NEWS HR

TERMINATION OF EMPLOYMENT – misconduct – s.394 Fair Work Act 2009 – application for unfair dismissal remedy – applicant dismissed following an investigation into his company fuel card use which identified that unleaded petrol had been purchased on two occasions over a month, such an occurrence would not have occurred if the applicant was driving diesel vehicle which he was allegedly instructed to drive – applicant denied being told to only drive the diesel vehicle and submitted he drove a multitude of unleaded vehicles and used the fuel card to purchase petrol for those vehicles – applicant admitted to occasionally using the card to purchase fuel for his own vehicle on weekends – Commission found there was a valid reason for dismissal due to the applicant’s breach of the fuel card policy on the weekends – Commission found applicant not provided the appropriate level of procedural fairness on the basis the applicant was not given an opportunity to respond – Commission took into account that the respondent did not enforce a vehicle log book, did not attempt to source CCTV footage from t he relevant petrol station for many weeks after the alleged misuse of the petrol card – found the respondent had not sufficiently made out its accusation of fraudulent behaviour on the two occasions – harsh, unjust and unreasonable – applicant awarded four weeks’ pay plus superannuation. Smith v Buick Holdings P/L t/a DVG Automotive Group – Midland City.

Some matters just drag. Sydney Trains is facing a second day within the portals of the Fair Work Commission facing down the accusatory finger of an ex-employee (Yehia). Other attendees today include: Allergen Australia Pty Ltd (Girardi), Indigenous Land Corporation (McCaffrey), Alcamaco Pty Ltd (Parmented), Central Cleaning Supplies (Vurovecz), Serco Citizen Services Pty Ltd (Boyd), Get Qualified Australia Pty Ltd (Lang), Hampton Transport Services Pty Ltd (McMillan), Rock Logistics Pty Ltd (Makbool), Viva Dental Pty Ltd (Bradley), Wingham Beef Exports Pty Limited (Glindemann), Palm Island Community Company Ltd (Wallis), Westside Bus Company Pty Ltd (Armstrong), International Health and Medical Services Pty Ltd (Hucker), P.R. Hepple & Sons Pty Ltd (Snowden-Bassett), Hilti Australia Pty Ltd (Pinar), Mink Property (Brown), Princess Properties Pty Ltd (Clarke), Australian Bill Comparisons Pty Ltd (Hartas), Hampton Transport Services Pty Ltd (McMillan), Bliss Organics Hair Studio (Rubeck), Palm Island Community Company Ltd (Wallis), WorkPac Pty Ltd (Harding), Statewide 1 Pty Ltd (Herewini).

TERMINATION OF EMPLOYMENT – extension of time – representative error – s.394 Fair Work Act 2009 – application for unfair dismissal remedy – application lodged on 30 September 2015 and not within 21 days of dismissal – no objection from respondent – exceptional circumstances test as considered in Nulty – ordinary meaning requiring consideration of all circumstances – combination of factors when viewed together may reasonably be seen as producing situation which is out of ordinary course, unusual, special or uncommon – solicitor advised applicant to seek internal review after dismissal and to engage union assistance – solicitor advised union representative of incorrect termination date – applicant dismissed on 8 September rather than 14 September – Robinson applied – conduct of applicant central consideration in deciding whetehr representative error provides acceptable explanation for delay in filing – Commission found applicant was notified of dismissal on 8 September – applicant sought internal review and respondent was aware of dispute – respondent did not dispute evidence provided in support of case – Commission found factors together weigh in favour of exceptional circumstances – reasonable explanation for delay – extension of time granted. Resetar v BHP Billiton Iron Ore P/L.

TERMINATION OF EMPLOYMENT – remedy – compensation – s.394 Fair Work Act 2009 – Commission found applicant was unfairly dismissed – decision in transcript – unable to determine appropriate remedy due to insufficient material – advised respondent to provide views on reinstatement – statisfied reinstatement inappropriate – order for payment of compensation considered appropriate – adopted approach taken in Haigh – applicant provided evidence to find alternative employment – Commission found applicant made reasonable efforts to mitigate loss – ordered $9702 compensation. Dang v Multisteps P/L.

TERMINATION OF EMPLOYMENT – extension of time – representative error – s.394 Fair Work Act 2009 – application for relief from unfair dismissal lodged outside 21 day time limit – applicant relied on union representative to lodge claim on his behalf – applicant unable to make sufficient contact with representative prior to expiry of 21 day time limit – question whether exceptional circumstances existed to warrant an extension of time [Nulty] – Commission held there was a reasonable explanation for delay – applicant was entitled to rely on representative to lodge application [Robinson] – applicant took reasonable steps to contact representative – merits of applicant’s case not strong but not unarguable – extension of time granted. Barfield v Temples (WA) P/L.

Colorpak Limited is providing today’s entertainment with its defence to a s.739 (application to deal with a dispute) lodged by an army of its staff (Bryant/Easdon and others). Other companies on parade include: AMP Ltd (Lees); Sydney Trains (Yehia); Asciano (White); Combined Communications Pty Limited (Wyborn); Sherpa Kids SA/NT (Trigg); Tilt Trays Australia Pty Ltd (Takats); The Association of Professional Engineers, Scientists and Managers, Australia (Schlumberger); Victorian Building Authority (Mulcahey); Principals Australia Institute (Pearman); Lardner Mechanical Repairs Pty Ltd (Morton); TAL Services Limited (Craven); RGC Brands Pty Ltd (Walia); The Australian Olive Oil Supplies (Grazia); The Attoh Family Trust (Bridger-Darling); Melissa Cakes (Buzi); Spotless Services Australia Ltd (Renike/Muraleedharan); and Polevine Pty Ltd (Baron).

TERMINATION OF EMPLOYMENT – application to dismiss by employer – ss.394, 587 Fair Work Act 2009 – application by respondent for dismissal of application – applicant previous employed as a bus driver – Commission notified application settled after directions for filing submissions were issued – vacated hearing dates and set aside directions in anticipation of filing of notice of discontinuance – over 12 months later, Commission wrote to applicant seeking the unfiled notice of discontinuance – applicant did not file and alleged he was pressured by representative into accepting agreement – respondent opposed application being relisted on the basis that it would have no reasonable prospects of success, owing to prior settlement of the claim – Commission sought submissions on whether a settlement was reached, and on the issue of the applicant’s alleged failure to prosecute his case in a timely manner – applicant had contacted the Commission several times over the 12 month period to advise that no settlement had been reached – Commission’s file notes showed applicant had contacted Commission and had been told to put his request for further directions and a listing in writing but had failed to do so – Commission satisfied that settlement, of the type contemplated in Masters v Cameron, was reached between parties and that, pursuant to the decision in McKinnon v Eventide, this is binding upon the parties – Commission further satisfied that applicant failed to prosecute application in a timely manner and that there would be significant prejudice to respondent if it were allowed to progress – application to dismiss unfair dismissal application granted. Ayaz v Transdev NSW South P/L.

TERMINATION OF EMPLOYMENT – misconduct – ss.394, 400, 604 Fair Work Act 2009 – permission to appeal – Full Bench – at first instance the Commission dismissed the appellant’s application for unfair dismissal – Commission accepted evidence of witness and help valid reason for dismissal – appellant sought permission to appeal Commission’s decision – submitted significant error of fact – no direct evidence that identified appellant was driver of tram – alleged Commission failed to apply test in Briginshaw – Full Bench held the uncertainty of exact times given by witness did not result in evidence being given in error – held Commission did apply test in Bringshaw – Commission considered seriousness of termination for appellant – Full Bench held no significant error in decision – no grounds to attract public interest – permission to appeal refused. Appeal by Soares against decision of Lewin C of 3 July 2015 [[2015] FWC 4472] Re: KDR Victoria P/L t/a Yarra Trams.