Termination of employment – termination at initiative of employer – ss.394, 400, 604 Fair Work Act 2009 – permission to appeal – Full Bench – at first instance the Commission found that the employee had been dismissed and there was no valid reason for the termination of her employment – appellant submitted that too much weight was placed on the issue of family violence committed outside the workplace, that it acted reasonably and diligently in not terminating the employment of the employee’s former partner as requested – Full Bench found no issue of general application arising from the findings at first instance, and no issue of public interest – permission to appeal refused. Appeal by Eliana Construction and Developing Group P/L against decision of Roe C of 23 July 2015 [[2015] FWC 4864] Re: Moghimi
November 25, 2015
Anti-bullying – bullied at work – s.789FC Fair Work Act 2009 – application for an order to stop bullying – Commission to consider whether there was bullying conduct, whether alleged conduct by individuals formerly in the workplace is relevant and whether various conduct was reasonable management action – multiple and interrelated allegations considered against the evidence – Commission found some unreasonable conduct occurred – Commission to consider whether conduct created risk to health and safety – jurisdiction found – Commission to consider whether orders should be made – found that there have been significant subsequent positive developments in the workplace and that present circumstances of the applicant were uncertain – Commission not presently satisfied that orders can and should be made – further submissions sought. Ms LP
November 25, 2015
Patrick Stevedores Holdings Pty Ltd will dominate Fair Work portals with its army of disaffection (Ambrose, Freestone, Lucas, Sharp, Sotiri, Wright). Other alleged miscreants on parade include: On Track Community Programs (Minchinton), Alliance Paper Pty Ltd (Lawrence), The Trustee for Alliance Paper Products Unit Trust (Lawrence), Aurizon Operations Limited (Dissanayake), The Ranidash Pty Ltd (Kennedy), Cox Architecture Pty Ltd (Brazel), Scope Inc (Harris), Xmplar Building Solutions Pty Ltd (Hennigan), SA Group Enterprises Inc (Selth), Sonic Innovations Pty Ltd (Fleming), Marpav Pty Ltd (Harvey), Toll Transport Pty Ltd (Rafferty), Savannah Nickel Mines Pty Ltd (Wallis), Urban WA Real Estate Pty Ltd (Rowland), Sunny Sign Company Pty Ltd (Court), Wrightway Road Training Pty Ltd (Clifford-Smith), Jeremy J Hartley Pty Ltd (Erstich), Defence Housing Australia (Wilson), Blockbuster Redcliffe (Bradley), Moscou Holdings Pty Ltd ATF The Penguin Trust (Fields), The Greens NSW Inc (Medcalf), Australian Broadcasting Corporation (Tan), Jim Pearson Transport Pty Ltd (Luff) and Wyong Neighbourhood Centre Inc (Lambert).
November 24, 2015
The tourism sector is represented today by Jetstar Airways Pty Ltd (Anders) and Griffins Head Hotel Pty Ltd (Rungkat). Other entities facing unfair dismissal assertions include: GM Holden Ltd (Harvey), SACRT Trading Pty Ltd (Fleming), AGL Energy Limited (Poland), United Precast Pty Ltd (Collier), Only Floors (Hall), Dunbrae Pty Ltd (Figgins), Commonwealth of Australia (acting through and represented by the Department of Defence) (Jones), Millenium Coal Pty Ltd (Strack), Hans Setiawan (Thaha), Queensland Bulk Water Authority (Titmarsh), Savannah Nickel Mines Pty Ltd (Crowley), City of Perth (Frost), The Trustee for the Inkster Family (Hooper), YMCA WA (Thomas), Scho Homes Pty Ltd (Stevens), Downer EDI Engineering Power Pty Ltd (Burgess), Minnow’s Early Learning Pty Ltd (Balasupramaniam), EasyLift (Camilleri), Minifie Park Early Childhood Centre (Nicolaou), Commissioner for Public Enjoyment (Smith), MaxiTRANS Ltd (Valenzisi), Catholic Education Office, Archdiocese of Sydney (O’Connell), Endeavour Energy (Ee), New Horizons (Pass) and Pace Farm Pty Ltd (Galea).
November 23, 2015
The care sector is again over-represented in the Fair Work Commission with Eastern Health (Sirdesai) and Healthcare Procurement Partners Pty Ltd (Damms) being accused of unfair dismissals. Other employers facing similar allegations include: White Digital Pty Ltd (Isdale), Hunter Motor Group (Williams), Teys Australia Southers Pty Ltd (Chapman), Gilbarco Australia Pty Ltd (Sweet), Pro Floor (Tylor), Paradigm Cleaning & Professional Services Pty Ltd (Harland), Q Cam Processing Pty Ltd (Roberts), Plantman Equipment (Banda), Open University Australia Pty Ltd (Bianchi), Simplot Australia Pty Ltd (Ponnusamy), JaJa Pty Ltd (Karolczak), Tasmanian Posts Corporation Pty Ltd (Gee), Commissioner for Public Employment (Smith), Clarity CA Pty Ltd (Atkinson), Chi Kin Ken Ma (Te Rangipuawhe), Lakman Fernando Investments Pty Ltd (Brodie), Greencross Operations Pty Ltd (Kadhem), Croyberg Pty Ltd (Stevenson), Commissioner for Public Employment (Smith), Roo’s Consultants Pty Ltd (Dorsett), Signature Training Pty Ltd (Dorsett), Minnow’s Early Learning Pty Ltd (Balasupramaniam), BHP Billiton Cannington Pty Ltd (Turner), Australian Taxation Office (Rahman), Holman Webb Lawyers (Farrell), Southport Surf Lifesaving Club, Main Beach (Condren), A&S Ashen Family Trust (Fitzpatrick), North West Crewing Pty Ltd (Sullivan).
November 20, 2015
CASE PROCEDURES – appeals – OH&S review – cl.81 Offshore Petroleum and Greenhouse Gas Storage Act 2006 – r.53 Fair Work Commission Rules 2013 – application by Sedco seeking revocation of a decision by NOPSEMA to issue Improvement Notice 539 (IN 539) – application made pursuant to clause 81 of Schedule 3, Part 4, Division 5 of the OPGGS Act and rule 53 of the FWC Rules – important to note that Sedco has undertaken the work required under IN 539 – parties did not agree to the approach to be adopted by the Commission in hearing the application, and consequently, the appropriate questions to be determined – Sedco submitted that the Commission was required to consider the OHS Inspector’s decision and exercise of discretion to issue IN 539 as at the date of the hearing – NOPSEMA submitted that the Commission was required when considering the OHS Inspector’s exercise of discretion to issue IN 539, to adopt a ‘historical assessment’ – the nature of the appeal must ultimately depend on the terms of the statute conferring the right [Coldhan] – when exercising its powers a Tribunal required t pay ‘attention to the state of affairs existing at the time the Tribunal makes its decision’ [Shi] – OPGGS Act does not explicitly set out the approach to be adopted by the Commission – appropriate to consider the nature of decisions which can be made by OHS inspectors and the powers of the Commission as a reviewing authority – issuance of an improvement notice is not automatic or mandatory, inspector required to exercise a discretion – Sedco’s approach to the hearing was not whether the inspector had a ‘requisite reasonable belief’, but whether the Commission, at the time of the hearing, is satisfied on reasonable grounds the Sedco was contravening the OPGGS Act – appeal by Sedco not a review in the ordinary sense, but a fresh application for the Commission to determine a matter at the time of the hearing – approach appears to be inappropriate, and somewhat artificial – the Commission was being asked to make a determination on the inspector’s decision on the basis of circumstances which he could not possibly be aware of at the time he made the declaration – Commission has wide powers of determination of the matter – tests for the issuing of an improvement notice must be in accordance with the statute – satisfied that the decision to issue an improvement notice is ‘time specific’ to an inspection being carried out, based on reasonable grounds – satisfied that the Commission, as the reviewing authority, is required to consider an OHS Inspector’s decision at the time it was made – questions for determination will be those set out by NOPSEMA. Sedco Forex International Inc v National Offshore Petroleum Safety and Environmental Management Authority t/a NOPSEMA
November 20, 2015
TERMINATION OF EMPLOYMENT – extension of time – s.394 Fair Work Act 2009 – application for relief from unfair dismissal – application lodged out of time – applicant submitted application was delayed due to chronic morning sickness – respondent submitted applicant resigned from her employment – Commission found applicant’s illness left her incapable of filing application – on evidence presented, there was a prima facie case applicant did not resign from her employment – exceptional circumstances.
November 20, 2015
TERMINATION OF EMPLOYMENT – genuine redundancy – ss.389, 394 Fair Work Act 2009 – application for unfair dismissal remedy – applicant a ‘Supply Base Operator’ (SBO) performing transport and logistics services on Barrow Island – respondent in joint venture as part of Grogon Project – contract with venture partner provided that respondent held ‘town hall’ session with workforce prior to receiving such direction – found to have satisfied consultation obligation – applicant’s position of Warehouse SBO subsequently made redundant – respondent reviews available positions were unsuitable – applicant informed by telephone – content of telephone discussion disputed by parties – two positions considered, requiring specific licences – applicant conceded did not possess necessary licence for one position- found respondent came to wrong conclusion regarding applicant not holding licence for the other – held on basis of what respondent knew at time this was reasonable conclusion – position required experienced driver and was not a ‘fly-in, fly-out’ (FIFO) role – redeployment would have necessitated relocation to Sydney from Perth – Commission found redeployment not reasonable – dismissal was genuine redundancy – application dismissed. Kloczonek v Toll Energy Logistics P/L