NEWS HR

RIGHT OF ENTRY – suspension of permit – s.510 Fair Work Act 2009 – whether to suspend or revoke Mr Muhammed Kalem’s entry permit – Mr Kalem an official and organiser employed by the Construction, Forestry, Mining and Energy Union (CFMEU) – a holder of right of entry permit issued on 14 April 2016 with expiry date 14 April 2019 – in Director of the Fair Work Building Industry Inspectorate v CFMEU (Penalty Decision), Federal Court declared Mr Kalem contravened s.500 of FW Act and ordered he pay pecuniary penalty of $1,500 – on 2 May 2016, the Commission initiated consideration of whether Mr Kalem’s permit should be revoked or suspended – Parker and Ors considered – Commission accepted that Mr Kalem was now contrite and unlikely to engage in contravening conduct again – accepted that some time had passed since contravening conduct and that Mr Kalem has since not engaged in any relevant contravening conduct – accepted that contravention occurred only a few months after Mr Kalem commenced employment with CMFEU and so his inexperience or naivety was likely to have contributed to his conduct – however, Commission considered some of Mr Kalem’s answers given during cross-examination not a positive understanding of his wrongdoing or on his rights and obligations as permit holder – further, Commission considered nature and gravity of contravening conduct and impact of the contraventions, weighing strongly against Mr Kalem – Commission not persuaded it would be unreasonable to suspend entry permit – permit suspended for period of three months. Kalem

ENTERPRISE AGREEMENTS – dispute about matter arising under agreement – s.739 Fair Work Act 2009 – application filed by Australasian Meat industry Employees’ Union (applicant) to address concerns on the interpretation of clause 3.7 of the Woolworths Limited – Brismeat, Queensland and the Australasian Meat Industry Employees’ Union Agreement 2011 (the Agreement) – concerned if overweight allowance payable on all forms of approved absences from work – referred to modified principles of enterprise agreement interpretation imbedded in Berri – contention whether words used ambiguous, uncertain or capable of more than one meaning – respondent found relevant clause was ambiguous and unclear – form of extrinsic material admissible to aid interpretation of the Agreement – believed business records, minutes of bargaining meetings for 2011 Agreement, were accurate account of matters discussed – Commission held minutes were an objective account of the outcome of discussions as to the Agreement of the negotiating parties – respondent stated no intention to apply meaning of words as contended by the Union – Commission found overweight allowances do not apply to all forms of authorised absences, except for personal leave and jury duty – pro rata absences recognised – noted if such leave is taken for less than the full week then entitlement to pro rata overweight payments for the days employees at work – dispute resolved and determined. Australasian Meat Industry Employees’ Union, The v Brismeat Queensland (Woolworths Limited) t/a Brismeat

ENTERPRISE AGREEMENTS – dispute about matter arising under agreement – ss.595, 739 Fair Work Act 2009 – application to deal with a dispute in accordance with the Serco Defence Maritime Collective Agreement 2015 (the Agreement) – dispute regarding parity of rates between Master and Engineers – written guarantee provided 6 months after agreement approved providing for Masters and Engineers to be paid equally when employed on the same vessel – respondent raised objection to Commission determining matter – Berri principles considered – principles from CFMEU v Mt Arthur Coal P/L adopted – Commission needed to determine if written guarantee covered by clause 26.1 of the Agreement – determined it is not covered by the dispute resolution clause – the Agreement does not contain an express provision which would provide grounds for the Commission to find the dispute is about a matter arising under the Agreement – Commission concluded no power to make order sought by the applicant – Commission recommended Serco take all necessary steps to ensure undertaking is honoured for life of Agreement. The Australian Maritime Officers’ Union v DMS Maritime P/L t/a Serco Defence

TERMINATION OF EMPLOYMENT – valid reason – small business employer – s.394 Fair Work Act 2009 – application for unfair dismissal remedy – respondent is a small business – Commission considered whether dismissal was genuine redundancy – respondent could not afford to pay applicant’s wages – applicant’s role has not been filled, duties being performed by other employees – no consultation undertaken with applicant in advance of termination – dismissal was not genuine redundancy – dismissal was unfair but unlikely employment would have continued for long – compensation of $4000 granted plus 9.5% superannuation in addition to other moneys owed to applicant including superannuation and outstanding annual leave. Dawood v Universal LED Lighting P/L

TERMINATION OF EMPLOYMENT – performance – s.394 Fair Work Act 2009 – application for unfair dismissal – applicant dismissed for alleged poor performance and failing to identify potentially fraudulent car loan application – applicant’s dismissal found to be harsh and unreasonable – applicant’s failings did not constitute a valid reason for dismissal – applicant was notified of reasons for dismissal prior to termination and was given an opportunity to respond – respondent did not issue warnings regarding unsatisfactory performance and applicant was therefore not given an opportunity to improve – respondent did not follow proper procedures in effecting dismissal, although it had no access to a dedicated human resource management expert – applicant’s age, limited skill set and low likelihood of obtaining employment considered – applicant unfairly dismissed – ordered compensation of six weeks’ pay less tax, plus super, less any notice period paid. Phillipson v Fincar P/L

The Fair Work Commission will hear 23 unfair dismissal/labour dispute applications today. The full list is: TW Constructions (Ellem), The GEO Group Australia Pty Ltd (Reihana), The GEO Group (Reilly), Bei Fang Food Supplies Pty Ltd (Yang), Bristow Helicopters Australia Pty Ltd (McCreadie, Rowland), Xcel Pty Ltd (Jonassen), Martin Sayle (Musumeci), Community Accommodation and Respite Agency Inc (Van Praet), Merri Community Health Services (Stent), Glenview Community Services Inc (Tanner), Spartelaqua Pty Ltd as Trustee for the Karagiannis Practice Trust (Bruce), Bechtel Construction (Australia) Pty Ltd (Weir), BHP Billiton Iron Ore Pty Ltd (Sargent), Technosoft (Australia) Pty Ltd (Das), Medwest Health Care Pty Ltd (Dunne), Kascorp Pty Ltd (Brigante), E-Travel Pty Ltd (Graham), Probiotec Pharma Pty Ltd (Krajina), DFP Recruitment (Kumar), JJ’s Heating and Cooling Services (Tran), Solar Station Alpha Pty Ltd (von Erkel), Bowen & Pomeroy Pty Ltd (Fox).

The list of applications for relief from unfair dismissal is growing. The Fair Work Commission will hear 30 applications today. The full list is: Oakwood Aged Care (Pumpa), Re-Engage Youth Services Incorporated (Patterson), Confident Smile Dental Surgery (Alcorn), Mrs. Australia Pty Ltd (Banda), Pets Unit Trust (Loring), Toll Transport Pty Ltd (Borg), Light House Holding Trust (Singh), Ashton Manufacturing Pty Ltd (Turner), Yooralla (Hussainy), Ngaanyatjarra Council Aboriginal Corporation (Walker), FoodWorks East Fremantle (Willetts), Nexxis (Thompson), Assetlink Services (17) Pty Ltd (Al Shaher), Hudson (O), Contura Mining Pty Ltd (Martinez), Bristow Helicopters Australia Pty Ltd (Rowland), Gunnedah Leather Processors Pty Ltd (Goodacre), Apex Institute of Education (Dal), Top Notch Builders Pty Ltd (Doyle), Coles Supermarkets Pty Ltd (Holt), Ted Transport Pty Ltd (Thessman), Artisan Wine Storage Pty Ltd (Oldfield), Glorious Health Australia Pty Ltd (Aneke), Australian and New Zealand Banking Group Limited (Taylor), Startrack Express (Taylor), Judhar Pty Ltd (Carmody), Mezzanine Media Australia Pty Ltd (McWilliam), Hitachi Construction Machinery (Australia) Pty Ltd (King & Reid and Another), Coles Supermarkets Australia Pty Ltd (Singh), Foodworks East Fremantle (Willetts).

Twenty applications pertaining to labour disputes and unfair dismissal will be heard by the Fair Work Commission today. The full list is: Cimnnco International Pty Ltd (Owen), Schwing Concrete Constructions (Downes), Northwest Supermarkets Pty Ltd (Johnson), Solar Station Alpha Pty Ltd (von Erkel), Western Health (Footscray Hospital) (Krawczyszyn), AHS Hospitality Pty Ltd (Wehbe), Sancorp Industries Pty Ltd & Hosseini and Another (Anderson), Happy Tint Pty Ltd (Merchan), Ticar Pty Ltd ATF Ticar Family Trust (Christensen), Motor Trades Association of Western Australia (Inc) (Whelan), The GEO Group Australia Pty Ltd (Reihana), The GEO Group (Reilly), Sydney International Container Terminals Pty Limited (Colwell), Triple 888 Studios Pty Ltd & Quan and Another (Michael), St Vincent de Paul Society NSW) (Smith), Coal River Farm Investments Pty Ltd (Phillips), QF Cabin Crew Australia Pty Ltd (Bayfield), VetPrep Australia Pty Ltd (Smith), FSG Australia (Orr, Roberson).