TERMINATION OF EMPLOYMENT – unlawful termination – extension of time – s.773 Fair Work Act 2009 – application to deal with unlawful termination dispute made 130 days’ late – applicant submitted reasons for delay were to provide evidence position remained unfilled, recovering from surgery, representative occupied with carer and work duties and lack of understanding of rights – Commission found waiting for evidence not acceptable reason – had option of lodging before surgery and no evidence so incapacitated in 12 week period that unable to make application – could have chosen another representative – not understanding rights a common circumstance – not satisfied acceptable reasons for delay – not satisfied of exceptional circumstances – application dismissed. Vuleta v West Australian Turf Club t/a Perth Racing WA
January 19, 2016
ENTERPRISE AGREEMENTS – greenfields agreement – approval – s.185 Fair Work Act 2009 – decision previously published to approve agreement after being opposed by CFMEU – Commission indicated reasons to follow – CFMEU involved in negotiations for new enterprise agreement – CFMEU opposed approval – claimed not a genuine new enterprise and companies not engaged in joint venture – further claimed approval of agreement contrary to public interest and raised issue with signature requirements – Commission held employment of workers was for preparatory work – satisfied companies engaged in joint venture and nothing artificial or contrary to public interest – Commission satisfied with corrected signature page provided by applicant – dismissed objections of CFMEU – application approved. NorthConnex/AWU Civil Works Greenfield Agreement 2015-2019.
January 19, 2016
Termination of employment – extension of time – s.394 Fair Work Act 2009 – application for relief from unfair dismissal – application lodged 5 years outside statutory time limit – reason for delay included distress and illness – applicant aware of dismissal in 2010 and disputed application by lodging this application – prejudice to respondent neutral consideration – merit was a negative issue as application considered to be lodged in wrong jurisdiction – no issue as to fairness with any other person in similar position – applicant’s circumstances not out of ordinary, unusual, special or uncommon – Commission not satisfied exceptional circumstances exist – application dismissed. Gollan v Willoughby SES
January 19, 2016
Case procedures – application dismissed on FWC’s own initiative – ss.394, 399A, 593 Fair Work Act 2009 – application for unfair dismissal remedy – respondent lodged objection to application pursuant to ss.399A and 593 of FW Act – respondent stated applicant was dismissed for serious misconduct involving alleged theft – respondent advised it did not want matter heard until criminal matter relating to theft heard in Magistrate’s Court – criminal matter adjourned several times – applicant ultimately plead guilty and convicted – Commission contacted applicant on a number of occasions – applicant failed to comply with directions – Commission held application had no reasonable prospect of success and should be dismissed – satisfied dismissal was fair and complied with the Small Business Fair Dismissal Code – application dismissed. Box v Marshall Security Service P/L t/a Marshall Security Service
January 19, 2016
A heavy preponderance of today’s 33 employment challenges emanate from the care sector. The biggest contributor is Anglican Aged Care Services Group with five claims. The full list is: Copper Refineries Pty Ltd (Dennien), Metro Assist Inc (Cao), Sydney Trains (Cameron), Pacific National (NSW) Pty Ltd (Rich), Sushi Tribe Pty Ltd (Foster), Tony and Guy Leichhardt (Farshadi), Salsas Pty Ltd (Grafton), Startrack Express (Swan), Metro Trains Melbourne Pty Ltd (Wintle), Toll Transport Pty Ltd (Staniforth-Smith), SolarisCare Foundation Ltd (Gugiatti), Hampton Transport Services Pty Ltd (McMillan), Youngs WA Pty Ltd (Fishbourne), Anglican Aged Care Services Group (Kellett/Kidman/Dakenfull/Elwood/Nally), BNR Logistics Pty Ltd (Leota), Patterson Lakes Community Centre Inc (Rimmer), Moran Management (Burd), Karingal Inc (Carroll), Eastern Health (Kanyua), Territory Transit (Shukri), ACE Insurance Limited (Filer), Medibank Health Solutions Telehealth Pty Ltd (Smith), Australian Telecommunications Solutions (Maris), Busiko’s Pharmacy (Bradshaw), LBS Accountants (McDowall), Blue Care (Woolston) and GM Holden Ltd (Harvey).
January 19, 2016
The National Offshore Petroleum Safety and Environmental Management Authority is being challenged (rule 58 – application to review other decision) by Technip Oceania Pty Ltd in the Fair Work Commission this morning.
January 18, 2016
ENTERPRISE AGREEMENTS – dispute about matter arising under agreement – s.739 Fair Work Act 2009 – employees received letter from employer on 13 October 2015 advising them their “substantive position is access to Essential Energy’s business requirements and you will be redeployed effective 19 October 2015” – letter provided employees two options to “no longer attend for work, as there is no meaningful work for you to perform” and “complete a four week career transition program” – parties agreed question for Commission to answer “is Essential Energy entitled (under the Essential Energy Enterprise Agreement 2013 and the Management of Surplus Employees Policy dated 20 November 2013) to issue a direction to redeployees not to attend for work in circumstances where it asserts there is no meaningful work placement (as defined in the Policy)?” – unions submit direction to “no longer attend for work” is inconsistent with Policy which requires, Essential Energy place employees “into a meaningful work placement” – respondent submits nothing in the Agreement displaces the common law rights including there is no obligation on Essential Energy to provide work – extent that the Policy imposes a requirement on Essential Energy to place a redeployee into a “meaningful work placement”, such obligation does not require Essential Energy to create a new position and is limited to instances where a “meaningful work placement” is available – Commission found the answer to question agreed by parties to be no – respondent is restrained from giving effect to any direction, given to employees it has described as “redeployees in underfunded positions” on 13 October 2015, that they not attend for work and must place employees subject of the direction in a meaningful work placement as defined by the Management of Surplus Employees Policy – order issued. Australian Municipal, Administrative, Clerical and Services Union, Communications, Electrical, Electronic, Energy, Information, Postal, Plumbing and Allied Services Union of Australia, Association of Professional Engineers, Scientists and Managers v Essential Energy.
January 18, 2016
ENTERPRISE AGREEMENTS – dispute about matter arising under agreement – s.739 Fair Work Act 2009 – dispute concerned whether respondent required to pay applicant on occasion where he attended mine site for an OHS meeting which was cancelled – applicant previously paid four hours overtime in manner consistent with cl.11.2 (recall) for attending meetings – applied principles of Golden Cockerel – applicant was not instructed to attend in accordance with cl.11.2 – applicant’s argument based on fact he had been paid four hours in the past – argument did not assist with interpretation of clause of agreement – language not susceptible to more than one meaning – no regard to subjective intentions of parties – applicant not entitled to payment for voluntary attendance – application dismissed. Construction, Forestry, Mining and Energy Union v Leighton Contractors P/L.