NEWS HR

TERMINATION OF EMPLOYMENT – genuine redundancy – modern award coverage – ss.382, 389, 394 Fair Work Act 2009 – application for relief from unfair dismissal – jurisdictional objection that dismissal was a genuine redundancy – applicant employed in business now operated by respondent as a geoscientist since 1998 – respondent submitted that restructure resulted in applicant’s redundancy – submitted that it did not accept that applicant was covered by modern award but still engaged in meaningful and genuine consultation when definite decision to restructure was made – submitted that at meeting applicant was given opportunity to ask questions and provide feedback about redundancy – applicant submitted that redundancy not genuine – submitted that he was covered by Professional Employees Award 2010 (the Award) and respondent must comply with Award consultation clause – Commission determined that applicant satisfied Award definition of either Experienced or Professional Scientist and therefore covered by Award – found that respondent did not comply with Award consultation provisions by not providing information in writing and hence did not comply with s.389(1)(b) of FW Act – held that claim of genuine redundancy cannot succeed – held that respondent demonstrated it would not be reasonable to redeploy applicant – found that position occupied by applicant was redundant – found that although respondent did not provide applicant with written advice regarding redundancy it did not cause unfairness to the extent that the redundancy was harsh, unjust or unreasonable – application dismissed. Manescu v Baker Hughes Australia P/L

TERMINATION OF EMPLOYMENT – costs – ss.400A, 401, 611 Fair Work Act 2009 – application for unfair dismissal remedy dismissed as minimum employment period not met – respondent subsequently made application for costs against applicant and his legal representatives – Rohan Veal v Sundance Marine P/L cited – relevant principles concerning the interpretation and application of s.611(2)(a) FW Act stated in Church v Eastern Health and Baker v Salva Resources considered – Commission stated the basis on which it decided to dismiss unfair dismissal application is central to determination of costs application – Commission did not decide on jurisdictional points but dismissed unfair dismissal application in relation to the proper construction of a range of FW Act provisions as discussed in primary decision – satisfied that although unfair dismissal application was dismissed, applicant had reasonable prospects of success on basis of his arguments concerning proper construction of relevant legislative provisions – unfair dismissal application not made without reasonable cause – no unreasonable act or omission on part of applicant or his legal representatives which caused respondent to incur costs – respondent’s costs incurred in connection with participation in hearing in which arguable point of law was decided in respondent’s favour – application for costs dismissed. Harris v Laing O’Rourke Australia Construction P/L

TERMINATION OF EMPLOYMENT – misconduct – s.394 Fair Work Act 2009 – applicant commenced employment as a casual excavator operator in May 2015 – applicant dismissed via text message on 23 December 2016 – business of respondent is the demolition of residential and small commercial buildings and the removal of rubble – respondent claimed applicant caused damage to structure at a number of properties and damage to the respondent’s excavator – evidence of this damage was based solely on oral evidence of the witnesses – Commission found valid reason for dismissal – found complete absence of procedural fairness to the applicant leading to the dismissal and in the dismissal itself – also an absence of documented operating procedures, site reports or other documents providing guidance to the applicant of potential risks – Commission determined dismissal was harsh, unjust and unreasonable – reinstatement inappropriate – remedy of compensation appropriate – ordered payment of $4,750 (gross) as compensation. Kalioros v AC Demolition and Services P/L t/a AC Demolition

TERMINATION OF EMPLOYMENT – misconduct – ss.394, 400, 604 Fair Work Act 2009 – permission to appeal – Full Bench – at first instance the Commission found the appellant’s dismissal was not unfair, and dismissed her application for an unfair dismissal remedy – the appellant advanced four grounds for appeal, three of which were related to the findings made by the Commission and her conclusions, and the fourth relating to the decision to permit the respondent to be represented – Full Bench found each of the findings made was consistent with the evidence and was appropriate for the Commission to make – appellant pointed to no part of the evidence that could cause the Full Bench to conclude that the findings at first instance were in made in error – appellant has not identified any issue in the appeal that raises matters of importance or general application that would enliven the public interest for permission to appeal to be given – not in the public interest to grant permission to appeal – permission to appeal refused. Appeal by Ryan-Dengate against decision of Gooley DP of 13 April 2017 [[2017] FWC 2086] Re: Sunraysia Murray Group Training

TERMINATION OF EMPLOYMENT – extension of time – s.394 Fair Work Act 2009 – application for unfair dismissal remedy – applicant commenced employment 23 June 2006 – applicant employed as Cargo Manager for the Air/Sea Import & Export department – applicant submitted termination occurred 1 March 2016 – respondent submitted termination occurred 6 February 2016 by hand delivered letter – application lodged 21 March 2016 – respondent lodged objection to application on grounds that application was made outside the 21 days – respondent’s evidence of the termination letter was unsigned and not on company letter head – applicant provided video footage which he submitted showed respondent did not deliver termination letter – Commission found camera was located some distance away from applicant’s letterbox and was obstructed by a tree as such may not have been able to show respondent delivering letter – between 8 February to 1 March the applicant and respondent led separate evidence about text message and email correspondence – applicant submitted his correspondence was in the form of medical certificates and requests for personal leave – respondent submitted correspondence was seeking applicant contact him to discuss termination situation – Commission satisfied applicant’s behaviour of continuing to provide medical certificates and failing to request his personal belongings be returned to him indicated a lack of knowledge of a termination letter – Commission not convinced of respondents submissions that a lack of evidence from the applicant of any illness of inability to check his letterbox was a relevant consideration given applicant submitted he was not aware of any termination letter – Commission not satisfied that if termination letter was delivered that its contents was clear or unequivocal of termination – found intention of termination letter was that the applicant still attend work on following work day in order to receive a formal termination letter – found letter indicated a desire to terminate applicant’s employment but not when termination was to occur as such letter was not unequivocal and clear – not satisfied respondent’s follow up correspondence mentioned termination – Commission found applicant terminated on 1 March 2016 upon reading termination email – satisfied unfair dismissal application made within the 21 days – matter to be set down for hearing. Ilves v Lawson Worldwide Forwarding P/L

TERMINATION OF EMPLOYMENT – genuine redundancy – ss.389, 394 Fair Work Act 2009 – application for unfair dismissal remedy – respondent objected on basis that termination was genuine redundancy – respondent notified applicant position was surplus to requirements and applicant entitled to eight week redeployment period – applicant applied for two roles during redeployment process and was unsuccessful in both applications – applicant received notice of termination – applicant submitted respondent failed to meet consultation and redeployment obligations in enterprise agreement – respondent submitted that it fulfilled obligations under agreement – Ulan Coal Mines Limited considered – respondent argued its decision was consistent with Ulan as it was not appropriate to redeploy applicant and applicant not suitable for vacant positions – Commission found that respondent misunderstood the nature of assessment in s.389(2) of FW Act – applicant submitted respondent did not consider applicant for positions below applicant’s classification – respondent submitted it was entitled to redeploy applicant per ‘custom and practice’ to redeploy employees at same classification or one classification lower – Commission found respondent did not provide reasonable explanation for failure to consider applicant for 40 vacant positions – held respondent’s ‘custom and practice’ inconsistent with agreement that contemplates lower level redeployment – found respondent’s view that available positions not appropriate for applicant was not a basis for not putting these positions to applicant to consider – applicant not afforded an opportunity to consider salary maintenance in agreement as positions of lower classification were not put to him – vacant positions were not publicly advertised or accessible to applicant meaning applicant did not have opportunity to ask about positions he did not know existed – Commission found there were a number of positions, many at a lower classification, into which applicant could have been deployed – prepared to infer that applicant likely to be suited for at least one of 40 positions – dismissal of applicant not genuine redundancy – jurisdictional objection dismissed. Pallett v Federation University

TERMINATION OF EMPLOYMENT – performance – s.394 Fair Work Act 2009 – application for relief from unfair dismissal – applicant employed as Quality Assurance Manager – letter of termination said applicant ‘been spoken to a number of times in relation to matters corresponding with QA’ – applicant submitted there was no valid reason for termination – also submitted that there were no prior warnings, a lack of procedural fairness and an inability to bring a support person to termination meeting – applicant’s unchallenged evidence accepted by the Commission – respondent informed Commission it had entered voluntary administration – neither respondent nor administrator appeared for merits hearing – Corporations Act 2001 and Clifford v S & N Constructions P/L applied – ex-parte hearing of merits – Commission satisfied applicant not given opportunity to respond – found lack of human resources management specialists or expertise did not excuse dismissal without warning – found dismissal was absent of procedural fairness and natural justice – Commission satisfied termination was harsh, unjust and unreasonable – ordered compensation of 16 weeks’ pay plus superannuation. Crowe v R and R Poultry P/L t/a R&R Poultry

TERMINATION OF EMPLOYMENT – extension of time – ss.394, 400, 604 Fair Work Act 2009 – permission to appeal – Full Bench – at first instance the Commission refused the appellant an extension of the time to lodge an application for an unfair dismissal remedy and dismissed the application – appellant submitted nine grounds of appeal however the grounds only sought to challenge one aspect of the Commission’s consideration under s.394(3), namely the assessment of the merits of his application under paragraph (e) – Full Bench did not consider that anything raised by the appellant in his appeal notice gave rise to any arguable case that the Commission erred in its consideration under s.394(3) – found the appeal did not otherwise raise any issue which attracts the public interest – the matter was decided on its particular facts and raised no issue of principle or general importance – Full Bench do not consider that it would be in the public interest to grant permission to appeal – permission to appeal refused. Appeal by Golding against decision of Platt C of 12 April 2017 [[2017] FWC 2089] Re: Senwill Civil P/L t/a Senwill Civil