CONDITIONS OF EMPLOYMENT – wages – equal remuneration order – s.302 Fair Work Act 2009 – Full Bench – application by United Voice and the Australian Education Union (the Unions) for an equal remuneration order pursuant to s.302(3)(b) of the Fair Work Act 2009 (FW Act) in relation to the children’s services and early childhood education industry – separate application then made by the Independent Education Union of Australia (the IEU) – application heard concurrently and referred to as Equal Remuneration Case – the Unions sought equal remuneration order for ‘… employees who perform work in a long day care centre or preschool(s)’ covered by the Children’s Services Award 2010 (Children’s Services Award); the Educational Services (Teachers) Award 2010; or the Educational Services (Schools) General Staff Award 2010 – the IEU sought an equal remuneration order for ‘early childhood teachers (including early childhood teachers appointed as directors) who perform work in a long day care centre or preschool covered by the Educational Services (Teachers) Awards 2010′, other than those employed by a state or territory government – current Full Bench decision concerned the Unions’ application – previous decision issued by Full Bench [[2015] FWCFB 8200] (Preliminary Decision) addressed preliminary issues, including the jurisdictional prerequisites to be met prior to the making of an equal remuneration order – in relation to the question of whether a male comparator group was required in order to establish a case for an equal remuneration order under s.302, Preliminary Decision found that Commission must be satisfied that an employee or group of employees of a particular gender to whom an equal remuneration order would apply do not enjoy remuneration equal to that of another employee or group of employees of the opposite gender who perform work of equal or comparable value – comparative exercise in which the remuneration and the value of the work of a female employee or group of female employees is required to be compared to that of a male employee or group of male employees – Preliminary Decision held that the finding that Part 2-7 requires a comparator group of the opposite gender did not exclude the capacity to advance a gender-based undervaluation case under s.156(3) or s.157(2) of FW Act – Union’s third amended application filed in September 2016 included that proper comparator for the Diploma level and Certificate III classifications under the Children Services Award are the C5 and C10 classifications respectively in the Manufacturing and Associated Industries and Occupations Award 2010 (Manufacturing Award), with consequential adjustment for other classifications – addition of a comparator intended to permit the application to continue to be maintained under s.302 of the FW Act – in accompanying correspondence the Unions sought a hearing to determine a preliminary question as to whether the comparator proposed in the amended application satisfied requirement of a comparator in the Preliminary Decision – proposed preliminary question be whether the C5 and C10 classifications under the Manufacturing Award are a suitable comparator in this application for the purposes of s.302 of the FW Act – current Full Bench decision concerned whether the Commission should conduct preliminary hearing proposed by the Unions – the Unions submitted proposed comparators were established as appropriate in a previous AIRC Full Bench decision AIRC [PR954938] (2014 AIRC Decision) – in current proceedings Full Bench found comparative exercise to be carried out between the group of employees to be covered by the proposed order and an identified comparator group has three elements – firstly, the two groups must perform work of equal or comparable value – secondly, must be of the opposite gender – thirdly, must be unequally remunerated – once this jurisdictional prerequisite demonstrated, the Commission has discretion as to whether to make an equal remuneration order – Full Bench found posed preliminary question would not dispose of the entirety of the jurisdictional prerequisite for the making of an equal remuneration order, but only the first of the three elements identified – noted the Unions had made it clear that their case is that the 2004 AIRC Decision, and the alignment of rates in the comparator classifications since that decision, are sufficient to demonstrate equality or comparability in work value between those who would be covered by the equal remuneration order it seeks and its proposed comparator group – found it would be open for any employer respondent to the proceedings to adduce evidence to demonstrate that in fact no equality or comparability in work value and that either the 2004 AIRC Decision was wrong and should not be followed, or that changes to work since that time have meant that the 2014 AIRC Decision can no longer be relied upon – noted such evidence could well be extensive and necessity to hear such evidence would be sufficient to remove any procedural value in conducting such preliminary hearing – Full Bench considered that a preliminary hearing could only be justifiable in procedural terms if it were confined to question of whether the 2004 AIRC Decision, and subsequent alignment in rates, capable alone of conclusively demonstrating equality or comparability of work value (and, as a corollary, that no evidence that might conceivably be adduced by any party could demonstrate otherwise) – Full Bench proposed preliminary question be whether the Commission can be satisfied conclusively that the work performed by employees under C5 and C10 classifications in the Manufacturing Award is of equal or comparable value to the work of employees under the Diploma Level and Certificate III classifications in the Children’s Services Award respectively solely on the basis of the 2014 AIRC Decision and the subsequent alignment in award rates for the respective classifications – Full Bench rejected proposition of separate hearing to determine the Union’s proposed preliminary question – prepared to conduct such a hearing on the basis of Full Bench’s proposed question (subject to any parties’ agreed changes) – necessary for Unions to accept that the necessary consequence of a negative answer to the proposed question would be the dismissal of their application – if response affirmative, directions hearing to be listed regarding preliminary hearing – if answer negative, Full Bench to await further advice from the Unions as to how they wish to proceed with application – Full Bench to await advice from the IEU as to how it wishes to proceed with its application. Application by United Voice, Australian Education Union and Independent Education Union of Australia for an Equal Remuneration Order
July 14, 2017
TERMINATION OF EMPLOYMENT – application to dismiss by employer – deed of settlement – s.394 Fair Work Act 2009 – applicant employed from 6 August 2007 and summarily dismissed on 15 July 2016 – respondent purports binding settlement agreement made during member assisted conference on 6 February 2017 – settlement of $18,000 gross to be paid to applicant, termination would be treated as resignation, applicant would be provided with a statement of service and application would be discontinued – applicant disputes agreement was reached – applicant representative considered agreement had been reached and ceased acting for applicant from 8 February 2017 – issue with whether applicant instructed representatives for purported settlement amount and whether representatives made offers to respondent per applicant’s instructions – ss.399A, 587 FW Act considered – Commission cannot be satisfied that a settlement agreement has been concluded – cannot be satisfied steps have been taken to give effect to promissory terms of the agreement – legislative test under s.339A(1)(c) not met – Commission satisfied applicant’s representative received instructions to make an offer of $18,000 – satisfied applicant did not inform her representatives that she was without capacity to provide instructions – not satisfied settlement agreement was concluded and declined to dismiss application pursuant to s.399A(1)(c) – satisfied no deviation from principles in Thomas v Symbion Health – satisfied application to dismiss has no reasonable prospects of success because parties have entered into a settlement agreement – in accordance with agreement, payment of $18,000 gross less relevant taxation to applicant within 7 days – application to dismiss application for unfair dismissal dismissed. Gill v Rio Tinto Aluminium Limited t/a Rio Tinto Weipa
July 14, 2017
TERMINATION OF EMPLOYMENT – remedy – compensation – ss.390, 392, 394 Fair Work Act 2009 – decision issued 31 May 2016 found termination of applicant to be harsh, unjust and unreasonable [[2016] FWC 3542] – directions issued to each party for submissions on appropriate remedy – on 17 October 2016 Commission checked ASIC liquidation notices database and found Ashford Homes was being wound up voluntarily – ss.440D, 471B, 500 Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) considered – applicant sought compensation up to statutory cap – respondent submitted compensation manifestly unfair due to applicant’s misuse and over spending of company supplied fuel card – applicant employed with respondent for four years and two months – Commission determined total period applicant would have received remuneration had he not been dismissed to be 12 weeks – determined applicant would have received $31,035.25 – Commission satisfied applicant attempted to mitigate loss from date of dismissal – determined compensation would need to put applicant back in financial position he would have been in had he not been dismissed – amount to include applicable superannuation with appropriate tax deduction – compensation of $31,035.25 including applicable superannuation with appropriate tax deduction to be paid within 30 days of decision. Bechara v Ashford Homes P/L t/a Ashford Homes
July 14, 2017
TERMINATION OF EMPLOYMENT – misconduct – s.394 Fair Work Act 2009 – application for unfair dismissal remedy – applicant employed by respondent, Farstard Shipping for 16 years – applicant responsible for overall management and safe navigation of the vessel – in September 2016 applicant was rostered off but was asked if willing to assist on another vessel to mentor new Master – applicant subject to random alcohol test before attending vessel – applicant failed test – applicant was provided with a show cause letter and following an investigation, was terminated on 15 November 2016 for serious misconduct – applicant submitted that there were factors throughout the course of his employment which led to his drinking that evening – applicant submitted that throughout the course of his employment, he had made significant contributions to improvements in safety performance and demonstrated a willingness to take on additional duties – submitted there were mitigating circumstances which led to his drinking – Commission noted that respondent’s policies did allow for lesser penalties such as education and rehabilitation – Commission satisfied that applicant was provided with a reason for dismissal and given an opportunity to respond prior to the decision being made to dismiss him – Commission noted that applicant has an exemplary record with respondent; however, found that an incident in 2014 was never fully resolved neither in applicant’s mind, nor by respondent – Commission satisfied that although applicant did engage in alleged conduct the decision to dismiss him was harsh – Commission satisfied applicant was unfairly dismissed – respondent opposed reinstatement as it had lost trust and confidence in applicant – Commission satisfied that respondent has grounds to this claim – reinstatement not appropriate – Commission directed parties to file submissions regarding compensation. Rust v Farstad Shipping (Indian Pacific) P/L t/a Farstad
July 14, 2017
ENTERPRISE BARGAINING – protected action ballot – ss.437, 443 Fair Work Act 2009 – application for a protected action ballot order (PABO) – proposed protected action ballot of employees of AB Oxford Cold Storage Company P/L (Oxford) – National Union of Workers (NUW) bound by 2014 Agreement – NUW applied for PABO and Oxford advanced three objections including that NUW has not been and is not genuinely trying to reach agreement and that NUW has extraneous intention in seeking PABO – log of claims and issues discussed at bargaining meetings in dispute – Commission noted that although NUW may not have been actively trying to reach an agreement of late, this does not mean its efforts have not been or are not genuine – found no evidence NUW filed application for extraneous intentions – issue of nonpermitted matters and Esso Australia P/L v AMWU considered – Commission satisfied NUW has been and is genuinely trying to reach agreement with Oxford – restrictions on making an application under ss.437 and 438 not applicable – other statutory criteria have been met – PABO made. National Union of Workers v AB Oxford Cold Storage P/L
July 14, 2017
TERMINATION OF EMPLOYMENT – termination at initiative of employer – resignation – ss.386, 394 Fair Work Act 2009 – application for unfair dismissal remedy – 7 December 2012 applicant commenced employment with respondent – applicant submitted he had been unfairly dismissed either because his employment was terminated at the respondent’s initiative or, alternatively, because he was forced to resign following a course of conducted engaged in by the respondent – respondent denied dismissal, submitting that the applicant had voluntarily resigned on 4 November 2016 with an effective termination date of 30 November 2016 – on 24 June 2016 applicant requested a pay rise – respondent rejected the applicant’s request on the grounds that it could not afford the increase sought – in September 2016 the applicant began working after-hours for Xsight, a competitor of the respondent – during a meeting with the respondent on 4 November 2016, the applicant was notified that his engagement by Xsight was considered a breach of contract – applicant submitted that the respondent had previously consented to him working for other businesses to supplement his income, including for Xsight – applicant told that he had a week to decide between ceasing all work for Xsight or resigning his employment with respondent – applicant verbally resigned his employment during the 4 November 2016 meeting – respondent accepted applicant’s resignation and it was agreed that the employment would cease on 30 November 2016 – applicant submitted that from the 6 November 2016 he had tried to inform respondent that he did not intend to resign – respondent submitted that the applicant only sought to withdraw his resignation on 30 November 2016 – applicant informed the respondent that he regarded the editing team’s office relocation as an unfair termination and therefore did attend work – on 13 January 2017 the respondent submitted that the applicant’s failure to attend work was evidence that he abandoned his employment – Commission held that applicant was not dismissed from his employment – Commission neither satisfied that applicant’s employment was terminated on the initiative of respondent nor that applicant was forced to resign because of respondent’s conduct – respondent was under no obligation to grant applicant a pay increase nor was it unreasonable of it to insist that he not carry out work for competitors – Ngo considered – Commission satisfied no special circumstances existed such that respondent’s immediate acceptance of applicant’s resignation was unreasonable – respondent entitled to treat applicant’s resignation as effective – application dismissed. Javed v Proeye Video Productions t/a Proeye Video Productions
July 14, 2017
ENTERPRISE AGREEMENTS – termination of agreement – ss.225, 226, 319 Fair Work Act 2009 – Sch. 3, Item 16 Fair Work (Transitional Provisions and Consequential Amendments) Act 2009 – two employee applications to terminate Wilson Security-Western Australia Collective Agreement (Agreement) – matters adjourned for parties to negotiate new agreement – no progress made – subsequent employer application for Agreement to cover nontransferring employees not currently covered by the Agreement who perform same work as transferring employees – Commission dealt with termination applications before transferring employees application – public interest considerations distinct from interests of those covered by Agreement – Agreement made over seven years ago – industry minimum terms and conditions since changed – many Agreement terms and conditions now below the Security Industry Services Award 2010 (Award), including rates of pay and allowances – employer proposed significant undertakings to address shortcomings of Agreement compared to Award – their employee petition regarding terminating Agreement tainted and communication with employees mischievous – given scope and number of undertakings, acceptance of undertakings undermined s.3(f) of FW Act allowing one party to dictate agreement terms rather than negotiating with other parties – commercial advantage obtained from Agreement disincentive to negotiating new enterprise agreement – termination of Agreement likely to stimulate negotiations for a new agreement more suitable to employers business needs while ensuring objects of the FW Act regarding minimum terms and conditions of employment are satisfied – in public interest to terminate Agreement – Commission not satisfied views of employer and employees opposed to terminating Agreement were accurately informed and/or validly held – termination effective from 7 July 2017 – employer application for Agreement to cover non-transferring employees dismissed. Wilson Security-Western Australia Collective Agreement 2009
July 14, 2017
MODERN AWARDS – 4 yearly review – s.156 Fair Work Act 2009 – Full Bench – This decision should be read in conjunction with the decision of Vice President Watson issued on 27 February 2017 [[2017] FWCFB 1133] – the Australian Council of Trade Unions (ACTU) made a claim to include in all modern awards an entitlement for employees to take family and domestic violence leave – effect of the ACTU’s claim would be to provide all employees with a right to ten days paid family and domestic violence leave per year which does not accumulate and, if the leave is exhausted, up to two days of unpaid family and domestic violence leave on each occasion – whether it was necessary, for the purpose of ensuring that modern awards, together with the NES, provide a fair and relevant minimum safety net to include an entitlement for employees to take family and domestic violence leave – Full Bench have formed the preliminary view that it was necessary to make provision for family and domestic violence leave however have decided to dismiss the ACTU’s application because the Full Bench was not satisfied, at this time, that it was necessary to provide ten days paid family and domestic violence leave to all employees covered by modern awards – in rejecting the ACTU’s proposal the Full Bench have not rejected the view that family and domestic violence is a significant community issue, and that there needs to be a workplace response to family and domestic violence – Full Bench has formed the preliminary view that all employees should have access to unpaid family and domestic violence leave – in addition the Full Bench have formed the preliminary view that employees should be able to access personal/carer’s leave for the purpose of taking family and domestic violence leave – as the parties have not had an opportunity to make submissions or call evidence on these matters the Full Bench intend to provide the parties with such an opportunity. 4 yearly review of modern awards – Family & Domestic Violence Leave Clause