The Fair Work Commission will today hear an additional 29 unfair dismissal/labour dispute applications. St George College Inc (Filippi), Sam Technology Engineers Pty Ltd (Bernadou), Adlinda Bakehouse (Alien), Colliers International (SA) Pty Ltd (McCouaig), Georgiadis Lawyers Pty Ltd (Hutt), RFDS Western Operations Pty Ltd (Schouten), Coles Supermarkets Australia Pty Ltd (Schluter), The Corner Espresso House (Bigby), Australian Leisure and Hospitality Group Pty Limited (Slemint), One Key Workforce Pty Ltd (Haigh), Bama Services (Richardson-Steele), Raine and Horne Woodford (Rowlands), North End Tyres Pty Ltd (Al-Dawood), Sam Technology Engineers Pty Ltd (Bernadou), Esso Australia Pty Ltd (Hatwell), Keys and Remotes Pty Ltd (Lao), VicRoads (Jachowski), Coles Supermarkets Australia Pty Ltd (Pangly), Infosys Limited (Sharma), Coffey Services Australia (Abram), The Griffin Coal Mining Company Pty Ltd (Garner), Transport for NSW (Fussell), Commonwealth Bank of Australia (Zepidis), Sam Technology Engineers Pty Ltd (Bernadou), SERCO Justice & Immigration Services (Zammit), Asset Restoration Pty Ltd (Georges), Bristow Helicopters Australia Pty Ltd (Packington), Raine and Horne Woodford (Rowlands), Parramatta Mission (Pye).
October 17, 2018
The lawlist for the Fair Work Commission today includes 32 applications involving unfair dismissal/labour dispute. The full list is: Wandiyali (Kelly), Wandiyali Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Incorporated (Richards, Van Eyk), Lopigear Pty Ltd (Neary), Durra, Markelian (Allbon), Qantas Airways Ltd (Edmunds), Tabcorp Holdings Limited (Hancock), Spandex Asia Pacific Pty Ltd (Irvine), Sydney Trains (Pirozzi), Bliss Management Pty Ltd (Lozano), Toll Personnel Pty Ltd (Taulapapa), State of Victoria as represented by the Department of Treasury and Finance (Parolin), Serendipity (WA) Pty Ltd (Hoey), United The Grand Lodge of Antient Free and Accepted Masons of Victoria (McAnally), Step 5 Pty Ltd (Mercier), Nationwide News Pty Ltd (Naorin), Antonine College (Ilkovska), Modinex Manufacturing Pty Ltd (Watkins), R M Begg Kyneton Aged Care Pty Inc (Dunbar), Worldmark Pty Ltd (Georges), V/Line Pty Ltd (Lothian), Maroondah City Council (Tai-Rakena), SellYourCarFast Australia Pty Ltd (Fernandez), Programmed Skilled Workforce (and related bodies corporate within the Programmed Group of Companies) (Fitzpatrick), Canberra Greyhound Racing Club Inc (Peck, Thomas), Winnaa Pty Ltd (Roos), Modinex Manufacturing Pty Ltd (Watkins), Safe Places Community Services Limited (Watson), The Branding Office (McKechnie), Queensland Rail Transit Authority (Shearer), Holden (Reinke).
October 16, 2018
The unfair dismissal/labour dispute law list in the Fair Work Commission today includes the following: Concrete Employment Services Pty Ltd (Wittwer), Utilities Management Pty Ltd (Bushten), Queensland University of Technology (QUT) (Escobar), Jacobs Well Eggs Farm (Krishma), National Real Estate Solutions Pty Ltd ATF the NRS Unit Trust (Mitchell), CW & CG Dickinson (Taylor), Youfoodz Pty Ltd (Swanton), Cigarette & Gift Warehouse (Needham), Queensland Reconstruction Authority (Stone), Weatheralls Wodonga Hotel Proprietary Limited (Voncina), Global Care Group Inc (Stockton), Allan Hall Business Advisors Pty Ltd & Parish and Another (Moir), Qube Holdings Limited (Gattuso), Fortis Law Group Pty Limited (Tayyar), Southern Metropolitan Cemeteries Land Manager (Azzopardi), Marumina Pty Ltd (Arja), The Whole Box n Dice (Hall), Qantas Airways Ltd (Meintanis), Qantas Airways Ltd (Oei, Whippy), HD Projects Pty Ltd (Fasavalu), Communities@Work (Abosede), Port of Newcastle (McShane), Cedar Place Aged Care Facility Limited (Hall).
October 15, 2018
A lengthening queue of unfair dismissal/labour dispute remedy seekers will plead their applications in the Fair Work Commission today. the list is: National Australia Bank Limited (Zhou), MCR Computer Resources Pty Ltd (Koulos), Yeates Betts Solicitors (Cook), SAI Global Limited (Marsh), FOODORA Australia Pty Ltd (Klooger), San ANotnio Da Padova Nursing Home (Robach), ISS Security Pty Ltd (Ebba), Trinity Lutheran College (Wilkinson), GMT Business Services Pty Ltd (Allen), Gippsland & East Gippsland Aboriginal Cooperative Ltd (Ells, Finn, Harvey, Oestamann, Patten), Prosegur Australia (Kukalev), Kilmore Golf Club (Lindsay), The Trustee for Annex Unit Trust (Duncan), Latrobe Regional Hospital (Kays), United The Grand Lodge of Antient Free and Accepted Masons of Victoria (McAnally), Worldmark Pty Ltd (Georges), Australian Unity Group Services Pty Limited (Honore), Australian Laboratory Services Pty Ltd (Ramanananthan), Buildgroup Constructions Pty Ltd (Aljnabi), Alclad Architectural (Collins), Allen’s Freight (Moore), Ink Hotel Pty Ltd (Frisby), TLC Aged Care Noble Manor (Matthew), Kidspace Pty Ltd atf The Trustee for Kidzspace Management Unit Trust & Newman and Another (O’Brien), Shutdown Staffing Services (Prouten), Findex Group Limited (Renison), RefLIVE Pty Ltd (Downey), Mooloolaba Surf LifeSaving Club (Taylor), Ipswich Grammar School (McGrath).
October 12, 2018
Twenty-four unfair dismissal/labour dispute applications will be heard in the Fair Work Commission today. The list is: FOODORA Australia Pty Ltd (Klooger), Thales Australia Limited (True), Caltex (Buckley), Acrturus Nominees Pty Ltd (Jakobs), Austin Engineering Ltd (Hedges), Corridors College Limited (Wallis), St John of God Health Care (Skaines), RAC Distribution Pty Ltd (Perera), Institute for Aboriginal Development (Aboriginal Corporation (Lerossignol), ORC International Pty Ltd (Bastoni), State of Victoria (Tucker), Department of Defence (Geddes), GMT Business Services Pty Ltd (ALlen), King’s Wood International Pty Ltd (Denny), Energy Queensland Limited (Ward), Totally Aussie Security (Qld) Pty Ltd and Associated Entities (Greenslade), Host My Home Pty Ltd (Savimaki), Crossways Lutheran School Ceduna Association Inc (Puccio), Spotless Services (Bull), Totally Aussie Security (Qld) Pty Ltd and Associated Entities (Greenslade), National Australia Bank (Zhou), Viterra Operations Pty Ltd (Pridham, Rose), Norgrove Training Pty Ltd (McCloskey).
October 12, 2018
An application for variation of the Base Fire Protection Pty Ltd & CEPU NSW/NFIA Sprinkler Fitting Fire Protection Union Enterprise Agreement NSW & ACT 2015-2019 (s.210 – Application for approval of a variation of an enterprise agreement) will be decided by Deputy President Gostencnik in his Melbourne chambers today.
October 12, 2018
TERMINATION OF EMPLOYMENT – performance – procedural fairness – s.394 Fair Work Act 2009 – application for unfair dismissal – applicant employed as a Level C Senior Lecturer – dismissed on grounds of unsatisfactory performance relating to research output – applicant submitted that alleged failure to be ‘research-active’ was beyond the requirements of a Level C position – submitted that respondent failed to apply the relevant disciplinary process under the Flinders University Enterprise Agreement 2014 to 2017 and that the dismissal was harsh as no formal warnings in respect of performance had been issued since 2011 – Commission found that the research requirements of the applicant’s role were consistent with the Agreement – found that applicant was not capable or willing to meet the requirements of a Level C Academic despite recent improvement – satisfied there was a valid reason for dismissal – whether procedural fairness afforded – found that the 2011 warning was referred to the applicant several times before dismissal, however, it did not expressly include or exclude research performance – found the disciplinary process under the Agreement not generally applied – procedural deficiencies impacted on applicant’s capacity to respond and the degree to which he understood his employment was in jeopardy – applicant offered to accept demotion to a Level B position as contemplated as a disciplinary outcome under the Agreement – Commission satisfied that proposed demotion would have been a reasonable and proportionate response – respondent’s failure to consider demotion more fully as an alternative was unreasonable – satisfied that the dismissal was harsh – reinstatement to former position not appropriate – ordered compensation of $65,499 less applicable taxation. Lynd-Stevenson v Flinders University
October 12, 2018
TERMINATION OF EMPLOYMENT – misconduct – ss.394, 400, 604 Fair Work Act 2009 – appeal – Full Bench – at first instance the Commission found that the two appellants had not been unfairly dismissed – the dismissal of the appellants for serious misconduct occurred in a particular industrial context – protest line near the entrance to the Longford site – included very large inflatable ‘Scabby the Rat’ – use of offensive and intimidating language towards employees of contractors – in each of the appeals there are challenges to a number of the Commission’s factual findings – Full Bench mindful of the fact that the evidence at first instance was voluminous and in some respects conflicting – Commission reached conclusions based on favouring one witness over another, or because of the credibility of a witness – Short v Ambulance Victoria considered – in the context of appeals, Full Benches of the Commission have consistently held that findings of fact made by a Member at first instance should stand unless it can be shown that the Member ‘has failed to use or has palpably misused his advantage’, or has acted on evidence which was ‘inconsistent with facts incontrovertibly established by the evidence’ or which was ‘glaringly improbable’ – Mr Gelagotis’ appeal – grounds of appeal asserted that the Commission made errors of fact – Full Bench held it important to acknowledge the Commission’s observation that Mr Gelagotis was ‘not an impressive witness’ – in conduct cases the assessment of whether there was a valid reason for the dismissal is to be considered in isolation from the broader context in which the alleged misconduct occurred – Full Bench not persuaded that Mr Gelagotis established an arguable case of error in respect of any of the grounds of appeal – not persuaded the Commission made an error of principle or a significant error of fact – Full Bench not persuaded there were any other considerations which enliven the public interest – not satisfied it is in the public interest to grant permission to appeal – permission to appeal refused – Mr Hatwell’s appeal – grounds of appeal asserted that the Commission made errors of fact and that the Commission erred in the fact that he failed to take into account and/or failed to give equal significance to relevant s.387(h) matters in determining whether the dismissal was harsh, unjust or unreasonable; and erred by giving excessive weight to his reasons for concluding there was a valid reason for Mr Hatwell’s dismissal – Full Bench held that the ‘valid reason’ for Mr Hatwell’s dismissal was a single contravention of Esso’s harassment policy – the conduct occurred in the context of a protracted industrial dispute which had resulted in ‘significant tension’ in the workplace and constituted a ‘material change’ in the normal working environment – the relevant decision maker at Esso made it clear that she would not dismiss an employee for a single use of the word ‘scab’ – Full Bench considered that it was in the public interest to grant permission to appeal, and did so on the basis that the decision manifests an injustice – concluded that the decision was manifestly unjust and plainly fell outside the bounds of legal reasonableness as articulated in Li – appeal upheld – decision to dismiss Mr Hatwell’s unfair dismissal application quashed – in rehearing the matter the Full Bench adopted the Commission’s finding that there was a valid reason for dismissal however concluded that Mr Hatwell’s dismissal was harsh – follows that Mr Hatwell was unfairly dismissed – held Mr Hatwell’s conduct warranted a disciplinary response which fell short of dismissal – Full Bench remit the question of whether a remedy should be granted and, if so, the nature of that remedy, to Colman DP for determination. Appeals by Gelagotis and Hatwell against decision of Colman DP of 14 May 2018 [[2018] FWC 2398] Re: Esso Australia P/L t/a Esso