Termination of employment – genuine redundancy – ss.389, 394 Fair Work Act 2009 – respondent submitted that applicant was terminated because of inability and/or unwillingness to learn other duties and because there was no need for a full time employee doing the job that the applicant had been doing – respondent contended that the decision was taken after the applicant broke her ankle and was absent on personal leave – during applicant’s leave other employees performed applicant’s role in addition to their own jobs – respondent decided that applicant was not needed on that basis – applicant submitted that her job still existed despite it being spread around other employees – applicant submitted that a new staff member was employed to perform her role – Ulan Coal Mines considered – if there was no longer any function or duty to be performed by that person, his or her position becomes redundant – Commission satisfied that applicant’s role became redundant – applicant covered by modern award – respondent failed to comply with consultation requirements of modern award – respondent’s failure to consult meant that dismissal was not a case of genuine redundancy – Commission satisfied that termination unjust, as applicant denied an opportunity to discuss redundancy of her position and alternatives to termination – respondent ordered to pay applicant compensation of $5,472 taxed at the appropriate rate. Wright v Victorian Container Management P/L
December 10, 2015
Termination of employment – performance – s.394 Fair Work Act 2009 – applicant employed as a Crane Operator/Deck Pusher for 25 years – was operating a crane on an offshore drillship the Deepwater Millennium when another member of his work group was injured – the master link, weighing 32kg, fell approximately 60cm onto the worker’s foot – respondent investigations concluded that the root causes of the incident were that there was a failure to identify relevant hazards because there was no adequately risk assessment of the task, a simple lift checklist was not completed as required, and planning and communication was inadequate and ineffective – applicant dismissed – Commission found the applicant did not comply with the respondent’s safety policies as he was required to – two prior instances where applicant had been warned about unsatisfactory performance relevant – found valid reason for dismissal – dismissal not harsh, unjust or unreasonable – dismissal not unfair – application dismissed. Sakadakis v Sedco Forex International Inc
December 10, 2015
Anti-bullying – costs – ss.402, 611, 789FC Fair Work Act 2009 – respondents claimed costs on the ground that the applicant’s anti-bullying application was vexatious and without reasonable cause – applicant submitted well within her rights to make s.789FC application – reasonable clause to instigate application – Commission considered question of self-represented parties being entitled to costs – referred to decisions in Baker and Keep – Commission held it was entirely appropriate that applicants discontinued their applications given respondents were no longer on management committee and did not have cause to come into contact with applicants – although merits of application not finally determined applicants demonstrated applications were made with reasonable cause – not reasonably apparent that no prospect of success – considered meaning of vexatious – Commission not satisfied applications were made vexatiously – discretion to make order for costs not enlivened – application dismissed. Woods and Anor v Collie Chamber of Commerce and Industry Inc. t/a Collie CCI and Ors
December 10, 2015
Termination of employment – application to dismiss by employer – deed of settlement – s.394 Fair Work Act 2009 – parties reached settlement agreement at conciliation – applicant confirmed acceptance of offer via email – parties exchanged emails about terms of draft Statement of Service – terms of settlement not signed – respondent submitted applicant’s claim was extinguished – applicant’s representative advised agreement was in-principle and not binding – respondent evidenced settlement monies paid to applicant – applicant’s representative stated payment was unsolicited – if there is a binding agreement between parties to an unfair dismissal application, then application has no reasonable prospects of success and may be dismissed [Gorman] – Commission found binding agreement reached, however while applicant received the monies payable under the terms of settlement, she had not received the Statement of Service – matter not dismissed at this time – if respondent provides applicant with Statement of Service within seven days application will be dismissed. Lombardo v The West Australian Newspaper
December 10, 2015
Termination of employment – extension of time – representative error – s.394 Fair Work Act 2009 – application for unfair dismissal remedy – application lodged two days outside of statutory time limit – applicant submitted delay result of representative error – applicant dismissed on the basis of unsubstantiated allegations of misconduct – Nulty considered – Commission found circumstances that could be regarded as exceptional so as to support an extension of time – extension of time granted – application referred for conciliation. Selth v SA Group Enterprises Inc
December 10, 2015
Unions have told a Victorian inquiry into the labour hire industry there needs to be tougher regulations on labour hire companies, because an increasing number are simply going into liquidation when they cannot pay staff what they are owed. The National Union of Workers claims one former labour hire company in Geelong owes poultry workers as much as $20,000, but has gone into liquidation and the company director cannot be contacted. Tim Gooden from the Geelong Trades Hall Council said it was becoming increasingly difficult to chase other small labour hire companies suspected of underpaying staff. Mr Gooden said he had seen it twice this year, as well as at other workplaces he had not dealt with personally. “It’s becoming a very common tactic, to operate out of the boot of your car, sell workers, skim off the top, pocket the money and then when you’re challenged under the laws of the land, go into liquidation and disappear,” he said.
December 10, 2015
Owners of a Berwick service station have been fined almost $100,000 for underpaying two Indian workers as little as $10 an hour. Fair Work Ombudsman Natalie James found workers at the BP station on Clyde Rd were underpaid more than $111,800 between 2008 and 2012. They have since been back-paid. The Federal Circuit Court fined Liquid Fuel Pty Ltd $79,537 over the matter. Husband-and-wife managers Xin Zhang and Linda Qu were each fined $4504 and Ms Qu’s father Nian Li, the company director, was fined $3861. The court heard one of the workers was financially supporting his wife and daughter and said the low wages made it “very hard to survive”. He said there were times he had to borrow money to pay his rent. Ms James said the underpayments were “blatant exploitation” and described the overseas workers, who are now Australian citizens, as “vulnerable”.
December 10, 2015
Icon Water has rejected claims it appears to be making people redundant based on their age. The utility company was in the process of making 10 jobs redundant as part of a larger restructure that will see up to 50 positions culled. The company has extended the redundancy consultation process which will mean staff will not exit the organisation until the first week of February. The Professionals Australia union’s ACT director David Smith said Icon Water had not outlined which other organisations it had benchmarked itself against to inform the restructure. He had asked Chief Minister Andrew Barr to intervene on behalf of the ACT community to find out how services will be affected by the trimming of the workforce.