Its a supermodel moment for Fair Work Commissioners. There are so few cases to be heard, its just not worth getting out of bed. The list today includes: North Ryde Community Pre-School Inc (Hoolahan), STAPLES AUSTRALIA PTY LIMITED (Rivas), Boral Cement Limited (Ardrey), TAL (Kumaran), Ronpom Pty Ltd (Pomering), Hi-Quality Group Pty Ltd (Stafford), Churches of Christ Community Care in NSW (Gordon), Easy Payroll Perth Pty Ltd (Wrzoskiewicz), Bankwest (Au), SAE CREATIVE MEDIA INSTITUTE (Henebery), Convatech Pty Limited (Lim), Watman Pty Ltd & Pruckner (Newett, Stephenson), Qube Ports Pty Ltd (Campbell), OTR (Smith), Islamic College of SA (Avery), Collection House Group (Kopania).
February 21, 2017
ENTERPRISE AGREEMENTS – better off overall test – ss.185, 604 Fair Work Act 2009 – appeal – Full Bench – appellant made application for the approval of the All Trades Queensland P/L Apprentice/Trainee Enterprise Agreement 2015 (2015 Agreement) – 2015 Agreement was opposed by the Construction, Forestry, Mining and Energy Union (CFMEU), the Electrical, Electronic, Energy, Information, Postal, Plumbing and Allied Services Union of Australia (CEPU), and Australian Manufacturing Workers’ Union (AMWU) (collectively, the Unions) – dispute in the proceedings as to what were the applicable comparator instruments for the purpose of the application of the ‘better off overall test’ (BOOT) – appellant’s position was that the applicable comparator instruments were a number of Queensland State awards and orders preserved as ‘notional agreements preserving State awards’ (NAPSAs) – Unions’ position was that the relevant instruments were the modern awards, and that the 2015 Agreement was incapable of passing the BOOT by reference to these instruments – at first instance the Commission determined the relevant modern awards were the comparator instruments – appellant contended that decision was in error and should be quashed – appellant supported by the Housing Industry Association (HIA), the Queensland Master Builders Association Industrial Organisation of Employers (QMBA), and the Group Training Association of Queensland and Northern Territory Limited trading as the Apprentice Employment Network (Apprentice Employment Network) – Full Bench considered permission to appeal should be granted – appeal raised issues which were novel, complex, and had broader implications for the pay rates and conditions of employment for trainees and apprentices in Queensland – appellant’s submissions focused upon whether the relevant NAPSAs continued to apply to, or cover, it and its employees covered by the 2015 Agreement – Full Bench considered the critical question was whether the relevant modern awards relied upon by the Unions covered employees to whom the 2015 Agreement would apply if approved (regardless of whether the NAPSAs covered or applied to such employees) – s.48(1) of FW Act provides that a modern award covers an employee and an employer if it is expressed to cover them – Full Bench considered it was clear that the modern awards relied upon by the Unions were, at the ‘test time’ for the 2015 Agreement expressed to cover various categories of employees to whom the 2015 Agreement would apply if approved – question was then whether anything in the Fair Work (Transitional Provisions and Consequential Amendments) Act 2009 (Transitional Act) altered that position – Full Bench held Item 16 of Schedule 5 of the Transitional Act, while it operates to continue the coverage of award-based transitional instruments (ABTIs) to which it applies, does not displace the coverage of any modern award to an employee – item 16(5), while it provides that a modern award shall not apply to an employee while an ABTI still covers the employee, does not provide that a modern award shall not continue to cover the employee – Full Bench found no inherent conflict in there being coverage of an employee by two different instruments, since coverage is only concerned with the potential and not the actual application of the instrument – held decision at first instance was correct – permission to appeal granted – appeal dismissed – application for approval of 2015 Agreement referred back to Spencer C for final determination in accordance with this decision. Appeal by All Trades Queensland P/L against decision of Spencer C of 12 August 2016 [[2016] FWC 2832] Re: Construction, Forestry, Mining and Energy Union and Ors
February 21, 2017
RIGHT OF ENTRY – application for permit – s.512 Fair Work Act 2009 – application by the Construction, Forestry, Mining and Energy Union (CFMEU) for the issue of a right of entry permit to its official, Mr Harkins – Mr Harkins is employed as an organiser with the CFMEU – Australian Building and Construction Commissioner did not wish to make a submission in relation to this application – application determined without hearing – considered question of whether a person is a ‘fit and proper person’ [MUA] – also considered CEPU – Mr Harkins had previously worked for Incolink and Unions Tasmania, and was an official of the Communications, Electrical, Electronic, Energy, Information, Postal, Plumbing and Allied Services Union of Australia (CEPU), in which he was issued entry permits on three separate occasions – CFMEU filed declarations in support of application – these declarations advised Mr Harkins had received appropriate training, had not been convicted of an offence involving conduct described in ss.513(1)(b) or (c) of FW Act, and had not had any entry permit revoked, suspended or had imposed conditions on any such permit – Commission accepted the information disclosed as accurate and correct – declarations also disclosed that Mr Harkins previously engaged in unlawful industrial action constituted by a 24-hour strike of employees in the electrical industry in Tasmania, action was taken to be conduct of the CEPU and CEPU was ordered to pay a penalty in 2005 for contravening s.38 of the Building and Construction Industry Improvement Act 2005 – Mr Harkins filed a statement to the effect that he understood that he must comply with the law and gave an assurance that he will do so – Commission took into consideration the contravening conduct that resulted in the imposition of a pecuniary penalty, the significant passage of time between the conduct outlined above and the current application being made and Mr Harkins’ attitude to compliance with the law, in attributing appropriate weight to this particular permit qualification matter – previous application for a permit of Mr Harkins was made by the Tasmanian Branch of the CEPU in 2009, both the Committee of Management and proposed permit holder declarations in that matter failed to disclose the abovementioned contravention and penalty – the nature of the non-disclosure and the failure to return the Previous Permit within the statutory period was conduct of a serious kind and ought to have been included in the application for the Previous Permit – Commission held explanations provided to have been genuine and accepted that non-disclosure was one of inadvertence rather than deliberate – found ultimately, the assessment to be made is not a punitive one aimed at continuing to punish Mr Harkins for his past wrongdoing – the assessment was whether having regard to the permit qualification matters, some of which discloses past wrong doing, Mr Harkins was now a fit and proper person to hold an entry permit – application granted – entry permit to be issued. Construction, Forestry, Mining and Energy Union-Construction and General Division, Victoria-Tasmania Divisional Branch
February 21, 2017
ENTERPRISE BARGAINING – majority support determination – s.236 Fair Work Act 2009 – applicant requested to commence bargaining in relation to a geographically and operationally distinct group of employees of O’Keefe Heneghan P/L and Auslife P/L and Rocky Neill Construction P/L t/a KNF Construction (KNF Construction) – KNF Construction did not reply – KNF Construction has agreement covering all its employees with a nominal expiry date of 15 February 2017 – applicant distributed petition to employees – claims 48 out of 60 relevant employees signed petition, and accordingly, was an appropriate method in determining majority support – KNF Construction objected to whether the group of employees was fairly chosen and the use of the petition to determine majority support – applicant submitted that petition should be provided to the Commission on a confidential basis and compared to list of relevant employees provided by KNF Construction to determine whether there was a valid majority – KNF Construction did not consent – lodged application for an order to produce names and signatures on petition, otherwise they would be denied procedural fairness – applicant submitted disclosure of names would be a risk to employees privacy and rights to freedom and association – argument as to whether confidentiality order should be made – Commission did not find any requirement to provide names and signatures on a petition to an employer on an interlocutory basis – did not find it appropriate or necessary for respondent to view names and signatures of petition – Commission not satisfied that there would be procedural unfairness to respondent – satisfied that confidentiality order should be made with respect to petition – ordered petition to be treated as confidential – KNF Construction ordered to provide list of employees covered by application to Commission. Construction, Forestry, Mining and Energy Union
February 21, 2017
TERMINATION OF EMPLOYMENT – extension of time – representative error – s.394 Fair Work Act 2009 – application for unfair dismissal lodged 25 days late – applicant submitted reason for late lodgment was ‘wholly the fault’ of his union – within a week of being dismissed the applicant attended the United Voice office (his union) on 11 July 2016 and instructed them to lodge an unfair dismissal application on his behalf – applicant became concerned when he had not heard anything about his application, so attended the union offices on 20 July 2016 to make enquiries – union lodged application on 19 August 2016 – whether exceptional circumstances exist [Nulty] – Clark considered – Commission satisfied that applicant was blameless in the delay – found union failed to act upon repeated instructions – satisfied reason for delay was entirely a representative error on behalf of United Voice – satisfied there were exceptional circumstances – extension of time granted. Phan v GJK Facility Services P/L t/a GJK Facility Services
February 21, 2017
ENTERPRISE AGREEMENTS – dispute about matter arising under agreement – s.739 Fair Work Act 2009 – application to deal with a dispute under the Mt Arthur Coal Enterprise Agreement 2016 – applicant participated in random drug and alcohol test at work – later that night was directed to undertake further drug test and refused to do so – issued with a final written warning – applied to Commission to deal with dispute in accordance with dispute settlement clause in Agreement – unsuccessful conciliation of dispute – Commission to determine four questions in dispute – inconsistency in parties evidence – respondent contended to have collected first urine sample at about 7:05pm and second sample at about 7:40pm, whereas applicant contended to have provided sample at 6:45pm and 7:05pm – Commission found it unlikely that applicant would have been able to provide first urine sample so early in circumstances where not advised of selection earlier and considering having to wait to have test completed – the drug and alcohol tester contended that sample was ‘extremely warm to touch’ and alerted to possibility of sample being adulterated – sample was ineligible as temperature was too hot – requested second sample from applicant – second sample had same physical presentation as previous sample, namely, it was turbid and cloudy – was negative for drugs, however tester requested applicant be escorted back to health clinic to provide third sample so that there was no question of integrity – believed applicant was under the influence of drugs which potentially may have caused a hazard or risk to himself and/or other employees at the mine – was not allowed to touch bag or go out for a smoke – request for smoke was within the scope of the Testing Policy as supervisor would be escorting – refused to take third test – applicant was aware that refusal to provide further urine sample would be considered a breach of Mt Arthur’s drug and alcohol procedures – applicant stood down and driven home – Commission found that applicant breached the Drug and Alcohol Procedure by refusing to undertake drug test – not unreasonable for respondent to issue applicant with final written warning – not unreasonable for respondent to require applicant to meet with the Employee Assistance Program provider – drug and alcohol testing had not been unreasonable and had been in accordance with policies and procedures – Commission declined to grant any relief sought by applicant – application dismissed. Muller v Mt Arthur Coal P/L t/a Mt Arthur Coal
February 21, 2017
GENERAL PROTECTIONS – extension of time – ss.365, 366 Fair Work Act 2009 – application to deal with contraventions involving dismissal lodged one day late – reasons given for the delay included the Christmas and New Year period being within the 21 day timeframe, and that application was sent to the Commission by email within the 21 day time limit but it was not received – Commission held that there was no evidence that the employer would be prejudiced by extension of time – held there were exceptional circumstances [Nulty] warranting a grant of an extension of time – extension of time granted. Johnston v Empire Holdings P/L
February 21, 2017
TERMINATION OF EMPLOYMENT – termination at initiative of employer – resignation – ss.385, 386, 394 Fair Work Act 2009 – application for unfair dismissal remedy – applicant employed as a business development manager – claimed constructively dismissed by respondent while on approved leave – respondent contacted applicant to clarify an issue in regard to the payment of a Townsville based trainer – respondent contended applicant voluntarily resigned and was not dismissed – resignation was accepted – evidence supported other options were available to applicant outside of resignation – applicant did not retract resignation – Commission found there was no dismissal at the initiative of the employer – requirement under s.385(a) not met – application dismissed. Carroll v Gold Training P/L t/a Gold Training