NEWS HR

ENTERPRISE AGREEMENTS – approval – unlawful terms – ss.185, 604 Fair Work Act 2009 – permission to appeal – Full Bench – at first instance the Commission approved the Australian Federal Police Enterprise Agreement 2017-2020 – the appellant was a bargaining representative for the proposed agreement – central to the matter at first instance, and again agitated in the appeal, was the question whether clause 46 of the Agreement is an unlawful term within the meaning of s.194 of the FW Act because it is a discriminatory term as described in s.195 and/or an objectionable term within the meaning of s.12 – clause 46 makes provision for maternity leave, including paid maternity leave in certain circumstances – grounds of appeal included issues of procedural fairness, and whether the Commission erred in being satisfied that the Agreement does not include any unlawful terms – Full Bench did not consider that the absence of an oral hearing resulted in any denial of procedural fairness to the appellant – appellant made comprehensive written submissions and the bases for his objection to the approval of the Agreement were set out therein – the apprehended bias ground of appeal was founded on a comment said to have been made by the Commission during the telephone conference on 18 April 2018 – that maternity leave is by definition for women – appellant contended it was clear during that conference that the Commission was predisposed against the appellant’s discrimination argument – proceeding on the basis that the Commission made a statement or statements as asserted by the appellant, the Full Bench held that the Commission was formulating a proposition so that its correctness could be tested and expressing no more than a preliminary view or an inclination or disinclination towards an argument or conclusion – held that the apprehended bias ground of appeal advanced by the appellant must fail – appellant contended before the Commission, and again before the Full Bench, that clause 46(2) was an unlawful term – whether clause 46(2) is a discriminatory term, and whether it is an objectionable term – the appellant asserted on a number of occasions that the additional leave for which provision is made in clause 46(2) of the Agreement was not maternity leave and was as a matter of fact primary caregivers leave – Full Bench held the entitlement for which provision is made by clause 46(2) of the Agreement is plainly for additional maternity leave – noted the appellant did not lead evidence as to the nature of additional maternity leave as a matter of fact – the Commission can hardly be criticised for not taking into account a ‘fact’ which the appellant failed to establish by evidence, presumably thinking that an appropriate substitute was dogmatic repetition of an unsustainable mantra – Full Bench concluded that the impugned term did not directly discriminate against an employee covered by the Agreement because of or for reasons including the employee’s sex, sexual orientation, family or carer’s responsibilities – the impugned term is not an objectionable term within the meaning of s.12 – the grounds of appeal and contentions directed to this conclusion are rejected – Full Bench not persuaded that the appellant made out a case of arguable error – did not consider that the public interest is enlivened – held that the Commission’s ultimate conclusion at first instance was correct – permission to appeal refused. Appeal by Budd against decision of Kovacic DP of 17 May 2018 [[2018] FWCA 2776] Re: Australian Federal Police

CASE PROCEDURES – appeals – person aggrieved – s.604 Fair Work Act 2009 – appeal against decision to approve the FES Coal P/L Greenfields Agreement 2018 (approval decision) – FES Coal applied to have notice of appeal dismissed – FES application supported by CFMMEU – whether appellant is a ‘person aggrieved’ by approval decision – ‘person aggrieved’ capable of extending beyond persons whose legal interest are affected by decision in question – mere intellectual or emotional concern not enough – time for determining standing not fixed but depends on the circumstances – appellant is not, and has never been, an employee of FES or covered by the relevant agreement – was not involved in negotiations for agreement – not a representative of other persons affected – no suggestion that agreement operated to restrain appellant’s legal rights – no basis for concluding appellant has legitimate interest in ensuring Commission acts within its jurisdiction distinct from that of those directly affected by approval decision – appellant has no relevant interest beyond that of ordinary member of the public – appellant did not have standing – appeal incompetent – appeal dismissed. Appeal by Shorey against decision of Kovacic DP of 13 August 2018 [[2018] FWCA 4749] Re: FES Coal P/L; Construction, Forestry, Maritime, Mining and Energy Union

TERMINATION OF EMPLOYMENT – termination at initiative of employer – constructive dismissal – ss.386, 394 Fair Work Act 2009 – whether applicant dismissed on employer’s initiative – whether employee’s contract of employment repudiated – whether repudiation of contract constitutes constructive dismissal – respondent put new employment contracts with diminished commission arrangements to applicant – each was rejected – respondent continued to pay commission on existing contract terms – Commission satisfied that significant changes occurred in applicant’s work activities – not satisfied applicant’s restricted sales activities and reduced supervisory or managerial duties was repudiation of applicant’s contract – Commission did not find that respondent repudiated applicant’s contract or that employment relationship was terminated on the initiative of the employer on account of repudiation – did not consider that the business restructure was a termination at the employer’s initiative – Commission found applicant resigned – Easling v Mahoney considered – found applicant was dismissed in that he was forced to resign because of a course of conduct engaged in by employer – Commission found business restructure was not valid reason for dismissal – found dismissal unreasonable – dismissal unfair – ordered compensation of $11,535.26, taxed according to law, and $1,238.92 in superannuation contributions. Constable v 4WD Accessory Wholesale P/L t/a Caddy Adelaide

TERMINATION OF EMPLOYMENT – valid reason – s.394 Fair Work Act 2009 – application for unfair dismissal – applicant engaged as a Health Professional (Paramedic) – worked at the Mount Arthur Coal Mine operated by BHP – respondent was contracted by BHP to provide onsite drug and alcohol testing of workers and contractors engaged at the Mine – two incidents of alleged inappropriate conduct of the applicant during workplace drug and alcohol testing procedures – applicant included BHP in correspondence regarding employment matters between the applicant and the respondent – applicant dismissed by respondent after Mine site access removed by BHP – Commission found reasons given for dismissal could represent valid reason however no evidence to support them – found stated reasons for dismissal did not represent the true reason for dismissal – actual reason for the dismissal was the removal by the respondent’s client (BHP) of Mine site access for the applicant – exercise of a contractual right of a third party – found dismissal of the applicant was without valid reason involving established misconduct or capacity inadequacy – involved an entirely unjust and unreasonable process – found dismissal was harsh, unjust and unreasonable – ordered compensation of $7,648. Hocroft v Verifact P/L

The Fair Work Commission industrial dispute law list today includes: The Tea Centre Pty Limited (Patel), Sydney Credit Union Ltd (Kumar), 2Connect, Youth and Community Inc (Onuoha), Metwide Communications (Thomas), Peduba Cleaning Services (Zakria), Phytomed Australia Pty Limited (Grant), Gumala Enterprises Pty Ltd (McCulloch), Salini Australia Pty Ltd (Latham), TIOBE Pty Ltd (Chen), Kaytee Electrical & Sheetmetal Engineering Service (Le), Rincon Australia Pty Ltd (Rabel), Department of Justice and Regulation (Tay), Steveaugh T/A (Wright), Coles Supermarkets Australia Pty Ltd (Pangly), Queensland University of Technology (Mahoney), Energy Queensland Limited (Ward), BHP Coal Pty Ltd (Powling), The Trustee for the Bassem Pharmacy Trust (Taylor), Seacom Security Australia (Key), Utilities Management Pty Ltd (Bushten), N & HM Cooper Motor Search (SA) & Car Clearance Centre (SA), HACCP International Property Services (AlkemadE), Global Mining Services Pty Ltd (Connolly-Manga), Bacalar Pty Limited (Young), Port Authority of New South Wales (McDonald).

Sixteen unfair dismissal/ contract dispute applicants await hearing before a Fair Work Commissioner today. The lawlist is: Blue Care (Healy), Lorien Novalis School for Rudolf Steiner Education (Zaronias), Strategy1 HR Pty Ltd (Achram), Vintage Fm (Richards), Prosegur Australia Pty Ltd (Noiszewski, Smith), TruckTalk (Floyd), Rodaar Pty Ltd (Lawty), Hosch International Pty Ltd (Ip), Hanseatic Marine Engineering Pty Ltd (Thomas), A & A & A Di Medio & Son (Aust) P/L & A & A Di Medio & Son (Aust) P/L (Di Medio), Balmain N.B. Corporation Ltd (Paul), Wyndham Vacation Resorts Asia Pty Ltd (Karamanos), Lycamobile Pvt Ltd (Gnanaratnam), Boeing Defence Australia Limited (Smith), Staff Australia Pty Ltd (Avgoulis).

Fifteen unfair dismissal.labour claimants have lined up for a Fair Work Commission hearing today: Balmain N.B. Corporation Ltd (Paul), Scalabrini Village Limited (Ammellino), Andrew Valerio & Sons Funeral Directors (Maestrale), Central Capital Pty Ltd (Zhou), John Holland Group Pty Ltd (Buckley), JBAN Pty Ltd (Bradley), Ixom Operations Pty Ltd (McMillan), In Vitro Technologies Pty Ltd (Saunders-Stent), The Australian National University (Kendrick), Stryker Australia Pty Ltd (Simpson), Jubi Pty Ltd (Weiss), The Trustee for G & B Leavy Family Trust (Le), Seven Oaks Hospitality (Sotomayor Abarzua), Flight Centre Travel Group Limited & Moir (Hunter), The Playford Hotel (Nesci).

Eighteen unfair dismissal applicants will be heard today in the Fair Work Commission. the list is: Richard Vella Excavations And Landscaping (Phillips), Wellteq Pty Ltd (Doria) Verifact Pty Ltd (Horcroft), Byblos Finance (Pascale), Ryan Wilks Pty Ltd (Puszka), Qube Logistics Pty Ltd (Beames), Serco Australia Pty Limited (Singh), Cambridge Gulf Limited (Maiolo), Global Care Group Inc (Stockton), RFDS Western Operations Pty Ltd (Schouten), Ambulance Victoria (Davis), Regis Aged Care (Kemokai), Bevmarks (Wiener), Australia and New Zealand Banking Group Limited (Guedson), North Buderim Pharmacy (Cole), Employment Advocacy Solutions Pty Ltd (Buttress), Bunnings Group Limited (Stranges), Gippsland and East Gippsland Aboriginal Co-operative Ltd (Harrison).