NEWS HR

TERMINATION OF EMPLOYMENT – termination at initiative of employer – constructive dismissal – s.394 Fair Work Act 2009 – application for relief from unfair dismissal – applicant employed as a Lecturer from 19 January 2009 until resignation on 7 October 2016 – applicant claimed he was forced to resign to enable access permanent disability insurance benefits and superannuation funds – was diagnosed with depression and anxiety leading to inability to attend work – provided medical certificate stating he could work with restrictions that included avoiding contact and working from home – applicant was advised that this was not possible and that no suitable duties could be assigned to him – medical report received by the respondent on 14 April 2014 stated applicant was unable to work for three months and may then be able to commence a return to work program – respondent requested a further medical examination on 2 July 2014 advising applicant would be on unpaid personal leave until then – applicant advised respondent he was too ill to attend the examination and that he was applying for temporary disability benefits through his superannuation fund – applicant did not resume work between 4 April 2014 and resignation – applicant resigned in order to access permanent superannuation entitlements – Commission found that the decision not to allow applicant to return to work until a certificate of capacity was obtained was reasonable – found refusal to allow modified duties and conclusion that working from home was impractical was reasonable – respondent did not breach obligations to assist the return to work of an injured employee – no obligation to pay applicant for time not worked – decision to refuse the applicant to work from home was not a decision to stand down the employee – decision to refuse work from home and place on approved unpaid personal leave was not a demotion – Commission not satisfied that the dispute over work from home forced applicant to resign – applicant resigned after not being able to work for several years due to need for income and incapacity for work – applicant not dismissed – unfair dismissal remedy cannot proceed – application dismissed. Weber v Deakin University

ENTERPRISE BARGAINING – bargaining representative – privacy – s.185 Fair Work Act 2009 – application for approval of the Ron Southon P/L Enterprise Agreement 2016-2020 – CFMEU was not a party to the agreement – CFMEU sought access to Forms F16 and F17 lodged by employer – prior approval for enterprise agreement had been appealed by CFMEU [[2016] FWCFB 8413] (the Appeal) – Appeal had been allowed on the grounds that the agreement contravened s.55 of FW Act – employer submitted that access to the documents should be balanced with the need to protect the privacy of the individual bargaining agents – further submitted that the comments of the Full Bench in the Appeal relating to access to the documents were obiter – Full Bench had said that the Forms F16 and F17 should be ‘freely available to any member of the public’ unless exceptional circumstances ‘justify an order of confidentiality’ – CFMEU submitted that employer had not identified any exceptional circumstances that would prevent their access to the documents – Commission found that employer had provided no basis for conclusion of exceptional circumstances, and concluded that the Full Bench had considered the issue of access to the forms which was fully argued – Commission held that the finding of the Full Bench could not be considered obiter and was bound by the decision of the Full Bench – copies of the forms to be forwarded to the CFMEU. Construction, Forestry Mining and Energy Union v Ron Southon P/L

TERMINATION OF EMPLOYMENT – genuine redundancy – ss.389, 394 Fair Work Act 2009 – applicant employed in Customer Service Team – Team included four Customer Support Advisors and a Team leader in addition to applicant – applicant only person made redundant as a result of September 2016 restructure – applicant argued redundancy was a sham – submitted no significant reduction in workload and no significant operational change – Commission found reduction in workload due to removal of Forward Order Program the removal of technical and training support and change in focus in national dealers key accounts – Commission accepted applicant submission that no reduction in her workload occurred prior to her redundancy – did not accept reason for applicant’s dismissal was her complaint about Customer Service Manager – Commission satisfied that reduction from five Customer Support Advisors to four was because of changes in the operational needs of the business and a rational projection of reduction in future workload – Commission satisfied redeployment not possible – Commission satisfied process invited and provided consultation about redeployment – not satisfied process invited or proposed any consultation about the operational changes themselves and measures to avert or mitigate the adverse effects of such changes – not satisfied the consultation requirements of the Clerks Private Sector Award 2010 were met – Commission found dismissal was not a genuine redundancy – satisfied dismissal was unfair – reinstatement not sought by applicant and opposed by employer – amount of severance package and earnings from other employment deducted from calculated amount – ordered compensation of $4,590.95, taxed accordingly. O’Shea v Stihl P/L

ENTERPRISE AGREEMENTS – dispute about matter arising under agreement – s.739 Fair Work Act 2009 – application to deal with a dispute under the Fulton Hogan Industries P/L NSW State Collective Agreement 2015 – Fulton Hogan conducts a road maintenance business – work often needs to be done quickly, at night or on weekends – sometimes necessary for employees to switch from night work to day work, or vice versa, during weekly roster cycle – employees paid eight hours ordinary pay on ‘rest day’ between cessation of night shift and commencement of day shift – dispute concerned payments that must be made to an employee who undertakes a shift change part way through the week and is then directed to work a fifth shift during the week – Fulton Hogan contended that work performed on a ‘fifth shift’ was part of their ordinary hours of work, and employees can be required to work such hours and are entitled to be paid their ordinary rate of pay – AWU contended that work performed on a ‘fifth shift’ was overtime, and employees may refuse to work those hours if they are unreasonable, and if worked must be paid as overtime – AWU posed two questions for arbitration: whether ‘rest day’ considered as time worked; and are ordinary hours concluded (ie reach 38) at the end of the fourth day – proper construction of clause 18.7 of the Agreement considered – Commission held ‘fifth shift’ not additional hours and is to be paid at ordinary rate of pay – answer to two questions no – application dismissed. The Australian Workers’ Union v Fulton Hogan Industries P/L

ENTERPRISE AGREEMENTS – approval – s.185 Fair Work Act 2009 – application for approval of a single-enterprise agreement – whether genuine agreement – whether scope fairly chosen – application to approve MTP Enterprise Agreement 2016 by Thiess P/L – no employee or union bargaining representatives – three employees said to be covered and all voted in favour of agreement – agreement will cover employees engaged to work at or in connection with Mt Pleasant Mine Project – Thiess not yet successful in obtaining contract – no Thiess employees are or have been working at Mine – if successful in gaining contract hundreds of workers expected to be employed under agreement – Thiess submitted the three employees were engaged at time of vote in work necessary for and preparatory to work at Mine on equipment owned by Thiess which it may require for project – three employees selected from Brisbane based maintenance team and sent to Nebo and Mt Thorley sites to inspect and repair equipment – Construction, Forestry, Mining and Energy Union (CFMEU) raised concerns about lack of genuine agreement and scope not fairly chosen – CFMEU allowed to be heard – submitted employees not properly informed of effects of agreement – concerned about better off overall test (BOOT) and NES – concerned about cashing out annual leave – Thiess agreed to provide undertakings regarding pay rates, annual leave provisions, including for shiftworkers, all inclusive rates (to exclude overtime which is not part of the regular roster), and how they are calculated, to meet the BOOT – Commission satisfied undertakings address concerns and do not result in financial detriment to an employee – satisfied requirements for approval were met other than issues related to legitimacy of agreement being made and scope of agreement not being fairly chosen – CFMEU submitted the three employees not covered by agreement, not operationally, organisationally or geographically distinct and had no real interest in agreement – submitted scope excludes bargaining a greenfields agreement and denies those who will be employed at Mine opportunity to bargain – Commission not satisfied work performed by the three employees fell within coverage at 3.1(b) of agreement but satisfied work would fall within scope should Thiess obtain contract – not satisfied that the employees who voted were covered by agreement – s.186(2)(a) of FW Act not met – cannot approve agreement – however, if wrong, Commission also not satisfied scope of agreement fairly chosen nor agreement genuinely agreed to by employees covered by it – ss.186(3), (3A) and s.188(c) not met – cannot approve agreement – application dismissed. MTP Enterprise Agreement 2016

ENTERPRISE BARGAINING – majority support determination – ss.236, 237 Fair Work Act 2009 – application for a majority support determination lodged by Australian Workers’ Union (AWU) – employer to be covered by proposed agreement Huon Aquaculture Company P/L (HAC) – employees to be covered by proposed agreement engaged in farm attendant duties in connection with marine operations at Macquarie Harbour, Tasmania – HAC opposed making of determination on basis that it had agreed to bargain with AWU – submitted it did not consider relevant employees to be geographically distinct from rest of Tasmanian workforce and not ‘fairly chosen’ – AWU relied on remote nature of Macquarie Harbour site to support argument that relevant employees were geographically distinct from rest of Tasmania – Commission satisfied AWU was bargaining representative for relevant employees – satisfied majority of employees wished to bargain for proposed agreement – satisfied preconditions contained in ss.236(1), s.237(2)(a) FW Act satisfied – precondition contained in s.237(2)(b) considered – role of a majority support determination is to commence the bargaining process when there is majority support among employees to collectively bargain, when their employer has not agreed to do so [Coca-Cola] – Commission found that HAC had agreed to bargain with relevant employees and therefore s.237(2) was not fulfilled – application dismissed. ‘Australian Workers’ Union, The

ENTERPRISE AGREEMENTS – dispute about matter arising under agreement – s.739 Fair Work Act 2009 – Australian Manufacturing Workers’ Union (AMWU) and the Australian Workers’ Union (AWU) (the Unions) applied to Commission to deal with dispute in accordance with dispute settlement procedure in Brockman Engineering P/L Workshop and Site Collective Bargaining Agreement 2014 (Agreement) – Brockman provided tank maintenance services to Viva Energy Australia P/L under contract – Viva employed employees to perform maintenance work on specialised plant and equipment but did not employ employees to perform tank maintenance work – Viva employees were regulated by Shell Geelong Refinery Enterprise Agreement 2013 – Maintenance Employees (Viva Agreement) – dispute concerned interpretation and operation of clause 39, colloquially known as ‘jump up clause’ – question to be determined whether Brockman required, under the jump up clause, to apply wage rates or any other benefits of the Viva Agreement that were superior to those applying under the Agreement – Commission agreed with Brockman that provision of clause 39 as a whole were ambiguous and did not operate in the manner contended by the Unions – determined that the entitlement created by clause 39 should be broken into four constituent elements: that ‘an employee is employed or engaged at a site/client premises’; there must be ‘a general provision that applies to employees engaged on that site/client premises’; that ‘general provision’ must provide ‘benefit that is superior to the provisions of’ the Agreement; and, if the first three elements were satisfied then ‘the superior conditions shall apply’ to that employee – Commission held there was no real dispute that the first and third elements were satisfied but doubted whether provisions of Viva Agreement could properly be said to be a ‘general provision that applies to employees engaged on the client/site premises’ – that Viva Agreement had limited application and only applied to Viva’s employees, notwithstanding that they were engaged on Viva’s premises – Commission determined accordingly and no orders necessary. “Automotive, Food, Metals, Engineering, Printing and Kindred Industries Union” known as the Australian Manufacturing Workers’ Union (AMWU) and Anor v Brockman Engineering P/L

Ankush Sharma has had his unfair dismissal claim against CMBM T/A Cleaning Company tossed out because he failed to respond to the Fair Work Commission. “A number of attempts were made to make contact with Mr Sharma on his mobile number without success. An email was sent and a voice message was left for Mr Sharma to contact my Chambers,” said Commissioner Simpson.