MODERN AWARDS – 4 yearly review – s.156 Fair Work Act 2009 – Full Bench – decision deals with redrafting of a number of clauses in modern awards which have been identified as ‘standard clauses’ [see [2016] FWC 4756] – the standard clauses subject to plain language re-drafting are: A. Award flexibility; B. Consultation about major workplace change; C. Consultation about changes to rosters or hours of work; D. Dispute resolution; E. Termination of employment; F. Redundancy; G. Transfer to low paid job on redundancy; and H. Employee leaving during redundancy notice period – in decision issued on 28 August 2017 (the August decision) [[2017] FWCFB 4419] Full Bench finalised terms of most of standard clauses – issue arose as to whether clause E.1(c) of termination of employment standard term was a type of provision which may validly be included in a modern award and, if it was, whether such a provision was necessary to achieve modern awards objective – interested parties were invited to make submissions – variety of submission received – in consideration of whether clause E.1(c) was type of provision which may validly be included in a modern award the Full Bench expressed a number of provisional views regarding the amendment of clause E.1(c) and have sought further submissions – in the August decision the Full Bench invited further submissions regarding a revised version of standard clause G – the revised clause contained modifications to clauses G.1 and G.3 only, with clause G.2 having been finalised – submissions were made by the ACTU and the AMWU – standard clause G varied – directions will be issued in respect of the filing of submissions and the further hearing of this matter. 4 yearly review of modern awards – Plain language – standard clauses
October 31, 2017
INDUSTRIAL ACTION – order against industrial action – ss.418, 425 Fair Work Act 2009 – multiple applications – protected industrial action at ASC P/L – advanced stage of bargaining for replacement enterprise agreement – action being engaged in during access period and in lead-up to vote – appropriate to order cooling-off having regard to factors in s.425 – suspension order made – claim of unprotected industrial action – assertion by ASC P/L that CEPU not genuinely trying to reach agreements – orders sought under s.418 – conduct to date insufficient to warrant orders – unnecessary and contrary to public interest to make interim orders under s.420 – application adjourned. ASC P/L v Communications, Electrical, Electronic, Energy, Information, Postal, Plumbing and Allied Services Union of Australia
October 31, 2017
TERMINATION OF EMPLOYMENT – termination at initiative of employer – ss.386, 394 Fair Work Act 2009 – application for unfair dismissal remedy – applicant alleged she was unfairly dismissed by respondent – respondent submitted applicant was not dismissed but resigned – applicant applied for extended annual leave which respondent initially granted and had an overseas holiday booked and paid for – respondent then revoked leave approval – applicant submitted she was forced to resign under duress as respondent placed her in an impossible position – Commission accepted that applicant resigned under burden of immense pressure – Fitzgerald considered – Commission found applicants resignation was not forced by conduct of respondent – applicant not dismissed – application dismissed. Bengel v Gloss Accessories P/L t/a Gloss Accessories
October 31, 2017
TERMINATION OF EMPLOYMENT – genuine redundancy – ss.394, 386 Fair Work Act 2009 – application for relief from unfair dismissal – Commission considered whether job no longer required to be performed by anyone because of operational requirements – evidence of operational changes which were necessary to maintain ongoing viability of business – considered Ulan Coal Mines Commission satisfied respondent no longer required applicant’s role to be performed – no evidence of redundancy being a ‘smokescreen’ to cover unfair dismissal – considered obligation to consult – applicant not covered by a modern award or enterprise agreement – Commission satisfied redundancy was a genuine redundancy – application dismissed. D’Alessandro v Gallery Homes P/L t/a Gallery Homes
October 31, 2017
RIGHT OF ENTRY – application for permit – s.512 Fair Work Act 2009 – application for right of entry permit – permit qualification matters under s.513 considered – applicant disclosed one matter – previously found guilty of contempt and ordered to pay a fine of $20,000 – Commission considered disclosure not to be sufficient to disqualify applicant from holding an entry permit – satisfied applicant has held permits consistently since at least 2003 – no evidence to suggest applicant has acted in a manner inconsistent with obligations under the FW Act – significant passage of time between applicant’s previous conduct and current application being made – applicant a fit and proper person – entry permit issued. Construction, Forestry, Mining and Energy Union
October 31, 2017
CASE PROCEDURES – representation – ss.394, 596, 601 Fair Work Act 2009 – appeal – Full Bench – at first instance the Commission found the appellant had not been dismissed and dismissed the appellant’s unfair dismissal application – Woolworths jurisdictional objection on basis that the appellant had voluntarily resigned from his employment – initially listed for hearing on 29 May 2017 on the question of whether permission to appeal should be granted only – after hearing from the parties the Full Bench determined that one contention of appealable error in the appeal was arguable and raised an issue of general importance such that it would be in the public interest to grant permission to appeal – considered appeal grounds that appellant was misled by Commission regarding respondent’s legal representation and that there was misrepresentation and deceit relating to legal representation – Woolworths lawyer attended but did not seek permission and did not engage in oral advocacy – considered ss.596 and 609 FW Act and FW Rules 11 and 12 regarding representation – Warrell and NSW Bar Association considered – neither decision dealt with scope of representation under s.596 – concept of ‘appearing’ for party in legal proceedings not unambiguous – apparent under ss.596 and 609 that ‘representation’ under s.596 is more than just advocacy at hearing – considered Australian Bar Association’s Barristers’ Conduct Rules – suggests ‘represented’ in s.596 not confined to appearing as an advocate – suggests ‘in a matter’ in s.596 not confined to hearing – s.596(1)(b) expressly provides representation includes making an application or submission’ to Commission – matters indicates ‘submission’ includes ‘written submission’ – Full Bench concluded s.596 not confined to permission for courtroom advocacy, and appears to have been drafted in a way that is deliberately distinct from predecessor legislation – clause intended beyond doubt that all aspects of representation in connection with matter were to be encompassed – on evidence related to cost application, Woolworths represented from at least early February 2017 by corresponding with Commission and making written submissions – Woolworths should have filed notice of representation commencing to act but not required to obtain permission for those activities prior to hearing because of FW Rule 12(3) exception – Woolworths billed for attendance at hearing – considered how lawyer could attend and provide legal services without representing client under s.596 – Commission rejected lawyer not acting as a representative based on Curtin and McKenzie – Commission erred in proceeding on basis that permission not required under s.596(2) merely because representative was not engaged in oral argument – alternatively, Commission erred by formally refusing permission whilst still allowing lawyer to engage in what Full Bench found to be legal representation at hearing – appellant did not identify any prejudice to him resulting from representation – Woolworths’ jurisdictional objection had overwhelming merit, and Full bench could not identify any reasonable possibility that different ruling on representation could have led to different outcome – appeal dismissed. Appeal by Fitzgerald against decision of Cambridge C of 5 April 2017 [[2017] FWC 1730] Re: Woolworths Limited
October 31, 2017
TERMINATION OF EMPLOYMENT – discontinuance – s.394 Fair Work Act 2009 – application for unfair dismissal remedy – recorded on electronic Commission file that parties reached settlement agreement following conference – parties notified Commissioner accepted applicant’s verbal discontinuance – applicant contacted chambers advising that respondent sought to introduce new terms to settlement agreement and requested matter proceed to hearing – applicant denied that he verbally discontinued matter at conference – submitted Commission has jurisdiction to amend or correct the error – Commission considered whether discontinuance could be set aside – notice of discontinuance can be set aside if filed by mistake or under duress however doubt that such a power may be exercised by the Commission [AB v Tabcorp] – found Commission has no jurisdiction to grant application to set aside discontinuance – determined that applicant’s application has no reasonable prospects of success – open to applicant to apply to a court to set aside discontinuance in light of AB v Tabcorp or to file a new unfair dismissal application – application dismissed. Le v RBA Architects and Conservation Consultants P/L
October 31, 2017
ANTI-BULLYING – likely to continue – s.789FC Fair Work Act 2009 – application for an order to stop bullying – applicant alleged she had been bullied at work by Ms Kotsiris, who is employed by Jo Mercer, collectively referred to as the ‘respondents’ – applicant resigned her employment during period of unpaid leave – respondents subsequently made application to Commission to dismiss applicant’s anti-bullying application on basis that application had no reasonable prospects of success due to applicant’s resignation – respondents submitted Commission cannot be satisfied applicant was at risk of being bullied at work as she was no longer employed by Jo Mercer – applicant submitted she had been forced to resign, was seeking reinstatement and her anti-bullying application should be put on hold pending outcome of dismissal application – Shaw, Re G.C., Obatoki, Atkinson and Willis considered – Commission found as applicant no longer employed at Jo Mercer, it could not be concluded that there was a risk she would continue to be bullied at work – Commission does not have power to make order – satisfied application had no reasonable prospect of success – should applicant succeed in securing reinstatement through her unfair dismissal application, applicant will be free to make another anti-bullying application – Commission granted respondent’s application on basis of no reasonable prospect of success – application dismissed. Resta v Jo Mercer and Anor