TERMINATION OF EMPLOYMENT – valid reason – s.394 Fair Work Act 2009 – applicant commenced employment with respondent on 30 October 2014 – applicant received promotions and a pay rise during period of employment – applicant mentioned to respondent he planned to at some stage start a business of his own and the respondent should not make any long term plans for him with the company – applicant received notice of termination via email on 2 August 2016 due to conflict of interest – applicant stated he was forced to start his own business a lot faster than intended due to his termination – business he started posed no conflict of interest as the target markets are different – respondent builds retaining walls and some hire work whereas the applicant’s business undertakes supply and delivery of materials – following termination of his employment the applicant’s marriage broke down due to financial stress and applicant now living with his father – respondent claimed he had heard applicant was promoting his new business on the company’s time however no evidence was produced to substantiate this fact – considered [Consolidated Paper Industries v Matthews] ‘An employee is not, however, prohibited during his employment from making preparations for setting up a business when the employment ends’ – respondent provided no evidence to support claim the applicant’s ability to perform effectively and safely on the site was compromised by the potential of him starting his own business – no conflict established before the Commission – Commission not satisfied a valid reason existed for the applicant’s termination – applicant had no opportunity to respond to the reason for termination – found applicant unfairly dismissed – remedy – reinstatement inappropriate – compensation – Sprigg applied – applicant’s annual base income was $90,000 – likely applicant would have remained in employment for 3 months following dismissal – applicant had not earned an income since starting his own business – applicant received four weeks wages following termination and this was deducted from compensation amount – applicant awarded eight week’s wages less tax – order issued. Berger v United Crib Block Construction P/L
March 27, 2017
TERMINATION OF EMPLOYMENT – remedy – ss.385, 394 Fair Work Act 2009 – applicant alleged employer engaged in unreasonable conduct which forced her to resign – Commission considered s.385(a) – whether applicant was a person who had been dismissed – s.386(1)(b) states that a person has been dismissed if they were forced to resign because of conduct engaged in by employer – applicant alleged that after company restructure, she found what she believed to be an advertisement for her job on an employment website – employer invited applicant to have discussions, and encouraged her to focus on her job as the company underwent significant change – however applicant sent letter from lawyer that ‘acted to galvanise the termination of employment’ – employer submitted that applicant voluntarily chose to resign, and clarified that the job advertisement was in relation to another role in a related company – Commission found that applicant had options other than resignation including accepting invitation to further discussions with employer – employer not responsible for dismissal – applicant ‘not a person dismissed from employment’ – application dismissed. Johnson v Granite Transformations P/L
March 27, 2017
ENTERPRISE BARGAINING – majority support determination – s.236 Fair Work Act 2009 – applicant requested to commence bargaining in relation to geographically and operationally distinct group of employees of O’Keefe Heneghan P/L and Auslife P/L and Rocky Neill Construction P/L t/a KNF Construction (KNF Construction) – initial decision ([2017] FWC 780) on 9 February 2017 in relation to confidentiality of names on petition obtained by the Construction, Forestry, Mining and Energy Union (CFMEU) – confidentiality order made – KNF Construction ordered to provide list of employees to Commission – Commission to examine list of employees and petition to determine whether majority support existed – KNF Construction appealed decision and accompanying orders and sought stay – stay application heard by DP Gooley on 22 February 2017 – not granted – hearing proceeded in respect of merits – substantive appeal with respect to confidentiality order yet to be heard – CFMEU submitted group fairly chosen – KNF Construction submitted choice of group artificial and did not provide sound basis to conclude majority of employees supported the application – KNF Construction also submitted majority of work to end on project in April 2017 so granting of application of little utility – Commission compared CFMEU’s petition with list of employees provided by KNF Construction – petition did not disclose majority support for bargaining – satisfied group fairly chosen on geographic basis – group is operationally distinct – limited duration of job weighs against application – cannot be satisfied of matters in s.237(2) of the FW Act as petition did not establish majority who want to bargain – CFMEU submitted Commission should order that the AEC conduct a ballot – order made that AEC conduct ballot as soon as practicable to determine whether majority want to bargain – order issued. Construction, Forestry, Mining and Energy Union
March 27, 2017
TERMINATION OF EMPLOYMENT – misconduct – s. 394 Fair Work Act 2009 – application for relief from unfair dismissal – applicant employed as a security guard – applicant dismissed due to generators, convertor and oil going missing from a site on 3 October 2016 during period where he was responsible for security – respondent failed to attend hearing – Commission decided it was reasonable to proceed in the absence of respondent as they were aware of hearing and had adequate notice – respondent submitted applicant had withdrawn claim because he entered into a separation agreement and signed a notice of discontinuance – applicant submitted he was led to believe that respondent’s representative had been acting on his behalf as well as on behalf of the respondent – applicant is not fluent in English, was not represented and did not have an interpreter when signing the documents – Commission not satisfied the terms of settlement and notice of discontinuance can be relied upon – respondent submitted applicant was a casual employee who was not employed on a regular and systematic basis – respondent did not provide pay slips or rosters – applicant gave uncontested evidence that he was paid $17 per hour and never received any pay slips – applicant submitted he worked a total of 160-170 hours during the six month period of his employment – Commission satisfied the period of applicant’s employment as a casual employee was on a regular and systematic basis – applicant submitted there was no valid reason for his termination and that respondent wrongly reached the conclusion that generators and compressors went missing from the site when he was responsible for security – applicant submitted he was directly watching the containers and the items did not disappear on his shift – applicant submitted he spoke to the manager who said the items disappeared between 1 and 3 October 2016 – applicant submitted a number of other guards worked between this period – Commission not satisfied there is valid reason for applicant’s dismissal related to his capacity or conduct – Commission accepted applicant’s evidence that he was not negligent in his duties – Commission satisfied lack of a valid reason and lack of procedural fairness mean that the dismissal was harsh, unjust and unreasonable – order for compensation made. Jan v NRS Engineering Solutions P/L
March 27, 2017
TERMINATION OF EMPLOYMENT – valid reason – s.394 Fair Work Act 2009 – application for relief from unfair dismissal – applicant employed as a warehouse forklift driver by respondent – applicant’s dismissal arose from three alleged procedural breaches of safety including two incidents of failing to obtain keys from truck driver and provide driver with ‘hit not’ device prior to loading; and one incident of using mobile phone whilst driving – applicant made aware of alleged breaches one month after the event and provided with 24 hours to respond – applicant was denied access to CCTV footage and witness statement – applicant submitted that dismissal was harsh, unjust and unreasonable – submitted that he was not afforded procedural fairness and disputed the three incidents that led to dismissal – applicant believed that he acted in accordance with loading procedures and that he used a UHF radio microphone, which was permitted, and not a mobile phone as claimed – respondent submitted that the allegations against applicant were substantiated and termination was not unreasonable – respondent claimed CCTV footage confirms at least two of the incidents and that witness evidence corroborates the other incident – Selvachandran requires reason for termination to be ‘sound, defensible or well-founded’ – Commission found that evidence presented did not establish that applicant had breached procedures – found witness evidence was not credible and CCTV footage did not corroborate alleged breaches – Commission found that respondent did not have valid reason to dismiss applicant – respondent’s failure to show applicant with CCTV footage impeded his capacity to respond – Commission satisfied that dismissal was harsh, unjust and unreasonable – reinstatement not sought – ordered compensation of $29,164.57 in lieu of 23.25 weeks applicant would have worked if not dismissed, taxed accordingly. Cornish v ISS Integrated Services
March 27, 2017
TERMINATION OF EMPLOYMENT – misconduct – ss.387, 394 Fair Work Act 2009 – application for relief from unfair dismissal – applicant employed as Operations Manager since January 2012 – employment terminated 7 September 2016 with immediate effect – applicant’s son employed as apprentice electrician with respondent – applicant approached HR Manager about why he had not been involved in discussion on 20 July 2016 about son’s apprenticeship progress – respondent submitted applicant’s employment terminated due to misconduct in meeting with HR Manager and refusal to participate in meeting to discuss written complaints – alleged applicant had behaved in an intimidating manner – applicant submitted termination was harsh, unjust and unreasonable – Commission found decision to terminate applicant’s employment based on behaviour during discussion on 20 July 2016 despite termination letter citing a number of reasons – in many cases the concepts of harsh, unjust or unreasonable termination will overlap Byrne & Frew – employer must have a valid reason that is sound, defensible and justified on objective analysis Rode – Commission found while applicant’s behaviour unacceptable, not satisfied the Rode test had been established – no valid reason – satisfied dismissal was harsh and unreasonable – remedy – reinstatement not appropriate – compensation – Sprigg applied – Commission satisfied applicant’s employment would have continued for at least a further 26 weeks – 10% deduction for contingencies – 20% deduction for applicant’s misconduct – $27,787.65 compensation (less tax) ordered. Hanson v Precept Services P/L
March 27, 2017
TERMINATION OF EMPLOYMENT – misconduct – Small Business Fair Dismissal Code – s.394 Fair Work Act 2009 – application for unfair dismissal remedy – respondent raised jurisdictional objection claiming dismissal was consistent with Small Business Fair Dismissal Code (the Code) – applicant and respondent worked together as senior hair stylists in same salon – respondent purchased hairdressing business and continued to employ applicant – applicant informed respondent of ongoing Workcover claim – respondent was not aware of claim as it had been made with previous owners of business – warned applicant to stop providing senior discounts beyond those authorised – regular verbal arguments in salon between parties – applicant required surgery for wrist, unfit for work for 4-6 weeks – respondent claimed to have discovered a piece of paper containing details of salon clients – contended client information was never written down as information was contained on client cards – applicant claimed to have requested another colleague to compile client contact details so as to reschedule their appointments – respondent arranged to meet with applicant 45 minutes after incident – applicant dismissed without notice – as a casual employee was not entitled to any payment of notice – respondent characterised reason for dismissal as serious misconduct and alleged applicant intended to ‘defraud’ the business through the theft of its client list for a future financial gain – Commission not satisfied dismissal effected in accordance with the Code – jurisdictional objection dismissed – Commission satisfied dismissal fell into consideration under ‘summary dismissal’ – satisfied respondent held a genuine belief applicant had engaged in conduct sufficient to justify summary dismissal, however not satisfied the belief was based upon reasonable grounds as dismissal effected within 45 minutes of incident – evidence indicated colleague took it upon herself to compile the list of client details to assist applicant in contacting clients – respondent did not undertake satisfactory investigation into matter – not satisfied applicant was dismissed in accordance with the Code – no evidence to support the allegation of theft by applicant – Commission satisfied on balance applicant was not guilty of alleged misconduct – no valid reason for dismissal – applicant not given a proper opportunity to respond to allegations – dismissal harsh, unjust and unreasonable – remedy – reinstatement inappropriate – compensation – Sprigg applied – 25% deduction for effect on viability of respondent – deduction of one week remuneration and a further $100 for earnings since dismissal – respondent to pay applicant $2,331.21 with 9.5% superannuation – payment to be made in six weekly instalments. Walker v CM Iandolo P/L t/a Ballistik Hair and Beauty Studio
March 27, 2017
ENTERPRISE AGREEMENTS – dispute about matter arising under agreement – s.739 Fair Work Act 2009 – application by Coates Hire under dispute resolution procedure in accordance with terms of Coates Hire Operations P/L National Agreement 2012 (Agreement) – on 20 April 2016, applicant wrote to 10 affected employees and proposed to stagger their commencement times between 7:00am to 9:00am – all affected employees’ ordinary hours were 6:54am to 3:00pm, not including overtime – proposed change would not affect total number of ordinary hours rostered but would create two shifts: 7:00am to 3:00pm and 8:54am to 5:00pm – proposed change would only change the start and finishing times of some of the affected employees – affected employees and respondent maintained applicant could not change commencement time unless it was by majority agreement – Agreement incorporated the Manufacturing and Associated Industries and Occupations Award 2010 (Award) – applicant submitted Agreement was silent on manner in which it could direct employee’s hours of work, however, because Agreement incorporated Award, it was necessary to review relevant provisions of Award – asserted Clause 36.2 of Award contained explicit right for it to exercise discretion as to when hours were worked – contended it had consulted with employees and their representatives in compliance with Clause 9.2 of Award – respondent submitted Clause 36.2 simply granted employer discretion to fix daily quantum of hours, not starting and finishing times – contended Clause 36.5 of Award provided mechanism for arranging ordinary hours of work – interpretation of Award and Agreement – Golden Cockerel applied – Commission found words used clearly stated intention to exclude facilitative provision and flexibility term of Award from Agreement – agreed with applicant that Clause 36.5(a) of Award was facilitative provision and therefore not incorporated into Agreement – held applicant could exercise unilateral right to direct affected employees to work ordinary hours at different times to their current ordinary hours – agreement with majority of affected employees not required – satisfied applicant had undertaken relevant consultation with affected employees and representatives – Commission recommended changes to affected employees not occur until Tuesday, 17 April 2017 to enable arrangements to be made for school pick-up obligations for employees with school-age children – dispute determined. Coates Hire Operations P/L t/a Coates Hire v ‘Automotive, Food, Metals, Engineering, Printing and Kindred Industries Union’ known as the Australian Manufacturing Workers’ Union (AMWU)