NEWS HR

TERMINATION OF EMPLOYMENT – misconduct – ss.387, 394 Fair Work Act 2009 – application for unfair dismissal remedy – applicant, who worked in coal mine, was driving underground personnel vehicle (SMV) carrying miners on three phase journey – applicant dismissed for allegedly deliberately ramming another SMV in phase 1 and tailgating an SMV in phase 2 – when miners alighted in phase 3, applicant brought his SMV to sudden stop close to miner – respondent’s investigation was deficient – insufficient evidence to sustain allegations in ‘show cause’ and termination letters – respondent obtained information regarding incident in phase 3 three months after termination – information discovered after termination could be relied upon to substantiate existence of valid reason [Shepherd] – serious breach of safety policies and procedures, whether deliberate or careless, will invariably result in finding that valid reason exists for dismissal [Northey] – Commission satisfied evidence showed applicant had driven SMV carelessly, recklessly and causing imminent safety risk when bringing SMV to sudden, jolting stop close to miner – this conduct was ‘serious misconduct’ and breached company safety and transport rules – valid reason for dismissal established – applicant not notified of changed reason for termination and not given opportunity to respond to allegation relating to conduct in phase 3 – lack of procedural fairness would normally lead to decision that termination was harsh and unfair, but this case is distinguishable on basis that it involved fundamental breach of safety, where employee wilfully, recklessly and carelessly placed safety of another employee at risk [Crozier distinguished] – applicant had not suffered detriment due to lack of procedural fairness – Commission found termination was not harsh, unjust or unreasonable – application dismissed. Cheetham v Helensburgh Coal P/L

TERMINATION OF EMPLOYMENT – extension of time – s.394 Fair Work Act 2009 – exceptional circumstances – application filed six days late – sent by Express Post from Whyalla to Adelaide two days before expiry of 21 day limit – applicant believed express post would arrive in time – envelope guaranteed next day delivery with a caveat requiring access to website to read it – website said where outside the express post network mail not covered by next day guarantee – different website page specifies the network covered – Whyalla is outside the network – another page had a delivery estimator – estimate based on Whyalla and Adelaide postcodes was that next business day delivery applied – fine print defined this as ‘available within the Express Post next business day delivery network, when lodged over the counter at a Post Office, or in a yellow street posting box’ – Whyalla Post Office sold express post envelopes and had two Express Post street post boxes – information provided was inconsistent – out of time lodgement delays due to issues with Express Post delivery tested in Leung v On Luck Chinese Nursing Home on appeal – and Yeoman v Liquip Victoria – both dealt with applications lodged one day out of time and found that postal delay constituted exceptional circumstances – Commission considered the circumstances weighed in favour of an extension of time based on exceptional circumstances – lodgement date for application extended to 1 July 2016. Van Soest v OneSteel Manufacturing P/L

TERMINATION OF EMPLOYMENT – termination at initiative of employer – s.394 Fair Work Act 2009 – applicant alleged dismissal was harsh, unjust or unreasonable – respondent objected to application on the basis applicant was employed pursuant to a fixed-term contract with an end date of 29 February 2016 – respondent submitted applicant was extended twice – applicant contended that he did not receive the second employment agreement issued in September 2014 to cover the period 1 October 2015 to 31 October 2015 and contended he only received a copy of it after his application for unfair dismissal had been lodged – applicant further contended he did not understand why there was a cut-off date of 29 February 2016 – respondent contend there had not been a dismissal at the initiative of the employer and the last employment period expiring on 29 February 2016 came to an end with the effluxion of time – Lunn considered – Commission found applicant last period of engagement was for a fixed period between 1 December 2015 and 29 February 2016 – satisfied that applicants employment with Wilson Security ended on 29 February 2016 due to the effluxion of time and not at the initiative of Wilson Security – jurisdictional objection upheld – application dismissed. . Beaumont v Wilson Security P/L

TERMINATION OF EMPLOYMENT – incapacity – permission to appeal – ss.394, 604 Fair Work Act 2009 – appellant sought permission to appeal first instance decision of Commission that dismissal not harsh, unjust or unreasonable – respondent at first instance identified performance issues related to applicant’s work – Commission at first instance held applicant’s failure to pass competency assessment carried out by respondent valid reason for dismissal – on appeal appellant claimed error of fact in finding that he was sufficiently warned about competency assessment – claimed failure to take into account evidence that competency assessment carried out without any warning provided to applicant that assessment would determine his future employment – whether person has been warned about unsatisfactory performance before dismissal factor Commission must take into account under s.387(e) of the Act – Commission at first instance found number of factual findings including that applicant was aware of respondent’s concerns regarding unsatisfactory performance – seriousness of issues under review in both mentoring program and performance improvement plan – applicant had opportunity to respond during competency assessment which he did not utilise – competency assessment ultimate event in comprehensive process dealing with respondent’s legitimate concerns about applicant performing in safety critical role -existing context of applicant’s employment made any further warning unnecessary – Full Bench found no error of fact significant in decision at first instance – no public interest in granting permission to appeal or matters of importance or general application raised by the appeal [GlaxoSmithKline Australia] – permission to appeal refused. Soper v Teekay Shipping (Australia) P/L

TERMINATION OF EMPLOYMENT – misconduct – ss.387, 394 Fair Work Act 2009 – application for unfair dismissal remedy – applicant dismissed for repeated unacceptable behaviour including intimidation, insulting remarks, ignoring or excluding individuals and public criticism – Commission found valid reason for dismissal noting applicant’s long record of repeated inappropriate behaviour, most obviously getting angry and shouting at colleagues – did not accepted that this was simply applicant’s nature or that he had a loud voice – applicant notified of reason for dismissal via general ‘show cause’ letter and notification of meeting to discuss inappropriate behaviour – opportunity to respond given at meeting – support person present, although person not of applicant’s choice – several warnings – respondent had qualified human resources professionals and followed reasonable procedures given its medium size – Commission satisfied applicant engaged in misconduct and was afforded procedural fairness – application dismissed. Diaz v Anzpac Services (Australia) P/L

TERMINATION OF EMPLOYMENT – misconduct – application for unfair dismissal remedy – s.394 Fair Work Act 2009 – applicant’s duties involved engaging with disengaged young people in the community, who face, or whose parents faced serious drug and alcohol problems – applicant tested positive to the drug and alcohol test – applicant dismissed – verbal amendments were made to the workplace drug and alcohol policy by respondent to allow instant dismissal for positive testing – applicant claimed that he had no recollection of the amendments made – zero tolerance policy warranted by respondent in the social context – Commission found valid reason for dismissal – dismissal not harsh, unjust or unreasonable – application dismissed. Owens v Bynoe Community Advancement Cooperative Society Limited t/a Bynoe CACS Ltd

ENTERPRISE AGREEMENTS – dispute about matter arising under agreement – s.739 Fair Work Act 2009 – application to have Commission determine dispute under the Pacific National Bulk Rail Enterprise Agreement 2013 (the Agreement) – jurisdictional issue of whether consultation clause and right to arbitration arise under clauses 30 and 31 of the Agreement were wholly dependent on a broader conclusion as to whether the subject matter of the dispute is about the application of the agreement – Commission had to first properly characterise the nature of the dispute (UFU v MFB) – Commission found from the orders sought by applicant and substance of case advanced by both parties that proper characterisation of dispute was a claim by the applicant that both the abolished position and the newly created roles are covered by the Agreement – respondent rejected applicant’s proposition and raised jurisdictional and merit questions as to why the Commission would not only refrain from answering the question, but should not, as a matter of jurisdiction, be able to determine the issue – Commission found abolished position and newly created roles not covered by the agreement and work performed in these roles not equivalent to work performed in a classification in the Agreement – held respondent not in breach of obligations under consultation clause – as dispute did not arise in relation to the application of the Agreement, dispute could not be brought under the Agreement – even if dispute could be brought under the Agreement, the Commission had no power to arbitrate – application dismissed for want of jurisdiction. Australian Rail, Tram and Bus Industry Union v Asciano Services P/L t/a Pacific National

TERMINATION OF EMPLOYMENT – inherent requirements – s.394 Fair Work Act 2009 – the applicant was a PUD driver who drove an 8 tonne truck – he was placed on modified duties as the result of a degenerative condition in his foot – employment was terminated on the basis that he could not safely perform the inherent requirements of his job – applicant examined by a TNT doctor as part of his workcover claim – after workcover claim declined, TNT advised it was unable to provide further modified duties and directed him to attend medical assessments to determine his fitness to work – the various reports concluded that he could not safely carry out the inherent requirements of the role without restriction – a show cause letter was sent to the applicant – the applicant provided certificates from his treating doctor stating that he was fit for work – TNT sought further information from the treating doctor who confirmed that the applicant was fit to resume work on a graduated basis – Commission considered what the applicant’s job was and the inherent requirements of that job – TNT were required to weigh up competing medical reports – it was not reasonable for them to allow the applicant to return to pre-injury duties as this would have put him at risk – there was no opportunity for redeployment – accordingly there was a valid reason for dismissal – procedural fairness afforded – dismissal not harsh, unjust or unreasonable – application dismissed. Pavlov v TNT Australia P/L