NEWS HR

The aged care sector and its healthcare cousins continue to dominate the Fair Work Commission’s unfair dismissal listings schedule. Yesterday it was a perennial visitor (Ian Hardy’s Helping Hand Inc) and today occasional attendees Bass Coast Regional Health (Hall), the Department of Human Services (Raykos) and Monash Health (Bannon). Others submitting to the oath include: SA Water Corporation (Giannakakos), Thermacon Insulation Pty Ltd (Beyan), Laser Bean Pty Ltd (Munckton), Australia Visa Link Pty Ltd (Li), Hadsec Group Pty Ltd (Tokoly), Metropolitan Fire and Emergency Services Board (Watt), M C Herds Pty Ltd (Edwards), Caulfield Grammar School (Pownall), Geelong Kindergarten Association (GKA) (Nilson), Coles Supermarkets Australia Pty Ltd and Bi-Lo Pty Limited (Hart), Doser Freight Forwarding Pty Ltd (Alsford), Officeworks Ltd (Kieruj), Carrera Total Pty Ltd (Saleski), BHP Billiton Iron Ore Pty Ltd (Finch), Mermaid Marine Vessel Operations Pty Ltd (Baker/Harty), Unilever Australia Trading Limited (Larkins), Endless Solar Operations Pty Ltd (Phillips), Ingleburn Veterinary Hospital (Pontinen), Woolworths Limited (Greentree), Santosheema Pty Ltd (Alexander), BIC Services Pty Limited (Anastasiou), DPG Services Pty Ltd (Nalder), Chi Kin Ken Ma (Te Rangipuawhe), HP Bowral Pty Ltd (Luckman).

A frequent visitor to the Fair Work Commission is an aged care home help mob in South Australia. Helping Hand Aged Care Inc under CEO Ian Hardy is redefining the phrase ‘hardy annual’. This visit is to defend an accusation of unfair dismissal (Judah). For a small organisation in a backwater, he manages to upset a lot of people, and is close to holding the record for most appearances from the minnow league. Other attendees today include: Big Difference Pty Ltd (Senior), Days Eggs Pty Ltd (Andrews), The Jewellery Group Pty Ltd (Foster), Richards (Green), University of Western Australia (Zarev), Wilson Security Pty Ltd (Loughnan), Kols Cleaning Services (Brown/Corbett), Sarina Russo Job Access (Australia) Pty Ltd (Kevin), The GEO Group Australia Pty Ltd (Ryan), Charles Sturt University (Lawless), BIC Services Pty Limited (Anastasiou), TNT Facility Management Pty Ltd (Edge), Sydney Trains (Yehia), WWRD Australia (Taouk), The Cancer Council NSW (Barr), Toll Transport Pty Ltd (Surjan/Kalfadopoulos), HNZ Australia Pty Ltd (Gorlin) and Geographe Real Estate Pty Ltd (Gillespie).

The aged care sector is again the predominant service industry represented in today’s unfair dismissal line-up at the Fair Work Commission. The representatives include RSL Care Ltd (Smith), Austin Health, St. John of God, Eastern Health (Burnett) and Heathcote Health (Walker). The other 22 entities on parade include: City Central Property Services Pty Ltd (Arthur), Days Eggs Pty Ltd (Andrews), AEM Consolidated Pty Ltd (Mugadza), Hobby Habit (Cook), Northside Community Service Limited (Petrelli), HNZ Australia Pty Ltd (Gorlin), Sesi Pty Ltd (Chant), The University of Sydney (Bao), Patterson Lakes Community Centre Inc (Backhaus), Evolution Traffic Control Pty Ltd (Burke), Comfort Delgro Cabcharge Pty Ltd (Row), Charles Sturt University (Lawless), Onesteel Wire Pty Ltd (Ross), Hickey Food Service (Brown), Scott Page Motor Body Repairs (Baker), LEDA Aluminium Pty Ltd (Chowdhury), Murrays Australia (Brackenrig), Aussie Cabinet Co Pty Ltd (Andrew), Sugar Research Australia (Lockett) and QGC Pty Ltd (Pyke).

TERMINATION OF EMPLOYMENT – misconduct – s.394 Fair Work Act 2009 – unfair dismissal application – applicant employed as team leader for City of Perth car parks – dismissed after independent investigation found falsified timesheet on five occasions – Commission found applicant wrongly indicated to respondent on two occasions that he had worked hours he had not worked – 28 minutes on one occasion and 1 hour and 51 minutes on another wrongly claimed – satisfied these actions constituted valid reason for dismissal – respondent undertook full investigation and applicant had full opportunity to respond – subsequent audit of other staff’s actual start and finish times compared to their rostered start and finish times identified some variance including some employees adopting practice of commencing work earlier than rostered start time and leaving earlier than rostered finish time – respondent’s decision not to take any disciplinary action against any staff but rather to only reinforce to them their obligations to adhere to rostered times not consistent with the manner in which it dealt with respondent – considering applicant’s eight years of service, respondent’s more lenient approach to other staff not working strictly in accordance with their rosters and the fact that on occasions applicant would undertake duties outside of his rostered hours, Commission concluded decision to dismiss harsh – satisfied dismissal unfair – noted that had the evidence before Commission supported a finding that all five allegations of wrongly claiming for time not worked were correct the dismissal would not have been unfair – application granted – reinstatement inappropriate – compensation appropriate – 25% reduction for misconduct in wrongly claiming hours – respondent ordered to pay compensation of 3 months remuneration less taxation. Casper v City of Perth.

TERMINATION OF EMPLOYMENT – Small Business Fair Dismissal Code – s.394 Fair Work Act 2009 – applicant dismissed for poor performance no written warning – not summary dismissal – Small Business Fair Dismissal Code did not apply as termination related to performance – Commission not satisfied problems with applicant’s performance – no valid reason for dismissal – considerable underpayment of wages – payment in lieu of notice insufficient to compensate for significant shortfall – termination harsh, unjust and unreasonable – reinstatement not appropriate – compensation appropriate – applicant attempted to mitigate loss – ordered compensation of $15,245.68 less tax. Christie v Kennedy’s Personal Training P/L t/a Kennedy’s Health and Fitness.

TERMINATION OF EMPLOYMENT – genuine redundancy – ss.389, 394 Fair Work Act 2009 – application for unfair dismissal remedy – applicant employed as Marketing Manager – respondent asserted dismissal a case of genuine redundancy – whether respondent compiled with consultation requirements – applicant submitted he fell within classification D.1.8 General Staff Level 5 in Educational Services (Post-Secondary Education) Award 2010- whether award applied – Commission found some aspects of applicant’s role administrative and fell within generic descriptors in classification – not satisfied Award applied – found respondent had no obligation to consult about making position redundant – no evidence any enterprise agreement applied – whether reasonable for applicant to be redeployed – what is reasonable has to be determined on case by case basis on objective facts – Commission found redeployment unreasonable – satisfied dismissal was genuine redundancy – application dismissed. Rahimi v Perth Education Group P/L t/a Technical College of Western Australia (TCWA).

TERMINATION OF EMPLOYMENT – performance – s.394 Fair Work Act 2009 – applicant performed duties as printing press operator since 2006 – applicant dismissed due to performance – respondent introduced new type of printing press to its operations in mid-2014 – all Printers given training – applicant received more training than any other Printer – applicant advised that his production was not up to the speed or standard required – applicant asked to be put with a more experienced assistant – respondent discussed setting the minimum acceptable standard as the average to which they would provide reports so t hat the applicant could identify any shortfalls in his performance compared to this standard – further meeting took place to discuss performance and employment – applicant dismissed – Commission found failure to meet the reasonable standard of performance the respondent required was a valid reason for his dismissal – satisfied dismissal was unfair – reinstatement not sought – respondent ordered to pay compensation of $2056, taxed accordingly. Gilbert v Picton Press P/L t/a Picton Press.

CONDITIONS OF EMPLOYMENT – redundancy – s.120 Fair Work Act 2009 – employer submitted employee entitled to 10 weeks redundancy pay having been employed for more than five years but less than six years – seeks to reduce employee redundancy entitlement to four weeks on the basis of having obtained ‘other acceptable employment’ – submitted redundancy came about through the non-renewal of the Wollongong outlet lease – further submitted on-going discussions with employee regarding the closure of the shop and discussed possible redeployment opportunities before the Wollongong store closed – employer offered two positions but employee declined both due to additional travel requirements and less responsibility – Hot Tuna considered – Commission found it clear that the employee was not aware her refusal to accept any alternate job offer would affect her redundancy entitlement – nor was she aware that if she secured work with an associated company her accrued entitlements would transfer – employer must demonstrate they have obtained other acceptable employment for the employee – positions offered to employee were acceptable and offered good career prospects but did not reflect full responsibilities of the redundant position and involved potential additional travel – Commission satisfied discretion available to reduce or eliminate its redundancy pay obligations to the employee should be exercised by reducing the entitlement to five weeks redundancy pay – order issued. The Trustee for Gruzin Family Trust and the Trustee for SWJ Investment Trust t/a Pointvale P/L & Performtech P/L v Thomson.