TERMINATION OF EMPLOYMENT – application to dismiss by employer – deed of settlement – ss.394, 587 Fair Work Act 2009 – respondent applied to have unfair dismissal application dismissed on basis that parties had reached a binding settlement agreement and therefore application had no reasonable prospects of success – issue in dispute was whether employee authorised representative from Australian Workers’ Union (AWU) to put offer of settlement to respondent’s representative – applicant refused to sign deed of release and sought to continue with application – Commission preferred AWU representative’s evidence which was supported by contemporaneous file notes – AWU had no cause to settle matter without instructions – Commission did not accept that AWU’s failure to provide a copy of the deed meant no agreement, nor did absence of written communication between AWU and applicant mean no agreement – Commission satisfied that a binding agreement had been reached of either the type in category 1 or 2 of Masters v Cameron – offer made by AWU accepted and a final document agreed between representatives – clear that a completed agreement was not conditional on an agreement being signed [Zoiti-Licstro v ATO] – a valid and effective accord and satisfaction extinguishes a pre-existing cause of action and continued pursuit of application based on such a cause may be considered without reasonable prospects of success [Australian Postal Corporation v Gorman] – Commission satisfied that a binding agreement was made and unfair dismissal application had no reasonable prospects of success – Commission exercised discretion under s.587 to dismiss application. Nolan v Benedict Recycling P/L t/a Bendedict Recycling P/L
July 15, 2016
TERMINATION OF EMPLOYMENT – Small Business Fair Dismissal Code – s.394 Fair Work Act 2009 – application for unfair dismissal remedy – applicant suffered a non-work related injury which prevented her from performing work and sent her medical certificate to the respondent – applicant submitted that when she told the respondent he suggested she should resign – applicant told respondent she did not intend to resign – respondent told applicant he was not going to terminate her employment and that before she returns to work she would need a fitness for work certificate – applicant continued to provide medical certificates – she provided respondent with an expected return to work date – respondent did not respond – applicant tried to call respondent multiple times and get in contact with him via email to confirm when she could come back to work and he did not provide an answer – applicant sent a final email stating if she didn’t receive a reply she will come to the conclusion she has been dismissed – respondent did not respond to this email – applicant subsequently filed an unfair dismissal application – Commission found that as applicant was ready to return to work and respondent failed to respond, this was a repudiation of contract by the employer was termination of employment – Commission prepared to accept unchallenged evidence that employer was a small business – no evidence on which to conclude respondent believed on reasonable grounds that applicant conduct was sufficiently serious to justify immediate dismissal and therefore Commission found Small Business Fair Dismissal Code had no application – termination harsh, unjust and unreasonable – reinstatement not sought – ordered compensation of $4230.80 taxed according to law, and $401.92 for superannuation. Hayes v Austrend International P/L
July 15, 2016
TERMINATION OF EMPLOYMENT – misconduct – s.394 Fair Work Act 2009 – application for unfair dismissal remedy – applicant dismissed for breaching Australian Public Service Code of Conduct (the Code) – in separate proceedings concerning adverse action claim in the Federal Court, applicant filed an affidavit asserting he a applied for an APS6 role and also submitted multiple other ‘dummy applications’ – ‘dummy application’ involved external candidate with no relevant experience – affidavit became evidence in proceedings before Commission – respondent argued applicant made false applications thus breaching trust and repudiating employment relationship – investigation by ‘Determining Officer’ engaged by respondent established that applicant’s friend actually made false applications – applicant contended that his friend copied his resume and selection criteria – applicant further contended that application by friend was ‘real’ but ‘dummy’ as he had copied his application – Commission to determine if respondent had valid reason to terminate applicant – Commission of the view that a ‘substantial and wilful’ breach of policy is a valid reason – found that on the balance of probabilities it was likely that applicant was either responsible for filing or being instrumental in filing one of the ‘dummy applications’ – Commission also found that respondent conducted full and extensive investigation into misconduct – Commission found valid reason for dismissal – dismissal not harsh, unjust or unreasonable – application dismissed. Rahman v Commonwealth of Australian as represented by the Australian Taxation Office
July 15, 2016
TERMINATION OF EMPLOYMENT – termination at initiative of employer – resignation – ss.386, 394 Fair Work Act 2009 – application for unfair dismissal remedy – jurisdictional objection – respondent contended that applicant resigned and was not dismissed – applicant employed as Commercial Insurance Broker – as a part of the 2015 performance review cycle respondent proposed to reduce applicant’s future remuneration – applicant indicated in an email to business connections that he was planning to leave respondent – meeting between parties where recollections of the conversation differed significantly – whether applicant resigned – applicant denied ever having tendered his resignation orally or in writing and claimed termination was at initiative of respondent – Commission of view that resignations do not need to be in writing to be effective – Commission determined termination of applicant’s employment was at his own initiative and not of the respondent – applicant not forced to resign because of conduct, or course of conduct, engaged in by employer – applicant not dismissed for purposes of s.385 of FW Act – application dismissed. Bonser v Nexus (Aust) P/L t/a Nexus Risk Services
July 15, 2016
TERMINATION OF EMPLOYMENT – high income threshold – ss.329, 332, 394 Fair Work Act 2009 – applicant lodged unfair dismissal application – respondent submitted reason for dismissal was genuine redundancy and that applicant not protected from unfair dismissal as she earned more than the high income threshold – whether applicant’s annual rate of earnings less than the high income threshold – applicant not covered by a modern award or enterprise agreement – applicant provided with motor vehicle with a nominal value attributed to increase in salary – soon after parties agreed substituting company motor vehicle with car allowance – respondent changed motor vehicle policy due to Fringe Benefits Tax liability – in lieu of company vehicle, applicant given option of either $20,000 allowance or to purchase company vehicle – applicant accepted allowance – applicant submitted car allowance was an expense allowance to compensate her for using her own vehicle in connection with business-related purposes and not part of her earnings – respondent submitted the allowance should not be viewed as a reimbursement, but rather as an allowance in lieu of the benefit of a company provided vehicle that was part of applicant’s contract – Commission not persuaded car allowance was reimbursement – applicant’s contract of employment already provided for reimbursement of travel expenses and entitlement – found applicant’s salary was increased – was provided with a company motor vehicle – entitlement to car allowance was unconditional – no suggestion it was not paid at start or end of employment period – total value of car allowance is to be included in applicant’s earnings – earnings amounted to $140,000 per annum – high income threshold exceeded – applicant not protected from unfair dismissal – application dismissed. Ni Mhorain v UON P/L
July 15, 2016
TERMINATION OF EMPLOYMENT – termination at initiative of employer – resignation – ss.386, 394 Fair Work Act 2009 – application for unfair dismissal remedy – applicant employed as electrician – throughout the conduct of the proceeding applicant alleged different dates of and reasons for his termination – an incident occurred at the premises of a customer, the customer alleged the applicant performed a ‘burn out’ on his premises – respondent showed applicant the photos sent from a customer which applicant disputed – respondent suggested they would discuss the matter the next day so conversation did not get heated – applicant turned up to work the next day however he did not complete any jobs he was assigned and did not return to work after that day – respondent submitted that applicant abandoned his employment as he did not present for work from 18 December 2015 – further submitted there was no termination at the initiative of the employer as the resignation was voluntary – in the alternative the respondent submitted there was a valid reason for termination as applicant used private work tools in breach of company policy – Commission not satisfied email sent by respondent on same day as the incident compelled applicant to resign from his employment or treat his employment as terminated – found there was no dismissal at the initiative of the employer – not necessary to determine whether dismissal was harsh, unjust or unreasonable – application dismissed. Wallis v Hallsons t/a Megals
July 15, 2016
MODERN AWARDS – 4 yearly review – ss.136, 142, 156 Fair Work Act 2009 – Full Bench – decision issued on 24 December 2015 (the December 2015 decision) which dealt with a number of proposed variations to the Pastoral Award 2010 that had arisen in the context of the Award Stage of the 4 yearly review of modern awards [[2015] FWCFB 8810] – remaining unresolved issue from the December 2015 decision concerned a claim by the Australian Workers’ Union (AWU) dealing with ‘learner shearers’ – issue in contention turns on the proper construction of ss.139 and 142 of FW Act – Full Bench satisfied the proposed definition of ‘learner shearer’ was a term about a skill based classification – Bowker considered – satisfied the variation the Full Bench proposed to make was justified by work value reasons; was necessary to meet the modern awards objective; and would ‘establish… a safety net of fair minimum wages’ as required by the minimum wages objective – Pastoral Award 2010 varied. 4 yearly review of modern awards-Pastoral Award 2010
July 15, 2016
MODERN AWARDS – dispute about matter arising under award – jurisdiction – ss.65, 593, 739 Fair Work Act 2009 – application to deal with dispute – applicant requested home based work arrangement (HBWA) pursuant to flexible working arrangement provision of respondent’s Review of Actions Policy (Policy) – applicant sought to work from Netherlands for six months in order to be with pregnant wife – respondent refused on reasonable business grounds – applicant covered by Public Service Enterprise Award 2015 – Commission found dispute resolution clause applies to matters under award or NES – HBWA not a matter under award – award did not give Commission power to deal with NES matters – in any event applicant exceeds high income threshold and award did not apply – dispute resolution procedure under applicant’s contract of employment not applicable as restricted to disputes arising under the contract – contract silent on HBWA and specifically excludes policies – Commission found no term of s.738 of FW Act applied and therefore Commission had no power to deal with dispute under s.739 – Commission found it had no power to deal with dispute under s.65 as applicant not yet a parent – Commission also found it had no power under respondent’s Policy for three reasons – application not properly made – policies specifically excluded in applicant’s employment contract and – Policy not an agreement but an internal instrument to reflect best business practice – applicant requested hearing remain private due to potential negative impact on career and personal nature of request – Commission found substantive issue of decision a legal question to be determined – would have no negative effect on applicant’s career – transparency in interests of ‘open justice’ – request refused – application dismissed. Brown v National Offshore Petroleum Safety and Environmental Management Authority t/a NOPSEMA