NEWS HR

TERMINATION OF EMPLOYMENT – extension of time – ss.394, 400, 604 Fair Work Act 2009 – permission to appeal – Full Bench – appellant contended Commission erred in refusing to extend time for filing unfair dismissal application lodged five days late – permission to appeal application could only be determined by reference to notice of appeal – no outline of submissions filed, nor appeal book – no appearance by either party at hearing – most of appellant’s ‘grounds’ for appeal consisted of offensive comments – intelligible grounds sought rerun of case – whether permission to appeal in public interest – whether significant error of fact – public interest test is discretionary and involves broad value judgment [Coal & Allied Mining] – Full Bench concluded original decision was not unreasonable, manifestly unjust, nor counter-intuitive – appellant’s reasons for delay included difficulty getting legal advice and caring responsibilities – appellant never properly articulated why these reasons impeded filing of unfair dismissal application – grounds for appeal mostly irrelevant and did not address statutory requirements – grounds did not identify error that would justify granting of permission to appeal in public interest – permission to appeal refused. Appeal by Webster against decision of Drake SDP of 1 September 2016 [[2016] FWC 6210] Re: Costa Exchange Limited t/a Berry Exchange

TERMINATION OF EMPLOYMENT – misconduct – ss.394, 400, 604 Fair Work Act 2009 – permission to appeal – Full Bench – at first instance the Commission found the appellant’s dismissal was unreasonable and unjust and ordered compensation of $1,100 – grounds for appeal included that there was no valid reason for dismissal; the respondent failed to provide appellant with fair treatment or to comprehensively and impartially investigate the allegations; and that the respondent had failed to prove that appellant committed serious misconduct – grounds of appeal did not challenge the Commission’s analysis and conclusions concerning the remedy – appellant submitted that the decision at first instance contained errors concerning the definition of serious misconduct and that it was in the public interest to clarify the definition – Full Bench considered that the appeal was fundamentally misconceived, because the issues it raised pertained to matters in relation to which the Commission made findings in his favour – held appeal sought to re-agitate issues upon which the appellant effectively succeeded before the Commission – found appellant had not demonstrated any arguable case of error in the decision and had not identified any issue requiring resolution at the Full Bench level – Full Bench had grave reservations about the manner in which the Commission dealt with the issue of remedy, particularly the assessment of the amount of compensation to be awarded – no appeal ground or submission advanced by appellant which challenged the assessment of compensation – not in the public interest to grant permission to appeal – permission to appeal refused. Appeal by Jimenez against decision of Cambridge C of 5 August 2016 [[2016] FWC 5141] Re: Accent Group t/a Platypus Shoes (Australia) P/L

ENTERPRISE AGREEMENTS – dispute about matter arising under agreement – s.739 Fair Work Act 2009 – Commission issued recommendation regarding dispute arising under Pacific National Coal NSW Enterprise Agreement 2013 (Agreement) – concerned restructure of Plan Delivery Section in respondent’s Hunter Valley operations – 10 occupants of former roles required to undergo competitive selection process as part of organisational restructure – four existing employees unsuccessful and faced redundancy – applicant contended respondent should have filled new roles by direct appointment in accordance with clause C2.4 of Agreement – Commission of view applicant’s reliance on clause C2.4 was misplaced – furthermore, Commission of view applicant was incorrect in assuming that employees should have automatically been appointed to new roles – Commission satisfied there was no utility or purpose in making recommendation/s sought by the applicant – dispute concluded. Australian Rail, Tram and Bus Industry Union v Asciano Services P/L t/a Pacific National

MODERN AWARDS – 4 yearly review – ss.117, 156, 323 Fair Work Act 2009 – Full Bench – number of matters referred to Full Bench regarding payment of wages on termination of employment – purpose of Statement to express preliminary view – ABI/Ai Group claim current framework in various awards unworkable and place increased burden on employers – proposals will reduce costs and promote modern award objectives – Full Bench of view s.323 FW Act requires employer to pay wages within a month but not clear whether it encompasses amounts accrued under award or NES – s.117 does however state that termination payment to be made prior to or upon termination – issue broader than previously appreciated – provisional view that each modern award should provide for payment of wages/other amounts owning on termination – proposal put forward by Full Bench for future discussion. 4 yearly review of modern awards – payment of wages

TERMINATION OF EMPLOYMENT – misconduct – ss.387, 394 Fair Work Act 2009 – application for relief from unfair dismissal – confidentiality order issued at beginning of proceedings – applicant employed as Corrective Service Officer (CSO) – dismissed for ‘gross misconduct’ – used unreasonable and unjustified force on prisoner – serious breach of the respondent’s Code of Conduct and Ethical Behaviour policy – applicant submitted no evidence of wilful or deliberate misconduct in particular incident – further submitted reasons for termination not defensible or justifiable on objective analysis of relevant facts and were prejudiced and not supported by credible evidence – respondent alleged applicant’s conduct was not authorised by s.143 of Corrective Services Act 2006 (Qld) (CS Act) – submitted use of force should be last resort – alleged applicant knowingly made false declaration in an official record – further submitted Commission should take into account special vulnerability of prisoners towards CSOs – Commission found that no witness gave evidence that strictly supported CCTV footage – Commission accepted respondent’s findings of investigation – found that applicant’s actions were not lawful actions required pursuant to s.143 of CS Act – satisfied of valid reason for dismissal and that misconduct was serious breach of respondent’s code of conduct – dismissal not harsh, unjust or unreasonable – application dismissed. Mr S v Respondent

TERMINATION OF EMPLOYMENT – small business employer – s.394 Fair Work Act 2009 – application for unfair dismissal remedy – applicant employed as jewellery sales executive – respondent submitted it was a small business and the dismissal complied with Small Business Fair Dismissal Code – applicant contended respondent not a small business and was an associated entity of larger organisation – Commission found respondent was not a small business employer as a principal organisation incorporated in Hong Kong controlled associate business – applicant dismissed for using mobile phone whilst driving and walking away without notice carrying property of business – respondent failed to inform applicant of these reasons – applicant believed real reason for dismissal was complaining about not being paid overtime – Commission found dismissal was sound, defensible and well founded – applicant was denied procedural fairness in dismissal process – held that dismissal was unjust and therefore unfair – ordered compensation of $2,902.50 before tax, plus superannuation at 9.5%. Lau v Nelson (Australia) J A P/L

MODERN AWARDS – dispute about matter arising under award – jurisdiction – ss.595, 739 Fair Work Act 2009 – dispute concerned written warning issued to applicant and her request to have written warning withdrawn – applicant sought to have Commission deal with dispute in accordance with Dispute Resolution clause contained in Clerks – Private Sector Award 2010 – respondent raised jurisdictional objection on basis that Commission had no jurisdiction to deal with application because dispute not about matter arising under relevant Award and/or National Employment Standards (NES) – submitted that applicant was employed under terms of Banking, Finance and Insurance Award 2010 rather than Clerks – Private Sector Award 2010 but that question of which Award had coverage was of no consequence as they contained same Dispute Resolution procedure – Commission satisfied nothing in Award or NES dealt with provision of warnings to employee about behaviour or work performance – held that terms of dispute procedure did not provide Commission with jurisdiction to deal with present application – application dismissed. Pavlic v SAI Global t/a SAI Global Property

GENERAL PROTECTIONS – extension of time – ss.365, 366 Fair Work Act 2009 – application to deal with contraventions involving dismissal – respondent submitted that the applicant had abandoned her employment – applicant cited medical treatment and time zone differences as reasons for lack of contact prior to termination – date of termination of employment in dispute – whether exceptional circumstances exist [Nulty] – reason for delay by applicant included medical care and miscarriage of pregnancy – Kornicki v Telstra-Network Technology Group considered – Commission satisfied exceptional circumstances present – extension of time granted. Flanagan v Coaching College P/L t/a Coaching College