TERMINATION OF EMPLOYMENT – identity of employer – overseas corporation – ss.14, 394 Fair Work Act 2009 – application for relief from unfair dismissal – respondent raised jurisdictional issues including that it had not employed applicant – applicant worked as miner in the Democratic Republic of Congo (DRC) in Africa on a fly in fly out (FIFO) basis – applicant signed two employment contracts with Byrnecut Underground Congo SARL (BUCS) but asserted he was recruited in Australia by respondent and paid by them – submitted that employment covered by Mining Industry Award 2010 – applicant further submitted that respondent should be considered employer because of corporate relationship with BUCS – respondent submitted they were part of 35 separate companies in group of companies – submitted that BUCS operated as separate legal entity – Commission considered meaning of ‘national system employer’ in s.14 of FW Act – found applicant employed by BUCS – also found applicant sought employment, signed employment contracts, took directions and was dismissed by BUCS – found applicant described BUCS as employer for taxation purposes – held the role of respondent in applicant’s recruitment, and as the payment agency was undertaken on behalf of BUCS, and could not establish respondent as the employer – Commission found there were a range of discrete entities which operate under the umbrella of the Byrnecut Group – evidence did not establish a single, corporate body which is a national system employer – Commission found that common ownership arrangements cannot be taken to extend FW Act to business which operates under laws in another country – Commission found applicant was an employee of BUCS – BUCS not national system employer and not corporation formed within limits of Commonwealth of Australia – application dismissed. Meagher v Byrnecut Offshore P/L
July 15, 2016
TERMINATION OF EMPLOYMENT – misconduct – s.394 Fair Work Act 2009 – two applications for unfair dismissal remedy – employee maintained that over a two to three year period he was subject to verbal harassment and physical touching by both applicants – employee exhibited sensitivity to being touched by males as consequence of childhood abuse experiences which caused significant distress – employee did not initially complain to respondent about applicants conduct as he was embarrassed and wished to be left alone – employee eventually raised his concerns with his supervisor – supervisor advised employee to leave the issue alone – employee started to take time off work – employee received show cause letter in respect to absences and his interactions with supervisor – employee made a complaint about applicants conduct to respondent – investigation by respondent found that conduct did occur and was contrary to Code of Practice and Workplace Behaviours Policy – respondent dismissed each of the applicants – found that employee was harassed and humiliated by applicants over a period of time causing employee distress – Commission found applicants had completed the Workplace Behaviours Policy and Standards Q&A and agreed to be bound by the policy – found that both applicants participated in wider workplace culture which targeted vulnerable employee and sought to cast him as social isolate and misfit – held both applicants ought to have appreciated that their conduct was counter-productive to respondent’s business objectives and contributed to an unsafe workplace – conduct was personally, socially and psychologically damaging to employee – found valid reason for dismissal of both applicants – found dismissal not harsh, unjust and unreasonable – the wider circumstances of case did not support strong arguments in mitigation – applications dismissed. Mr R and Mr Y v Toll Holdings Ltd t/a Toll Group
July 15, 2016
RIGHT OF ENTRY – application for permit – conditions – ss.512, 513 Fair Work Act 2009 – application by CFMEU for a right of entry permit for Mr Sutherland – Mr Sutherland currently holds two permits – Commission considered declarations disclosed in application to determine if Mr Sutherland was a fit and proper person to hold permit – CFMEU submitted fact that FWBC did not oppose application a relevant factor – Commission held lack of opposition from FWBC not relevant consideration – Commission did not know reasons why FWBC not opposed to application – Commission noted Mr Sutherland had not completed relevant training and involved in multiple unresolved proceedings that raise important, relevant concerns – proceedings at preliminary point only and no findings of fact made – allegations against Mr Sutherland untested – Commission held Mr Sutherland a fit and proper person to hold permit subject to conditions – permit to be issued. Construction, Forestry, Mining and Energy Union-Construction and General Division, Queensland Northern Territory Divisional Branch
July 15, 2016
ENTERPRISE AGREEMENTS – dispute about matter arising under agreement – s.739 Fair Work Act 2009 – dispute regarding proposed implementation of a six day roster – dispute settlement procedure empowers Commission to approve roster where parties cannot agree – considered approach of Commission in exercising powers that interfere with rights of management to operate business efficiently – reasonable basis for implementation of roster based on economic setbacks, difficulty making profit and low level of cane supply – five day roster not appropriate as it would extend crushing season and increase labour costs due to need to work overtime and weekends – arguments advanced by union not accepted – proposed roster and terms do not unnecessarily impact employee – roster and conditions approved. Bundaberg Sugar Ltd v Australian Workers’ Union, The and Ors
July 15, 2016
MODERN AWARDS – award modernisation – State reference public sector transitional award – Sch. 6A, Item 6 Fair Work (Transitional Provisions and Consequential Amendments) Act 2009 – Full Bench – State reference public sector transitional award modernisation – matter arises from the operation of Schedule 6A to the Transitional Act – Early Childhood Teachers Interim Award 1999 and Educational Services – Early Childhood Assistants – Victoria – Award 1999 – a group of Victorian Local Councils support the making of a State reference public sector modern award known as the Victorian Local Government (Early Childhood Education Employees) Award 2016 – this award will replace all existing instruments applying to employers covered by the award – the Australian Education Union (AEU) supported this approach – the Municipal Association of Victoria (MAV), which represents other local councils, has objected to the coverage of this award – the Australian Services Union (ASU) supported the position of the MAV – disagreement between the parties related to the scope of awards applying in the sector – Full Bench held that the Victorian Local Councils group and the AEU were the most directly involved in the particular employment covered by the proposed award and had participated fully throughout the process – other parties were less directly involved and had little involvement in the development of the agreed award – Full Bench satisfied that the terms of the award are consistent with the legislative provisions including the modern awards objective and the minimum wages objective – award made – award shall operate from 18 July 2016. Early Childhood Teachers Interim Award 1999 and Anor
July 15, 2016
REGISTERED ORGANISATIONS – representation rights – State representation order – s.137F Fair Work (Registered Organisations) Act 2009 – Full Bench – application for an order reflecting a State representation order – directions issued that the application be served on various registered organisations, transitionally recognised associations or recognised State-registered associations – directions required all unions served with the application to indicate a position in respect of the proposed order, and if opposed the basis upon which the order is opposed – application not opposed – since 1996, pursuant to representation orders made by the Queensland Industrial Relations Commission and the Australian Industrial Relations Commission, the Australian Workers’ Union of Employees, Queensland (AWUEQ) has had the exclusive right to represent the industrial interests of certain classifications of employees at Dalrymple Bay – unless otherwise ordered, the AWUEQ will cease to have standing in the federal industrial relations system from 1 January 2017, the relevant union will be the AWU – Both Dalrymple Bay and the AWU make application for an order reflecting a State representation order, the purpose of which is to maintain the status quo at Dalrymple Bay – Full Bench satisfied that each of the prerequisites for making an order were satisfied – considered it was appropriate to make an order to substantially the same effect as the 1996 State order – order issued. Dalrymple Bay Coal Terminal P/L & Australian Workers’ Union, The (002N)
July 15, 2016
MODERN AWARDS – 4 yearly review – ss.134, 156 Fair Work Act 2009 – Commission assessing the National Training Wage schedule (NTW Schedule) to determine whether it currently meets the modern awards objective – two proposals – standardising the NTW Schedule; and removing the NTW Schedule from all modern awards, save for the Miscellaneous Award 2010, and incorporating the NTW Schedule by reference into the other modern awards that currently contain the Schedule in full – proposed changes do not seek to change the entitlements for trainees under the NTW Schedule – interested persons are invited to make written submissions on the proposals by 4.00pm on Thursday, 28 July 2016. 4 yearly review of modern awards-National Training Wage
July 15, 2016
TERMINATION OF EMPLOYMENT – application to dismiss by employer – deed of settlement – ss.394, 399A Fair Work Act 2009 – applicant alleged he had been unfairly dismissed – applicant and respondent entered settlement negotiations – respondent submitted that a binding agreement was reached – applicant submitted that there was no binding agreement – applicant had advised his legal representative to pursue the offer made by the respondent however advised that he was no longer prepared to settle the matter on that basis – Commission considered correspondence between parties during the protracted settlement negotiation supported the respondent’s position – applicant asserted that any agreement was subject to the successful negotiation of a Deed of Settlement – Commission rejected this contention and considered that the deed was simply to confirm the agreed settlement – satisfied that a binding settlement agreement was reached – applicant acted unreasonably in failing to discontinue his application after a settlement agreement had been concluded – application dismissed. Kong v Citic Pacific Mining Management P/L t/a Citic Pacific Mining