CASE PROCEDURES – stay order – civil penalty privilege – ss.394, 589 Fair Work Act 2009 – application for stay in part of application for unfair dismissal remedy – respondent sought to have application stayed in part pending hearing and determination of general protections matter filed by applicant in Federal Court – respondent submitted there were similar facts and circumstances in both matters, which posed risk of inconsistent findings of fact and law in respect of same issues – further submitted that people & culture manager would be able to lawfully refuse to give evidence on basis of civil penalty privilege – Commission considered privilege against self-incrimination and noted that its applicability to Commission proceedings in relation to civil penalty provisions remained unclear without binding authority – prepared to adopt position that privilege against exposure to civil penalties should apply to Commission’s formal proceedings – in considering whether stay application should be granted, referred to principles in McMahon v Gould – Commission not satisfied respondent demonstrated real risk of injustice sufficient to deny applicant right to hearing in ordinary course – applicant’s right to prompt hearing of claim should not lightly be interfered with – applicant entitled to have application heard and determined as soon as practicable – staying unfair dismissal application in part may increase possibility of achieving perfect justice in evidentiary sense for respondent in Federal Court matter, but would involve potential of further delay in final disposition of application before Commission – Commission held there was no right for a stay in part or in whole of unfair dismissal proceedings – stay application dismissed – matter to be listed for directions and hearing. French v The Good Guys Discount Warehouse (Australia) P/L t/a Good Guys O’Connor
July 21, 2017
ENTERPRISE AGREEMENTS – dispute about matter arising under agreement – ss.604, 739 Fair Work Act 2009 – appeal – Full Bench – appeal against decision relating to dispute over meaning of ‘the structured training course’ in enterprise agreement – at first instance Commission found wording had a plain meaning which required appellant to provide an employee a two week cross-stage training course – Full Bench found arguable case of error – permission to appeal granted – grounds of appeal related to ruling that certain evidence was inadmissible, refusal to admit certain evidence amounting to a denial of natural justice, Commission’s construction of clause and application of its conclusion about the construction – Full Bench found Commission admitted and considered evidence of context and surrounding circumstances and other evidence – in light of this no denial of procedural fairness – Full Bench found Commission erred in construction of clause that two phrases ‘the structured training course’ and ‘a structured training course’ referenced the same course – appellant submitted they are different in that the first refers to a course occurring before the existence of the agreement and the second refers to a future course – in relation to application of principle, Berri is relevant to interpretation of agreement – principles of interpretation pertaining to intention, objectives, and purpose must take into account position of employees and their understanding of proposed agreement leading up to, and immediately prior to, vote to approve agreement – Full Bench concluded clause ambiguous and open to more than one meaning – appeal upheld – first instance decision quashed – application remitted to Commission for rehearing and determination. Appeal by EnergyAustralia Yallourn P/L t/a EnergyAustralia against decision of Clancy DP of 27 April 2017 [[2017] FWC 2298] Re: Construction, Forestry, Mining and Energy Union
July 21, 2017
TERMINATION OF EMPLOYMENT – Small Business Fair Dismissal Code – misconduct – s.394 Fair Work Act 2009 – application for unfair dismissal remedy – respondent a small business – objected to application on basis that dismissal was consistent with Small Business Fair Dismissal Code (Code) – respondent submitted applicant was dismissed because she acted dishonestly – respondent admitted at time of termination only had suspicions and not conclusive proof of dishonesty – considered whether employer held belief at time of dismissal, based on reasonable grounds, that conduct was sufficiently serious to justify immediate dismissal [Steri-Flow Filtration Systems] – Commission not satisfied emails tendered were evidence of misconduct let alone serious misconduct – not satisfied respondent had reasonable grounds for believing applicant’s personal disapproval impacted performance seriously enough to justify immediate dismissal – no reasonable explanation why applicant not given opportunity to respond to allegations and test their veracity – not satisfied respondent conducted investigation into grounds relied on to dismiss applicant – clear that respondent was aggrieved by conduct of others – majority of respondent’s evidence dealt with this conduct rather than applicant’s – respondent under significant financial, emotional and legal strain before dismissal which may have coloured decision making – Commission the dismissal not consistent with Code – parties strongly recommended to explore possibility of settlement – in absence of parties’ willingness to attend further conciliation, matter will be listed for merits hearing. Wiburd v Grandbridge Ltd
July 21, 2017
TERMINATION OF EMPLOYMENT – misconduct – s.394 Fair Work Act 2009 – application for unfair dismissal – applicant terminated for misconduct in relation to two incidents involving a co-worker – applicant submitted that there were procedural defects in respondent’s investigation of the incidents – further submitted that having regard to his length of service, personal and economic situation, and seriousness of allegations, the dismissal was harsh, unjust and unreasonable – respondent submitted that applicant’s behaviour was an inappropriate interaction in the workplace, threatening and upsetting to his co-worker, a breach of relevant enterprise agreement, a breach of Code of Conduct and Working Together Policy and inconsistent with workplace health and safety obligations – Commission found that applicant’s conduct in period leading up to and including his being stood down would meet definition of bullying as set out in s.789FD of FW Act – applicant submitted that his actions did not represent a risk to health and safety, but even if it did so it was minimal – found the impact that applicant’s conduct had on co-worker was sufficient to be satisfied it represented a risk to co-worker – found combination of conduct, continued denial of allegations during investigation and respondent’s findings that allegations were made out – conduct was a repetition of similar earlier conduct despite existence of earlier warning and training – found respondent had valid reason to dismiss applicant – satisfied respondent did give due weight to range of issues including applicant’s length of service – found there was valid reason for termination and that process followed was not procedurally flawed – not satisfied considerations under s.387(h) outweigh other considerations – found dismissal was not harsh, unjust or unreasonable – application dismissed. Braughton v Coca-Cola Amatil Limited t/a Coca-Cola Amatil
July 21, 2017
ANTI-BULLYING – bullied at work – repeated behaviour – reasonable management action – s.789FC Fair Work Act 2009 – application for an order to stop bullying – team leader and employer objected to application on basis that there was no repeated unreasonable behaviour, no risk to health and safety, and that in any event, the circumstances represented reasonable management action carried out in reasonable manner – Commission found circumstances involved two strong personalities who both have a genuine commitment to their work – no reason to doubt that applicant believed he had been bullied by being singled out and treated differently from other employees – this of itself not sufficient to establish he had been ‘bullied at work’ in context of legislative framework – Mac v Bank of Queensland Limited and ors considered – Commission satisfied team leader’s actions did not form any part of pattern of repeated unreasonable behaviour – unable to conclude team leader’s behaviour was unreasonable in the circumstances – team leader’s approach in dealing with team members was likely different from predecessors’ – this may have created concern among some employees but was not enough to constitute workplace bullying – Commission held there was no repeated unreasonable behaviour towards applicant in a way that can be said that he had been bullied at work – application dismissed. Krnjic
July 21, 2017
TERMINATION OF EMPLOYMENT – misconduct – s.394 Fair Work Act 2009 – application for unfair dismissal remedy – applicant employed since 1996 as a truck driver – dismissed after driving a B-Triple vehicle on a route that was not approved for such vehicles – vehicle regularly exceeded speed limit for B-Triple vehicles – Commission found that driving B-Triple vehicle on nonapproved route at an excessive speed a significant breach of the Heavy Vehicle National Law and obligations of applicant’s contract of employment – conduct risked safety of applicant and other road users – Commission found applicant’s conduct a valid reason to terminate his employment – not persuaded termination was harsh, unjust or unreasonable – application dismissed. McIntyre v Qube Logistics (SA) P/L
July 21, 2017
TERMINATION OF EMPLOYMENT – misconduct – ss.387, 394 Fair Work Act 2009 – applicant employed across varying roles at sugar cane mills – applicant owned personal sugar cane harvesting business – respondent issued notice that annual leave would not be granted during crushing season – applicant granted paid carer’s leave for wife’s pregnancy complications – applicant then granted three weeks annual leave – applicant claimed hours on paid carer’s leave spent caring for wife and out of hours harvesting personal cane – respondent believed applicant should not have cut cane during paid carer’s leave – employment suspended – at meeting respondent informed applicant employment would not be terminated if he complied with certain conditions such as submitting timesheets of working hours in own business – applicant did not agree – said this was an attempt to force him to resign as it was unworkable and invaded privacy – employment terminated on basis of serious misconduct – applicant alleged three separate incidents of discrimination against him from respondent – Commission found harvesting out of hours while on carer’s leave not valid reason for dismissal – nature of carer’s leave different from sick leave – where activities outside applicant’s ordinary hours of work and adequate care arranged then not employer’s concern – Commission found applicant’s unreasonable refusal to provide information that respondent reasonably and lawfully requested in the employment conditions valid reason for dismissal – dismissal not harsh, unjust, unreasonable or discriminatory – Commission noted respondent should consider appropriate payment during stand down period – application dismissed. Munro v Wilmar Australia P/L
July 18, 2017
Whilst forty-four unfair dismissal/labour dispute applications are due to be heard today by Fair Work Commissioners, twenty emanate from a single employee. The full list is: Tangentyere Council Aboriginal Corporation (Newchurch), Warrnambool Cheese and Butter Factory Company Holdings Limited (Brody), SMS Operations Pty Ltd (Edgar), Catholic Education Diocese of Bathurst (Churchland), Leeton Preschool Association Inc. (Norman), BGL Operations Pty Ltd (Tran), Wilson Services Company Pty Ltd (Marshall), Whitehaven Coal Mining Limited (Warren), Architectural Project Specialist (Nicolaou), Life Without Barriers (Ezea), ACT Government – Transport Canberra and City Services (Thomas), Stegbar Pty Ltd (Staniland), A and A Excavations (Cooper), Awabakal Local Aboriginal Land Council (Towers), Ron Finemore Transport Services Pty Ltd (Beale, Campbell, Catto, Curypko, D’Aloisio, Dimech, Galati, Gordon, Hennessey, Henshaw, Hine, Hooper, Lewer Marshall, Munro, Pavlovic, Powles, Smilevski, Smith), Solene Investments (Aus) Pty Ltd (Diaz), Beecham Motors Pty Ltd (Leivers), Austral Masonry (Kenny-Bakic), Cairns Community Legal Centre Inc (De Bonis), Outback Adventures Camping Stores (Whitehead), Sanpoint Pty Ltd (Arevalo), Australian Submarine Corporation Pty Ltd (Dean), Millennium Services Group Ltd (Hannemann), Community Caring Pty Ltd (Dignon, Morris).