RIGHT OF ENTRY – application for permit – ss.513, 604 Fair Work Act 2009 – permission to appeal – Full Bench – appeal against decision which found an official not a fit and proper person to hold an entry permit – at first instance Commission not satisfied applicant would perform role as permit holder in a way that respects obligations of role – nor satisfied any conditions could be imposed in accordance with s.515(1) of FW Act would alter that assessment – appellant asserted the Commission, in relying on findings of earlier Lendlease matter, conflated jurisdictional fact as actual fact, leading to inappropriate conclusion the official had been involved in organising unprotected industrial action – clearly apparent to Full Bench the Commission did not rely solely on findings in Lendlease and provided reasons beyond Lendlease, including reference to the conduct of Mr Robinson in Bechtel and Robinson – Full Bench not satisfied the Commission erred and not satisfied that there was an arguable case of error in this instance – Full Bench not satisfied of any issues which attract the public interest – permission to appeal refused. Appeal by Construction, Forestry, Mining and Energy Union-Construction and General Division, Queensland Northern Territory Divisional
July 14, 2017
ENTERPRISE AGREEMENTS – genuinely agree – ss.185, 186, 604 Fair Work Act 2009 – appeal – Full Bench – Commission at first instance dismissed application for approval of BGC Contracting P/L’s Mining Enterprise Agreement 2016 (the proposed agreement) – Commission held the proposed agreement was not genuinely agreed to by the employees who would be covered – not satisfied appellant took all reasonable steps to comply with its relevant access period obligations or that the effect of the proposed agreement was explained to employees – appellant submitted permission to appeal should be granted; appeal should be upheld and the first instance decision quashed – a number of grounds of appeal related to procedural fairness and that the various sections of the legislation were not correctly applied nor construed when dismissing the proposed agreement application – appellant asserted amongst other issues that it was not afforded the opportunity to provide undertakings to rectify the BOOT findings despite the parties express contemplation to do so – respondent posited the Commission’s first instance conclusion that the proposed agreement had not been genuinely agreed to was ineluctable – Full Bench held that appellant was denied procedural fairness because the appellant was not provided an opportunity to file further submissions in relation to undertakings after the first instance decision – not satisfied the employees had no stake in the proposed agreement – permission to appeal granted – in order to overcome the denial of procedural fairness appeal upheld – decision at first instance quashed – referred to Gostencnik DP for rehearing. Appeal by BGC Contracting P/L against decision of Deputy President Binet of 28 February 2017 [2017] FWC 852 Re: Automotive, Food, Metals, Engineering, Printing and Kindred Industries Union and Ors
July 14, 2017
CASE PROCEDURES – representation – ss.400, 596, 604 Fair Work Act 2009 – permission to appeal – Full Bench – applicant in unfair dismissal matter sought permission to appeal against Commission decision – submitted the Commission erred in finding the respondent was not a separate entity to the Commonwealth – erred in granting respondent permission to be represented by the Australian Government Solicitor (AGS) as relevant legislative and regulative exception was not applicable – erred in amending the respondent’s identification in the application – respondent agreed with the appellant that permission to appeal should be granted because the appeal raised an issue of broad application when AGS represents a federal department in any Commission proceeding – respondent maintained the proper respondent was the Commonwealth of Australia; its representatives were employees of the Commonwealth; maintained the exception to be represented plainly applied; and the relevant regulations enabled any APS employee to be authorised by the Agency Head to act as a public sector employee’s employer – Full Bench satisfied it would be in public interest to grant permission to appeal as the broader issue arose in the unfair dismissal appeals proceedings – Full Bench found the Commission was correct in identification of the proper respondent as the Department of Immigration and Border Protection was not itself an entity with legal personality – permission to be represented by AGS not required – permission to appeal granted – appeal dismissed. Appeal by Gibbens against decision of Commissioner Williams of 10 April 2017 [[2017] FWC 1938] Re: Department of Immigration and Border Protection
July 13, 2017
Twenty-five unfair dismissal/labour dispute applications are listed for hearing in the Fair Work Commission today. The full list is: Newcastle City Council (Cousins), Wireless & Optical Fibre Solutions Pty Ltd (Kingdom), ATM Logistics Pty Ltd (Molony), Run For It Pty Ltd (Constantinidis), Veolia Water Utilities Australia Pty Ltd (Grech), CPA Group (Baker, Fay, Lawton, Stannus), Special Broadcasting Service (SBS) (Bharadwaj), Metro Trains Melbourne Pty Ltd (Furneaux), Southern Migrant and Refugee Centre (Lee), City of Darebin (Byrne), Western Sydney Community Legal Centre Incorporated (Girdler), Silk Contract Logistics Pty Ltd (Attard), City of Sydney RSL & Community Club Ltd (Balgowan), DK Thompson Pty Ltd (Kluvetasch), UGL Operations and Maintenance Pty Ltd (Saxon), Woolworths (Marshall), Uraidla Physio (Mitchell), Mister Sunshine’s Pty Ltd (Vistoli), Daclo Vietnamese Ethnic School (Ngoc Lee, Nguyen), The Glen Hotel Pty Ltd (Kubie), The J & C Dart Family Trust (Jones).
July 12, 2017
Thirty applicants will seek to persuade Fair Work Commissioners of the efficacy of their unfair dismissal/employment breach cases today. The full list is: BHP Billiton Pty Ltd (Streeter), Safe Places Community Services Limited (Torrance), Wilmar Sugar Pty Ltd (Galbraith), Peabody Energy Australia PCI Pty Ltd (Hill), Target Australia Pty Ltd (Ablitt), Northbuild Construction Pty Ltd (Le Noelle), Navitas English Pty Ltd (Khayam), Broadspectrum (Australia) Pty Ltd (Johnson), Swinburne University of Technology (Calleri), Peabody Energy Australia PCI Pty Ltd (Hill), Monash University (Bluzer), FMG Personnel Services Pty Ltd (Etienne), Gippsland Water (Pendergast), Harbison Memorial Retirement Village (Phakathi), Genea Limited (Lauri), JDP Formwork Pty Ltd (Kvackovski), New Horizons Enterprises Limited (Edwards), Awabakal Local Aboriginal Land Council (Towers), Trilogie Resourcing Pty Ltd (Colefax, Johns), Macleay Daily Hire Pty Ltd (Sonneman), Newcastle Golf Club Limited (Goodbun), Pressed Juices Retail Pty Ltd (Lusi), PFD Food Services Pty Ltd (Buttar), Broadspectrum (Australia) Pty Ltd (Johnson), South Australian Water Corporation (Mammone).
July 11, 2017
Thirty unfair dismissal/labour breach applications will be heard by the Fair Work Commission today. The full list is: Daracon Group (Ryan), Migas Apprentices & Trainees (Harrison-Comrie), Early Links Inclusion Support Service Incorporated (Lee-Warner), Newcastle Golf Club Limited (Goodbun), Gilo Fashion Pty Ltd (Harvey), O’Brien Glass Industries Pty Ltd (Cass), Architectural Project Specialist (Nicolaou), Uniting Care Wesley Bowden (Fowler), National Australia Bank Limited (Selvanayagam), City of Canning (Birkbeck), The Glenelg Club (Popplewell), Karratha Katinas Pty Ltd (Huang), Department of Natural Resources and Mines (DNRM) (Wanninayake), Anglo Coal (Moranbah North Management) Pty Ltd (Wilson), AVJennings Holdings Limited (Dokoza), Treg Smith’s Autos Pty Ltd (Maiden), Northern Stevedoring Services (NSS) (Neliman), Healthcare Australia Pty Ltd (Sommer), Target Australia Pty Ltd (Sturgess), Woolworths Limited (Johns), Qantas Airways Limited (McRae), Mind Australia (Aius, Mills), Commonwealth of Australia (Australian Criminal Intelligence Commission) (Knight), Baxter Healthcare Pty Ltd (Portelli), Presbyterian Church of Victoria Social Services Committee (Boyce), Grill’d Health Burgers (Shellum), Ramsey Health (Bhusumane).
July 10, 2017
The Fair Work Commission has eighteen unfair dismissal/contract dispute applications to be heard today. The full list is: The Millennium Services Group Ltd (Hannemann), Transit Resources Pty Ltd (Hawkes), Commonwealth Bank of Australia Limited (Hall), Linfox Armaguard Pty Ltd (Hunter), G James Extrusion Co Pty Ltd (Pegler), Mater Limited (Jones), Montserrat Day Hospitals (McCandless), Karan Grewal Pty Ltd (Gill), Sydney Trains (Buckley, Shields), COOH Pty Ltd (Moyle), Heavy Duty Plumbing (McDonald), Lemon & Sin Trading Pty Ltd (Khong), Kletsas Holdings Pty Limited (Frith), TNT Australia Pty Ltd (Marshall), The Online Media Agency Pty Limited (Pham), The Australian Capital Territory as represented by the Chief Minister, Treasury and Economic Development Directorate (Martsoukas), Flight Centre Travel Group Limited (Barrett).
July 7, 2017
The Fair Work Commission has a moderate list of 27 applicants claiming unfair dismissal or labour contract breach today. The list is: Mungo Lodge Investments Pty Ltd (Roberts), Captains of Rye (Glenn), Metro Trains Melbourne Pty Ltd (Furneaux), B&D Doors & Openers (Hodgins), Gate Gourmet Services (NSW) Pty Ltd & Fisch and Others (Woodhouse), Ikea Pty Ltd (Hacinas), Neville’s Bus Service Pty Ltd (Furtner), Serco Australia Pty Ltd (Ramos), DK Thompson Pty Ltd (Kluvetasch), Blairlogie Living and Learning (Mummery), Apple Pty Ltd (Yardley), Red Dog Construction & Developments & Elliott Property Group (Hart), Watters Electrical Pty Ltd (Lee), Virgin Australia Airlines Pty Ltd (Dawson), McDonald’s Rockbank Outbound (Fissha), Westpac Banking Corporation (Sureka), Curtin University of Technology (Lichtenzveig), Joondalup Smash Repairs Pty Ltd (Sherrett), Expert Data Cabling Pty Ltd (Heaver), Dirtybits Pty Ltd (Manhire), Coles Supermarkets (Lukic), Causeway Holdings Pty Ltd (Wingate), Cabin Services Australia (Wederay), JB Dental (Queensland) Pty Ltd as Trustee for the John Burgess Family Trust, Marc Miller Pty Ltd as Trustee for the Miller Discretionary Trust (Cheah), The Barton Family Trust (Hope), Causeway Holdings Pty Ltd (Wingate).