NEWS HR

TERMINATION OF EMPLOYMENT – misconduct – s.394 Fair Work Act 2009 – application for relief from unfair dismissal – applicant employed as a prison officer at Acacia Prison – dismissed following an investigation into four allegations of misconduct – initial investigation into allegations conducted by respondent – following the lodgement of a dispute notification with the Commission, Resilience Solutions P/L (Resilience) appointed to investigate – respondent argued that the four breaches caused serious safety risks to other Acacia employees, prisoners and the general public – Commission not satisfied the applicant’s conduct was of the kind likely to cause such risks – not satisfied that the actions of the applicant caused ‘serious reputational damage and risk to the profitability of Serco’s business’ – Resilience concluded that, based on her interview, the applicant failed to understand and appreciate the wider implications of security related breaches, Commission found merit in this conclusion – not satisfied that there was a valid reason for summary dismissal for serious misconduct – found summary dismissal was a disproportionate response to the misconduct occurred – satisfied that the summary dismissal for misconduct was harsh, unjust or unreasonable – however, satisfied there was sufficient material on which the respondent could determine there was a valid reason for the termination of the applicant’s employment with notice – dismissal with notice would not have been harsh, unjust or unreasonable – respondent ordered to pay compensation of an amount equal to the quantum of notice that would have been properly paid to the applicant had her employment been terminated with notice – accrued long service leave should also be paid – both amounts should be paid with interest. Fallens v Serco Australia P/L t/a Serco Acacia Prison.

TERMINATION OF EMPLOYMENT – contractor or employee – ss.394, 400, 604 Fair Work Act 2009 – permission to appeal – Full Bench – appeal against decision at first instance that appellant was not an employee – Full Bench considered whether grounds of appeal attracted public interest – at first instance Commission held nature of relationship between appellant and respondent was one of principal and independent contractor, rather than employer and employee – Full Bench held appeal did not give rise to any public interest considerations and Commission had made no significant error of fact – permission to appeal refused. Appeal by Marya against decision of Gregory C of 8 September 2015 [[2015] FWC 6135] Re: Network Transport Services P/L.

INDUSTRIAL ACTION – order against industrial action – ss.418, 604 Fair Work Act 2009 – permission to appeal – Full Bench – at first instance the Commission ordered that industrial action stop – employees of ASP who are members of The Maritime Union of Australia (MUA) and who were allegedly refusing to perform work as directed so as to enable the vessel named MV Portland to sail from Portland, Victoria, to Singapore – grounds of appeal advanced included that the Commissioner erred in finding the refusal of employees to perform work was industrial action, finding the industrial action was being organised by the MUA and finding the direction of the respondent sail the MV Portland to Singapore for hand over to the new owner was a lawful, or a reasonable direction – the nature of appeal against an order under s.418 of the FW Act requires the establishment of a House v The Kind error [MUA v Patrick Stevedores Holdings] – Full Bench held that as none of the grounds of appeal appeared to have substance it was not appropriate to grant permission to appeal – permission to appeal refused – stay order made on 19 November 2015 discharged [PR574155]. Appeal by The Maritime Union of Australia against decision of Cambridge C of 17 November 2015 [[2015] FWC 7898] Re: ASP Ship Management P/L.

TERMINATION OF EMPLOYMENT – discontinuance – s.394 Fair Work Act 2009 – application for relief from unfair dismissal – on 17 November 2015 the respondent advised the Commission that the parties had reached an in principle settlement and on the same day , the applicant filed a notice of discontinuance – on 19 November 2015 the applicant advised the Commission that he had filed the notice of discontinuance by mistake and under extreme duress – he said he was not in a fit or proper state of mind when he filed the notice of discontinuance and asked that his application be reopened – Commission does not have the power to set aside a notice of discontinuance and that any such application would need to be made to the Court [AB v Tabcorp Holding Limited] – filing a notice of discontinuance does not preclude the filing of a further unfair dismissal application [Narayan] – application to set aside the notice of discontinuance dismissed. McCaig v DP World Melbourne Limited t/a DP World Melbourne.

A Christchurch woman who was accused of shopping online on company time has been awarded $8000 in lost wages and compensation. Victoria Self was employed by consultancy firm Receivables Management Limited (RML) in 2014, but was unjustifiably dismissed by her employer just over a month later. Her 90-day employment trial was cut short after colleagues reported to managers that she was “always” on Trade Me and personal internet sites. Following her dismissal, the case was taken to the Employment Relations Authority which found the company breached conditions of trial provisions and has since been ordered to pay compensation on the grounds of humiliation and to make up lost wages. Self claims she was denied a “dignified exit” and “humiliated in front of other staff members” following an unexpected termination letter. She said her manager Ross Fleming forced her to pack up her belongings and leave the company premises after a brief meeting. Self, who worked with the consultancy firm in 2014 between July and August, said she was unjustifiably disadvantaged as the company failed to comply with its human resources policy. RML denied this, adding that Self did not sign an IEA employment contract when she started the job.

A university has allegedly let two staff ‘go’, and now the pair are seeking continued tenure via an application to the Fair Work Commission. Other entities on parade today include: Queensland Rail Limited (Engeln), ISS Integrated Services Pty Ltd (Vandenheuval), Inghams Enterprise Pty Ltd (Wong), Savannah Nickel Mines Pty Ltd (Wallis), Golden Dragon Palace (Hui), BBX Australia (Jones), Ron Finemore Transport Services Pty Ltd (Singh), Brandison Pty Ltd (Andrews), Reinforced Concrete Pipes Australia (Hunt), Carrera Total Pty Ltd (Saleski), Zest Pty Ltd (Scolyer), The University of Western Australia (Ardagh), Serco Australia Pty Ltd (William), Professionals Australia (Schlumberger), Manbulloo Ltd (Bransby), Absolute Caulker Pty Ltd (Georgeson), The University of Western Australia (Zarev).

Enterprise agreements – dispute about matter arising under agreement – s.739 Fair Work Act 2009 – application concerning a dispute as to the performance of duties by employees in senior staff positions – relevant agreement the Schweppes Australia Huntingwood (NSW) Enterprise Agreement 2013-2016 – Schweppes maintained that while the ‘Manufacturing Supervisor’ position is not covered by the Agreement, relief machine duties may be performed in order to ensure that line operation is continuous – submitted that nothing in the Agreement prevents this – United Voice submitted the Commission should stop the performance of such work as it is covered by the Agreement and should only be performed by Agreement covered employees – contended this is consistent with the intention of parties as well as custom and practice on site – Schweppes submitted that the Commission did not have jurisdiction to arbitrate the dispute as it concerns work of employees not covered by Agreement – Commission satisfied it has jurisdiction to make an order to settle dispute – Wanneroo and Golden Cockerel applied – Commission found that while the Agreement does not apply to managerial staff, it also does not describe or restrict work done by them – no provision that only Agreement covered employees can perform production work – held that while the delineation between agreement covered work and managerial staff work may have changed, it has not been substantiated as contrary to the Agreement – given the content of the Agreement, Commission not satisfied the order sought by United Voice is appropriate – application dismissed. United Voice v Schweppes Australia P/L

Case procedures – costs – ss.375B, 604, 611 Fair Work Act 2009 – application for costs by respondent – applicant made application for Commission to deal with a general protections dispute involving dismissal – application was dismissed as it was filed outside of statutory time limit and no exceptional circumstances existed – application sought permission to appeal – matter listed for hearing on whether permission should be granted – applicant requested, and was granted, an extension of time in which to file submissions – applicant subsequently discontinued application – respondent sought costs – respondent submitted that neither of the errors of fact cited by the applicant were errors of fact – respondent submitted that the fact the appeal was discontinued two days prior to hearing is evidence that appeal had no prospects of success – applicant submitted she sincerely believed application had merit and was in public interest – applicant submitted she discontinued application because of cost of legal representation and deteriorating mental health – Commission not satisfied that application for permission to appeal made vexatiously or without reasonable cause – Commission not persuaded costs were incurred because of an unreasonable act or omission – application for costs dismissed. Noronha-Barrett v Australian National University