INDUSTRIAL DISPUTE – stand down – ss.524, 526 Fair Work Act 2009 – applicants stood down by respondent in 2014 – applicants employment terminated in 2015 – period between stand down and termination applicants received no pay – applications made after termination of employment and not at time of stand down – respondent exercised jurisdiction issue – whether applicants are within scope of s.526 FW Act – applicants must be within meaning of s.526(3)(a) – parties unable to direct Commission to any authorities where application under s.526(3) of FW Act was made by former employee – Fair Work Bill 2009 Explanatory Memorandum considered relating to operation of s.526 – at time of application employee must be experiencing or about to experience consequences of stand down – applicants had opportunity between stand down and termination to complain about stand down and chose not to do so – applicants now seeking to recover underpayment of wages – Commission does not have jurisdiction to deal with underpayment of wages – Commission concluded respondent’s jurisdictional objection upheld and applicants applications dismissed. Schell and Anor v Ensign Australia P/L.
January 18, 2016
TERMINATION OF EMPLOYMENT – remedy – ss.392, 394 Fair Work Act 2009 – Commission previously found applicant had been unfairly dismissed – reinstatement not an option given the nature of the relationship between the parties – parties made further submissions on the matter of compensation for decision to be heard on the papers – Sprigg formula adopted – no submission on effect of the order on the viability of the employer – length of service in dispute – applicant mitigated loss by finding alternative employment – Commission satisfied applicant would have been employed for a further six months if not for the dismissal – order for compensation in the sum of @2,936, being the loss of earnings incurred by applicant in the 26 weeks following dismissal – order issued. Peterson v TCB Trading P/L, TCB (CIB) P/L, Security Logistics Australia P/L.
January 18, 2016
TERMINATION OF EMPLOYMENT – extension of time – s.394 Fair Work Act 2009 – application for relief from unfair dismissal – application lodged 508 days after dismissal took effect – applicant last performed work in April 2014 – lodged Workcover claim, claim rejected, appeal lodged against decision and appeal upheld in February 2015 – there are no exceptional circumstances found given the length of time that has elapsed – Commission found applicant’s case is without merit or lacking any substance [Kornicki v Telstra-Network Technology Group] – Commission refused application for an extension of time – jurisdictional objection upheld – application for an unfair dismissal remedy dismissed. Saeed v Wild Breads P/L.
January 18, 2016
CASE PROCEDURES – evidence – production of documents – ss.394, 590 Fair Work Act 2009 – application for issue of orders for production of documents against six persons and entities – respondent seeking medical documents – Commission satisfied orders sought by respondent have apparent relevance to matters requiring determination – critical question of whether applicant was under influence of drugs or alcohol at time of dismissal – definition of term “document” provided in Evidence Act 1995 (Cth) considered – consideration of whether orders should relate to records of any drugs, or only synthetic drugs – Commission satisfied material sought could reasonably assist on issues in proceedings – Commission found appropriate in all circumstances for orders to be made to wider class of drugs, not only synthetic drugs. Wright v AGL Loy Yang P/L.
January 18, 2016
Twenty-nine applications (unfair dismissal/dispute/appeals) will be heard today in the Fair Work Commission. The attendees list is as follows: Harbourtown Tyre and Battery Pty Ltd (Gottwald); Metro Express Trransport Group (Harris); Toft Endurance Pty Ltd (Barnard); ALH Group Pty Ltd (Faulkner); Central Queensland University (Potter); Central Queensland University (Potter); MSD Wholesale Pty Ltd (Pithia); MSS Security Pty Ltd (Singh); On Track Community Programs (Bridge); Reddy Security Services (Buckley); Grippsland Group training Ltd t/as Apprenticeship Group Australia (Russell); Ruis Transport Services Pty Ltd (Mahoney); Qube Ports Pty Ltd (Goodwin); Sibelco Australia Limited (Medlicott); PCYC Newcastle (Armstrong); Goulburn Mulwaree Council (Cooper); Central Queensland University (Potter); Flight Attendants’ Association of Australia – International Division (Fed) (Diack); Eastern Health (Armstrong); Commonwealth of Australia (Australian Taxation Office) (Shamir); Spotless (Sheikh-Abdi); Rinnai Australia (Cooke); Graham A Ryan (Di Pietro); Karingal Inc (Carroll); Bendingo Kangan Institute (Dixon); A Whole New Approach Pty Ltd (GM Holden Ltd); GM Holden Ltd (Newbond); Grippsland Group training Ltd t/as Apprenticeship Group Australia (Russell); and Commonwealth of Australia (acting through and represented by the Department of Defence) (Maddison).
January 15, 2016
TERMINATION OF EMPLOYMENT – performance – s.394 Fair Work Act 2009 – applicant summarily dismissed – received three written reprimands regarding work performance – respondent submitted applicant’s employment terminated for dereliction of duty and gross misconduct – further verbal warnings issued to applicant in relation to work performance – Commission considered if dismissal was harsh, unjust or unreasonable – respondent bears onus of establishing serious misconduct that justifies summary termination – test of whether employer can demonstrate reasonable grounds for holding belief employee guilty of misconduct that justifies summary termination – test of whether employer can demonstrate reasonable grounds for holding belief employee guilty of misconduct [Harley] – valid reason is one which is sound, defensible or well-founded but not capricious, fanciful, spiteful or prejudiced [Selvachandran] – issue separate from determination if termination was harsh, just or unreasonable [Toby] – provisions must ‘be applied in a practical, common sense way to ensure that the employer and employee are each treated fairly'[Selvachandran] – valid reason required consideration in establishing fairness of termination [Wililo] – Commission found valid reason existed for applicant’s termination – procedural fairness requires employee opportunity to respond before decision to terminate [Crozier] – applicant put on notice with respect to work standard before termination – applicant unaware of two issues that led to dismissal – failure of procedural fairness not found – Commission not satisfied termination of employment was not unfair – determination of dismissal was harsh, unjust or unreasonable notwithstanding the existence of a valid reason involves a weighing process [Australian Postal Corporation] – Commission concluded termination was not harsh, unjust or unreasonable – application dismissed. Cockroft v InterPark Australia P/L t/a InterPark Australia.
January 15, 2016
TERMINATION OF EMPLOYMENT – costs – ss.400A, 611 fair Work Act 2009 – application for costs by respondent in dismissal matter – unfair dismissal application dismissed – applicant sought permission to appeal – appeal refused – respondent submitted it incurred costs because of multiple unreasonable acts by applicant when they failed to accept settlement offers – respondent sought costs – Commission has power to award costs where first party causes other party to incur costs because of an unreasonable act or omission – factors to consider include outcome of application, frequency of offers, whether settlement discussions were made early enough to minimise or mitigate costs and whether first party was advised by other party that they would be seeking costs – Commission satisfied applicant aware employer intended to pursue costs – Commission satisfied applicant unreasonably rejected $25,000 offer – Commission satisfied applicant caused costs to be incurred by employer because of unreasonable act of failing to agree to terms of settlement – Commission not prepared to order applicant to pay all costs – respondent directed to file and serve itemised schedule of costs by 7 December 2015. Nesbitt v Dragon Mountain Gold Limited.
January 15, 2016
TERMINATION OF EMPLOYMENT – Small Business Fair Dismissal Code – s.394 fair Work Act 2009 – respondent alleged applicant stole $200 from safe drop – contended this amounted to serious misconduct justifying summary dismissal – applicant denied theft – submitted during shift they noticed amount in safe was $200 over docket total – applicant informed respondent and was told it should be $400 over – applicant summarily dismissed – not suggested anyone else took money – Pinawin applied – found respondent clearly and unequivocally held belief applicant stole money – respondent’s suspicion applicant was stealing money held to have crystallised into a belief in theft when informed safe drop was $200 over – respondent went to considerable lengths to satisfy itself as to correct amount left in safe, attending shop on night before applicant commenced work – Commission satisfied respondent’s belief reasonable in circumstances – dismissal consistent with Small Business fair Dismissal Code – application dismissed. Glass v Boss J Holdings P/L t/a Foodworks Fuel Bacchus Marsh.