TERMINATION OF EMPLOYMENT – extension of time – date dismissal took effect – s.394 Fair Work Act 2009 – application for relief from unfair dismissal made 19 June 2015 – 39 days outside 21 days time limit – whether exceptional circumstances exist [Nulty] – dispute over when dismissal took effect – dismissal does not take effect unless and until communicated to employee who is dismissed [Burns] – applicant only became aware of dismissal on 1 June 2015 – Wilson relevant to communication of dismissal – applicant did not deliberately avoid receipt of termination letter – applicant’s illness weights in favour of being granted extension of time – found exceptional circumstances – Commission found application not out of time, in any case satisfied exceptional circumstances warranted applicant being allowed further period for application to be made. Curtis v Suncorp Staff P/L
November 20, 2015
TERMINATION OF EMPLOYMENT – misconduct – s.394 Fair Work Act 2009 – application for unfair dismissal remedy – applicant dismissed for serious misconduct – applicant employed as Train Driver Trainer – applicant failed to c heck whether co-driver was on board following a brief stoppage to check trains breaks – co-driver informed applicant she was going for a toiler break – applicant misinterpreted this to mean she would be using on board facilities – applicant unaware co-driver had left train – applicant could not locate driver after moving off again – co-driver was found walking along track several kilometres away – respondent launched investigation – respondent alleged serious safety breaches by applicant in violation of policies, procedures and Code of Conduct – respondent submitted two primary reasons for dismissal – leaving co-driver behind – speeding – Commission found first allegation not made out – second allegation was ‘one off incident’ – mitigating circumstances – criticism of employer’s handling of investigation – inconsistence treatment as co-driver not dismissed – applicant did not have any disciplinary history in over nine years of service – dismissal unfair – reinstatement sought – reinstatement not impracticable – loss of trust and confidence not established – reinstatement awarded – orders sought for continuity of services and lost remuneration – significant discount for lost remuneration due to breach of respondent’s safety policies – applicant awarded remuneration he would have otherwise earned by for dismissal – less 3-% – continuity of services recognised – orders made. White v Asciano Services P/L t/a Pacific National
November 20, 2015
GENERAL PROTECTIONS – costs – s.365 Fair Work Act 2009 – respondent claims application was commenced without proper basis and without reasonable cause and made vexatiously – respondent also claims that its legal costs were necessary and reasonable – Keep and Church considered – Commission was not satisfied application was made vexatiously – applicant believes the things he sought to assert as workplace rights were exactly that – no party represented in conference – application does not does not meet the criteria for the awarding of costs – application dismissed. Corcoran v Gamma Business Solutions P/L
November 20, 2015
TERMINATION OF EMPLOYMENT – misconduct – s.394 Fair Work Act 2009 – unfair dismissal application – applicant employed as apprentice butcher in final year of apprenticeship – applicant charged with being an accessory after the fact to murder – later granted bail – employer telephoned applicant’s mother to advise applicant’s employment was terminated – employer claimed employees would resign if required to work with applicant and customers would boycott store – employer claimed dismissal was consistent with Small Business Fair Dismissal Code because applicant had engaged in conduct that caused series and imminent risk to the reputation, viability or profitability of business – Commission accepted, at time of dismissal, employer believed applicant’s actions were sufficiently serious to justify immediate dismissal – not satisfied employer had reasonable grounds to form this belief – dismissal not consistent with Code – no presumption that a criminal conviction alone is a valid reason for termination – considered the shop was located in a small country town and applicant was the only named offended in the media – held there was a valid reason for dismissal but that the process of dismissal was at best deficient – applicant two-thirds of his through apprenticeship and had not secured alternative employment – although valid reason for dismissal applicant not afforded procedural fairness – reinstatement not appropriate – held dismissal was unfair – ordered compensation equivalent to six weeks’ wages. Deeth v Milly Hill P/L
November 20, 2015
TERMINATION OF EMPLOYMENT – minimum employment period – ss.384, 394 Fair Work Act 2009 – application for unfair dismissal remedy – applicant employed around May 2012 as casual bus driver pursuant to written contract – respondent raised jurisdictional objection that applicant had not completed minimum employment period – Commission noted applicant received work properly described as regular – key issue whether pattern of work systematic – Commission adopted in allocation of work during applicant’s employment – satisfied employment regular and systematic – per approach in Shortland, breaks in employment not during school holidays held not to count towards minimum employment period but periods when work allocated did count and could be added such that applicant completed six months regular and systematic employment – satisfied applicant had reasonable expectation of ongoing employment, notwithstanding express term to the contrary in written contract – minimum employment period completed – jurisdictional objection dismissed. Burke v Marist Brothers St Joseph’s College t/a St Joseph’s College
November 20, 2015
TERMINATION OF EMPLOYMENT – misconduct – ss.391, 394 Fair Work Act 2009 – team leader for rail related services organisation dismissed for serious and wilful misconduct including removing copper pipes without appropriate authorisation and using company time to do so – suspicion applicant had been preparing to steal copper pipes – employer must establish misconduct on balance of probabilities [Briginshaw] – dispute over extent to which employees should have engaged in work breaking down items – Commission satisfied applicant’s role allowed a level of discretion and judgement – satisfied when applicant undertook removal of copper pipes from test rig he was acting in manner considered properly within his discretion – satisfied no significant time pressure on employees – Commission not satisfied applicant’s conduct merited anything more than counselling or a warning – dismissal harsh, unjust or unreasonable – applicant reinstated – parties to agree on compensation amount for remuneration lost. Chandra v UGL Rail Fleet Services Ltd
November 20, 2015
TERMINATION OF EMPLOYMENT – extension of time – s.394 Fair Work Act 2009 – unfair dismissal application lodged 105 days out of time – whether exceptional circumstances exist – applicant suffered difficult personal circumstances – affected by mental illness – hospitalised for 20 day period – marriage broke down – applicant made several attempts to find accommodation – meaning of ‘exceptional circumstances’ considered [Nulty] – test for granting extension involves both broad discretion and high hurdle of exceptional circumstances [Lombardo] – applicant aware of statutory requirements – Commission prepared to accept 20 day period of hospitalisation amounted to exceptional circumstances however Commission found no other reasonable explanation for additional long periods of inactivity – applicant admitted to inappropriate and disrespectful conduct towards end of employment – applicant denied poor performance – Commission found case not without merit however no reasonable explanation why applicant did not lodge within first 11 days of dismissal – no exceptional circumstances found – application existed [Nulty] – extension of time granted. Shannon v Urban WA Real Estate P/L
November 20, 2015
TERMINATION OF EMPLOYMENT – valid reason – s.394 Fair Work Act 2009 – applicant dismissed for excessive personal use of phone and subsequent refusal to agree to repayment plan – international call costs incurred totalled $22,630 – Commission accepted applicant not aware of Acceptable Use Guideline but he was aware of IT policy – IT policy made argument that applicant had unlimited personal international phone calls untenable unfeasible – applicant originally warned rather than dismissed – respondent dismissed applicant when relationship reached point of breakdown – applicant’s refusal to repay money unreasonable – respondent had suggested a three year repayment plan but indicated openness to discuss alternatives – unreasonable of applicant not to enter into repayment agreement – valid reason for dismissal – applicant notified of reason and given opportunity to respond – no procedural deficiencies affected dismissal – Commission accepts that had applicant been notified earlier of excessive use he would not have accrued such a significant debt – respondent had attempted to negotiate over a nine month period – respondent acted reasonably in relation to matter while applicant’s position in relation to matter hardened – dismissal not unfair – applicant dismissed. Applicant v NBN Co Limited t/a NBN