Enterprise Agreement 2015 – agreement states that entitlements to redundancy payments will be provided for in the FW Act – offer of redeployment from position of supervisor on $50.00 per hour to tradesman on $35.00 per hour – decrease in wages by 30% and loss of other benefits such as a company phone and fuel card – respondent did not accept the offer of other employment as he ‘cannot afford to live on those wages’ – Commission found that the offered employment was not ‘other acceptable employment’ – no reduction in redundancy pay – application dismissed. Dalart P/L t/a Charman Roofing

CASE PROCEDURES – representation – ss.394, 596 Fair Work Act 2009 – application by respondent to be represented by a lawyer in hearing of two applications for unfair dismissal remedy – Commission not satisfied that the matter involved complexity beyond that which would ordinarily be found in two, interrelated, unfair dismissal matters – given the size of the respondent’s operation, which included HR specialists and legal staff, Commission not convinced that the employer could not effectively represent itself without external legal representation – issue of fairness between the parties a matter of significance – respondent submitted that it would be grossly unfair if they were unable to be represented as they submitted that there were no suitable HSBC employees who could familiarise themselves with the circumstances of the matters – applicants submitted that, as they were unrepresented, there would an imbalance if the employer was permitted legal representation – Commission influenced by factors regarding fairness between the parties and the requirement for informality [Warrell] – Commission found that unnecessary formality would be created as well as an imbalance between the parties if the respondent was granted permission to be represented – Commission not satisfied respondent unable to effectively represent itself – permission refused. Ahmed and Anor v HSBC Bank Australia Limited

INDUSTRIAL ACTION – order against industrial action – s.418 Fair Work Act 2009 – application for an order to stop etc. industrial action – failure to be able to get sufficient employees to work overtime – AGL had been unable to return Unit 1 to service – level of unionisation amongst the station operators high – Commission needed to be satisfied that industrial action was occurring – specifically that there was a ban on the performance of overtime contrary to clauses 15 and 73 of the Loy Yang Power Enterprise Agreement 2012 or contrary to custom and practice regarding the performance of overtime – inadequate evidence to establish that any employee had unreasonably refused to work overtime – good reason to be suspicious that the difficulties AGL had in being able to get sufficient workers to work overtime was a response to the decision to terminate the Agreement – satisfied that station operations employees are effectively able to refuse overtime – in the absence of evidence about how directions were given and the reasons given for refusal and that the number of requests and refusals was out of the normal, Commission not able to be satisfied that actions of employees had been contrary to custom and practice regarding the performance of overtime – not satisfied that industrial action was in fact happening or was threatened, impending or probable or was being organised – could not make the order sought – decision in this matter had been a fine balance – should the problem continue or should further evidence emerge the decision might be quite different. AGL Loy Yang P/L t/a AGL Loy Yang v Construction, Forestry, Mining and Energy Union and Anor

INDUSTRIAL ACTION – order against industrial action – s.418 Fair Work Act 2009 – application for an order to stop etc. industrial action – in a decision of 16 January 2017 the Commission refused to grant an order under s.418 of FW Act [[2017] FWC 306] – further application was made by AGL on 17 January 2017 – AGL sought to rely upon the material in the earlier proceeding – considered appropriate given the allegations and orders sought were similar – AGL provided detailed evidence of the approaches made to individual employees – for nine of the last 11 shifts AGL have been unable to achieve the minimum staffing levels specified in the Loy Yang Power Enterprise Agreement 2012 to operate all four units of the power station – Commission satisfied this is unprecedented – satisfied by the new evidence considered in conjunction with the earlier evidence that industrial action was occurring – satisfied, on the balance of probabilities, that the failure of sufficient employees to agree to work overtime and the extraordinary level of sick leave was a result of collective action – satisfied that not only was there industrial action happening but it was also probable that it would continue – whether or not the CFMEU was organising the industrial action – held that Mr Hardy was acting with the authority or apparent authority of the CFMEU – having found that unprotected industrial action was occurring and was also probable, and having found that it was being organised by Mr Hardy and the CFMEU, the Commission must issue an order that it stop – considered that one month was an appropriate time period for the Order. AGL Loy Yang P/L t/a AGL Loy Yang v Construction, Forestry, Mining and Energy Union and Anor

TERMINATION OF EMPLOYMENT – misconduct – s.394 Fair Work Act 2009 – application for relief from unfair dismissal remedy – applicant performed various tasks for the respondent, including fitting sounds systems and other equipment into motor vehicles – applicant was summarily dismissed by the respondent on grounds of serious misconduct after a series of incidents over a three day period – applicant performed a burnout in the driveway of the respondent’s business; had not installed equipment to an appropriate standard on a customer’s vehicle and subsequently treated the customer in an aggressive and contemptuous manner when they returned the following day to rectify the fitting; and made rude and aggressive gestures to a security camera in the workshop – respondent asked applicant to attend a meeting on 16 August 2016 to ‘Show Cause’ – applicant did not attend the meeting – applicant dismissed on 16 August 2016 on grounds of serious misconduct – the applicant acknowledged each incident but suggested they occurred largely as a result of his frustration with working conditions of the business – submitted that dismissal was a disproportionate response – respondent submitted that each incident, when viewed individually or in combination, demonstrated that the applicant did not intend to have an ongoing role in the business – Commission satisfied that each incident was significant and accentuated by the fact they occurred over three consecutive days – satisfied these incidents provided the basis for summary dismissal on grounds of serious misconduct – dismissal not harsh, unjust or reasonable – application dismissed. Spurr v Valley Retreat Investments P/L t/a Autobarn Melton

TERMINATION OF EMPLOYMENT – termination at initiative of employer – resignation – ss.385, 386, 394 Fair Work Act 2009 – application for unfair dismissal remedy – applicant was working as a marketing specialist – applicant tendered a letter of resignation – subsequently claimed she was forced to resign – respondent contended the applicant had resigned of her own volition – whether or not applicant was ‘dismissed’ within the meaning of the FW Act – applicant had an unhappy and difficult time at work – respondent submitted there were a number of performance issues – applicant wrote resignation letter as she was worried about the possibility of being terminated and having this on employment record – Commission found applicant was not dismissed and had resigned – application dismissed. Iacono v Police Financial Services Limited t/a BankVic