NEWS HR

ENTERPRISE AGREEMENTS – dispute about matter arising under agreement – s.739 Fair Work Act 2009 – disputes under UGL Operations and Maintenance P/L Ichthys Onshore Construction Greenfields Agreement and Kentz P/L Ichthys Onshore Construction Greenfields Agreement relating to inclement weather/cyclone preparation – Commission held that the agreements in question enabled an affected employee to remain onsite during inclement weather – did not allow employer to direct employees not engaged in active work to leave site (where particular criteria are met) – Commission also held that employer is required to pay an affected employee for their scheduled work where the employee exercises the option to stay. “Automotive, Food, Metals, Engineering, Printing and Kindred Industries Union” known as the Australian Manufacturing Workers’ Union (AMWU) v UGL Operations and Maintenance P/L and Anor

TERMINATION OF EMPLOYMENT – costs – ss.394, 400A Fair Work Act 2009 – application for costs incurred in relation to unfair dismissal matter – Commission previously found respondent employer did not have valid reason to terminate applicant’s employment and dismissal unfair – consent order issued on 30 January 2017 to reinstate employee and back pay for remuneration lost – applicant made application pursuant to s.400A for costs – applicant submitted that agreement had been reached between parties at conciliation conference before Commission on 10 August 2016 and that failure of settlement to eventuate was unreasonable act on respondent’s part which caused him to incur costs – respondent opposed costs on grounds that settlement proposals made during conciliation process inadmissible and could not be relied upon – no delay by respondent after decision made to warrant order of costs – applicant’s success did not by itself justify order of costs – parties agreed to resolve proceedings in terms set out by consent – Commission noted well-accepted principle that each party bears its own costs in relation to matter before Commission – s.400A concerned with unreasonable acts or omissions in connection with ‘conduct or continuation’ of a matter already instituted, not with whether it was reasonable to have instituted matter in first place [Gugiatti] – Commission held finding that applicant unfairly dismissed not relevant to claim of unreasonable acts or omissions by respondent – offers made during earlier conciliation conference also not to be taken into account – the fact that respondent lost its case did not mean it had no prospects of success – no concerns raised by applicant or his solicitor that respondent was responsible for any unreasonable delay – Commission found respondent’s defence of unfair dismissal claim made by applicant not unreasonable and satisfied that respondent did not cause applicant to incur costs because of any unreasonable acts or omissions in connection with conduct or continuation of matter – application for costs dismissed. Petreski v Sydney Water Corporation t/a Sydney Water

ENTERPRISE AGREEMENTS – dispute about matter arising under agreement – s.739 Fair Work Act 2009 – dispute concerned appropriate penalty rate payable to drivers who worked on 27 December 2016 – dispute arose in relation to application under dispute resolution procedure in the SUEZ environment Australia – Recycling & waste recovery Brisbane Drivers Enterprise Agreement 2015 for Drivers engaged in SUEZ environment Australia – Recycling & waste recovery operation of the Brisbane City Council’s Contracts (the Agreement) – applicant submitted applicable rate payable was payment for ordinary hours normally rostered and a rate of double time for all work performed – applicant submitted that 27 December was a substitute day for Christmas day and thus the rates payable on Christmas Day applied – respondent paid employees for the public holidays as well as the hours worked on this day at the rate of time and a half – respondent submitted work on 27 December was work within ordinary working hours and was subject to ordinary rates – Commission found Good Friday and Christmas Day attract penalties under the Agreement but that Christmas Day was 25 December not 27 December – Commission found rate payable to employees working on 27 December was ordinary time and a half provided that the work was performed within ordinary working hours of those employees plus any amount payable in respect of the weekly wage for public holidays. Transport Workers’ Union of Australia-Queensland Branch v Suez Recycling and Recovery P/L t/a Suez

TERMINATION OF EMPLOYMENT – misconduct – s.394 Fair Work Act 2009 – application for unfair dismissal remedy – applicant worked in service station – incident involved unarmed customer who demanded money and cigarettes and threatened to jump counter – applicant did not obey offender’s demands and tried to outsmart offender – respondent had a procedure for employees to follow in the event of an attempted robbery or an armed robbery – Commission satisfied applicant did not comply with important elements of respondent’s procedure – applicant acknowledged respondent’s procedure was not followed because no ‘arms’ were involved – Commission considered applicant’s argument disingenuous – found incident was an attempted robbery and respondent was not unreasonable in expecting applicant to have followed its procedure, at least in general terms – applicant was aware of respondent’s procedure but failed to comply – applicant’s conduct was a valid reason for dismissal – Commission noted applicant had received previous warning for failing to comply with respondent’s Food Safety procedures – previous warning advised applicant further unacceptable conduct could result in termination of employment – Commission also noted that applicant’s continued refusal to accept the error in his actions had destroyed any confidence respondent could have that the applicant had learnt from what occurred and could be relied upon in the future – found dismissal was neither harsh, unjust nor unreasonable – applicant not unfairly dismissed – application dismissed. Mistry v Woolworths Limited t/a Woolworths Fuel

TERMINATION OF EMPLOYMENT – extension of time – unfair dismissal – s.394 Fair Work Act 2009 – applicant applied for unfair dismissal remedies in respect of her dismissal by the respondent – the applicant made her application 23 days after her dismissal, which was 2 days over the 21 day time limit – the question was whether there were exceptional circumstances warranting an extension of time under s.394 of the Act – the main reasons that the applicant offered for her delay was that she was ill after her dismissal, including a period where she was admitted to hospital, English was her second language and she could not use a computer and so she found it difficult to lodge an application – the Commission accepted that, although the circumstances that caused the delay were not unusual or rare, the confluence of relatively ordinary matters amounted to exceptional circumstances – the application was granted, and an order granting an extension of time was made. Baltas v ISS Facility Services Ltd t/a ISS Facility Services

ENTERPRISE AGREEMENTS – dispute about matter arising under agreement – s.739 Fair Work Act 2009 – application to deal with dispute under Boeing Australia Component Repairs P/L Enterprise Agreement 2013 to 2016 (Agreement) – whether an employee was entitled to be reclassified from Aerospace Tradesperson 1 (AT1) to Aerospace Tradesperson 2 (AT2) -issues in dispute were: the proper construction of the accountabilities and requirements of an AT2; whether there was a business need for employee to perform those accountabilities and requirements; and whether he achieved those standards – applicant submitted that employee should have been recognised as performing work at AT2 level from when he applied for reclassification and respondent should make back payment for wage differential between two classifications – Commission identified several accountabilities of AT2 classification that employee was not performing and/or achieving, such as assisting team leaders in carrying out assessments of work to be carried out by Tradesperson 1 employees, assisting in the ongoing Internal Quality Auditing of Boeing processes, and undertaking basic estimating tasks – respondent submitted that clause 5.2.2.1 of Agreement concerning progression application applies only when an employee is performing a role of higher classification because of a business need, and not merely because employee holds competencies which employee is not required to utilise in the regular course of work – respondent submitted that there had been insufficient work to justify the existing AT2s to perform their additional accountabilities in this role – Commission held employee was not and had not been performing the accountabilities required of an AT2 – he was not entitled to be reclassified and his reclassification application had been properly refused – no orders necessary. “Automotive, Food, Metals, Engineering, Printing and Kindred Industries Union” known as the Australian Manufacturing Workers’ Union (AMWU) v Boeing Australia Component Repairs P/L

TERMINATION OF EMPLOYMENT – misconduct – s.394 Fair Work Act 2009 – application for unfair dismissal remedy – applicant was employed as a primary school teacher – dismissed on 17 January 2017 after multiple allegations of misconduct – respondent alleged applicant made inappropriate physical contact with students; informed students to not divulge certain stories to adults; had previously been spoken to of the importance of appropriate professional boundaries and had breached the Victorian Institute of Teachers Code of Conduct – applicant conceded to some of the allegations but submitted there was valid reason for physical contact with the students – Commission did not accept there was valid reason for applicant’s physical contact with students – Commission satisfied the gravity of applicant’s conduct constituted valid reason for dismissal – noted applicant had a choice and could have declined student’s physical contact – accepted some instances of misconduct occurred but did not accept some of the respondent’s allegations were substantiated – satisfied applicant breached professional obligations – satisfied respondent had previously spoken to applicant about the importance of maintaining appropriate professional boundaries, notified applicant of reasons for dismissal and gave an opportunity to respond before making decision to dismiss – Commission weighed the potential to put respondent’s students at risk from others against the gravity of applicant’s conduct – noted it was not apparent applicant accepted the seriousness of misconduct during the proceedings as the given conduct was not trivial or unimportant – found the termination of the applicant’s employment was not a disproportionate response to applicant’s misconduct – application dismissed. Adams v Department of Education and Training

The list for the Fair Work Commission today includes: Siemens (William Royar), JB Hi-Fi Group Pty Ltd (Wilson), Manildra Stockfeeds Manufacturing Pty Ltd & NSW Sugar Milling Co Op Ltd & Parker (Marsh), Whittaker Building Group Pty Ltd (Skuse), Menzies International (Australia) Pty Ltd (Van Tussenbroek), Star Track Express Pty Ltd (Williams), Lynch Manufacturing NSW Pty Ltd (Maciel), Baia the Italian Pty Ltd (Mezino), Falbury Pty Ltd (Layt), Blackham Resources Ltd (Adams), Curtin University (Reynolds), Chevron Australia Pty Ltd (Ghobrial) Golden West Corporate Total Management Pty Ltd (Gordon), Preformed Line Products (Aust) Pty Ltd (Burke), Gandel Metals (Brenac), The Trustee for Lyndhurst Tavern Discretionary Trust (Baranage), ALDI Stores Pty Ltd as General Partner of ALDI Stores (A Limited Partnership), Champion Pictures Group (Russell), Entire Fire Protection Pty Ltd (Wilson), Tele Magic (Polkinghorne), Australian Scholarship Group Friendly Society Limited (Tonellato), Community Living Australia Ltd (Turner), Woolworths Limited (French), SA Mushrooms (Stefan), Jens Hair Design (Petty), St Johns Community Care Ltd (Kross), Mothers Pantry (Moyes), BMI Group Pty Ltd (Engelbrecht), Upstream Production Solutions Pty Ltd (Salina), Coles Supermarkets Australia Pty Ltd (Higgins), Embassy of the Republic of Tunisia (Mejri), The Trustee for Forzpak Unit Trust (Colless), South Oakleigh Club (Gillmore), (Aviation Training Australasia Pty Ltd (Hertaeg), Ventura Bus Lines (Li), Siemens (William Royar), Commissioner of State Revenue (Kerr), Jens Hair Design (Petty), Jase Investments Pty Ltd Australia (Smithers), Colin Joss & Co Pty Limited (Bennett), Ace Traffic Control (Hunter), Fawcett Plumbing Pty Ltd (Knight), Green Valley Grains P/L (Lee), Sprayworx Pty Ltd (Hayward), Suncorp Staff Pty Ltd (Copping), Teys Australia Central Queensland Pty Ltd (Rodrigues), Healthcare Australia Pty Ltd (Sommer), One Care Ltd (Leahy), Optus Administration Pty Limited (Tevita), Star Track Express Pty Ltd (Schuiling), Andrew Kohn Pty Ltd (Scop), BlueScope Steel Limited (Willmot), Thorpe Custom Trucks (Luapo), Cloverdale Admin Services Pty Ltd (Lao), Kingston City Council (Shafai).