NEWS HR

MODERN AWARDS – 4 yearly review – ss.134, 138, 156 Fair Work Act 2009 – Full Bench – AMWU sought to vary the coverage of the Graphic Arts, Printing and Publishing Award 2010 (the Award) by replacing references to ‘regional daily newspaper’ with ‘daily newspaper’ – sought to remove the exclusion for shiftworkers accruing additional annual leave – sought to insert new redundancy provisions, additional sick leave entitlements and jury service make-up pay – other than the coverage and shiftworker variations, AMWU’s claims were opposed by employer parties – Full Bench decided to clarify the coverage of metropolitan daily newspapers by amending the definition and to remove the exclusion for shiftworkers accruing additional annual leave – the other claims were rejected – Full Bench not required to form a view about whether the Award currently covers metropolitan daily newspapers, sufficient to observe there is ambiguity or uncertainty about coverage – held that the variation achieves the modern awards objective by creating a simple, fair and relevant safety net – Full Bench saw no reason why shiftworkers should be excluded from accruing additional leave under the Award – AMWU submitted that it sought to introduce the existing industry standard for redundancy, sick leave and jury service – the employer parties submitted these would be substantive variations to the Award – there is no existing industry standard so there would be additional costs for employers – Full Bench noted that more beneficial entitlements in enterprise awards and agreements in the sector were not relevant in establishing provisions of the Award – jury service make-up pay was considered during award modernisation and that Full Bench determined it was not appropriate for the Award – Full Bench found that there was no existing higher standard regarding personal leave in the sector – Full Bench found that the more beneficial redundancy provisions were limited to situations of voluntary redundancy – without an evidence based merits case there is no basis to introduce a higher standard in the Award – the Award will be varied by replacing all references to ‘regional daily newspaper’ with ‘daily newspaper’ and amending the shiftworker provision. Graphic Arts, Printing and Publishing Award 2010

ENTERPRISE AGREEMENTS – ambiguity or uncertainty – ss.217, 604 Fair Work Act 2009 – appeal – Full Bench – decision on appeal concerned application by the National Tertiary Education Industry Union (NTEU) to vary the Monash University Enterprise Agreement (Academic and Professional Staff) 2014 (‘the Agreement’) to remove ambiguity or uncertainty in relation to the number of hours sessional staff are paid for marking – Commission at first instance found ambiguity or uncertainty, but not as the NTEU had contended – Commission identified ambiguity concerning payments made to sessional staff who are engaged in marking where that marking is not part of a composite rate already paid – satisfied that it was the mutual intention of parties that sessional staff would receive an hourly rate for all hours spent marking subject to determination by the Dean with respect to the hours allowed for marking – Commission ordered variation to Agreement accordingly – appellant submitted that Commission erred in finding ambiguity where none existed and one which neither party contended – erred in ordering a variation to the Agreement that had neither been sought by the parties nor put to them for consideration – NTEU submitted that Commission was entitled to exercise broad discretion under s.217 of the Act to vary the Agreement to reflect the mutual intention of parties on finding that several provisions in Agreement created ambiguity or uncertainty – Full Bench found that ambiguity or uncertainty identified by Commission was not raised with parties during proceedings – while this may not be fatal by itself, the appellant was not provided with an opportunity to respond to the proposed variation determined by the Commission – Commission satisfied that natural justice was denied to appellant – permission to appeal granted – appeal upheld – decision at first instance quashed – application remitted to Kovacic DP. Appeal by Monash University against decision of Bissett C of 8 November 2016 [[2016] FWCA 7945] Re: National Tertiary Education Industry Union

MODERN AWARDS – 4 yearly review – s.156 Fair Work Act 2009 – Full Bench – Decision issued by Full Bench on 23 October 2015 in relation Group 1C, 1D and 1E awards [[2015] FWCFB 7236] – Decision dealt with a number of technical and drafting issues which arose from the exposure draft for the Manufacturing and Associated Industries and Occupations Award 2010 (Manufacturing Award) and the Professional Diving Industry (Industrial) Award 2010 (Industrial Diving Award) – interested parties provided feedback including proposals to amend some provisions – Full Bench considered, rejected and adopted some proposals which resulted in the addition, deletion and amendment of some provisions – identified inconsistencies with earlier decisions in relation to the calculation and application of casual loading to any all-purpose allowances and drafting in the exposure draft for the Manufacturing Award – Full Bench concluded to maintain the standard wording generally used in exposure drafts and did not alter the definition of casual ordinary hourly rate – inconsistencies were also identified in the Industrial Diving Award in relation to a 38 hour week for offshore divers and 33 hour week for inshore divers – concluded inconsistences should be resolved by prescribing a 38 hour week for inshore divers – Full Bench noted any further outstanding technical and drafting issues; identified errors in the exposure drafts or in the draft determinations or summaries of submissions in relation to the Manufacturing award or the Industrial Diving Award to be forwarded to [email protected] by 30 June 2017 – revised exposure drafts for all Group 1 awards to be amended and republished incorporating the revised standard clauses in accordance with the Plain language processes – further directions to be issued to deal with any outstanding issues – awards will be republished for final comment. 4 yearly review of modern awards – Award stage – Group 1

CONDITIONS OF EMPLOYMENT – redundancy – ss.119, 120, 122 Fair Work Act 2009 – applicant made respondents redundant – applicant seeking reduction of redundancy entitlements payable – applicant claimed it obtained respondents acceptable alternative employment – respondents opposed application on basis they found alternative employment themselves – respondents commenced employment with new employers immediately or shortly after termination – Commission considered meaning of ‘obtain’ in Hunt Energy, FBIS International, Derole Nominees, Clothing Trades and Allman – Commission noted that ‘obtain’ alternative employment is not an absolute test on employer’s ability to obtain employment but refers to action which causes employment to become available (Derole) – Commission considered meaning of ‘other acceptable employment’ in Spotless Services, Oscar Oscar, Felix, Vicstaff and DRW Investments – alternative employment not synonymous with identical employment but terms and conditions should be no less favourable overall – applicant offered some of the respondents employment at applicant’s related childcare centres – six respondents rejected offer of employment with applicant – applicant submitted Commission should apply s.122(3) of FW Act disentitling respondent who rejects an offer of employment made on terms substantially similar – Commission satisfied offer of employment with related childcare centres were acceptable alternative employment – Commission rejected claim that employment unacceptable due to additional 1.15 hour travel time – Commission found whether employee rejects or accepts an offer is not test of whether employment acceptable – Commission reduced redundancy payable – Commission found offer of employment with related child care with lesser duties, uncertainty about when the Centre would open or lesser pay was not acceptable – applicant submitted it obtained alternative employment for respondents by engaging consultant who organised interviews – respondents submitted that applicant merely encouraged respondents to facilitate their own obtainment of employment – Commission not satisfied applicant found respondents employment as a result of conscious and intended actions and no basis to reduce redundancy – applicant submitted two respondents did not cooperate with applicant – applicant submitted that employer should not be penalised because employee refuses to cooperate with every effort made by the employer – respondents submitted that Act does not confer a positive obligation on an employee – Commission found respondent’s new employment was not a result of conscious and intended act of applicant as respondent would not accept assistance – Commission noted no obligation in Act that require employees to cooperate with employer in obtaining employment – Commission not satisfied that applicant obtained employment for respondents – two respondents also rejected offer of employment from related childcare centre – Commission reduced redundancy as offers were reasonable acceptable alternatives. Norwest Child Care Centre P/L v Paul and Ors

INDUSTRIAL ACTION – order against industrial action – ss.19, 418 Fair Work Act 2009 – application for orders under s.418 FW Act against Maritime Union of Australia (MUA) and its employees employed at Webb Dock Drive in respect of unprotected industrial action involving stoppages of work and reductions in productivity that occurred on several occasions – Commission had previously made interim order on 8 May 2017 – submitted that application related to industrial action that is ‘threatened, impending or probable and/or is being organised’ in form of ban or limitation on performance of work by employees and failure or refusal by employees to attend for work – employees were engaged under terms and conditions in Toll Shipping Melbourne Stevedoring Enterprise Agreement 2015 (the Agreement) – application was made in response to unprotected industrial action that had taken place at site during previous three weeks and constituted industrial action under s.19(1)(b) and/or (c)– submitted that recent unprotected industrial action and the outstanding issues raised by MUA indicated that further industrial action was likely – submitted that action was being organised by MUA – MUA submitted that there was no on-going industrial action and it had instead given notice of issues requiring further discussion and any evidence about past action that might have occurred was not sufficient to support conclusion that unprotected industrial action was ‘threatened, impending or probable’ – MUA submitted that any order made should not be directed to all officeholders of MUA as this would extend orders to officeholders who were not involved in alleged industrial action at site – Commission satisfied that unprotected industrial action had occurred in the recent past at Webb Dock site – found that unprotected industrial action was not currently happening at the site – satisfied that protected industrial action was at least ‘impending or probable’ based on what had occurred at site in the recent past and nature of outstanding and on-going issues – satisfied that officials of the MUA had been involved in organising action – Esso considered – held order to be directed only at stoppages of work – appropriate to extend terms of order to include MUA officials involved in organising action involving stoppages of work – appropriate for order to operate for further period of one month to allow time for discussions about issues identified by MUA – order issued. Toll Transport P/L t/a Toll Shipping v The Maritime Union of Australia

ANTI-BULLYING – order to stop bullying issued – s.789FC Fair Work Act 2009 – application for an order to stop bullying – applicant employed at Mag Wheel and Tyre P/L – application made against co-owner of company who is also applicant’s uncle – alleged bullying conduct related to repeated verbal abuse, physical intimidation, ridicule of personal achievements and undermining the applicant in front of other staff and customers – Commission issued a statement on 16 May 2017 which outlined a broad proposal for resolution – further statement issued on 30 May 2017 which indicated there was a sufficient jurisdictional basis for the making of interim consent orders preventing the parties from directly communicating with each other, including verbal, written or electronic communication, and from being within 10 metres of each other – Mag Wheel and Tyre P/L also ordered to provide proposal for implementing anti-bullying training and policies and procedures to avoid workplace bullying or other inappropriate conduct in the workplace – Commission noted in separate proceedings applicant charged on summons in respect of two matters alleged to have taken place on 13 April 2017, firstly causing injury without lawful excuse and secondly, unlawful assault – interim intervention order issued by Heidelberg Magistrates’ Court against applicant on 18 April 2017 to not commit family violence – interim orders as discussed in Re Lynette Bayly and Quinn v Overland considered – Commission found orders appeared ineffectual in keeping parties apart and ordaining workplace civility – satisfied this matter featured rare and unusual circumstances and there would be a prejudice to multiple parties if interim orders not made – such orders appropriate although issued lightly and exercised with considerable caution – orders will operate until the application is heard. Mr Kypuros

ENTERPRISE AGREEMENTS – dispute about matter arising under agreement – ss.590, 603, 739 Fair Work Act 2009 – matter related to dispute under the BlueScope Steel Port Kembla Steelworks Agreement 2012 (the Agreement) involving BlueScope’s proposal to introduce the Trade Operator Model (TOW) into its Hot Mills Department – BlueScope proposed to restructure work and training of Tradepersons and Operators within business to realise cost savings in [[2015] FWC 6512] – Commission allowed introduction of TOM on understanding that a review would be conducted into its operation in April 2016 – proposed review had been overlooked and was brought to attention of the Commission by AMWU in separate matter – Commission subsequently issued notice of listing to conduct a conference in relation to review – BlueScope issued jurisdictional objection relating to the capacity of Commission to conduct review – BlueScope submitted that this was a process not open to the Commission and therefore, the proceedings had concluded with the implementation of the TOW – contended that if the review was within the Commission’s power it has since been extinguished by the making of newer 2015 agreement – AMWU contended that absent any appeal, the Decision at first instance stands – submitted that proceedings had not concluded and that TOM was introduced subject to Commission’s review – AMWU submitted that Commission was entitled to conduct the review to inform itself in accordance with s.590 – Commission held that process had not been concluded and it would be procedurally unfair to unions to ignore review – found that BlueScope did not take opportunity to appeal decision at first instance and evidence indicated that they were waiting for Commission to undertake review – Commission not persuaded that the making of 2015 agreement settled dispute, given that the duties, skills and competencies of each classification, which are core to the review, are not yet settled in that agreement – jurisdictional objection not made out – application dismissed – conference to be convened on 15 June 2017 to discuss process of the review. The Australian Workers’ Union and Ors v BlueScope Steel (AIS) Port Kembla

ENTERPRISE AGREEMENTS – dispute about matter arising under agreement – s.739 Fair Work Act 2009 – Construction, Forestry, Mining and Energy Union (CFMEU) notified Commission of a dispute with Hyne Timber in accordance with the relevant enterprise agreement (EA) – CFMEU asserted employer had not complied with consultation provisions in EA or relevant modern award in relation to imminent redundancies – employer asserted CFMEU did not have standing to make application and cannot make application on behalf of members who are no longer employees – employer submitted Commission does not have jurisdiction to deal with matter – Commission determined CFMEU, officers and members employed by Hyne are bound and covered by EA – Commission considered RTBU v Asciano Services P/L that it is contrary to obligations of Act to automatically dismiss applications where every employee party was not identified by name on s.739 application – Commission determined CFMEU and its officials were bound to EA – Commission determined CFMEU can lodge application in its own right – determined decision in Asciano allows CFMEU to notify Commission of dispute in accordance with Dispute Procedure in EA for any unnamed member including a member that has been terminated while issue was in dispute. Construction, Forestry, Mining and Energy Union v Hyne Timber P/L t/a Hyne Timber